Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder with Mindy & Megan!

Megan Owens & Mindy Johnson

🎙️ Welcome to Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder! We’re your hosts, Megan and Mindy — sisters, storytellers, retired educators, and lifelong lovers of true crime and all things mysterious. From chilling cold cases to strange small-town secrets, we’ll dig deep into the stories that keep you up at night… especially the ones hiding right here in the heart of Missouri. Our podcast launched Fall 2025, and we are excited to take you on a journey through the twists, turns, and mayhem that make our state’s history both fascinating and frightening. If you have a case or topic suggestion, please email the sisters at missourimayhemsisters@gmail.com. 🕵️‍♀️🔍 All are welcome! Thank you for listening, subscribing, and reviewing our podcast! We appreciate you!

  1. The 1906 Easter Weekend Lynching of Three Innocent Men - Springfield, Missouri

    3D AGO

    The 1906 Easter Weekend Lynching of Three Innocent Men - Springfield, Missouri

    In this episode, Megan and Mindy explore the harrowing story of racial violence in Springfield, Missouri, that unfolded on Easter weekend in 1906. They delve into the events leading to the lynching of three innocent Black men, the societal context of racial terror, and the lasting impact on the community. This heavy but essential history reveals how prejudice and silence perpetuate injustice and underscores the importance of remembrance and reconciliation. Primary Archival Collections Katherine Lederer Ozarks African American History Collection: Housed at Missouri State University's Meyer Library, this collection includes over 7,500 documents and photographs documenting Black history in the Ozarks.Greene County Archives: Contains official records from 1906, including jail records, bench warrants, and grand jury testimony related to the event.Springfield-Greene County Library: The Local History Department maintains a collection of newspaper and magazine articles, as well as scholarly papers on the tragedy. Springfield-Greene County African American Heritage Trail: This trail includes a dedicated stop at Park Central Square, featuring a historical marker unveiled in 2019 that memorializes the three victims.History Museum on the Square: Located near the site of the lynching, the museum features permanent exhibits and digital archives detailing the event and its impact on the community.The Story of Fred Coker, Horace Duncan, and Will AllenEqual Justice Initiative (EJI): Partnered with local organizations for a soil collection ceremony in 2020 to acknowledge the racial injustice and include the victims in a national memorial exhibit. "Easter, 1906" (Musical Album & Documentary): A choral work by composer William Averitt and poet Robert Bode, performed by the Missouri State University Chorale, which seeks to raise awareness about the lynchings.Many Thousand Gone: Springfield’s Lost Black History by Katherine LedererWicked Springfield, Missouri: The Seamy Side of the Queen City by Larry Wood:Includes historical accounts of criminal history and notable lynchings in Greene County.

    27 min
  2. The Hyatt Regency Walkway Collapse - Kansas City, Missouri 1981

    MAR 30

    The Hyatt Regency Walkway Collapse - Kansas City, Missouri 1981

    Discover the tragic and complex story behind the deadliest structural collapse in U.S. history up to 2001 — the 1981 Hyatt Regency skywalk disaster in Kansas City. Join Megan and Mindy as they delve into the events, survivors' stories, engineering failures, and the haunting legacy that still echoes today. Main Topics Covered: The construction, architecture, and design flaws of the Hyatt Regency HotelThe night of the collapse: timeline, chaos, and rescue effortsThe investigation, legal fallout, and changes in engineering safety standardsSurvivor stories: trauma, heroism, and community impactThe ongoing legacy and memorial efforts to honor victimsKey Investigative & Technical Resources National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) Investigation Report: The definitive government investigation (NBSIR 82-2465) detailing the structural failure mechanism.Simpson Gumpertz & Heger (SGH) Case Study: Detailed engineering analysis of the connection failure.ASCE Library (Vol 16, No 3): An analysis of the structural failure and the faulty redesign.UNT Digital Library - NBS Investigation: The full text of the official NBS report on the collapse.Online Ethics Center at UVA: Examines the case as a primary example of professional negligence and ethical failure in engineering.University of Florida Library Guide: Compiled sources including peer-reviewed articles and educational materials.YouTube - Engineering Failure Case Study: A detailed, visual explanation of the "fast-track" construction failure, highlighting how the change was approved.Archives & Historical Context Missouri State Archives (RG 998.519): Contains extensive documents, including court records, police files, and official reports.Structure Magazine - Remembrance: A retrospective on the disaster and its impact on professional liability.

