Theory of Change

Devex

Theory of Change is a podcast about the future of global development — and the people trying to reshape it. Hosted by Devex Senior Reporter Michael Igoe, the show features candid conversations with leaders in philanthropy, foreign policy, technology, finance, media, and humanitarian aid about the forces transforming how global change actually happens: power, politics, money, influence, and ideas. Not a panel. A conversation with a real person. Episodes are published every Tuesday. Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@devex The podcast is produced by Devex Associate Editor Thomas Cserép and Mai Ylagan.

  1. 4d ago

    Is America a developing country?

    When all 193 United Nations member states adopted the Sustainable Development Goals in 2015, their defining breakthrough was universality.  Unlike their predecessors, the SDGs were designed to apply to every nation, wealthy or poor. Yet more than a decade later, the United States remains one of only three countries in the world — alongside Myanmar and Haiti — that has never submitted a voluntary national review tracking its progress, according to Sarah Mendelson, director of Sustainable Futures at Carnegie Mellon University and former U.S. government official. “That's a really intentional list to be on for 10 years. I think that's really telling,” Mendelson said. On the latest episode of Devex’s Theory of Change podcast, Mendelson explained why Washington has long resisted the idea that global development happens at home, too. She traces this blind spot to a bipartisan belief in American exceptionalism and a Cold War-era reluctance to treat health, housing, food, and clean water as fundamental human rights rather than commodities.  While U.S. policymakers have historically viewed development as something America exports abroad, Mendelson argued that disaggregated data — when and where it exists — tells a very different story. For example, while the aggregate life expectancy for American men sits at 76.5 years, that number drops to 65.9 for Black men in Chicago, 65.2 in Washington, D.C., and 62.2 in Memphis — putting outcomes in major U.S. cities on par with or behind countries receiving significant U.S. foreign assistance, such as Ethiopia (64.4) and Jordan (75.9), according to Mendelson’s research. “We tell ourselves a story about America and American exceptionalism, which is not wholly wrong. ... But when you compare the United States on things like life expectancy, health outcomes, education, it's not a good story. There's a lot of hurt out there,” Mendelson said. “There's a lot of people experiencing serious socioeconomic deprivation." Mendelson, who served as U.S. ambassador to the United Nations Economic and Social Council, said that when she was working on the Sustainable Development Goals agenda, she was contacted by Americans from Flint, Michigan, who wanted to understand how the SDGs might help them secure access to clean drinking water. “I just paused because I thought, well, on the one hand, yes, this is absolutely how it's designed, but I don't know where in the American government there's going to be receptivity to this,” she said. Following the dismantling of the U.S. Agency for International Development and recent U.S. midterm elections driven by domestic economic frustration, Mendelson argued that Washington can no longer afford to treat foreign assistance and domestic well-being as separate worlds.  Instead of choosing between global leadership and an "America First" posture, she makes the case for rebuilding U.S. development capacity to operate both at home and abroad — connecting domestic communities to global innovations and finally embracing the SDG mandate to leave no one behind.

  2. Nov 10

    AI and the humanity of health care

    For decades, international development has gravitated toward tangible interventions that produce quantifiable results: Specialized clinics, diagnostic machinery, donated pharmaceuticals, and targeted vertical programs designed to eliminate specific diseases.  Yet the most sophisticated medical supplies remain useless without trained personnel, as Seed Global Health CEO Dr. Vanessa Kerry points out. “Shots don’t put themselves in arms,” Kerry said on Devex’s Theory of Change podcast. “You can put as much tech or as many medicines as you want into a system, but if you don’t have someone to deliver them, the system falls apart. You need someone to catch a baby; you need someone to hang a bag of blood.” Kerry outlined a critical bottleneck across global development: While sub-Saharan Africa shoulders roughly a quarter of the global disease burden, it commands barely 3% of the world’s health workforce. Kerry traced her own realization of this imbalance back to her medical training in Rwanda, where an unattended, complicated birth threw the stark absence of frontline skilled personnel into sharp relief. That formative episode inspired her to create Seed Global Health, an organization dedicated to long-term partnerships with governments to train doctors, nurses, and midwives along national priorities rather than temporary donor whims. Today, global health is facing a series of compounding crises.  Accelerating climate shocks, emerging epidemics, and sweeping bilateral aid contractions threaten to roll back decades of hard-won progress. Yet Kerry, who was recently appointed WHO director-general’s special envoy for health resilience, argued that prevailing development models continue to repeat the mistake of fragmentation.  Donors routinely earmark billions separately for pandemic preparedness, noncommunicable diseases, and climate adaptation, without recognizing that all three initiatives rely on the exact same clinical staff, laboratories, and supply chains. Kerry called for a shift toward systemic resilience, underpinned by country ownership. Instead of forcing finance and health ministries to juggle dozens of disjointed bilateral programs and competing reporting frameworks, Kerry argues donors must rally around a streamlined principle: “One health plan, one budget that aligns to that health plan, and one reporting metric.”  In Uganda, this country-led approach to emergency medicine and triage training has cut the 24-hour mortality rate in emergency rooms by nearly 40%, Kerry said. As Silicon Valley heralds artificial intelligence as a potential leapfrog tool for low-resource health delivery, Kerry pushed for a vital dose of frontline reality. While AI algorithms and portable diagnostics hold genuine promise to empower clinicians, technology remains a multiplier — not a substitute. “You can’t multiply by zero,” Kerry warned. “If we don’t have the fundamental infrastructure and pieces in place ... it doesn’t matter how fast AI can take us. You need to have a health care worker that is holding the ultrasound.”  Beyond clinical logistics, Kerry insisted that compassionate care in moments of terror or bereavement remains an irreplaceable human transaction.

