Grey Tales

Cris Frickenschmidt

Mythology, folklore, legends. We all know and love them. But where did they come from? How did they evolve? How is everything connected. Let's dig in together. This is a journey into the stories that come from the darker days of old.

  1. 3d ago

    Mami Wata: The African Goddess Who Came from a German Circus Poster

    You'll find her on altars, masks and painted walls from Senegal to Tanzania: Mami Wata, Mother Water. She grants wealth, and in return she demands loyalty, sacrifice and sometimes your sanity. But her best-known image, a woman with long hair and snakes, isn't African at all. It goes back to a circus poster printed in Hamburg in the 1880s. In this episode, I follow that picture's trail: from a mask in Côte d'Ivoire, via a colour print from Bombay, all the way back to the world of Carl Hagenbeck's notorious "human zoos". And I try to find out who the woman on the poster really was. A photograph in a Hamburg archive calls her Samoan. On posters in Paris and New York, she was the Hindu snake charmer Nala Damajanti. And in 1887, a Paris newspaper revealed a very different name. Plus: the legends of the golden comb and the dangerous pact from Liberia, a German anthropologist who saw Minoan priestesses in a circus poster, and the question of who Mami Wata really belongs to. Sources Himmelheber, Hans & Ulrike (1958): Die Dan – ein Bauernvolk im westafrikanischen Urwald. Stuttgart: Kohlhammer. The comb story and wall paintings of the water mother among the Dan.Himmelheber, Hans (1965): Article in Paideuma 11, pp. 114–118. First demonstration that Mami Wata carvings derive from a printed image.Wintrob, Ronald M. (1970): Mammy Water: Folk Beliefs and Psychotic Elaborations in Liberia. Canadian Psychiatric Association Journal 15(2), pp. 143–157. Vai and Kissi accounts; psychiatric perspective.Drewal, Henry John (1988): Performing the Other: Mami Wata Worship in Africa. TDR 32(2), pp. 160–185. The image's spread across 14 countries and 41 cultural contexts.Frank, Barbara (1995): Permitted and Prohibited Wealth: Commodity-Possessing Spirits, Economic Morals, and the Goddess Mami Wata in West Africa. Ethnology 34(4), pp. 331–346. Wealth, pacts and their price.Van Stipriaan, Alex (2003): Watramama/Mami Wata: Three Centuries of Creolization of a Water Spirit in West Africa, Suriname and Europe. In: Collier & Fleischmann (eds.), A Pepper-Pot of Cultures. Amsterdam: Rodopi, pp. 323–337. The water mother in the diaspora.Drewal, Henry John (ed.) (2008): Mami Wata: Arts for Water Spirits in Africa and Its Diasporas. Los Angeles: Fowler Museum at UCLA. Exhibition catalogue; the first-contact origin thesis.Jell-Bahlsen, Sabine (2008): The Water Goddess in Igbo Cosmology: Ogbuide of Oguta Lake. Trenton: Africa World Press. A local water goddess as counter-perspective.Wendl, Tobias (2008): Trajektorien einer Ikone. Hans Himmelheber und die Erforschung des Mami Wata-Kults. Lecture, VDFAK spring conference, Munich (in German). The search for "Schleisinger", the Maladamatjaute photograph, Bonny 1901, reception history.Drewal, Henry John (2013): Beauteous Beast: The Water Deity Mami Wata in Africa. In: Mittman & Dendle (eds.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Monsters and the Monstrous. The Breitwieser lead, Indian imagery and Papi Wata.Lademann-Priemer, Gabriele (2013): Mami Wata – Muttergottheit und Verführerin, Helferin und Dämon. In: Kahl & Lademann-Priemer (eds.), Lebensstörungen und Heilungen. Hamburg: Missionshilfe Verlag (in German).Jell-Bahlsen, Sabine (2024): Mami Wata. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of African History. Overview and scholarly debate.Hagenbeck, Carl (1909): Von Tieren und Menschen. Berlin. His recollection of Nala Damajante (omitted from the 1912 English edition, Beasts and Men).Le Gaulois, 17 March 1887: Court report revealing the name Emilie Poupon.

