TAOI (these aren’t our ideas)

Jake and Josh
  • 0.0 (0)
  • Religion & Spirituality

These Aren’t Our Ideas is a podcast that questions inherited beliefs, challenges religious certainty, and explores where our ideas actually come from. We dig into Christianity, science, the Bible, theology, philosophy, psychology, and history—pulling from biblical scholarship, ancient literature, Greek and Jewish worldviews, and modern thinkers. This isn’t about tearing things down for the sake of it. It’s about intellectual honesty, curiosity, and following the evidence wherever it leads. Many of the ideas we carry feel personal, sacred, or unquestionable—but most of them were handed to us. In this podcast, we ask: Who gave us these ideas? Why do we believe them? And what happens when we really examine them? If you’ve ever felt tension between faith and reason, tradition and truth, belief and doubt—this space is for you.

  1. 2d ago

    Junip: “In Every Direction” - Finding Your Center

    In this bonus conversation, Jake and Josh discuss doubt, grief, and the music and books that led them to question external authorities structures like religion. They explore what it means to stop looking outward for direction and instead find the center of themselves. We talk about the band, Junip. Having just found them at a crucial point of life, their music has been an integral part of moving forward as adults, particularly for Jake and his brother who lost their father last year. Now in our early 40’s, what does it mean to move forward, to accept things as they are, to find and operate out of our “center." Through honest conversation about loss, privilege, and choice, they discuss “peace" through the lens of self‑actualization—the freedom to decide for yourself, accept responsibility, and live from your own core. Here is a link to a playlist for Junip, on Spotify, including the song from the podcast, “In Every Direction."  Junip Playlist

  2. 3d ago

    Rap, Reunion & Rebirth: A Candid Chat on Faith and Peace

    Jake and Josh begin with playful banter about a surprise rap, reminiscing about DC Talk, Michael W. Smith, and concert memories while sharing family moments. The conversation deepens into a discussion about peace, rebirth, and the contrast between faith-based spiritual peace and the contentment earned through life experience and acceptance of impermanence.

  3. Sep 30

    Belief: How Does it Play Out? (Part 5)

    Belief, particularly Christian belief, looks very different depending on where you are, when you are, and who you’re talking to and being influenced by. What are we supposed to “believe” in? The concept is so much more complicated than we pretend it is. People have and continue to believe all kinds of different things related to Jesus and Christianity. Christianity is fundamentally different in Egypt than it is in Ethiopia than it is in Russia. Eastern Orthodoxy looks fundamentally different than Bible Belt non-denominational Protestant-style expressions. Which one holds the “right belief?” How is anyone supposed to know?  And, this was God’s plan all along? As Christianity has played out in society, we have purview into why this “right belief” system makes no sense. Do we even have a choice to believe, or is it something you’re “born with.” Some passages make it sound like that’s the case.

  4. Sep 23

    Belief: Doubting Thomas (Part 4)

    In this episode, Josh takes a spin at Belief. We look at belief through the lens of the apostles and the gospels. What was Doubting Thomas’s deal?

  5. Sep 16

    Belief: Why Is “Correct Belief” Most Important (Part 3)

    What if belief in concepts isn't simply "what the Bible teaches"? What if it's one interpretive model among many that can be built from the same collection of texts? In this episode, we put these concepts to the test—not by leaving the Bible behind, but by diving deeper into it. We examine the major categories at the heart of belief, including the nature of God, the nature of humanity, sin, salvation, judgment, eternal destiny, and truth itself. Then we ask a provocative question: Could the Bible support radically different conclusions? Using passages from both the Old and New Testaments, we explore alternative biblical models that challenge some of the foundational assumptions. Is humanity fundamentally fallen, or are we primarily image-bearers of God? Is sin rebellion, ignorance, injustice, or a failure to love? Is salvation about escaping hell, participating in transformation, or being united with God? Does Scripture point toward eternal punishment, annihilation, or the eventual reconciliation of all things? We also investigate passages that have inspired Christian Universalists, early church theologians, and modern scholars to imagine a God whose ultimate purpose is restoration rather than exclusion. Along the way, we encounter Paul's cosmic vision of resurrection, multiple heavens, the restoration of all things, and a much stranger and more diverse biblical world than many modern Christians realize. The goal of this episode isn't to prove one theology over another. It's to demonstrate that Scripture is far more complex, diverse, and open to interpretation than systems like The Concepts often acknowledge. If multiple models can emerge from the same Bible, what does that say about certainty, doctrine, and the way we construct our understanding of God?