    54 min
  3. The 2011 Joplin Tornado - The Day Joplin Changed Forever

    MAR 23

    The 2011 Joplin Tornado - The Day Joplin Changed Forever

    In this Missouri Mayhem episode, the sisters delve into the dramatic story of the May 22, 2011 EF5 tornado that ravaged Joplin, Missouri — one of the deadliest in U.S. history. Join us as we explore the community’s response, survivor stories, and lessons learned to prepare for future storms. Key Topics: The historical significance of Joplin and its ties to Missouri’s rugged, hardworking rootsMeteorological science behind tornado formation in Tornado Alley, including EF scale ratingsMinute-by-minute account of the tornado’s impact, from formation to aftermathSurvivor stories: hospital nurse, bathtub miracle, and trapped motoristsThe importance of preparedness: emergency plans, impact-based warnings, and community resilienceMemorials and community rebuilding efforts reflecting strength and hopeHow Missouri’s safety protocols and warning systems have evolved post-Joplin.Official Reports & Research Government & Engineering Studies National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) – Joplin Tornado Investigation — Detailed technical study on building performance, emergency communications, and structural impact. FEMA “Joplin, MO, Tornado Lessons Learned Study” — A federal review of the response and recovery, including operational and logistical insights. University Thesis: A people’s recovery: the Joplin tornado of May 22, 2011 — Survivor narratives, social capital, and recovery analysis. Emergency & Disaster Relief American Red Cross (Missouri) — Emergency support, shelter, meals, mental health services, and anniversary reflections on their Joplin response. The Salvation Army Disaster Relief — Meals, care, emotional support, and long-term recovery initiatives for survivors. Direct Relief — Medical supply support and emergency aid to health centers during the tornado response. Convoy of Hope — Participated in disaster relief operations with tools, supplies, and community support. Local Recovery & Rebuilding Resources Rebuild Joplin / City of Joplin Official Recovery Page — Current efforts to rebuild housing, volunteer opportunities, and community recovery programs. Joplin Area Habitat for Humanity – Story of Recovery — Housing construction efforts and community rebuilding narrative since 2011. Community Foundation of the Ozarks – Joplin Tornado Recovery Reflections — Fundraising history, grants, and long-term community support.

