The FIR Podcast Network Everything Feed

The FIR Podcast Network Everything Feed

Subscribe to receive every episode of every show on the FIR Podcast Network

  1. 1d ago

    FIR #536: The New Phase of AI Adoption is All About Behaviors

    AI may save one employee time while leaving colleagues with hours of cleanup. It can also make managers less trusting, persuade experts to abandon sound judgments, and replace the everyday conversations through which people learn from one another. A growing body of research suggests that the next wave of workplace AI challenges has as much to do with human behavior as with the technology itself. In this short midweek FIR episode, Neville and Shel examine four emerging challenges: the trust penalty attached to AI use, the hidden cost of correcting AI-generated work, “persuasion bombing,” and weakening connections between colleagues. They also consider how AI could reshape organizational authority, and whether keeping a human in the loop offers much protection when that person lacks the time, confidence, or expertise to challenge the output. For communicators, the implications extend well beyond announcing new tools or sharing productivity success stories. Shel and Neville discuss making AI practices visible, equipping managers, protecting human relationships, and measuring the work AI creates alongside the time it saves. Are organizations becoming more productive, or simply getting faster at passing work to someone else? Links from this episode: Using ChatGPT at work? Your boss may trust you less, new study finds The future of the firm Clutch Report: 76% of Workers Ask AI the Questions They Are Too Embarrassed to Ask Coworkers AI’s ‘Persuasion Bombing’ Can Make Experts Question Themselves Workers losing a day a week fixing ‘AI slop,’ study finds AI’s Hidden Cost: Nearly Half Face Rising Workloads Amid Widespread Burnout, Study Finds AI errors hitting business finances and delaying projects globally Why is AI accelerating work but not improving it? Our research with 9,500+ workers explains the AI transformation gap AI risks widening the workplace divide, new report finds Implementing AI: How Companies Might Manage — Even Avoid — Employee Burnout AI Employees Excel at Tasks but Lack Organizational Awareness Five traps to avoid when using AI in the workplace When AI enters the org chart, who really holds the power? The next monthly, long-form episode of FIR is tentatively scheduled to drop on Monday, November 30. We host a Communicators Zoom Chat most Thursdays at 1 p.m. ET. To obtain the credentials needed to participate, contact Shel or Neville directly, request them in our Facebook group, or email fircomments@gmail.com. Special thanks to Jay Moonah for the opening and closing music. You can find the stories from which Shel’s FIR content is selected at Shel’s Link Blog. You can catch up with both co-hosts on Neville’s blog and Shel’s blog. Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this podcast are Shel’s and Neville’s and do not reflect the views of their employers and/or clients. Raw Transcript: Neville Hobson: Hi, everyone, and welcome to For Immediate Release. This is episode 536. I’m Neville Hobson. Shel Holtz: And I’m Shel Holtz. That first wave of issues AI created for employees and leaders was easy to name: hallucinations, data leaks, copyright. Neville, you and I reported on all of these. But a second wave is arriving, and it has less to do with the technology than with how people behave when they’re using it and when they’re around it. Communication is all about influencing behavior. That puts this squarely in our territory. I went through a pile of new research over the last week, and four challenges stood out. I’ll tell you what they are, then what I think internal communications might be able to do about them. The first challenge I’m calling the “trust penalty.” Researchers at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem published six studies in The Leadership Quarterly on how supervisors react when they know an employee used AI. In one experiment, supervisors trusted an employee’s report of time spent on a task 68% of the time when the employee did the work independently. When the employee used AI, only 24% of supervisors trusted that report. The supervisors weren’t judging the quality of the work. They just knew AI was involved. But when the organization specifically encouraged AI use, that penalty shrank until it was no longer statistically significant. When AI was prohibited, or there was no policy at all, supervisors penalized it. Silence works like a ban, which may explain a survey commissioned by Arden University that found 53% of workers don’t even tell their supervisors how they use AI. Second is the “cleanup tax.” That same Arden University survey of 2,000 working adults found that 46% of workers fix colleagues’ AI mistakes, taking an average of about seven hours a week. Neville, you and I have talked about producing AI slop at work. It may improve the productivity of the employee producing it, but there’s lost productivity downstream among the people who have to use it and fix it. Hubstaff, which sells time-tracking software, surveyed about 1,100 U.S. employees. Forty-six percent of AI users say their expected workload has increased since they started using it. Only 5% say it has decreased. Sixty-nine percent reported burnout in the past year, and 55% told their manager they were fine when they weren’t. Hubstaff itself notes that the data doesn’t prove AI causes burnout. A survey of 411 business leaders from Paligo found that 70% say an enterprise AI application gave a materially wrong answer or took a materially wrong action at least monthly. Yet only 27% measure the time spent verifying the accuracy of those AI outputs. We count the time saved. We don’t count the time spent cleaning up. A UCLA Anderson piece adds the management angle: When employees are ranked against one another, AI-boosted output basically raises the bar for everyone. Third is “persuasion bombing.” A Harvard Business School working paper analyzed about 5,000 prompts from 72 Boston Consulting Group consultants checking AI output. When the consultants challenged a wrong answer, the AI often didn’t back down. It leaned on claimed credibility, used flattery, and presented precise-sounding numbers. Sometimes it reinforced wrong conclusions. Sometimes it talked consultants out of recommendations the data actually supported. Co-author Steven Randazzo put it this way: AI may still be driving the car. A human in the loop isn’t enough if that human can be talked out of being right. Fourth, we’re turning to each other less. This is another issue we’ve mentioned in at least one previous episode. In a survey of 669 U.S. workers, 76% had asked AI a work question they were too embarrassed to ask a colleague. Fifty-seven percent say AI is creating silos on their teams, and 51% report fewer check-ins from teammates. Miro’s survey of more than 9,500 people found that 69% say most AI-assisted work happens in private sessions, which the report identifies as the main reason gains from AI don’t scale across the organization. A PA Consulting survey of 2,000 U.K. employees found that 70% of senior leaders say AI lets them do things they couldn’t do before, but only 38% of junior staff say the same thing. What do we do? You know I love my lists. Here are three things. First, get leadership support for AI use in writing. Repeat it over and over, and equip managers to talk about it. Treat manager enablement as a communications deliverable, because the manager’s reaction is where employees actually experience those penalties. Second, make AI work visible and verification a shared standard. Showcase real examples on the intranet, including what got checked and what got fixed. Demonstrate how AI slop costs time further down the chain. Disclosure becomes normal, and private sessions become shared practice. Third, help leadership measure the right things. Push for tracking review time, rework, and workload, not just hours saved. Tell employees how the time they save will be used. If the answer is just more work, they’re going to figure that out anyway, but it’s better that they hear it from us. Protect the human channels: mentoring, check-ins, and a norm that says it’s fine to ask a real person the question you need answered. Neville, I’m curious what you’re hearing about this trust penalty on your side of the pond. Neville Hobson: It’s fascinating going through all the articles you shared. What struck me most, in a summary view, is that we’re seeing evidence that AI can make individuals more productive while creating additional work for their colleagues. It can help people access information while weakening the relationships through which organizational knowledge is shared. It can produce extraordinarily convincing work while undermining the expertise we need to judge whether that work is any good. You alluded to that in what you were saying. For me, the common thread is that AI adoption is becoming a much bigger organizational communication challenge than many people have recognized. I have one specific question to start with, a devil’s advocate view, I suppose. Think about all the metrics you quoted. Are we seeing a new version of the old obsession with measuring outputs rather than outcomes? Is that what we’re looking at? Should communicators challenge how their organizations define and measure AI productivity? Those are points that need answers. Shel Holtz: I agree 100%. We need to look at what we’re measuring and how we’re measuring it. A lot of organizations have gone into this expecting it to improve productivity, and that’s what they’re looking for. They’re looking for it from the people using AI. Nobody is looking downstream at the people who receive those outputs and have to spend seven hours a week correcting them. That adds to their workload and burnout. I’m not suggesting we shouldn’t measure productivity improvements. Absolutely, we should. But we need to figure out whether those imp