  6. Sep 9

    Belief: Fundamental Christianity - A Psychological and Philosophical Critique (Part 2)

    For decades, these concepts have provided a powerful framework for understanding reality, God, human nature, suffering, salvation, and our ultimate destiny. But what happens when we step outside the system and examine its assumptions? In this episode, we break down the core architecture of belief in fundamentalist concepts, and explore the philosophical, psychological, and scientific challenges to its central claims. Is anxiety really evidence of separation from God, or can modern psychology offer a different explanation? Does meaning require a divine source, or are humans natural meaning-makers? Is belief in these concepts uncovering objective truth—or constructing one possible worldview from a much larger set of possibilities? We examine how comprehensive belief systems create coherence, identity, certainty, and belonging, while also asking whether psychological comfort should be confused with objective truth. Along the way, we explore questions about human nature, morality, religious experience, free thought, group identity, and the tendency of all ideological systems—religious and secular alike—to become self-reinforcing. Rather than attacking faith itself, this conversation investigates a deeper question: Why are humans so drawn to grand explanations that promise to make sense of everything? And what happens when we begin to question the framework that once explained the world to us? This episode is an exploration of belief, certainty, meaning, and the psychological architecture behind the systems we use to understand reality.

  7. Sep 2

    Belief: Fundamentalism & the Jesus Movement (Part 1)

    In this episode, we look at the deep fundamental baptist belief we were raised on, and how it came out of the cultural upheaval of the late 1960s and 1970s. As thousands of young Americans abandoned traditional institutions in search of meaning, community, spirituality, and purpose, the Jesus Movement emerged as a powerful alternative. While some seekers turned toward Eastern religions, communes, or psychedelic exploration, others found answers in Christianity. Drawing from an engineering mindset and a desire to explain life through a coherent biblical framework, our pastor developed a comprehensive system designed to answer humanity’s biggest questions: What is reality? What is the nature of man? Why do we suffer? What is our purpose? How do we find God? What happens after death? We explore how these concepts provided certainty, identity, and meaning to a generation hungry for answers, and how the movement fit into the broader story of the Jesus Movement, intentional communities, and the search for ultimate truth. Rather than dismissing the movement as mere religious indoctrination or celebrating it uncritically, we examine the historical, cultural, and psychological forces that made these concepts so compelling—and why its influence continues to be felt decades later.

  8. Aug 26

    Did Jesus Rise From the Dead? Part 3: John's Cosmic Christ

    Part 3 of our resurrection series turns to the final Gospel and perhaps the most theologically developed portrait of Jesus in the New Testament. By the time we reach John's Gospel, Jesus is no longer simply an apocalyptic prophet, Jewish Messiah, or risen servant of God. He is the eternal Word who existed before creation, participated in the creation of the universe, descended from heaven, and openly identifies himself with the divine. John's Jesus doesn't gradually become exalted after his death—he arrives on the scene already possessing a cosmic identity. How does this theological evolution shape John's resurrection account? In this episode, we examine the striking differences between John and the earlier Gospels. The empty tomb story grows more detailed. The appearances of Jesus become more dramatic. Thomas is invited to touch Jesus' wounds. The beloved disciple appears as a privileged witness. The resurrection is no longer simply evidence that God vindicated Jesus; it becomes the culmination of a story in which the divine Logos returns to the glory he possessed before the world existed. We explore how John's resurrection narrative reflects the highest Christology in the New Testament and ask whether it represents historical memory, theological development, or both. What happens when we read the resurrection stories chronologically—from Paul, to Mark, Matthew, and Luke, and finally to John? Do we see independent testimony, or a tradition that becomes increasingly elaborate and theologically grand over time? Join us as we conclude our series by examining the Gospel that presents the most exalted vision of Jesus and the most developed resurrection account in the New Testament.

See All (23)

About

These Aren’t Our Ideas is a podcast that questions inherited beliefs, challenges religious certainty, and explores where our ideas actually come from. We dig into Christianity, science, the Bible, theology, philosophy, psychology, and history—pulling from biblical scholarship, ancient literature, Greek and Jewish worldviews, and modern thinkers. This isn’t about tearing things down for the sake of it. It’s about intellectual honesty, curiosity, and following the evidence wherever it leads. Many of the ideas we carry feel personal, sacred, or unquestionable—but most of them were handed to us. In this podcast, we ask: Who gave us these ideas? Why do we believe them? And what happens when we really examine them? If you’ve ever felt tension between faith and reason, tradition and truth, belief and doubt—this space is for you.

Information