    Mami Wata: The African Goddess Who Came from a German Circus Poster
  2. Nov 6

    The Children of Hamelin – What Really Happened on June 26, 1284 (Brothers Grimm series 5/5)

    On June 26, 1284, a hundred and thirty children left the German town of Hamelin. Not one came back. This isn't an invention of the Brothers Grimm: a church window, a record from 1384 and a fifteenth-century manuscript all remember it. But the oldest sources have no rats, no unpaid fee and no revenge. In the final episode of my Grimm series, I peel back the layers of the Pied Piper legend, ask when and why the rats were added, and go through the major theories: plague, dancing mania, the Children's Crusade and emigration to the east. There's no answer. But there is a street where, to this day, no music is played. 📚 Sources and Further Reading Wolfgang Mieder: The Pied Piper: A Handbook. Westport: Greenwood, 2007. → A comprehensive handbook on the legend, its sources and its reception. Robert Browning: "The Pied Piper of Hamelin." In: Dramatic Lyrics, 1842. → The best-known English-language version. Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm: Deutsche Sagen. 2 vols. Berlin, 1816/1818. No. 245: "Die Kinder zu Hameln." → The Grimms' version, compiled from eleven older sources. English translation in Donald Ward (ed. and trans.): The German Legends of the Brothers Grimm. Hans Dobbertin: Quellensammlung zur Hamelner Rattenfängersage. Göttingen: Schwartz, 1970. → The foundational edition of the sources. (German) Hans Dobbertin: Quellenaussagen zur Rattenfängersage. Hameln: Niemeyer, 1996. → An expanded source collection with Dobbertin's own interpretation. (German) Jürgen Udolph: "Zogen die Hamelner Aussiedler nach Mähren? Die Rattenfängersage aus namenkundlicher Sicht." Niedersächsisches Jahrbuch für Landesgeschichte 69 (1997), pp. 125–183. → The place-name argument for the eastward-settlement theory. (German)

    The Children of Hamelin – What Really Happened on June 26, 1284 (Brothers Grimm series 5/5)
  3. Oct 31

    Cursed: A Roman Ring, a Death Chair and a Painting That Won't Burn. My Halloween special 2026!

    A gold ring from Roman Britain with a thief's name engraved on it. A pub chair that killed everyone who sat in it. A purple stone locked away in seven boxes. And a cheap print of a crying child that, in 1985, half of Britain was afraid to keep at home. For this Halloween special, I'm telling four short stories about cursed objects. First the legends, the way their believers tell them. Then a quick look at what's really behind each one: a Roman curse tablet that still exists, a chair that turned out to be 140 years too young, a horror writer who may have staged his own curse, and a tabloid panic that ended in a bonfire. Four objects, four storytellers. And the question I keep coming back to on this channel: who tells a story, and why? Sleep well… Yours, Cris Sources R. G. Collingwood, "Inscriptions" (1932), in R. E. M. and T. V. Wheeler, Report on the Excavation of the Prehistoric, Roman and Post-Roman Site in Lydney Park, Gloucestershire. Publishes the Silvianus curse tablet and the faint "rediviva" addition.J. R. R. Tolkien, "The Name 'Nodens'" (1932), appendix to the same Lydney report. Tolkien's study of the god's name, the link between Lydney and Middle-earth.Francis Haverfield, "Further remarks on the Ring of Senicianus" (1888–89), Transactions of the Bristol & Gloucestershire Archaeological Society. An early warning against linking ring and tablet on the strength of a name alone.Chaloner W. Chute, A History of The Vyne in Hampshire (1888). The family history that first set the ring and the curse side by side.William Grainge, The Vale of Mowbray (1859). Local history recording the 1702 murder of Daniel Auty by Thomas Busby.Stuart Minting, "18th Century murderer's chair continues to captivate supernatural fans", The Northern Echo (2014). Reports the furniture historian's dating of the chair to around 1840.Natural History Museum, London, behind-the-scenes blog on the cursed amethyst. Full text of Heron-Allen's 1904 letter and the curators' view that the curse was likely invented.Christopher Blayre (Edward Heron-Allen), "The Purple Sapphire" (1921). The short story the curse may have been staged to promote.Massimo Polidoro, "Curse That Painting!", Skeptical Inquirer (2012). Overview of the Crying Boy panic of 1985.Punt PI, BBC Radio 4, Series 3, Episode 4 (2010). Steve Punt's fire tests on original Crying Boy prints.David Clarke on the Crying Boy curse, Squaring the Strange podcast, episode 141. On the late origin of the Don Bonillo legend. #GreyTales #CursedObjects #Halloween #Folklore #HauntedObjects