  3. Nov 3

    Why Republicans turned on USAID

    When former USAID Administrator Andrew Natsios looks at the recent dismantling of the agency he once led, he sees both a national security crisis and a bitter irony.  While Natsios believes U.S. foreign aid was due for a major overhaul, he blames a combination of pressures from outside the agency for undermining America’s commitment to long-term development. It was not the agency’s own failings that left it vulnerable, but a series of “clashes” between development and other power structures inside the U.S. government. Speaking on Devex’s Theory of Change podcast, he argued that the growth of the federal “counterbureaucracy” — oversight entities such as the Office of Management and Budget and rigid Federal Acquisition Regulations — paralyzed the agency long before it was formally disassembled. By forcing development officers to produce short-term quantifiable outputs and spend money rapidly, Washington made genuine, multiyear institution building nearly impossible. “What they’re asking us to do is two things which are diametrically opposed,” Natsios argued.  By demanding instant statistical proof of success while berating the agency for not offloading programs to partner governments, the counterbureaucracy trapped the U.S. Agency for International Development in an impossible double bind, Natsios said. The Republican former politician led the agency from 2001 to 2006, during the George W. Bush administration. His forthcoming book, “Guns Are Not Enough: Foreign Aid in the National Interest,” provides an intellectual framework for understanding how the U.S. development bureaucracy worked — and why it often didn’t. Natsios rejected the idea that Elon Musk’s dismantling of USAID through the Department of Government Efficiency was about government effectiveness or balancing the budget. Instead, he sees it as another example of backlashes that tend to follow socioeconomic crises in American history. “All of those previous events in American history were accompanied by massive isolationist, anti-immigrant, ultranationalist, protectionist, high tariff trends in American politics,” he said. He also shared his own theory for why U.S. foreign aid efforts struggle to garner public support from Americans — and his own experience accompanying the conservative media commentator Rush Limbaugh on an eye-opening trip to Afghanistan. Looking ahead, Natsios insisted that piecemeal fixes under the U.S. State Department will fail. Instead, he called for the creation of a cabinet-level, independent department that unifies the U.S. International Development Finance Corporation, the Millennium Challenge Corporation, and global health programs into a single operational agency.  Natsios sees Cold War-era breakthroughs such as the Green Revolution and South Korea's economic transformation as proof that America’s development work succeeded precisely when its mission directors had operational autonomy and field-level authority.

  4. Oct 27

    Do think tanks need a rethink?

    If a Washington, D.C., think tank publishes a voluminous policy paper, but barely anyone reads it, does it have an impact? Not really, according to Todd Moss, long-time development think tank leader and founder of the Energy for Growth Hub. Moss, who joined Devex’s Theory of Change podcast, sees a glaring mismatch between many organizations that claim to be in the business of informing policy decisions and the government officials who actually make those decisions. “The top 10 think tanks in the U.S. produced 1,500 reports last year,” Moss said, referencing recent estimates. “Some of them have real nuggets of wisdom, but lots of them are just incredibly boring and pointless, and no one will read them.” For Moss, the insistence on producing heavy reports and staging ceremonial public panels represents a deeper structural failure: losing sight of actual policy outcomes. Busy government officials, buried under back-to-back 15-minute meetings, rarely have the bandwidth to digest 14-page executive summaries, let alone full-length volumes.  What they need instead, he said, is clear decision memos, outside experts who understand institutional politics, and — in many cases — years of strategic patience. Moss points to a recent breakthrough his own organization contributed to by deploying that playbook: the World Bank’s decision to lift its long-standing ban on financing nuclear energy projects. Changing the mind of a notoriously risk-averse, multishareholder institution took seven years of painstaking mapping, cross-party coalition building, and direct engagement with inside allies, he said. “I was literally told, you will never be able to change this. We will never do this,” Moss said. “When I think about lessons from this, I think about tactics, alliances, and patience.”

