Shook by Ava

Shookbyava

If you’re fascinated by true crime, unexplained mysteries, UFO encounters, paranormal stories, internet rabbit holes, and the strangest corners of the internet, you’re in the right place.

  1. Oct 8

    Caleb Flynn Murder Case: American Idol, a Secret Affair & the Shocking Trial

    A former American Idol contestant, a secret affair, disturbing text messages, and a wife found murdered in her own home. In this episode of Shook by Ava, we're diving into the shocking true crime case of Caleb Flynn, the former American Idol contestant and worship pastor convicted of murdering his wife, Ashley Flynn, in Tipp City, Ohio. Caleb and Ashley appeared to have the perfect Christian marriage. They met at Lee University, married in 2010, and built a life together with their two young daughters. But behind closed doors, Caleb was involved in a secret relationship with a younger woman named Alleigha Botner. During Caleb Flynn's 2026 murder trial, prosecutors revealed thousands of messages between Caleb and Alleigha, including disturbing conversations about Ashley's death, ultimatums about divorce, and communications exchanged shortly before the murder. We'll explore how Caleb and Ashley met, the affair that threatened their marriage, Alleigha Botner's explosive courtroom testimony, the suspicious circumstances surrounding Ashley's murder, and the evidence that led to Caleb Flynn's guilty verdict. And one of the biggest questions surrounding this case: Why wasn't Alleigha Botner charged with anything? From the shocking 911 call to the courtroom revelations, this is the tragic story of Ashley Flynn and the murder case that captivated true crime audiences. Topics covered: Caleb Flynn trial, Ashley Flynn murder, Alleigha Botner testimony, American Idol contestant murder case, Caleb Flynn affair, 2026 true crime, and the Caleb Flynn guilty verdict. 🎙️ Listen now on Shook by Ava for the full story.

    Caleb Flynn Murder Case: American Idol, a Secret Affair & the Shocking Trial

  2. Sep 25

    They Survived TWO Mass Shootings: Stories of the Unthinkable Happening Twice

    What are the chances of surviving a mass shooting… only to experience another one? In this episode of Shook by Ava, we explore the documented stories of people who experienced more than one mass shooting—including survivors connected to the 2017 Route 91 Harvest Festival shooting in Las Vegas, the 2018 Borderline Bar & Grill shooting, the 2021 Oxford High School shooting, and the 2023 Michigan State University shooting. We follow the stories of Brendan Kelly, Telemachus “Tel” Orfanos, Jackie Matthews, Emma Riddle, and Kylie Ossege—including survivors who escaped two shootings only months apart, a Route 91 survivor who tragically lost his life during the second attack, and a teenager who survived being shot at Oxford High School before experiencing another campus shooting at Michigan State. These are stories of survival, trauma, coincidence, and the unimaginable reality of experiencing mass violence more than once. 🎧 In this episode: Route 91 Harvest Festival, Las Vegas shooting, Borderline Bar & Grill, Oxford High School, Michigan State University, mass shooting survivors, true crime, survivor stories, and unbelievable real-life events. Content warning: This episode discusses mass shootings, gun violence, death, injuries, and traumatic experiences. Listener discretion is advised. Follow Shook by Ava for more true crime, disturbing real-life stories, mysteries, and cases that will leave you shook.

    They Survived TWO Mass Shootings: Stories of the Unthinkable Happening Twice

  3. Sep 23

    True Crime & MLMs: The Disturbing Connections Behind Famous Murder Cases

    What do the Watts family murders, Jodi Arias, Amway conventions, Monat, and other disturbing true crime cases have in common? Multi-level marketing. In this episode of Shook by Ava, we’re diving into the strange and sometimes shocking connections between MLMs and true crime. We’ll look at Shanann Watts and her involvement with Thrive, how Jodi Arias and Travis Alexander met through Pre-Paid Legal, the murder of Monat mentor Alexis Sharkey, and several lesser-known cases where companies like Amway and Herbalife became intertwined with murder investigations. We’ll also explore the psychology behind MLMs—including social proof, sunk-cost fallacy, cognitive dissonance, community pressure, and the constant push to portray a successful, picture-perfect lifestyle online. In some of these cases, the MLM was simply part of someone's life. In others, it was how the people involved met, where the crime unfolded, or even part of an alleged cover story. ⚠️ MLM involvement does not cause violent behavior, and this episode does not suggest that these companies were responsible for the crimes discussed. Instead, we're examining the unusual connections MLM culture has had to several fascinating true crime cases. 🎙️ Cases discussed include: Shanann Watts, Jodi Arias & Travis Alexander, Alexis Sharkey, Preeta Gabba, Ben Novack Jr., Huang Baoying, and Ammasai. Keywords: true crime, MLM, multi level marketing, MLM true crime, Shanann Watts, Chris Watts, Thrive, Le-Vel, Jodi Arias, Travis Alexander, Pre-Paid Legal, LegalShield, Alexis Sharkey, Monat, Amway, Herbalife, MLM psychology, pyramid schemes, murder cases, Shook by Ava