  2. 2d ago

    OTSP #12: When the CEO is the Crisis

    When a company’s identity is wrapped around a beloved CEO, a sudden departure under a cloud raises questions that a leadership announcement alone cannot answer. What should employees be told while an investigation continues? What happens to corporate values if the person at the top appears exempt from them? And who should be communicating when the board is making the decisions? Jensen Huang’s departure from NVIDIA provides the starting point for a broader discussion about employee trust, leadership accountability, and preparing for a crisis involving the CEO. In this episode of “On the Same Page,” Shel and Mark explore how to communicate internally during an abrupt leadership transition. They discuss explaining what is known and what remains uncertain, listening before assuming what employees are worried about, and connecting leadership decisions to the organization’s values and code of conduct. They also examine the board’s responsibility to communicate with employees, the risks of leaving an information vacuum, and how a new CEO’s first days can establish trust through visibility, listening, and consistent action. Links from this episode: NVIDIA Announces CEO Transition A Message to Our Company Read Nvidia’s internal emails about Jensen Huang * Nvidia employees petition for Jensen Huang’s return * Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigns after reports of affair and extramarital relationships Nvidia’s board is still investigating Jensen Huang despite his resignation, sources say Jensen Huang, an architect of the AI boom, resigns as Nvidia CEO Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang Resigns After Multiple Affairs, Including With Alleged Chinese Spy Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigns: Live updates Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang resigns in wake of affair, spy scandal The resignation of Jensen Huang from Nvidia and everything that has followed What Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang said in email as board launches probe NVIDIA Board Opens Investigation Into CEO Jensen Huang After Affair Admission Nvidia probe into CEO affair raises thorny * ‘Stay, with less’: Why Nvidia’s board may rein in Jensen Huang rather than fire him Embattled Nvidia Chief Turns to Heller Inc. * Nvidia’s Jensen Huang crisis tests the limits of CEO personal branding When the Big Boss Behaves Badly: 3 Things HR Wants to Do in Wake of Nvidia Scandal Jensen Huang Admits Affair: When the EVP Wears a Leather Jacket What Founders Can Learn From Nvidia’s Board Crisis and Interim Leadership Handoff 60% of Professionals Say Jensen Huang Should Remain Nvidia CEO Amid Affair Scandal, Blind Survey Finds Course Notes: Aligning your comms strategy during leadership changes How to get ahead of speculation in leadership transitions What to Do in the First Week After a CEO Resigns When the CEO Is Fired: How to Handle Workers’ Angst Following the founder Nvidia employees rich, happy, problem, insiders say * The Vast Majority of OpenAI Employees Ask the Board to Resign Raw Transcript: Shel Holtz: Hey, Mark, how’s everything? Mark Dollins: All is well, Shel. How about you? Shel Holtz: Everything is great here. We’re going to have a great conversation today. Before we jump into that, though, I’d like to read a couple of the comments we’ve gotten. I’ve been reticent in pulling up the comments so that we have the comments from the last episode ready for this episode. But I do have one comment from Episode 11, and then from Episode 10 there was one that asked a question. So I thought we’d cover that one too. Mark Dollins: Okay, we love questions. Shel Holtz: In Episode 11, we were talking about how to reach the front line. Heiko Scherer writes, “Glad you push back on the idea that the frontline staff only cares about schedules and pay. In most crews, the company news gets read too. It just has to show up where they already are.” Mark Dollins: Sounds like violent agreement. Shel Holtz: Yes, you’ll get no argument from us. In Episode 10, we were talking about some research that showed employees’ trust in each other has been falling. Stephen Smith writes, “Coworker trust is the layer most change plans skip because it’s below the org chart. When AI output lands on a colleague’s desk needing rework, the cost isn’t just time. It is a small judgment about whether that person can be relied on. Internal strategic communications can help by making the new norms explicit, like who checks what before work is passed on.” And then he asks, “Did Mark see teams getting those ground rules well?” Mark Dollins: A good question, and thank you for asking it. The answer is yes. Teams are increasingly holding each other accountable for any use of AI. Number one, to disclose: Did you use AI in creating this deliverable? Number two: Did you check the facts represented in this against other sources to make sure it’s accurate? And then, third, take a step back and look at the whole thing and say, “Does this really make sense?” We all know AI makes mistakes. It doesn’t always follow clear logic in some cases. What I’m finding is that teams increasingly don’t want to have to deal with, A, the rework, and, B, the distrust it creates with a colleague who does something and then just hits the send button without taking ownership and accountability for what’s in it. I think that’s going to become the new norm. And if it isn’t, it really should, very quickly. Shel Holtz: I couldn’t agree more. Thanks for those questions. Really appreciate it. I promise to do a better job of sharing the comments we get on the next episode. But let’s jump into our topic this week. Wow, what a week it has been. On Thursday, NVIDIA announced that Jensen Huang, who co-founded the company back in 1993, had resigned as CEO, president, and board member, effective immediately. The filing didn’t give any reason for his leaving, but here’s the timeline. You’ve probably heard most of this, but just in case you’ve been under a rock: On Sunday, Huang told employees he’d been unfaithful to his wife. The same day, the board announced an independent investigation and said it had confidence in him. By Wednesday night, the board was meeting about his future. Thursday morning, he was gone. All of this, of course, followed the revelations made about two weeks earlier that he had been having a relationship with somebody who was, at the finding of the U.S. government, a Chinese intelligence asset. They called her a spy. I’m not so sure that’s exactly right, as much as somebody they recruited to get close to Huang and be able to share information she gets from him. For our purposes, what we’re looking at is four days from the board saying, “We have confidence,” to “Effective immediately.” Wired puts the cost at a trillion dollars in market value since these allegations surfaced. Much of this is reported, not necessarily established as fact. Huang admitted the infidelity. By the way, we’re talking about not just the Chinese intelligence asset, who’s the CEO of a company in Singapore—if we were a tech podcast, we’d get into a lot more of those details—but also what looks like a couple, maybe even a few, relationships with subordinates in the organization, including somebody who reported directly to him. The board says its investigation is continuing. But for our purposes, NVIDIA is an avatar here. What happens when a beloved CEO, the person a company’s growth and identity are wrapped around, leaves suddenly and under a cloud? Every communicator needs a plan for that, and I honestly don’t know how many do. Three things stood out. First, don’t promise an outcome you don’t control. That statement of confidence in Huang lasted four days. Second, the employees. Before he resigned, a longtime engineer used an internal suggestion box to ask the board to share its findings and formally ask employees what they thought about Huang continuing as CEO. Wired reports that the post has drawn more than 1,600 comments, and a lot of them are asking for Huang’s return. Then he left just as the inquiry began, and people inside the company are asking why. That’s a listening failure as much as it’s a failure of governance. Now employees are hearing a host of tech executives and pundits insisting the board was hasty and should reinstate him. I haven’t heard what the employees at NVIDIA are hearing from their interim leadership about that. And third, there’s what employees actually heard. The chair’s memo and interim CEO Colette Kress’s first note thank Jensen and look ahead. Neither one mentions the investigation or why he left. Kress deserves credit for acknowledging a difficult period ahead and giving people a date: There’s going to be an all-hands meeting on November 18. But that’s a week from when all of this was breaking. So, Mark, what do you do in those first 24 hours, first 96 hours? What do we tell people who love the leader of the company? And do we even have a plan for that? Mark Dollins: You’re talking about internal as well as external crisis communication. This is a crisis for NVIDIA; there’s no question about it. I have a good friend who actually works there who told me about this upcoming meeting and how eager he is to learn what is happening and how the company will explain it. Anytime you have an event like this, everyone looks to one thing as a baseline or a guardrail, and that is the company values. If you cannot explain a decision for this CEO to step down, or anything related to that, and connect it to what the company values and how it takes action against those values, you’re really just drifting without an oar. It’s a pretty rudderless situation. The first thing I actually did, Shel—and maybe you’ve done things like this before—was go and look at NVIDIA’s values. I have to tell you, and I’m a non-tech guy, but when I looked at their values, it was so interesting to see that none of them