  5. Oct 20

    How to talk about failure

    What happens when an organization built on maximum cost-effectiveness discovers that one of its flagship programs isn't delivering the results it promised? For Evidence Action, the answer was clear — if uncomfortable: follow the data, own the mistakes, and scale back. In a recent episode of Devex’s Theory of Change podcast, Evidence Action’s new CEO, Danielle Bayer, unpacked the nonprofit organization’s recent decision to wind down its Dispensers for Safe Water program across parts of East Africa, the backlash that followed, and what high-integrity implementation looks like in an evolving development landscape. “Most organizations choose to make decisions and keep them internal,” Bayer said. “In this particular instance, we not only said that the program didn't work as we thought it should, but also that we made mistakes here.” The decision to publicly air these operational mistakes sparked intense debate within the effective altruism and global development communities. While many praised the nonprofit's radical transparency, some critics questioned whether pointing to evidence was being used as a shield for poor implementation. Bayer was candid about the trade-offs: “Admitting mistakes is hard, and it may mean you lose trust with some funders and the public. The truth is all organizations make mistakes. If we're not being transparent, it’s not that mistakes aren't happening — it's just that people aren't sharing them.” She also spoke about what the future of cost-effectiveness looks like in the face of sharply declining global health aid, how Evidence Action codesigns programs with partner governments, and why she urges caution in the face of an upswell of interest in artificial intelligence.

  6. Oct 8

    Zipline's global drone delivery vision

    The California-based drone delivery company Zipline made waves last year when it secured a $150 million pay-for-performance grant from the U.S. State Department to scale up its operations in Africa. That announcement came just months after the State Department took control of the U.S. government’s foreign aid portfolio in the wake of USAID’s dismantling, and the deal with Zipline was portrayed as an emblem of the new direction of U.S. global health aid. One year later, Zipline is working through the sometimes arduous process of negotiating with partner country governments over the terms of their expansion. But the company’s ambitions extend well beyond the five African countries included in the State Department grant.  At the same time, a new partnership with Uber has the company poised for massive expansion inside the United States, from healthcare to consumer goods — driving estimates of Zipline’s potential valuation to $20 billion. Zipline is expanding into urban environments, launching its precision delivery platform in cities such as Kigali, Rwanda, while scaling healthcare partnerships in the U.S. with major institutions like the Cleveland Clinic and the Veterans Affairs hospital system. The same autonomous tech that delivers critical blood products in West Africa is now poised to power instant delivery for retail and food. Zipline’s Africa CEO and head of international expansion, Caitlin Burton, joined Devex’s Theory of Change podcast for a live recording at the Devex Impact House in New York. Burton shared the company’s growth story — from its origins in Rwanda to Uber Eats — and its planetary ambitions. “We have to grow way faster over the next five years than we did in the last five years,” Burton said. “We are just now getting to national scale in really, really, really important places. We need to do that in many, many more places.” Behind Zipline’s expansion plans, there is also a critique of legacy global health institutions and funding structures, which the company found resistant to what they could offer. “People were staking out territory instead of operating a system, and that was weird to us,” Burton said. “There are three things you really need in a health system: you need well-trained health workers that are compensated ... you need the drugs themselves, and then you need a way to get them to the patient,” Burton said. “Everyone seemed to have forgotten about the supply system.”

  7. Sep 29

    Live from UNGA with Buddy Shah

    In a live episode of the Theory of Change podcast, Buddy Shah, CEO of the Clinton Health Access Initiative and chair of the Anthropic Long Term Benefit Trust, shared an inside look at the intersection of global health, market-shaping agreements, and artificial intelligence. "The mistake that many of us are making ... is looking for an AI point solution. What's a cool use case where you can develop an AI tool and slot it into an existing system? And I think the much more important question is: If you could redesign the system for a world where you have very powerful AI tools, what would that look like?" Shah said during the podcast, which was recorded last week at the Devex Impact House in New York on the sidelines of the United Nations General Assembly.  Shah pulled back the curtain on CHAI’s landmark deal to secure generic manufacturing of lenacapavir — a twice-yearly injectable drug offering 99% effectiveness against HIV infection.  By negotiating the price down from $28,000 per year in the U.S. to $40 per patient per year in lower-income countries, Shah explained how CHAI, Gilead, generic manufacturers, and global health partners believe they are creating a path that could spell the end of HIV over the next decade. Addressing his dual role managing corporate governance at Anthropic, Shah previewed how artificial intelligence could fundamentally reshape health delivery in low- and middle-income countries through mobile diagnostics and AI clinical assistants.  He emphasized that LMICs may leapfrog high-income nations in adopting these technologies, while highlighting how incoming philanthropic capital from the AI sector could help fund major systemic solutions.

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
10 Ratings

About

Theory of Change is a podcast about the future of global development — and the people trying to reshape it. Hosted by Devex Senior Reporter Michael Igoe, the show features candid conversations with leaders in philanthropy, foreign policy, technology, finance, media, and humanitarian aid about the forces transforming how global change actually happens: power, politics, money, influence, and ideas. Not a panel. A conversation with a real person. Episodes are published every Tuesday. Subscribe to our YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@devex The podcast is produced by Devex Associate Editor Thomas Cserép and Mai Ylagan.

You Might Also Like