The Judgemental Minds Society

Julien P

longtime friends giving their unsolicited, unfiltered takes on movies and trailers, whether you asked for it or not. Come find more stuff, including weird rants about trailers and more on our YouTube channel . https://youtube.com/@thejudgementalmindssociety

  1. 5d ago

    The Death Of Robin Hood Bored Us To Tears

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! We review The Death of Robin Hood, a dark reinvention of the legendary outlaw starring Hugh Jackman. The movie presents an aging Robin Hood haunted by his violent past and searching for redemption but does this grim deconstruction justify using the Robin Hood name? We discuss the promising opening, brutal action, beautiful cinematography, slow island storyline, Hugh Jackman’s performance, and why the film ultimately disappointed us. We also compare it with the Kevin Costner and Russell Crowe versions and debate whether Hollywood still knows how to tell a compelling Robin Hood story. This review contains major spoilers. Did The Death of Robin Hood work for you? Which Robin Hood movie is the best? Let us know below.

    The Death Of Robin Hood Bored Us To Tears

  2. Oct 23

    Hope Review: We Disagree (One Of Us Is Honest)

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! HOPE movie review: impressive filmmaking or an alien thriller that overstays its welcome? Hugo and Julien debate the Korean sci-fi film in a brutally honest episode of The Judgemental Minds Society. Hugo attempts to defend HOPE while Julien has already lost all hope. We break down the cinematography, alien designs, CGI, endless chase sequences and the shift from atmospheric mystery to monster mayhem. We also discuss the ending, post-credits scene and whether a shorter cut could have saved the movie. Did HOPE work for you, or did the suspense turn into exhaustion? Tell us in the comments, and subscribe for more movie reviews, trailer reactions and film debates. #HopeMovie #HopeReview #KoreanCinema #MovieReview #SciFiMovies #AlienMovies #KoreanMovies #SciFiHorror #CreatureFeature #FilmReview #MoviePodcast #FilmDiscussion #Cinema #TheJudgementalMindsSociety #TJMS

    Hope Review: We Disagree (One Of Us Is Honest)

  3. Oct 16

    The Exorcist, An Atmospheric Masterpiece.

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Does The Exorcist (1973) still deserve its reputation as the scariest movie ever made? In this Halloween episode of The Judgemental Minds Society, we revisit William Friedkin’s horror classic and debate what still works—and what feels less frightening today. From the haunting Iraq opening and Regan’s possession to Father Karras and the disturbing hospital scenes, we discuss the film’s performances, documentary style, extended cut and infamous spider-walk scene. We also compare supernatural horror with Constantine and explore why the atmosphere of 1970s New York and Washington, D.C. remains so compelling. Is The Exorcist still terrifying, or does its greatest strength lie in its atmosphere? Share your verdict in the comments, like the video and subscribe for more film reviews and movie discussions. Spoilers ahead. #TheExorcist #TheExorcist1973 #WilliamFriedkin #HorrorMovies #ClassicHorror #HorrorReview #MovieReview #FilmPodcast #HorrorPodcast #HalloweenMovies #70sCinema #TheJudgementalMindsSociety The Exorcist, The Exorcist 1973, The Exorcist review, The Exorcist movie review, William Friedkin, classic horror movies, horror movie review, scariest movie ever, Halloween movies, 1970s horror, Linda Blair, Max von Sydow, Jason Miller, Ellen Burstyn, Father Karras, Regan possession, The Exorcist ending, Exorcist spider walk, The Exorcist extended cut, Constantine, horror podcast, film discussion, The Judgemental Minds Society, TJMS

    The Exorcist, An Atmospheric Masterpiece.

  4. Oct 8

    Digger : Absolute Cinema, Absolute Tom Cruise Or How I learned To Stop Worrying And Love The Oil

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Digger review with spoilers! Is Tom Cruise delivering one of the best performances of his career? Hugo and Julien discuss Alejandro González Iñárritu’s unconventional film, its shocking twists, and why they’re calling it a masterpiece. From Cruise’s extraordinary monologue to John Goodman and the ensemble cast, we break down the performances, the film’s play-within-a-film structure, and its emotionally devastating ending. We also debate its environmental message, political satire, the “woke” criticism, and whether Tom Cruise’s blockbuster reputation creates the wrong expectations. With comparisons to Birdman, Magnolia, Brazil, Dr. Strangelove, and Synecdoche, New York, we explore why Digger demands your attention—and why it stayed with us long after leaving the theater. ⚠️ Full spoilers, including major twists and the ending. Did Digger move you, frustrate you, or leave you confused? Share your verdict in the comments and subscribe to The Judgemental Minds Society for more candid movie reviews and film debates. #Digger #TomCruise #AlejandroInarritu #JohnGoodman #MovieReview #SpoilerReview #FilmDiscussion #FilmPodcast #TheJudgementalMindsSociety How this was made

    Digger : Absolute Cinema, Absolute Tom Cruise Or How I learned To Stop Worrying And Love The Oil

  5. Oct 2

    Resident Evil Review: Too Many Jokes, Not Enough Horror?