  3. 5d ago

    FIR #535: Communicating in the Wake of Big Tech's Big Political Gamble

    Political access can open doors, but what happens when the political landscape changes? Big Tech’s close relationships with Donald Trump set the stage for a discussion of corporate reputation, executive judgment, and the limits of communications counsel. Nick Clegg’s assessment of Silicon Valley’s embrace of Trump raises a familiar question: Does having a seat at the executive table mean communicators have the influence to challenge a potentially damaging decision? Neville Hobson and Shel Holtz explore what chief communication officers should advise when commercial interests, political relationships, and corporate values collide, and what to do when that advice is ignored. They also consider how to prepare executives for scrutiny, answer employees’ questions, and rebuild trust through changes in behavior. For communicators, the challenge extends well beyond explaining a CEO’s decisions to helping shape better ones. Links from this episode: When political access becomes a reputational liability Tech Billionaires Face Tricky Political Waters After Democratic Midterm Sweep Getting Too Close to Trump Was a Mistake Silicon Valley’s political spending spree meets a blue wave — and a data center revolt Corporations Pour Record-Smashing $737 Million Into 2026 Midterms Preparing for Congressional Oversight in the 120th Congress: What Organizations Should Expect Prepare Now for Congressional Oversight Investigations Industry still has room to close the AI trust gap Communities opposed to data centers will end up “backwards and poor,” Trump says The next monthly, long-form episode of FIR is tentatively scheduled to drop on Monday, November 30. We host a Communicators Zoom Chat most Thursdays at 1 p.m. ET. To obtain the credentials needed to participate, contact Shel or Neville directly, request them in our Facebook group, or email fircomments@gmail.com. Special thanks to Jay Moonah for the opening and closing music. You can find the stories from which Shel’s FIR content is selected at Shel’s Link Blog. You can catch up with both co-hosts on Neville’s blog and Shel’s blog. Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this podcast are Shel’s and Neville’s and do not reflect the views of their employers and/or clients. Raw Transcript: Shel Holtz: Hi, everybody, and welcome to episode 535 of For Immediate Release. I’m Shel Holtz. Neville Hobson: And I’m Neville Hobson. The Democrats’ sweeping victories in the U.S. midterm elections have changed the political landscape dramatically, and some of America’s biggest technology companies may now be wondering whether their close relationships with Donald Trump have become a reputational liability. Over the past two years, big tech executives have invested considerable money and effort in cultivating those relationships. Some went well beyond conventional political engagement, with public displays of loyalty that sometimes looked remarkably like appeasement. Elon Musk is perhaps the most extreme example. According to Politico, he spent around $446 million supporting candidates in the midterms, many, if not most, of whom lost. Now, with Democrats set to control both houses of Congress, there’s talk of investigations into corporate relationships with the Trump administration, including possible preferential treatment and commercial arrangements. There’s an interesting perspective on all this from Nick Clegg, the former U.K. deputy prime minister and former president of global affairs at Meta. Writing in The Atlantic this week, Clegg argues that Silicon Valley’s embrace of Trump was a predictable strategic miscalculation driven by competitive fear of missing out, political grievances, and overconfidence. What particularly caught my attention was his suggestion that a kind of herd mentality took hold. Once Musk established his relationship with Trump, other technology executives apparently feared being left behind. That’s a fascinating challenge for senior communicators. If a CEO believes competitors are gaining political advantages, how does a chief communication officer persuade that CEO to consider the longer-term reputational risks? If everyone else appears to be making the same calculation, does that make it harder to challenge the prevailing wisdom? Of course, companies need constructive relationships with governments. But there’s a significant difference between political engagement and becoming so closely identified with a particular leader that your company’s reputation becomes tied to their political fortunes. I explored this in an article on my Studio6 blog earlier this week. What particularly interests me, Shel, is the role of senior corporate communicators in these decisions. We discussed this ourselves in FIR 532 a few weeks ago, when we questioned whether having a seat at the executive table actually translates into genuine influence. These political relationships present a particularly revealing test. Were communication leaders involved when their CEOs decided to cultivate such close relationships with Trump? Did they challenge the decisions? We simply don’t know. They may have given excellent advice and been overruled, or they may have had little involvement in the decisions at all. But there’s an important distinction here. It’s one thing for a CEO not to recognize the reputational risks of a particular course of action. It’s quite another to understand those risks and decide that the commercial benefits justify taking them anyway. If the CEO knowingly proceeds, has the communicator fulfilled their responsibility by explaining the risks and making a recommendation? Or should they do more, perhaps ensuring the implications are considered by the wider leadership team or board? Remember, these are global