    Cursed: A Roman Ring, a Death Chair and a Painting That Won't Burn. My Halloween special 2026!
  4. Oct 30

    Were Hansel and Gretel Murderers? The Satire Half of Germany Believed (Grimm series 4/5)

    Hansel and Gretel were really two adult bakers who murdered a rival in the Spessart forest in 1647 to steal her gingerbread recipe. That's what a 1963 book claimed, and half of Germany believed it. The catch: it was a satire by the cartoonist Hans Traxler. In episode 4 of my Grimm series, I look at invented origins: from the Baker Witch to the Snow White of Lohr, which started as an April Fool's joke among tavern regulars and now appears on highway signs, to the question of why one region of Hesse calls itself Little Red Riding Hood Country. And why fairy tales so badly need a home address. 📚 Sources and Further Reading Vanessa Joosen: Critical and Creative Perspectives on Fairy Tales: An Intertextual Dialogue between Fairy-Tale Scholarship and Postmodern Retellings. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 2011. → Includes an analysis of Traxler's book as a "fictive nonfictional text." Donald Haase (ed.): The Reception of Grimms' Fairy Tales: Responses, Reactions, Revisions. Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1993. → Discusses the reception of Traxler's hoax among other responses to the Grimms. Tim Harford: "The Truth About Hansel and Gretel." Cautionary Tales podcast, October 2021. → An English-language podcast episode on Traxler's satire. Christine Shojaei Kawan: "Innovation, Persistence and Self-Correction: The Case of Snow White." Estudos de Literatura Oral 11–12 (2005–2006), pp. 237–252. → On the international tradition of Snow White and attempts to localize it. Hans Traxler: Die Wahrheit über Hänsel und Gretel. Frankfurt am Main: Bärmeier & Nikel, 1963 (new edition Stuttgart: Reclam, 2007). → The satire itself; the new edition includes an appendix on its origins and reception. (German) Wolfgang Vorwerk: "Das 'Lohrer Schneewittchen'. Zur Fabulologie eines Märchens." In: Christian Grandl / Kevin J. McKenna (eds.): Bis dat, qui cito dat. Festschrift for Wolfgang Mieder. Frankfurt am Main: Peter Lang, 2015, pp. 491–503. → The detailed origin story of Snow White of Lohr, by a member of the Lohr circle. Available online via the town of Lohr. (German) Bernhard Lauer: "Wem gehört 'Schneewittchen'?" Hessische Blätter für Volks- und Kulturforschung 44 (2009), pp. 390–425. → A folklorist's view of the places that claim Snow White. (German) Eckhard Sander: Schneewittchen. Märchen oder Wahrheit? Gudensberg-Gleichen: Wartberg, 1994. → The Margaretha von Waldeck and Bergfreiheit thesis. (German) Hans Moser: "Vom Folklorismus in unserer Zeit." Zeitschrift für Volkskunde 58 (1962). → The essay that introduced the concept of folklorism. (German)

    Were Hansel and Gretel Murderers? The Satire Half of Germany Believed (Grimm series 4/5)
  5. Oct 23

    Little Red Riding Hood: Werewolves, Cannibalism and a Girl Who Saves Herself (Grimm series 3/5)

