The Reel Rematch

The Reel Rematch

The Reel Rematch is the ultimate podcast about Hollywood’s strangest trend, twin films. Each episode dissects two movies with strikingly similar plots released around the same time. Were they duelling studio projects, creative coincidences, or shameless copycats? From Armageddon vs Deep Impact to The Prestige vs The Illusionist, we unpack the rivalries, behind-the-scenes chaos, and box-office outcomes to decide which film truly wins the match. Think movie nerd detective work meets cinematic showdown.

  1. A Hijacking vs Captain Phillips: Which Somali Pirate Film Won?

    5D AGO

    A Hijacking vs Captain Phillips: Which Somali Pirate Film Won?

    Two Somali pirate films, one tense hostage thriller clash. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we compare A Hijacking and Captain Phillips, two films that turned modern piracy into gripping big-screen drama. We break down the similarities, the key differences, the box office battle, critical response, performances, tone, legacy, and which film ultimately delivers the stronger take on a Somali pirate hijacking.

    1h 32m
  2. Happy Feet vs Surf’s Up: Which Penguin Film Won?

    APR 27

    Happy Feet vs Surf’s Up: Which Penguin Film Won?

    Two penguin films, one mid-2000s animated clash. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we compare Happy Feet and Surf’s Up, two penguin-centred animated films released within a year of each other. We break down the similarities, the key differences, the box office battle, critical response, performances, tone, legacy, and which film ultimately delivers the stronger big-screen take on penguins. Follow The Reel Rematch wherever you get your podcasts for more twin-film face-offs.

    1h 11m
  3. Mirror Mirror vs Snow White and the Huntsman: Which Snow White Film Won?

    APR 13

    Mirror Mirror vs Snow White and the Huntsman: Which Snow White Film Won?

    Two Snow White films, one very strange Hollywood collision. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we compare Mirror Mirror and Snow White and the Huntsman, two 2012 reimaginings of the same fairy tale released just months apart. We break down the similarities, the key differences, the box office battle, critical response, performances, tone, legacy, and which film ultimately delivers the stronger big-screen take on Snow White. Follow The Reel Rematch wherever you get your podcasts for more twin-film face-offs.

    1h 13m
  4. Kick-Ass vs Super: Which Dark Superhero Film Hit Harder?

    MAR 30

    Kick-Ass vs Super: Which Dark Superhero Film Hit Harder?

    Two brutal, R-rated superhero films, one chaotic twin-film collision. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we compare Kick-Ass and Super, two 2010 films that took the superhero genre in darker, bloodier, and more morally unhinged directions. We break down the similarities, the key differences, performances, violence, satire, critical response, legacy, and which film ultimately delivers the sharper and more memorable anti-superhero hit. Follow The Reel Rematch wherever you get your podcasts for more twin-film face-offs.

    1h 1m
  5. Madagascar vs The Wild: Which Animated Zoo Escape Film Won?

    MAR 16

    Madagascar vs The Wild: Which Animated Zoo Escape Film Won?

    Two animated animal escape adventures, one very lopsided twin-film battle. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we compare Madagascar and The Wild, two family films released less than a year apart about zoo animals breaking free and heading into the wild. We break down the similarities, the key differences, the box office battle, critical response, humour, voice cast, legacy, and why one film became a hit while the other disappeared into the jungle. Follow The Reel Rematch wherever you get your podcasts for more twin-film face-offs.

    57 min
  6. Won’t You Be My Neighbor? vs A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood: Which Mister Rogers Portrait Endures?

    MAR 2

    Won’t You Be My Neighbor? vs A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood: Which Mister Rogers Portrait Endures?

    Two acclaimed tributes to Fred Rogers, one thoughtful and moving showdown. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we’re joined by Matt Greene to compare Won’t You Be My Neighbor? and A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood, two very different portraits of Mister Rogers released just a year apart. We break down the similarities, the key differences, emotional impact, performances, cultural resonance, legacy, and which film ultimately offers the more powerful and enduring portrait of kindness, empathy, and community. Follow The Reel Rematch wherever you get your podcasts for more twin-film face-offs.

    1h 42m
  7. Zodiac vs The Zodiac: Which Zodiac Killer Film Hit Harder?

    FEB 16

    Zodiac vs The Zodiac: Which Zodiac Killer Film Hit Harder?

    Two films, one infamous killer, and one very uneven true-crime showdown. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we compare Zodiac and The Zodiac, two films released two years apart that tackle the unsolved Zodiac Killer case from very different angles. We break down the similarities, the key differences, historical accuracy, psychological tension, performances, critical response, cultural impact, legacy, and which film ultimately captures the paranoia of an unsolved mystery more effectively. Follow The Reel Rematch wherever you get your podcasts for more twin-film face-offs.

    59 min
  8. Capote vs Infamous: Which Truman Capote Film Gets It Right?

    FEB 2

    Capote vs Infamous: Which Truman Capote Film Gets It Right?

    Two biographical dramas, one writer, one murder case, and one very unusual twin-film collision. In this episode of The Reel Rematch, we compare Capote and Infamous, two films released a year apart that explore Truman Capote, In Cold Blood, and the personal cost of turning real-life horror into literary fame. We break down the similarities, the key differences, performances, critical response, audience impact, legacy, and which film ultimately delivers the sharper and more definitive portrait of Capote at work and in decline. Follow The Reel Rematch wherever you get your podcasts for more twin-film face-offs.

    1h 9m
See All (18)

About

The Reel Rematch is the ultimate podcast about Hollywood’s strangest trend, twin films. Each episode dissects two movies with strikingly similar plots released around the same time. Were they duelling studio projects, creative coincidences, or shameless copycats? From Armageddon vs Deep Impact to The Prestige vs The Illusionist, we unpack the rivalries, behind-the-scenes chaos, and box-office outcomes to decide which film truly wins the match. Think movie nerd detective work meets cinematic showdown.

Information

  • Creator
    The Reel Rematch
  • Years Active
    2025 - 2026
  • Episodes
    18
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.
  • Show Website
    The Reel Rematch