In September 1991, 21-year-old carnival worker William “Tony” Ault disappeared from the DeKalb County Free Fall Fair in Indiana. What investigators eventually uncovered was far darker than a simple missing-person case. Tony had become involved with a small group of traveling carnival workers connected by secrecy, occult beliefs, and a disturbing past. One of those men, Jimmie Lee Penick, had already committed murder in Ohio just weeks earlier—and Tony knew about it. Believing he was being invited to join the group, Tony agreed to take part in a private initiation after the fair closed. Instead, he was taken to an isolated farm building outside Auburn, Indiana, where the night turned into a brutal, carefully planned murder. In this episode of Death Kissed Traveler, we follow the full timeline of the case: Tony’s life on the traveling midway, the carnival workers surrounding him, Penick’s previous murder, the events of September 25, 1991, Tony’s disappearance, the discovery of his remains, the arrests, the investigation, the court cases, and the sentences that followed. This true crime story combines dark carnival history, murder, traveling carnival culture, cult-like behavior, Satanic practices, ritual violence, amusement industry history, unsolved details, criminal investigation, and one of the darkest crimes ever connected to the American midway. If you love true crime podcasts, dark history, carnival history, creepy amusement park stories, bizarre murders, cult cases, disturbing historical crimes, and real-life horror, this episode is for you. Step beyond the lights of the midway and into the true story of The Carnival Cult Murder. Death Kissed Traveler — horror, history, hauntings, and the dark side of the amusement world. Produced by Sun-Kissed Traveler. Visit sun-kissedtraveler.com for a free vacation quote and show sources. Written by Marissa Benson. Music and Sound Effects Epidemic Sound. Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/deathkissedtravelerpodcast/ Tik Tok: https://www.tiktok.com/@deathkissedtravel?_t=ZT-90F2Dn2tEU9&_r=1 Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/share/1Da6bkCo3o/?mibextid=wwXIfr