    In the Grimms' version, a huntsman saves Little Red Riding Hood. In Perrault's, she's eaten. But in a peasant tale from Burgundy, recorded in the 1880s, the girl eats her own grandmother's flesh, undresses in front of a werewolf, and in the end saves herself. In episode 3 of our Grimm series, we dig for the dark roots of Little Red Riding Hood: from a Latin schoolbook written around 1023, through the Paris salons of Charles Perrault, to a study that analyzes fairy tales with the tools of evolutionary biology. And we ask whether that ancient oral tradition ever really existed, or whether it's a fairy tale itself. 📚 Sources and Further Reading Jamshid J. Tehrani: "The Phylogeny of Little Red Riding Hood." PLOS ONE 8/11 (2013), e78871. → The family-tree study of Little Red Riding Hood and related tales. Open access. Jan M. Ziolkowski: "A Fairy Tale from before Fairy Tales: Egbert of Liège's 'De puella a lupellis seruata' and the Medieval Background of 'Little Red Riding Hood'." Speculum 67/3 (1992). → The key study of Egbert's girl among the wolves. Ruth B. Bottigheimer: Fairy Tales: A New History. Albany: State University of New York Press, 2009. → The counter-thesis of a book-based history of fairy tales. Journal of American Folklore 123, no. 490 (2010). → Responses to Bottigheimer by Dan Ben-Amos, Francisco Vaz da Silva and Jan M. Ziolkowski. Alan Dundes (ed.): Little Red Riding Hood: A Casebook. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 1989. → A collection of key texts and interpretations, including an English translation of the Story of Grandmother. Paul Delarue / Marie-Louise Tenèze: Le Conte populaire français. Vol. 1, Paris 1957, further volumes to 1985. → The great catalogue of French folk tales in which Delarue published the Story of Grandmother. (French) Yvonne Verdier: "Grands-mères, si vous saviez… Le Petit Chaperon rouge dans la tradition orale." Cahiers de Littérature orale 4 (1978). → The ethnological reading of the needles and pins. (French; full text available via the BnF) Yvonne Verdier: Façons de dire, façons de faire. La laveuse, la couturière, la cuisinière. Paris: Gallimard, 1979. → The village study from Minot on which her reading is based. (French) Charles Perrault: Histoires ou contes du temps passé. Paris, 1697. → Perrault's original, with its verse moral. Public domain, widely available online and in translation.

    Little Red Riding Hood: Werewolves, Cannibalism and a Girl Who Saves Herself (Grimm series 3/5)
  6. Oct 16

    Rapunzel Was Pregnant – The Pages the Brothers Grimm Cut (Grimm series part 2/5)

    Nothing added, nothing embellished: that's what the Brothers Grimm promised in the preface to their fairy tales. At the same time, they rewrote their book again and again over nearly half a century and seven editions. In episode 2 of our Grimm series, we lay the versions side by side: how Rapunzel's pregnancy disappeared, how Snow White's mother became a stepmother, why Rumpelstiltskin ends three different ways, and why Cinderella's sisters only lost their eyes in 1819. Plus the big debate: were the Grimms preservers, editors or forgers? 📚 Sources and Further Reading Maria Tatar: The Hard Facts of the Grimms' Fairy Tales. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1987 (expanded 2nd edition 2003). → On how violence increased across the editions while sexuality was erased. A very readable entry point. Ruth B. Bottigheimer: Grimms' Bad Girls and Bold Boys: The Moral and Social Vision of the Tales. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1987. → A quantitative analysis of punishment, speech and silence among female and male characters. John M. Ellis: One Fairy Story Too Many: The Brothers Grimm and Their Tales. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1983. → The controversial argument that the Grimms deliberately misrepresented their sources. Jack Zipes: "Mountains out of Mole Hills, a Fairy Tale." Children's Literature 13 (1985), pp. 215–219. → A critical response to Ellis. Jack Zipes (trans.): The Original Folk and Fairy Tales of the Brothers Grimm: The Complete First Edition. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2014. → The 1812/1815 texts in English, including the tales later dropped, so you can compare them with the familiar versions yourself. D. L. Ashliman: Rumpelstilzchen von den Brüdern Grimm – a comparison of the 1810, 1812 and 1819 versions. University of Pittsburgh (online). Ashliman's site also offers English translations of several Grimm tales in multiple versions. → The three versions side by side, sentence by sentence. (German texts) Heinz Rölleke (ed.): Die älteste Märchensammlung der Brüder Grimm. Synopse der handschriftlichen Urfassung von 1810 und der Erstdrucke von 1812. Cologny-Genève: Fondation Martin Bodmer, 1975. → The basis for any comparison between the manuscript and the first printed edition. (German) Heinz Rölleke: Die Märchen der Brüder Grimm. Eine Einführung. Stuttgart: Reclam, 2004. → Overview of the editing style, the stylistic ideal and the relationship between Jacob and Wilhelm. (German) Lothar Bluhm / Heinz Rölleke: "Redensarten des Volks, auf die ich immer horche." Märchen – Sprichwort – Redensart. Stuttgart/Leipzig: Hirzel, 1997 (expanded new edition, Trier: WVT, 2020). → The key study of Wilhelm's insertion of idioms and proverbs. (German) Lothar Bluhm: Märchen als Literatur aus Literatur. Die "Kinder- und Hausmärchen" der Brüder Grimm. Berlin: Metzler, 2023. → Reads the collection as the product of a deliberate literary design. (German) Hans-Jörg Uther: Handbuch zu den Kinder- und Hausmärchen der Brüder Grimm. Berlin: de Gruyter, 2008. → Standard reference on the versions of every single tale. (German)

