Not Penny's Podcast

Not Penny’s Podcast

Welcome to Not Penny's Podcast, a rewatch podcast of the hit ABC show, "LOST", but with a twist. Your host, Michael, is a diehard Lostie, but his co-host, Rebecca, has never watched it! Come along with us as we got back to The Island, on Not Penny's Podcast!

Episodes

  1. Sep 17

    Episode 11 - "The Island Has a Plan"

    Not Penny’s Podcast — Season 1, Episode: “Deus Ex Machina” Locke’s faith in the island is put to the ultimate test. This week on Not Penny’s Podcast, we dive into one of Season 1’s biggest Locke episodes as his relationship with Boone takes a dangerous turn. We talk about Locke’s mysterious connection to the island, Boone’s growing frustration, the discovery that sends them deeper into the jungle, and the question hanging over everything: Is Locke following the island’s plan — or is he completely losing his mind? Plus: the hatch mystery gets even bigger, Boone continues making questionable decisions, and we try to figure out exactly what the island is trying to tell Locke. Another episode, another dozen questions, and absolutely no answers. Come for the mystery. Stay for the bad decisions. Absolutely — “Deus Ex Machina” is a great one for Not Penny’s Podcast because it gives you plenty to play with: Locke’s mysterious connection to the island, Boone’s frustration, the hatch, and the increasingly weird question of whether the island is actually choosing these people. The Locke & Key Trust the Island Locke, Stock & One Big Mystery Boone Trouble The Island Has a Plan Faith, Fate & the Hatch What the Hell Is Locke Doing? Everybody Loves Locke The Island Chooses Locke Down Faith, Fear & Falling Planes A Boone Too Far The Man Who Saw the Island The Hatch Is Getting Real Deus Ex Machina: Locke’s Lost Faith My pick for your podcast: The Island Has a PlanIt feels intriguing without giving away anything beyond what listeners see in the episode. Not Penny’s Podcast — Season 1, Episode: “Deus Ex Machina” Locke’s faith in the island is put to the ultimate test. This week on Not Penny’s Podcast, we dive into one of Season 1’s biggest Locke episodes as his relationship with Boone takes a dangerous turn. We talk about Locke’s mysterious connection to the island, Boone’s growing frustration, the discovery that sends them deeper into the jungle, and the question hanging over everything: Is Locke following the island’s plan — or is he completely losing his mind? Plus: the hatch mystery gets even bigger, Boone continues making questionable decisions, and we try to figure out exactly what the island is trying to tell Locke. Another episode, another dozen questions, and absolutely no answers. Come for the mystery. Stay for the bad decisions. Locke’s faith is tested, Boone gets in over his head, and the island seems to have a plan. We break down “Deus Ex Machina” and all its biggest mysteries. #NotPennysPodcast #Lost #LostRewatch #LostPodcast #LOSTTV #LostFans #ABCLOST #DeusExMachina #JohnLocke #BooneCarlyle #LostSeason1 #TVPodcast #RewatchPodcast #MysteryTV #TVRewatch

  2. Sep 4

    Episode 10: The Numbers are Bad

    4, 8 , 15, 16, 23, 42 This week on Not Penny’s Podcast, we dive into LOST’s “Numbers,” unpack Hurley’s mysterious past, question the island’s obsession with math, and make some very questionable theories. What could possibly go wrong? #LOST #LostTV #LostRewatch #LostPodcast #NotPennysPodcast #LOSTFans #LOSTSeason1 #TVRewatch #RewatchPodcast #FirstTimeWatcher #TVPodcast #MysteryPodcast

  3. Aug 28

    Episode 9 - Love, Lies & Lost in Translation

    This week on Not Penny’s Podcast, we’re getting Lost in Translation as we finally dive into Jin and Sun’s story. 💔 Who’s telling the truth? Who deserves our sympathy? And can anyone on this island communicate like a normal human being?! Plus, Rebecca continues her first-watch journey — which means the theories are getting GOOD. 👀 🎧 Listen now wherever you get your podcasts! #NotPennysPodcast #Lost #LostRewatch #LOSTPodcast #LostTV #JinAndSun #LostFans #LostABC #TVRewatch #Podcast #PodcastRecs #FirstWatch #LostSeries #DharmaInitiative

  4. Aug 21

    Episode 8 - Everybody Has Daddy Issues

    Claire is finally back with the survivors, but Ethan isn't finished with her yet. Charlie takes matters into his own hands, and the group is forced to confront just how dangerous the mysterious others might be. Then it's time to dig into Sawyer's past, as we learn the heartbreaking story behind his name, his obsession with revenge, and the letter that has haunted him for years. We're talking Ethan, Claire, Charlie, Sawyer, Kate, Locke, wild boars, revenge, daddy issues, questionable life choices, and all the new mysteries the Island keeps throwing at us. Plus, Rebecca gives us her first-watch reactions and theories as we continue our journey through the Island—one questionable decision at a time. Spoiler warning: This episode contains spoilers through Lost Season 1, Episodes 15 & 16. Listen, subscribe, and join us as we ask the most important question of all: does anyone on this island have a healthy relationship with their dad?