companies. What looks like pragmatic political engagement in Washington may look quite different to employees, investors, and customers in London, Brussels, or elsewhere. I have two questions. First, looking back over the past two years, what should the CCOs of these technology companies have been advising their CEOs? If Clegg is right about the herd mentality in Silicon Valley, how would communicators have challenged that thinking? What should they have done if their advice was ignored? It’s worth mentioning that Nick Clegg occupied such a role when he was at Meta. What did he do about all this? Facebook was one of the companies involved, with Mark Zuckerberg cozying up to Trump. Second, what should those same CCOs be advising now? Should they defend the political relationships as commercially necessary, acknowledge mistakes where appropriate, or recommend a more fundamental reassessment of how their companies engage with political power? The question isn’t simply how to communicate your way out of a difficult situation. It’s whether communication leaders have the influence, judgment, and courage to help prevent that situation from arriving in the first place. Shel Holtz: It’s been an interesting week here in the U.S., to say the least. I do want to offer our usual disclaimer that we’re not expressing our own personal political views here. We’re talking about the political landscape and its impact on communicators in the wake of the “blue tsunami,” as it’s being referred to. Usually these are waves, but this was a big wave. To your first question—what should these CCOs have been doing over the last two years?—I think they should have been sharing polling numbers and other data with their leaders. They should have been showing them that the numbers were looking pretty bleak in terms of approval ratings for Trump in general and his handling of the economy, but also for data centers and AI. The U.S. has an outsized hatred of AI. If you look at the data center resolutions on the ballot in multiple states and municipalities, I think I heard there was one that passed that actually favored data centers. The other 40-some that passed were moratoriums and other measures to slow or stop the development of these huge buildings. There was plenty for communicators to share with their leaders, saying, “Look, the headwinds are tough, and going all in with Trump is going to backfire on you. It may be time to take your foot off the gas on this particular relationship.” I have no doubt that the reason they didn’t is that they were pretty high on the lack of regulation. What they all want is to pursue the development of their products without being hindered by regulation. I think that’s the main thing they were interested in. The mantra we keep hearing from both the government and industry leaders is that we have to beat China, and anything we do to constrain that effort is going to harm U.S. national security and our leadership in AI. I heard just yesterday—I think I was listening to Machine Gods, the new podcast from Kevin Roose and Casey Newton, who formerly did Hard Fork at The New York Times and are now with NPR—that one of the lowest-polling statements anybody could make to a voter was, “We have to do this to beat China.” I think it was Casey Newton who said that would get you thrown out of the room by the average voter, who doesn’t care about China. They care about these things in their neighborhoods, jacked-up electricity rates, the environment, their jobs, and whether they’ll be alive in five years. I think these leaders got high on the support they were getting for their viewpoint, and that made them want to cozy up to the administration. Here we are. The Democrats could read the tea leaves. They made tech titans—and this is a quote, although I don’t remember who said it—“avatars of inequality and corruption.” This was in their victory speeches. The Nasdaq dropped more than 5% on AI stock selling, and executives are now facing any number of investigations in Congress. Then there was Reid Hoffman, who is on the left but is a tech bil

  4. Nov 10

    Employee Signal #1: What Change Management Demands

    In the first episode of Employee Signal, Mark Dollins examines what change management demands of communications and HR leaders, drawing on three years of research conducted with Jon Stemmle. In their 2026 survey, 79% of respondents said change management was a competency employee communicators should acquire. In a separate preliminary review of public LinkedIn profiles, about 6% displayed a formal change-management credential. That measures visible credentials, not someone’s ability to do the work. Mark explores the difference between communicating a decision and helping shape it, the credential differences by seniority, and three capabilities communicators need: communication craft, change management and AI fluency. Start with this exercise: Look at your last three change communications. Did you explain a decision or help make it? Read and subscribe to Employee Signal Employee Signal is Mark’s Substack on employee communications, engagement and change. Watch or listen to the free episodes and subscribe for future editions. Paid subscribers receive this edition’s five-step action plan, development options, and three AI prompts to apply the ideas. Visit Employee Signal North Star Communications Consulting Website Explore the book Mark co-authored with Jon Stemmle: Engaging Employees through Strategic Communication, Skills, Strategies, and Tactics Second Edition Connect with Mark on LinkedIn Get full access to Employee Signal by Mark Dollins at employeesignal.substack.com/subscribe The post Employee Signal #1: What Change Management Demands appeared first on FIR Podcast Network.

  5. Nov 5

    FIR #534: Is A Scandal-Based Marketing Campaign Worth the Risk?