    Rapunzel Was Pregnant – The Pages the Brothers Grimm Cut (Grimm series part 2/5)
  7. Oct 9

    The Old Woman Who Never Was: Who Really Told the Grimms Their Fairy Tales (Grimm 1/5)

    Little Red Riding Hood, Sleeping Beauty, Snow White: ancient German folk tales, passed down by old peasant women at the spinning wheel? Not quite. In the first episode of our five-part Grimm series, we ask who actually told the Brothers Grimm their fairy tales. We follow a manuscript that traveled through a Trappist monastery in Alsace all the way to Geneva, watch Heinz Rölleke bury a star witness who never existed, and look behind the most famous portrait in German fairy-tale history. 📚 Sources and Further Reading Heinz Rölleke (ed.): Die älteste Märchensammlung der Brüder Grimm. Synopse der handschriftlichen Urfassung von 1810 und der Erstdrucke von 1812. Cologny-Genève: Fondation Martin Bodmer, 1975. → The standard edition of the Ölenberg manuscript, setting the 1810 manuscript beside the 1812 first edition. Replaced the older Lefftz edition. Heinz Rölleke: "Die 'stockhessischen' Märchen der 'Alten Marie'. Das Ende eines Mythos um die frühesten KHM-Aufzeichnungen der Brüder Grimm." Germanisch-Romanische Monatsschrift N.F. 25 (1975), pp. 74–86. → The article that dismantled the "Old Marie" attribution and identified Marie Hassenpflug as the contributor. (German) Heinz Rölleke: Die Märchen der Brüder Grimm. Eine Einführung. Stuttgart: Reclam, 2004. → Concise overview of how the collection came about, who contributed and how the texts were edited. (German) Joseph Lefftz (ed.): Märchen der Brüder Grimm. Urfassung nach der Originalhandschrift der Abtei Ölenberg im Elsaß. Heidelberg: Winter, 1927. → The first complete edition of the Ölenberg manuscript. Superseded by Rölleke 1975, but important for the history of research. (German) Holger Ehrhardt (ed.): Dorothea Viehmann. Kassel: Euregio, 2012. → Collected volume on Viehmann's life and tales, with contributions by Heinz Rölleke and others, including an essay on French influences in her stories. (German) Holger Ehrhardt: "Ein übersehenes Märchen von Dorothea Viehmann." Fabula 64 (2023), no. 3–4, pp. 243–281. → Argues that "The White Bride and the Black Bride" goes back to Viehmann, based on newly found early manuscripts. (German) University of Kassel: press release on the discovery of 54 previously unknown early Grimm manuscripts, December 2023. → Background on the new manuscript finds. (German) Hans-Jörg Uther: Handbuch zu den Kinder- und Hausmärchen der Brüder Grimm. Berlin: de Gruyter, 2008. → Standard reference on every tale in the collection, its sources and versions. (German) For English-language readers: Jack Zipes' translation of the 1812/1815 first edition, "The Original Folk and Fairy Tales of the Brothers Grimm" (Princeton University Press, 2014), includes the tales later removed, such as Bluebeard and Puss in Boots. The Ölenberg manuscript can be viewed in digitized form at e-codices, the Virtual Manuscript Library of Switzerland.