  5. Jul 31

    "Episode 7: Family Ties and Island Lies"

    In this episode of Not Penny's Podcast, we're diving into Lost Season 1, Episodes 13 and 14: "Hearts and Minds" and "Special." Boone is forced to confront his complicated relationship with Shannon as Locke pushes him toward a painful lesson about letting go. Meanwhile, Michael struggles to connect with Walt, whose mysterious abilities raise even more questions about what makes him so... special. We break down Locke's philosophy, Boone's unforgettable journey, Walt's growing mystery, and the themes of family, trust, and destiny that continue to shape the survivors' lives. Along the way, we share behind-the-scenes trivia, favorite moments, Easter eggs, and our thoughts on how these episodes set up what's still to come. Whether you're watching Lost for the first time or returning to the Island for another rewatch, join us as we unpack "Family Ties and Island Lies." Spoiler warning: This episode contains spoilers through Season 1, Episodes 13 and 14 of Lost.

  6. Apr 13

    Episode 6: “Daddy Issues & Locked Cases”

    Jack’s past catches up with him, Kate’s secrets get messy, and the case…well, it’s anything but closed. Dive into All the Best Cowboys Have Daddy Issues & Whatever the Case May Be on Not Penny’s Podcast! Are you watching along with us? Just want to drop a quick hello? Email us at NotPennysShow@gmail.com! #LostRewatch #NotPennysPodcast #LostTV

  7. Apr 5

    Episode 5: “You’re Not Alone (Except You Totally Are)”

    The Island said: “You thought this was a survival show? Think again.” This week on Not Penny’s Podcast: Golf courses, French warnings, psychic babies… and a guy who DEFINITELY wasn’t on the plane!!

  8. Feb 15

    Episode 4: "Live Together, Die Alone"

    This week on Not Penny’s Podcast, we’re diving back into the mystery with Season 1, Episodes 5 & 6. Alliances start forming, secrets begin slipping, and the island reminds everyone that survival isn’t just physical — it’s personal. We break down the biggest character moments, early clues you might’ve missed, and how these episodes quietly set the tone for everything that comes next. 👀 Rewatch along with us as the questions grow, the tension builds, and the island gets a little harder to understand. #NotPennysPodcast #LOSTRewatch #LOSTTV #TVRewatchPodcast #Podcast

  9. Jan 26

    Episode 3: Island of Redemption

    Not Penny’s Podcast is back on the island, rewatching Lost Season 1, Episodes 3 and 4: “Tabula Rasa” and “Walkabout.” We break down Kate’s clean slate, the secrets starting to surface among the survivors, and the John Locke reveal that changed Lost forever. This is the moment the show proves it’s more than a survival story—and why it hooked us for good. 🎧 Press play and revisit where Lost truly found its footing.

  10. Jan 21

    Episode 2: "Guys...where are we!?"

    Not Penny’s Podcast kicks off the rewatch with Lost’s iconic pilot. We break down the crash, first impressions of the survivors, early mysteries, and the moments that made us realize this show was going to be something special. 🎧 Back to the island—where it all began

  11. Jan 15

    Episode 1: Now Boarding, Not Penny's Podcast

    Welcome to Not Penny's Podcast, a rewatch podcast of the hit ABC show, "LOST", but with a twist. Your host, Michael, is a diehard Lostie, but his co-host, Rebecca, has never watched it! Come along with us as we got back to The Island, on Not Penny's Podcast! In "Episode 0: Now Boarding, Not Penny's Podcast", hear Michael and Rebecca discuss how Lost as a series has stood the test of time, and how this rewatch will work to avoid spoilers, and enjoy the series again through a first time viewer!

  • 11 Episodes

Ratings & Reviews

4.3
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

Welcome to Not Penny's Podcast, a rewatch podcast of the hit ABC show, "LOST", but with a twist. Your host, Michael, is a diehard Lostie, but his co-host, Rebecca, has never watched it! Come along with us as we got back to The Island, on Not Penny's Podcast!

Information

  • Creator
    Not Penny’s Podcast
  • Years Active
    2026
  • Episodes
    11
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Not Penny’s Podcast
  • Show Website
    Not Penny's Podcast