    True Crime & MLMs: The Disturbing Connections Behind Famous Murder Cases

  4. Aug 20

    Hayden Panettiere: Her Life, Career, Struggles & Tragic Death at 36

    Hayden Panettiere spent nearly her entire life in the spotlight. From becoming a child actress and starring in Remember the Titans to her breakout role as Claire Bennet in Heroes, her unforgettable performance as Juliette Barnes in Nashville, and her fan-favorite role as Kirby Reed in the Scream franchise, Hayden built a career spanning more than three decades. But behind the success was a much more complicated story. In this episode of Shook by Ava, we look back at Hayden Panettiere's life and career, including growing up in Hollywood, motherhood and postpartum depression, her public battle with addiction, her relationship with Wladimir Klitschko, the difficult custody situation involving their daughter Kaya, her journey toward recovery, and the devastating loss of her younger brother Jansen. We also discuss Hayden's return to Hollywood, her decision to finally tell her own story, and her sudden death at just 36 years old. Rather than defining Hayden by the final chapter of her life, this episode looks at the entire story of a woman millions of us watched grow up on screen. Keywords: Hayden Panettiere, Hayden Panettiere podcast, Hayden Panettiere death, Hayden Panettiere life story, Hayden Panettiere career, Heroes, Nashville, Scream, Kirby Reed, Juliette Barnes, child stars, Hollywood, celebrity documentary #HaydenPanettiere #Heroes #Nashville #Scream #ShookByAva

    Hayden Panettiere: Her Life, Career, Struggles & Tragic Death at 36

  5. Jul 28

    Bigfoot & Other Cryptids Failed Human Experiments? | MKUltra, Dogman & The Dark Theory Explained

    What if Bigfoot, Dogman, the Rake, and other cryptids aren't mythical creatures at all... but the result of secret government experiments? In this episode of Shook by Ava, we're exploring one of the internet's most chilling conspiracy theories: the idea that cryptids may actually be failed human experiments that escaped into the wilderness. Could there be a connection between documented government programs like Project MKUltra, the legends surrounding the Montauk Project, and the mysterious creatures reported by hikers, hunters, and campers for decades? We'll examine the real history behind secret human experimentation, discuss why so many cryptids share surprisingly human characteristics, and explore how this theory has become one of the most talked-about ideas in the paranormal community. Throughout the episode, we'll separate documented historical facts from speculation, looking at where the evidence ends and where conspiracy theories begin. Whether you're fascinated by Bigfoot, Dogman, Skinwalkers, government conspiracies, or unsolved mysteries, this episode takes a deep dive into one of the most disturbing "what if" scenarios ever imagined. ⚠️ Disclaimer: This episode is intended for entertainment and discussion purposes. While it references real historical events such as Project MKUltra, the theory connecting cryptids to human experimentation is speculative and has not been proven. If you enjoy paranormal mysteries, conspiracy theories, and unexplained phenomena, be sure to follow the podcast so you never miss a new episode. Bigfoot, Cryptids, Dogman, MKUltra, Montauk Project, Human Experiments, Government Conspiracy, Paranormal, High Strangeness, Skinwalker, The Rake, Unsolved Mysteries, Secret Experiments, CIA, Mystery Podcast, Horror Podcast, Conspiracy Podcast

    Bigfoot & Other Cryptids Failed Human Experiments? | MKUltra, Dogman & The Dark Theory Explained

  6. Jul 24

    Emilie & Brady Kiser: The Police Report, Trigg's Drowning, and Why the Internet Turned on Them

    Emilie Kiser built a massive following by sharing her life as a wife, mother, and lifestyle influencer. But after the tragic drowning death of her three-year-old son, Trigg Kiser, public attention shifted from sympathy to scrutiny. In this episode, we examine the timeline of events surrounding Trigg's drowning, compare the family's public statements with details contained in the released police report, and discuss how social media reactions changed as more information became public. We'll cover: Emilie Kiser's rise as a social media influencerBrady Kiser's account of what happened that dayKey details documented in the police reportA resurfaced video that reignited online discussionHow public opinion shifted across TikTok, Instagram, Reddit, and other platformsThe difference between verified facts, police findings, and internet speculationThis episode is intended to examine publicly available information and encourage thoughtful discussion. The goal is to distinguish documented facts from rumors while exploring how social media can influence public perception during high-profile tragedies. If you enjoy deep dives into true crime, internet controversies, influencer news, and real-life cases, be sure to follow the podcast for new episodes every week. Emilie Kiser, Brady Kiser, Trigg Kiser, Trigg Kiser drowning, Emilie Kiser police report, Brady Kiser police report, Emilie Kiser case, Trigg Kiser case, influencer controversy, TikTok influencer, police report analysis, true crime podcast, internet controversy, social media backlash, Chandler Arizona, drowning investigation, influencer news, true crime commentary, crime analysis, internet investigations, viral controversy, public records, police documents, breaking internet news, high profile cases #EmilieKiser, #BradyKiser, #TriggKiser, #TrueCrime, #TrueCrimePodcast, #PoliceReport, #InternetControversy, #InfluencerNews, #TikTokNews, #SocialMedia, #CurrentEvents, #CrimeAnalysis, #TrueCrimeCommunity, #Podcast, #ShookByAva, #BreakingNews, #PublicRecords, #CaseAnalysis, #CrimeCommentary, #InternetCulture