    The Old Woman Who Never Was: Who Really Told the Grimms Their Fairy Tales (Grimm 1/5)
  8. Oct 2

    Disney Was Offered Ireland's Folklore Archive, and Took the Leprechaun! (Ireland 2/2)

    Last week we told the old stories. Today we ask who wrote them. The leprechaun probably isn't named after his "little body" at all, but after Roman priests whom Irish monks took for a race of wolf-men. His oldest story is a teaching tale about the law of distraint. In the nineteenth century he wore red, not green. The book that made him famous was lost by its editor and rewritten by his friends, and then translated by the Brothers Grimm. And when Walt Disney was offered Ireland's greatest folklore archive, he chose an American children's book instead. Sources — Jacopo Bisagni, "Leprechaun: a new etymology", Cambrian Medieval Celtic Studies 64 (2012), pp. 47–84. The core source for this episode. Shows that the oldest manuscript form is lupracán, argues that the "little body" reading is linguistically very hard to sustain, and derives the word from the Luperci, whom Irish scholars, via Augustine, understood as a race of shapeshifters. Also contains the critique of Binchy's eighth-century dating of the Fergus saga. — D. A. Binchy, "The Saga of Fergus mac Léti", Ériu 16 (1952), pp. 33–48. The standard edition of the Fergus saga; source of the traditional etymology and dating. — Neil McLeod, "Fergus mac Léti and the Law", Ériu 61 (2011), pp. 1–28. Shows that the Fergus saga was constructed as a legal teaching tale on distraint. — Simon Rodway, "Mermaids, Leprechauns, and Fomorians: A Middle Irish Account of the Descendants of Cain", Cambrian Medieval Celtic Studies 59 (2010), pp. 1–17. Edition of the tale of Ambia the siren and Becnait, mother of the leprechauns. — Diarmuid Ó Giolláin, "An Leipreachán san Ainmníocht", Béaloideas 50 (1982), pp. 126–150, and "The Leipreachán and Fairies, Dwarfs and the Household Familiar: A Comparative Study", Béaloideas 52 (1984), pp. 75–150. The foundational folkloristic study, based on more than three hundred manuscripts from the Irish folklore archives; places the leprechaun with dwarfs and household spirits rather than the fairy host. — Maureen Murphy, "Croker, Thomas Crofton", Dictionary of Irish Biography. Source for the lost manuscript, the co-authors, the edition history and the later criticism. — Thomas Keightley, The Fairy Mythology (later edition). Contains Keightley's admission that he invented The Soul Cages from a legend collected by the Brothers Grimm. — Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm (trans.), Irische Elfenmärchen, Leipzig 1826. Translation of Croker's collection with the introduction "Über die Elfen". — Frank Kinahan, "Armchair Folklore: Yeats and the Textual Sources of Fairy and Folk Tales of the Irish Peasantry", Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 83C (1983), pp. 255–267. Traces Yeats's fairy classification back through McAnally to O'Hanlon. — Tony Tracy, "When Disney Met Delargy: 'Darby O'Gill' and the Irish Folklore Commission", Béaloideas 78 (2010), pp. 44–60. The main source for the Killarney chapter. — Diane Negra (ed.), The Irish in Us: Irishness, Performativity, and Popular Culture, Durham 2006. Background for reading the modern leprechaun as a descendant of anti-Irish caricature. — General Mills, "The History of Lucky Charms"; Atlas Obscura on Waldo the Wizard. Sources for the launch and temporary replacement of the Lucky Charms mascot. — Dáil Éireann, debate of 11 December 1963. John A. Costello's criticism of Irish tourist advertising. Next episode: the start of our series on the Brothers Grimm.

    Disney Was Offered Ireland's Folklore Archive, and Took the Leprechaun! (Ireland 2/2)

About

Mythology, folklore, legends. We all know and love them. But where did they come from? How did they evolve? How is everything connected. Let's dig in together. This is a journey into the stories that come from the darker days of old.