    When brands deliberately provoke outrage, is the backlash a crisis or a planned part of the marketing strategy? Reformation’s campaign featuring Olivia Jade Giannulli, whose family was embroiled in the college admissions scandal, raises questions about using controversy to sell products. The campaign’s charitable donation from each sale adds another layer to the discussion, but does generating attention justify the risk to a brand’s reputation? In this episode, Neville and Shel explore the differences between calculated provocation, taking a principled stand, and accidentally causing offense. Drawing on campaigns from Reformation, Nike, American Eagle, and others, we debate how to measure success beyond mentions and whether communicators should have the authority to stop a campaign when the reputational risks outweigh the likely benefits. Attention may be easy to count; the cost to trust is something else altogether. Links from this episode: Marketing Brew Article Brands can use scandal to their advantage — but it can easily go awry The Reformation / Olivia Jade campaign Celebrity Ads Keep Making People Angry. Is That the Point? Nothing Says ‘Sorry for the College Admissions Scandals’ Like Selling College Sweatshirts! From Sydney Sweeney to Olivia Jade: Why Fashion Brands Are Betting on Controversy Olivia Jade’s Reformation campaign pokes fun at college admissions scandal Olivia Jade Reformation campaign / college admissions scandal Rage bait and outrage as brand strategy The Outrage Economy: Why Companies Are Embracing Rage-Bait in High-Stakes Gamble Are brands betting on backlash? How controversy became the new brand strategy Ragebait is everywhere. Should marketers lean in? What happens when the ragebait marketing machine runs its course? Brands Are Paying to Make You Mad Research on whether bad publicity pays When Is Bad Publicity Good? Finding Your Company’s ‘Controversy Sweet Spot’ Any PR is good PR: A little online controversy is not bad for business Balenciaga’s controversial new campaign and the long history of ‘shockvertising’ Scandal-to-comeback arcs How celebrities work their way back into the spotlight after scandals Being on ‘The Traitors’ can rehabilitate a celebrity’s image. It can also ruin it. Lean in vs. apologize When the apology becomes the crisis So, you’re facing a boycott. But will it hurt you in the long run? Crisis or comedy: when should brands laugh it off? The next monthly, long-form episode of FIR is tentatively scheduled to drop on Monday, November 30. We host a Communicators Zoom Chat most Thursdays at 1 p.m. ET. To obtain the credentials needed to participate, contact Shel or Neville directly, request them in our Facebook group, or email fircomments@gmail.com. Special thanks to Jay Moonah for the opening and closing music. You can find the stories from which Shel’s FIR content is selected at Shel’s Link Blog. You can catch up with both co-hosts on Neville’s blog and Shel’s blog. Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this podcast are Shel’s and Neville’s and do not reflect the views of their employers and/or clients. Raw Transcript: Neville Hobson: Hi, everyone, and welcome to For Immediate Release. This is episode 534. I’m Neville Hobson. Shel Holtz: And I’m Shel Holtz. When a brand deliberately builds a campaign around a scandal, is that courageous? Or is it just rage bait masquerading as marketing with a charity twist? Marketing Brew’s Jennimai Nguyen tackled that question last month in a piece that’s been popping up in my feeds more than once. Let’s talk about it, because the case at the center of it is almost perfectly engineered to divide a room of communicators. Back in 2019, influencer Olivia Jade Giannulli was at the center of Operation Varsity Blues, the college admissions scandal. Her parents, Lori Loughlin and Mossimo Giannulli, pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit fraud after she was admitted to the University of Southern California through a fake rowing recruitment. She dropped out, went quiet, and eventually came back as an influencer. Fast-forward to this fall. Reformation, the fashion brand that went public over the summer, made her the face of its “Good Sport” campaign. The hero product is a crewneck sweatshirt that just says “College.” The Instagram caption—and I’m paraphrasing only slightly—says she’s back on campus in a crew that suits her better than the other kind. Net proceeds from sales of this product go to YES Scholars, a nonprofit that helps underprivileged students get to college. People commenting on the campaign split pretty much the way you’d expect: half the audience calling it iconic and the other half calling it insensitive. The Marketing Brew piece doesn’t just describe the controversy. Nguyen gets Derek Rucker, a marketing professor at Northwestern’s Kellogg School, to lay out a framework for thinking about when leveraging a scandal works and when it doesn’t. It boils down to three things. First, the old line that any publicity is good publicity. Rucker’s answer is—and I’m quoting him here—“definitively no.” Brands that court controversy can lose sales, lose audiences, and sometimes spend money cleaning up after the campaign. Second, intentional controversy is really a bet about math. Rucker’s example is Nike’s Colin Kaepernick campaign in 2018. We discussed that more than once at the time here on FIR. Nike wasn’t surprised by the backlash. They were expecting it, but they were betting that the audience that shared their values was bigger than the audience that didn’t. That is a strategy. He notes that it’s an easier bet for smaller brands because there’s less of an existing audience to alienate. Reformation, though, just IPO’d and wants to appeal to a broad swath of millennials and Gen Z. That makes the bet riskier. Third—and this is the part I find most interesting for anybody who deals with crises—you can tell whether the controversy was intentional by watching what the brand does next. Rucker points to two tells. One is the charitable donation attached to the product. Reformation did it with YES Scholars. American Eagle did it last year with the Sydney Sweeney jeans and Crisis Text Line. The other tell is the absence of an apology. Rucker’s line is that these brands aren’t going to apologize because they’re not sorry. They’re targeting a specific audience, and the people who were offended were never part of that target. Contrast that with Converse, which pulled its Karina campaign and issued a flat-out apology within days when people pointed out that the imagery evoked the Ku Klux Klan and lynching symbolism. That’s what unintentional controversy looks like. Rucker’s advice there is the opposite: apologize immediately, take it down, and explain to consumers what happened. I would add, beyond what Rucker said, explain what you’re going to do to make sure this doesn’t happen again. The framework is: intentional or not, and does the response match? Reformation’s silence isn’t a failure of crisis communications. It was their strategy from the get-go. Yet Rucker’s own closing thought is that, if he were starting a brand, he wouldn’t go this route because there are plenty of ways to stand out that don’t involve controversy. Neville, I’m curious where you land on this. Is Reformation being clever, or is this a brand that just told its most offended customers it doesn’t need them? Neville Hobson: It’s interesting. I don’t believe that Olivia Jade story was familiar to a lot of people here. I remember seeing news reports at the time. Isn’t that the issue that Felicity Huffman was involved with, and William H. Macy? Shel Holtz: Absolutely. Same one. Neville Hobson: Now it rings big bells, I must admit. My immediate thought, listening to what you were saying and reading some of the reports on all of these, is that controversy generates attention. We know that. But attention isn’t the same as trust, reputation, or commercial success. Communicators have a responsibility to challenge the strategy, not simply manage the fallout. I’m wondering whether, in these examples—notably American Eagle and Reformation—we’re confusing the ability to generate attention with the ability to build a brand. If everyone’s talking about the controversy but nobody is talking about the product, have they really succeeded? That’s the first thing that comes to mind. How would you measure the success? I guess this is really the crystallization of my thought here: How would you measure the success of a deliberately controversial campaign? Shel Holtz: I think it depends on what their goal for the campaign was. If it was building awareness of the brand, that’s pretty easy. You can measure sentiment: How many people supported this? How many didn’t? Into which camps did they fall? If you’re targeting millennials and Gen Z, and they’re more likely to think this was cool, especially given that the proceeds are going to a charity, then you can call it a success. If the goal was selling a ton of these shirts, that’s pretty easy, too. But the question is, when you release a new product or look at the other items in your product line, have you seen a lift there as well? I don’t think a communicator would have told Nike not to do the Colin Kaepernick ad. I think they said, “Look, you’re going to get backlash, but it’s from customers we’re not particularly interested in. We’re interested in the larger audience that’s going to support this and buy these shoes.” That’s what ended up happening. Nike suffered some backlash. I remember seeing shoes being burned in barbecues and things like that. But at the end of the day, Nike’s reputation is fine. Their profits are fine. They didn’t suffer at all. By and large, I think they’re seen as stan

  6. Nov 1

    Are You Reaching Your Frontline?