    1 hr
  4. The Horrific Murder of Cassidy Rainwater - Windyville, Missouri 2021

    MAR 16

    The Horrific Murder of Cassidy Rainwater - Windyville, Missouri 2021

    In this Missouri Mayhem episode, Mindy & Megan explore the heartbreaking story of Cassidy Rainwater, a mother of six whose life was tragically cut short in the Missouri Ozarks. We delve into her background, the events leading up to her disappearance, and the chilling discovery that unraveled a brutal crime. This case underscores the importance of community vigilance, digital evidence, and the devastating impact of vulnerability in rural areas. Key Topics: Overview of the 2021 Cassidy Rainwater case and its geographic setting in Windyville, MissouriCassidy's background: childhood, struggles, and life circumstances leading up to her disappearanceThe involvement of James Phelps and Timothy Norton, and their connection to the victimHow digital evidence, including disturbing photos uploaded online, was pivotal in solving the caseThe horrifying details of the crime scene: dismemberment, preservation in a freezer, and evidence found on propertyCourt proceedings, sentencing, and the justice served to the perpetratorsThe community’s response, including vigils and efforts to memorialize CassidyBroader themes: vulnerability of those experiencing housing instability, rural dangers, and online exploitationHow small acts like tips and digital footprints can prevent heinous crimes.Official Legal & Investigative Resources Missouri Case.net: The official portal for Missouri Courts. You can search for "James Phelps" and "Timothy Norton" to view public dockets, sentencing records, and the $30 million civil judgment filed in Dallas County.FBI National Press Releases: The FBI Kansas City Field Office issued statements regarding the digital forensic analysis that cracked the case.Missouri Tort Victims’ Compensation Fund: Information on how the family can access funds following the wrongful death judgment.Primary Local News Coverage These outlets have followed the case from the initial missing person report in August 2021 through the final sentencing in 2023: Springfield News-Leader: Provided the most detailed timeline of events and investigative reporting on the "Colorado" cover story.KY3 News (Springfield, MO): Captured video footage of the memorial services and interviews with Cassidy’s son, Aden.KOAM News Now: Released specific details from the probable cause affidavits regarding the contents of the freezer and the "7-24" labels.Cold Case Resources (Tracy Wahwassuck) The Charley Project: Maintains a profile on Tracy Denise Wahwassuck, which details the parallels between her disappearance and her daughter Cassidy’s.Laclede County Sheriff’s Office: The agency still handling the open investigation into Cassidy’s mother’s death.

    41 min
  5. The Tanner Ward Case - Trenton, MO 2017 - #justicefortannerward

    MAR 9

    The Tanner Ward Case - Trenton, MO 2017 - #justicefortannerward

    In this Missouri Mayhem episode, the sisters delve into the perplexing disappearance and death of 19-year-old Tanner Ward in Trenton, Missouri. Despite official rulings of suicide, numerous inconsistencies and unanswered questions keep Tanner’s case alive in the community’s heart. Join us as we explore the facts, theories, and ongoing fight for justice. IF YOU HAVE MORE INFO ABOUT THIS CASE, PLEASE CONTACT: DALLAS COUNTY SHERIFF DEPT - (417) 345-2441TRENTON POLICE DEPT - (660) 359-5557Primary News & Reporting True Crime News (Crime Watch Daily / Chris Hansen) “Mystery in Missouri: What Happened to Tanner Ward?” – Covers the disappearance, discovery, decomposition details, and family objections – Includes statements from Trenton police and Tanner’s motherKTTN Radio (Trenton, MO) Endangered Person Advisory Issued for Tanner Ward – Initial disappearance details, physical description, timeline – Local reporting closest to the caseGallatin North Missourian (December 2017 archives) Body Identified as Tanner Ward – Official identification, coroner involvement, suicide ruling – Statements from local officialsTrenton Police Department – Public statements regarding the suicide ruling – Claims regarding decomposition, animal activity, and length of suspension.Grundy County Coroner’s Office – Cause and manner of death determination – Autopsy coordination with Kansas City forensic labMissouri State Highway Patrol – Endangered Person Advisory June 13, 2017Crime Watch Daily with Chris Hansen – National exposure of the case – Highlights inconsistencies raised by the family – Introduced the case to a broader true-crime audience.

    55 min
  6. The Tragic Abduction & Murder of Kelsey Smith - Kansas & Missouri 2007