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Is the new Resident Evil movie worth watching? Hugo and Julien clash over survival horror, video game fan service, and whether the film delivers real scares—or just a disposable popcorn ride. In this episode of The Judgemental Minds Society, we break down what works and what falls flat: jokes that undercut the tension, CGI monsters, echoes of The Thing, rushed pacing, and familiar Resident Evil details like Raccoon City, typewriters, and green herbs. Does capturing the games make it a good horror movie? Expect spoilers, disagreements, and absolutely no agreement on how much Hugo knows about Resident Evil. What did you think of Resident Evil? A fun horror ride or a missed opportunity? Tell us in the comments. Subscribe to The Judgemental Minds Society for more movie reviews, horror discussions, and unfiltered film debates with Hugo and Julien. #ResidentEvil #MovieReview #HorrorMovies #zachcregger

    Resident Evil Review: Too Many Jokes, Not Enough Horror?

  6. Sep 24

    The End of Oak Street : A Terrible Family… and Some Dinosaurs

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! The dinosaurs might be the least of this family’s problems. In our spoiler-filled review of THE END OF OAK STREET, we discuss why the mystery, family drama, and prehistoric chaos didn’t work for us. We break down Anne Hathaway and Ewan McGregor’s characters, the CGI and cinematography, the J.J. Abrams mystery-box formula, and an ending that left us with more frustrations than answers. Could this have worked better as a short Twilight Zone episode? Spoilers throughout, including the ending. Did the mystery work for you, or did the ending lose you? Share your take in the comments, and subscribe for more movie reviews and debates. #TheEndOfOakStreet #MovieReview #SpoilerReview

    The End of Oak Street : A Terrible Family… and Some Dinosaurs

  7. Sep 19

    Confessions of a Dangerous Mind: George Clooney’s Best Movie?

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Is Confessions of a Dangerous Mind George Clooney’s best film as a director? In this episode, we revisit Clooney’s stylish 2002 directorial debut, written by Charlie Kaufman and starring Sam Rockwell as game-show producer Chuck Barris—a man who claimed to have lived a secret double life as a CIA assassin. We discuss the film’s unusual production history, Kaufman’s objections to the finished movie, its dark humor and striking visual style, and whether Barris’s incredible story contains any truth. We also look at Sam Rockwell’s remarkable performance, the star-packed supporting cast—including Drew Barrymore, Julia Roberts, George Clooney, Brad Pitt, and Matt Damon—and the film’s disappointing box-office run. Is it an overlooked masterpiece, an unsettling character study, or simply a bizarre Hollywood experiment? And does it remain the strongest movie George Clooney has directed? Warning: This review contains spoilers. Let us know in the comments: Do you think Chuck Barris was telling the truth—and would Confessions of a Dangerous Mind earn a place in your top 100 movies? #ConfessionsOfADangerousMind #GeorgeClooney #SamRockwell #CharlieKaufman #MovieReview #FilmReview #CultMovies #cinematic

    Confessions of a Dangerous Mind: George Clooney’s Best Movie?

  8. Aug 27

    Is Manhunter (1986) Michael Mann's Best Movie?

    Got something to say to this podcast? Send a voicemail, and you might hear yourself on the next episode! Did you know Anthony Hopkins wasn't the first Hannibal Lecter? Today, we dive deep into Michael Mann’s 1986 neon-soaked masterpiece, Manhunter. In this episode, we break down why this stylish 80s thriller remains the ultimate Thomas Harris adaptation: The Remake: Why Manhunter outshines the 2002 Red Dragon remake. The Cast: Analyzing William Petersen's intense portrayal of Will Graham and Tom Noonan's terrifying Tooth Fairy. The Debate: Comparing Brian Cox's chilling, grounded Hannibal to Anthony Hopkins' iconic performance. Behind the Scenes: We uncover insane set trivia, from Michael Mann's extreme directing tactics to making fake blood out of 7-Eleven ketchup. Don't forget to like, subscribe, and leave a comment below with your favorite Hannibal Lecter performance! Manhunter 1986, Manhunter movie review, Michael Mann movies, Hannibal Lecter first movie, Brian Cox Hannibal Lecter, Red Dragon vs Manhunter, William Petersen Will Graham, Tom Noonan Tooth Fairy, 80s thriller movies, Miami Vice aesthetic, Thomas Harris adaptations, The Judgemental Minds Society, movie podcast, film analysis.

    Is Manhunter (1986) Michael Mann's Best Movie?
See All (37)

About

longtime friends giving their unsolicited, unfiltered takes on movies and trailers, whether you asked for it or not. Come find more stuff, including weird rants about trailers and more on our YouTube channel . https://youtube.com/@thejudgementalmindssociety

Information