    Reaching frontline employees takes more than an app, a digital sign, or a weekly briefing for supervisors to deliver. Employees working in manufacturing plants, on delivery routes, on construction sites, and in healthcare settings have different opportunities to receive information—and different needs. Communicators may not control the channels those employees rely on, and getting a message in front of someone doesn’t mean they understood it or could act on it. Before auditing channels or proposing another communication tool, organizations need to answer a more basic question: What are they trying to accomplish? In this episode of “On the Same Page,” Shel Holtz and Mark Dollins explore how to make frontline communication relevant, accessible, and useful. Drawing on recent studies and examples from their careers, they discuss working with local managers, equipping supervisors to interpret decisions, creating opportunities for employees to ask questions, and testing approaches before expanding them. They also challenge the assumption that frontline employees care only about schedules and pay, and offer a practical way to uncover the gap between publishing information and communicating it successfully. Links from this episode: The frontline information gap: why more technology hasn’t made work easier 3 Reasons Frontline Workers Experience a Communication Gap 2025 International Employee Communication Impact Study Team dynamics on the front line: How managers and organizations impact this overlooked key to retention Staffbase-Commissioned Study Finds Only 23% of US Frontline Workers Feel Fully Supported Subscribe to Employee Signal, Mark’s New Substack! Raw Transcript: Mark Dollins: Hey, Shel, how are you doing? Shel Holtz: I am doing great, Mark. How about yourself? Mark Dollins: I’m doing very well here in Connecticut, just past Halloween, and I guess we’re ready for Christmas. We kind of skip directly to the next major holiday. There’s this Thanksgiving thing in the way. It’s crazy. Shel Holtz: Yeah, on my end Hanukkah starts almost immediately after Thanksgiving, so I’ve got to get ready. Mark Dollins: They’re all jumbling together. But I was thinking today we could talk about a topic that I hear a lot about from my clients. Of course, I spent a lot of time working on this in my roles leading employee communications for a number of large multinational companies. The topic is frontline communications. Invariably, the question always comes to me first: “Hey, Mark, we need to figure out how to improve our frontline communications, so we need to do an audit.” And I say, “Well, let’s talk about something that we need to answer first, and that is: What are you trying to accomplish?” Interestingly enough, most of my clients can’t really answer that question because they haven’t thought it through fully. They’ve got some ideas, but they really do need to have a very clear sense of what they want to do with frontline communications. It comes with a lot of, let’s just say, politics and potential conflict. It’s not as easy as, “Well, we own all the channels and we own all the ability to reach our frontline employees,” because, especially in most larger organizations, the truth is communications does not. I’m curious if you’ve got similar things happening in your world, where you’re working or in the world of consulting that you’ve come from. I would imagine you’ve tackled this topic a time or two. Shel Holtz: Most definitely, throughout my career. My first corporate communications job was with an energy company. Oil production was way at the top of the list. You had people out in the oil patch, people on offshore oil rigs, people in refineries, all of them in different conditions and different circumstances for getting information. We had people on ships, on the tankers. I worked for a pharmaceutical company where you had salespeople out in the field driving around to doctors’ offices all day. You had people working in labs and in production facilities. I was with Mattel, the toy company, so manufacturing was a big deal there, as well as people like retail merchandisers. And now I’m with a construction company, so every construction site, every project, is a different siloed frontline collection of employees. Certainly, during the 21 years I consulted, this was an issue for a lot of my clients. It’s interesting that you brought this up as a topic. The day you sent me the email suggesting this was the same day I got an invitation to a webinar from Forrester and Staffbase. They had just finished a brand-new survey on frontline communication. So I think we have a lot to talk about here. Mark Dollins: We certainly do. I think you’ve made probably one of the most important points of all already, and that is: This is not a one-size-fits-all solution for anybody. As you were talking about the industries that you’ve worked in, I was reflecting on the work that I did when I was with PepsiCo for almost 20 years. You would think that the way a Frito-Lay route delivery driver has access to company channels and communications would be somewhat similar to what happens on the beverage side. And the truth is, that’s not the reality. Not just across industries, but even within the same company, that frontline experience, whether you’re in manufacturing or distribution or whatever you’re doing, is going to be different. It takes a lot of thought and a solution that looks at all those potential scenarios. Shel Holtz: I think in a lot of those really large organizations, you end up with communicators in big business units, big divisions, and they’re making decisions on their own for their people. They may have a dotted line to the top-line corporate communications, but they’re dealing more with the corporate-level messaging and communications. In a lot of cases, they’re dealing with executive communications and don’t have that much influence over how information gets to the front line. Mark Dollins: Yeah, and especially when you’re in the manufacturing area, ownership of those channels does not belong to communications. It belongs to those shift supervisors and the staff management at that location. They have very limited windows in which they can communicate, and they’re going to own it as much as they possibly can and prevent outside influences from stepping into it. So that’s another bit of politics that we’ll talk about. Shel Holtz: And it brings us back to manager communications too, doesn’t it? Mark Dollins: Absolutely. Number one. I thought maybe we could start with—you know how I’m big on data—talk to us about the results of that survey. It’d be a curious place to start and see how our experiences line up with what the new research is telling us about frontline communications. Shel Holtz: Sure. There are some interesting findings out of this. I summarized the ones that I found most interesting. First, more than half of employees who responded to this survey, which included managers, by the way, receive necessary work information through six or more channels. So access to information can coexist with fragmentation, but it also leads to the potential for inconsistency. Mark Dollins: Wow, okay. Shel Holtz: Do you want to talk about each of these as we go through them? Mark Dollins: No, keep going. This is all good. Shel Holtz: Okay. Twenty-seven percent report moderately to very inconsistent information across channels, which speaks to that fragmentation. Getting to your earlier point, distribution of this needs clear ownership and version control. Forty-eight percent report lower productivity or operational efficiency when needed information is missing. So failures in communication have operational consequences. Forty-four percent report greater risk of errors, quality problems, or missed deadlines. So “Did they see it?” really becomes an inadequate measure of success. I know that’s what a lot of communicators did measure: “Did you see this information?” And 83% of frontline workers expect a single app combining work activities and information to have a high or very high impact. They’re looking for simplicity, but this measures expectations and not demonstrated results. Is giving a phone to employees adequate? You have to look at a couple of things. First, do the conditions allow them to use a phone while they’re working? Do they have individual accounts? Is there reliable connectivity where they’re working to use their phones? When they do have allowed time to read, can they also ask questions? Do they have that allowed time? Does the night shift get the same opportunity as the day shift? There’s a lot to consider here, and the nature of the work also matters. A nurse, a delivery driver, a retail associate, somebody working on a construction project site—they don’t all automatically get the same channel strategy. Or if they do, it wouldn’t be very effective. Mark Dollins: Nor necessarily should they have the same channel strategy, to our earlier point in this discussion. All of those data points lead me to wanting to know more. As I think about those macro trends, how does this work where I’m working and with my employee communication base? I’ll go back to that question. People want to audit. Okay, yes, please do audit in order to get the data on how your organization is working with and responding to those issues. You’ve got to have data to help you make those decisions. But before you go out and measure things, you still have to know: What is it that I’m trying to accomplish? Am I trying to drive a CSR message into an operating environment? If so, the only way I have to get there is through a shift supervisor and a supervisor’s meeting. Probably not going to be a big successful strategy for you, right? What is my lane that I want to stay in, where I actually ca