    MAR 2

    The Tragic Abduction & Murder of Kelsey Smith - Kansas & Missouri 2007

    In this Missouri Mayhem episode, Mindy & Megan delve into the heartbreaking case of 18-year-old Kelsey Smith, abducted in broad daylight in Kansas City in 2007. Her story highlights the importance of awareness, quick action, and legislative change to prevent similar tragedies. Key Topics: The detailed timeline of Kelsey's abduction and discoverySurveillance footage and the predator's profileThe role of cell phone records and delayed investigationsThe creation and impact of the Kelsey Smith ActPreventative safety tips for women in public spacesThe heroic efforts of her family and community to honor her legacyHow her story led to national policy changesTips for personal safety and awareness in everyday life. Resources: Official & Background Information Wikipedia – Murder of Kelsey Smith A detailed case summary, timeline, key facts, links to original sources, and external resources like archived documents. 🔗 Wikipedia page: Murder of Kelsey Smith — overview, details of the abduction, investigation, arrest, and aftermath. FBI Archive — Kelsey Smith Foundation & Case Summary Official archived FBI material including summary of the case and response, plus the origins of the Kelsey Smith Foundation. 🔗 FBI archives — includes background on the investigation and aftermath. Major News Coverage from the Time These are primary news reports from 2007 that document the key moments of the case: • KCUR – Police Arrest Suspect in Kelsey Smith Murder Case Discusses the suspect arrest and initial law enforcement statements. • Missourinet – Accused Killer Eligible for Death Penalty Context on charges and legal proceedings in 2007. • Missourinet – Suspect in Kelsey Smith Killing Has Violent Past Additional background on the accused’s history and investigation details. • CBS News Reports (Archived) Multiple early AP/CBS reports (formerly hosted online) covering: Arrest and charges filedLocation of the body in a wooded areaEarly trial coverageNote: These older news links may now only be accessible via archives or news databases. Media & Documentary References National Media Coverage The case was reported nationally and featured on multiple platforms such as: CNN and NBC News coverage of the abduction and arrestFeatured on America’s Most WantedTrue-crime TV episodes (e.g., Investigation Discovery) These programs include background interviews, case analysis, and surveillance footage highlights.

    42 min
  7. The Murder of Ken Rex McElroy - Skidmore, MO 1981 - Small Town Vigilante Justice

    FEB 23

    The Murder of Ken Rex McElroy - Skidmore, MO 1981 - Small Town Vigilante Justice

    Missouri Mayhem - The Murder of Ken McElroy - Discover the dark history behind Skidmore, Missouri, where community fears and legendary vigilance led to an infamous unresolved murder. This episode explores how a town's attempt at justice spiraled into a centuries-long mystery filled with violence, silence, and unanswered questions. 📚 RESOURCES & FURTHER LISTENING Harry N. MacLean — In Broad DaylightFBI historical case summariesMissouri State Highway Patrol archivesA&E City Confidential episode on SkidmoreNewspaper archives from the Kansas City Star and St. Joseph News-PressThe Breaking Point of a Town - Website - timeline

    50 min
  8. President for a Day - David Rice Atchison - Platte County, MO - 1849

    FEB 16

    President for a Day - David Rice Atchison - Platte County, MO - 1849

    Missouri Mayhem - In this episode, we explore the fascinating myth surrounding Missouri politician David Rice Atchison, who allegedly served as U.S. President for a single day in 1849. We dive into the historical context of mid-19th century America, the political chaos of 1849, and the truth behind this intriguing legend—plus, what it reveals about history, myth, and power. EXPANDED REFERENCES U.S. Senate Historical Office – No, David Rice Atchison Was Not President for a DaySnopes – Was David Rice Atchison President for One Day?Shapell Manuscript Foundation – Atchison correspondenceMissouri Life Magazine – March 4, 1849Library of Congress – Presidential InaugurationsNational Archives – Presidential Succession HistoryUniversity of Missouri Special Collections

    24 min
See All (43)

Trailers

4.8
out of 5
9 Ratings

About

🎙️ Welcome to Missouri Mayhem: Mystery & Murder! We’re your hosts, Megan and Mindy — sisters, storytellers, retired educators, and lifelong lovers of true crime and all things mysterious. From chilling cold cases to strange small-town secrets, we’ll dig deep into the stories that keep you up at night… especially the ones hiding right here in the heart of Missouri. Our podcast launched Fall 2025, and we are excited to take you on a journey through the twists, turns, and mayhem that make our state’s history both fascinating and frightening. If you have a case or topic suggestion, please email the sisters at missourimayhemsisters@gmail.com. 🕵️‍♀️🔍 All are welcome! Thank you for listening, subscribing, and reviewing our podcast! We appreciate you!

Information

You Might Also Like