    Emilie & Brady Kiser: The Police Report, Trigg's Drowning, and Why the Internet Turned on Them

  7. Jul 24

    The Rake or a Skinwalker? | A Grandfather's Terrifying True Encounter (User Submitted Story)

    What did this man's grandfather really encounter deep in the woods all those years ago? In this chilling user-submitted true horror story, a listener shares the terrifying experience their grandfather had with a mysterious creature that many believe resembles The Rake—while others insist it could have been a Skinwalker. What began as an ordinary night quickly turned into an encounter that would haunt him for the rest of his life. Was it simply an unknown animal... or something far more sinister? In this episode, we dive into every eerie detail, examine the similarities between descriptions of The Rake and Skinwalker legends, and leave it up to you to decide what was really lurking in the darkness. 👁️ Have a true scary story of your own? You can submit it for a chance to be featured in a future episode. If you enjoy true paranormal stories, cryptid encounters, Skinwalker sightings, The Rake, Appalachian horror, creepy camping stories, and unexplained mysteries, be sure to follow the podcast so you never miss a new episode. The Rake, The Rake creature, Skinwalker, True Skinwalker story, True Rake encounter, Cryptid encounter, Cryptid stories, True scary stories, Real horror stories, User submitted horror stories, Listener submitted stories, Paranormal podcast, Horror podcast, True paranormal encounters, Unexplained creature, Creepy woods story, Forest horror, Camping horror story, Appalachian horror, Native American legends, Creepy encounter, Supernatural experience, Real monster sightings, Unexplained mysteries, Dark stories, Scary podcast, Horror narration, Cryptozoology, Urban legends, Things seen in the woods, Creature sightings, Mysterious creatures, True cryptid encounters, Scary camping stories, Real supernatural stories, Horror narration podcast, Creepy true stories, Unexplained encounters, Monster in the woods, Night creature, Wilderness horror Hashtags #TheRake, #Skinwalker, #TrueScaryStories, #HorrorPodcast, #Paranormal, #Cryptids, #Cryptid, #ScaryStories, #TrueHorror, #CreepyStories, #UserSubmittedStories, #ListenerStories, #MonsterEncounter, #ParanormalPodcast, #Unexplained, #DarkStories, #ForestHorror, #Woods, #HorrorCommunity, #Scary, #Supernatural, #Creepy, #Cryptozoology, #Mystery, #UnsolvedMysteries, #NightmareFuel, #Storytime, #HorrorNarration, #ShookByAva, #Podcast

    The Rake or a Skinwalker? | A Grandfather's Terrifying True Encounter (User Submitted Story)

  8. Jul 6

    The Most Disturbing 911 Calls Ever Recorded | True Crime Cases Behind the Calls

    Some 911 calls capture the exact moment a normal day turns into a nightmare. In this episode of Shook by Ava, we explore some of the most disturbing 911 calls ever recorded and the chilling true crime stories behind them. These real emergency calls reveal moments of fear, survival, confusion, and tragedy — leaving listeners with haunting questions long after the call ends. We’ll dive into the background of each case, what led up to the emergency call, the investigation that followed, and the shocking details behind some of the most unforgettable moments in true crime history. From desperate calls for help to cases that took unexpected turns, these recordings show the reality behind some of the darkest moments people have experienced. ⚠️ Listener discretion is advised. This episode discusses real crimes, emergency situations, violence, and disturbing events that may be upsetting to some listeners. Topics: True Crime, 911 Calls, Disturbing Calls, Scariest 911 Calls, Emergency Calls, True Crime Stories, Crime Cases, Criminal Investigations, Real Life Horror, Unsolved Mysteries, Dark Stories, Shook by Ava. #TrueCrime #911Calls #Disturbing911Calls #ScaryStories #TrueCrimePodcast #CrimeStories #RealLifeHorror #TrueCrimeCommunity #DarkStories #CrimeDocumentary #MysteryPodcast #ShookByAva

    The Most Disturbing 911 Calls Ever Recorded | True Crime Cases Behind the Calls
See All (16)

About

If you’re fascinated by true crime, unexplained mysteries, UFO encounters, paranormal stories, internet rabbit holes, and the strangest corners of the internet, you’re in the right place.

Information

  • Creator
    Shookbyava
  • Years Active
    2026
  • Episodes
    16
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Shookbyava
  • Show Website
    Shook by Ava