  7. Oct 31

    Circle of Fellows #134: Lead, Communicate, and Connect

    What becomes possible when people feel seen at work? As workplaces feel increasingly transactional, helping people know they matter is both a human and leadership imperative. When people feel seen, they are more likely to engage, contribute, connect, and thrive. There are many ways we help people feel seen, but one of the simplest and most powerful is appreciation: noticing who people are, what they bring, and the difference they make — and letting them know. In this conversation, four IABC Fellows explored the role leaders and communicators play in creating workplaces where people feel seen, and appreciation becomes part of how we lead, communicate, and connect. What changes in people, teams, and organizations when people know they matter, and what gets in the way? About the panel: Although Zora Artis began her career outside the communications field, she has had an outsize impact on the profession since entering it more than 20 years ago to as an account director and then strategic planner with branding and integrated marcomms agencies. Since then, she has led her own brand and communications consultancy and served as CEO of a 20-person creative, digital, and strategic communication firm. In 2019, formed her current management consulting practice, bringing together strategic alignment, brand, and communication expertise. She has received five Gold Quill awards. Her significant contributions to the profession and the body of knowledge include her original research with IABC colleague Wayne Aspland on strategic alignment, the role of communications and leadership – the first substantial research effort for the reconfigured IABC Foundation – and co-authoring a subsequent white paper, “The Road to Alignment,” supported by 27 senior communicators from five continents. Zora has also researched the correlation between strategic alignment and experiences and the impact on stakeholder value and brand. This has led her to develop her own proprietary Alignment Experience Framework. She has also examined gender equity, perceptions, and bias in organizations, and wrote a chapter on this topic for the Quadriga University e-reader, Women in PR. Since joining IABC a decade ago, she has contributed as a volunteer, including serving as chair of the IABC Asia Pacific Region and IEB director; she currently chairs the 2022 World Conference Program Advisory Committee. As a certified company director and chair of the IABC Audit and Risk Committee, she introduced proper risk oversight into the board’s processes. Zora received the 2021 and 2015 IABC Chair’s Award for Leadership and was named IABC’s 2020 Regional Leader of the Year. She is also a Strategic Communication Management Professional, Fellow of the Australian Marketing Institute, and Certified Practicing Marketer. John G. Clemons, SCMP, ABC, APR, IABC Fellow, an independent communications consultant based in North Carolina, has held senior executive and consultant roles throughout his career in corporate and organizational communications. He specializes in providing strategic counsel and support to top executives and corporate offices at Fortune 500 companies. John has served as chair of IABC and holds accreditations from both IABC and PRSA. John has worked with Walmart, Raytheon, and Marriott (among others). John has been an adjunct instructor for six years at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte and Loyola University in New Orleans. Founder and Principal of Fluency Leadership, Catherine Ducharme, IABC Fellow, PCC, CLC, is a career communicator, certified coach, and facilitator with more than 35 years of experience in communication and leadership. She has held senior roles across public relations, corporate, internal, and marketing communication in industries, including high-tech and health sciences, grounding her work in deep, real-world expertise. Building on that foundation, Catherine now focuses on developing communication and marketing professionals to be exceptional leaders. Catherine is also the author of the book SEEN: The Power of Appreciation at Work. Jennifer Wah, MC, ABC, has helped clients deliver ideas, plans, words, and results since she founded her storytelling and communications firm, Forwords Communication Inc., in 1997. With more than two dozen awards for strategic communications, writing, and consulting, Jennifer is recognized as a storyteller and strategist. She has worked in industries ranging from healthcare and academia to financial services and the resource sector, and she is passionate about using storytelling strategically to support business outcomes. Although she has delivered workshops and training throughout her career, Jennifer formally added teaching to her experience in 2013, first with Royal Roads University and more recently as an adjunct professor of business communications with the UBC Sauder School of Business, where she now works part-time to impart crucial communication skills to the next generation of business leaders. When she is not working, Jennifer spends her time cooking, walking her dog, Orion, or discussing food, hockey, or music with her husband and two young adult children in North Vancouver, Canada. Raw transcript: Hi, everybody, and welcome to episode 134 of Circle of Fellows. This is the monthly panel discussion among Fellows of the International Association of Business Communicators, of which I am one. I’m Shel Holtz. I am Senior Director of Communications at Webcor. We’re a commercial general contractor operating in California, and I’m coming to you from our headquarters offices in San Francisco. Today I am joined by four of my friends, four IABC Fellows. I will ask them to introduce themselves in just a minute. First, I want to let everyone know what we are talking about today: the role communications can play in ensuring that employees feel seen and heard at work. From the description that we shared: In this conversation, we’ll explore the role leaders and communicators play in creating workplaces where people feel seen and appreciation becomes part of how we lead, communicate, and connect. Recognition undoubtedly will be part of this conversation as well. I hope that you who are joining us live will participate in the conversation. You should do that by sharing a comment in the comment field on YouTube. I’ll be able to share that on the screen for our panelists, and we will pivot to talk about your observation, your question, your experience. I’m very much looking forward to your engagement. It really makes these things even more fun than they already are. They’re already fun because I get to moderate a panel of friends. I’m going to ask them to introduce themselves now, starting with Zora. Hello, everyone. I’m coming to you from Melbourne in Australia, so it’s Friday morning for me. I love being here with friends, as Shel put it: Catherine, John, Jennifer, and Shel, of course. I’m a strategic alignment specialist. I am a facilitator, leadership coach, and advisor. Thank you. Great. Thanks, Zora. John, you’re up. Hello, everyone. I’m John Clemons, and I’m coming to you from Huntersville, North Carolina. I’ve worked in my career for a number of Fortune 100 companies, including Marriott International, AT&T, and Walmart. I am now a communications consultant and an adjunct professor for two universities. Great to see you, John. Catherine, you’re next. Hi. I’m Catherine Ducharme, coming to you from Vancouver, British Columbia. I am a leadership coach, and I develop leaders. I’ve been in communications for most of my career, and I’m also the author of the book SEEN: The Power of Appreciation at Work. This is a topic that’s near and dear to me, so I’m looking forward to discussing it with my friends here. I think it’s highly appropriate that you be part of this panel, given the theme of your book. Next to you is your neighbor here on this panel, as well as in Vancouver, Jennifer. Hi, everyone. Just theoretically up the street from Catherine, and pleased to be here. I work as a storytelling consultant with my own boutique agency, Forwords Communication. I teach at the UBC Sauder School of Business as an instructor there. I love it all, and love these Circle of Fellows gatherings and the conversations that come out of them, which are always both unexpected and insightful. I’m particularly pleased to be here on this topic. I love Catherine’s new book. Terrific. I’m going to have to give that a read. This is a really interesting topic. I have been focused to some extent here at my job on psychological safety, something that we believe in. As I was reading through the topic and some of the comments that you, the panel, shared in advance, I connected those dots: You can’t feel seen and heard if you don’t feel safe to speak up in the first place. I was wondering if you felt that way, if you think psychological safety is part of what we’re talking about here. Catherine, I’d like to start with you, given that this is the focus of your book. I love that thread that you pull through of psychological safety, because I think being seen is all about building relationships and trust. Without psychological safety underpinning everything, if we don’t feel safe to speak up, to see people in a vulnerable way, to show up differently, we remain quiet. I think that’s what’s happening in a lot of workplaces today. It becomes very transactional. Some of us can feel like cogs in the wheel because we don’t feel safe to say what we need to say, to see each other as human beings in the workplace. Catherine, can you explain a little bit what you just said, “show up differently”? What exactly are you saying? I love that. I think particularly as leaders in the workplace, we have an opportunity to be more relational in how we show up. As organizations, we can often focus on getting the work done, efficiency, results, metrics, and all of tha

  8. Oct 26

    FIR #533: The Two Distinct Realities of AI Adoption

    In this long-form October 2026 episode of For Immediate Release, Neville and Shel report on FGS Global’s research, “Winning the Debate on AI.” More than 7,000 people across seven countries rate AI as the least trusted technology in widespread use, yet 37% became more positive after hearing about its benefits. Shel looks at Microsoft’s move of communications into its corporate, external, and legal affairs group, and its plan to put employees out front telling the company’s story. Neville examines OpenAI’s Locked Chats and the gap between the name and what the feature delivers. Shel reports on Fresh’s finding that 28% of employees meet company news through an AI summary first, and on how to write content that survives it. Neville asks what a Northern Ireland council’s return to a printed newsletter says about channels and measurement. Shel closes with the Wharton 2026 AI Adoption Report, in which managers and the employees they manage describe two very different workplaces. In his Tech Report, Dan York reports on the critical PHP vulnerabilities fixed in the October 21 security release. The two remote code execution flaws affect any server hosting a PHP application, which is why WordPress and other platforms urged immediate updates. Dan covers why the release was coordinated, the role AI plays in the story, and the xkcd comic that captures how much of the internet depends on a few critical components. He then turns to Freedom House’s Freedom on the Net 2026 report, “Seismic Shifts on the Global Internet,” and to the French government’s pressure on Meta, TikTok, and other platforms as protests spread this weekend. He closes with two fediverse stories: the Social Web Foundation’s Fediverse Multimedia Grants, funded by a $200,000 Interledger Foundation grant, and what’s coming in Mastodon 5.0, including a redesigned composer and navigation. We’d love to hear from you: comment on LinkedIn, Facebook, Threads, or WhatsApp, email fircomments@gmail.com with or without an audio file attached (or use the voicemail button on the FIR website to record a comment directly from the web). Links from this episode: New research: Winning the debate on AI Radar Pulse: Winning the debate on AI Microsoft Rethinks Communications As Employees Take On Storytelling Role Using locked chats in ChatGPT OpenAI Adds Locked Chat Feature to ChatGPT to Hide Sensitive Convos Behind PIN Codes AI summaries overtake workplace communications, Fresh says AI Research Summaries ‘Exaggerate Findings,’ Study Warns Ruwiki explains: Why AI summaries need more context Council to spend £30,000 on print title amid low views of digital newsletter Council goes back to printed newsletter as no appetite found for digital edition 2026 AI Adoption Report Links from Dan York’s Tech Report Security advisory: Critical remote code execution vulnerabilities, update now Critical PHP Security Release Dependency [HEADLINE NEEDED] Seismic Shifts on the Global Internet France puts Meta, TikTok, other platforms on notice over riot content as “Acte II” protests loom Interledger Foundation awards $200,000 to Social Web Foundation to support decentralized social media Fediverse Multimedia Grants 5.0: Laying the foundation 5.0: A closer look The next monthly, long-form episode of FIR is tentatively scheduled to drop on Monday, November 30. We host a Communicators Zoom Chat most Thursdays at 1 p.m. ET. To obtain the credentials needed to participate, contact Shel or Neville directly, request them in our Facebook group, or email fircomments@gmail.com. Special thanks to Jay Moonah for the opening and closing music. You can find the stories from which Shel’s FIR content is selected at Shel’s Link Blog. You can catch up with both co-hosts on Neville’s blog and Shel’s blog. Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this podcast are Shel’s and Neville’s and do not reflect the views of their employers and/or clients. Raw Transcript: Neville Hobson: Hi everyone, and welcome to the For Immediate Release podcast, long-form Episode 533 for October 2026. I’m Neville Hobson in Somerset, England. Shel Holtz: And I’m Shel Holtz in Concord, California. Neville Hobson: This month we have our usual six great stories to share with you, plus, as usual, Dan York’s Tech Report. But first, let’s begin with a recap of the episodes we’ve published over the past month and some listener comments. In the long-form Episode 529 for September, published on the 28th of September, our lead story reported on a Press Gazette investigation that found dozens of experts quoted in the mainstream media who don’t actually exist. And PR agencies are unwittingly sharing them with the press. This poses a credibility issue for the agencies and the media, we said, requiring a layer of verification unlike anything we faced before. Other stories include a crisis communication handbook for boards from the CIPR and the UK Institute of Directors. And we’ve got a handful of comments here, don’t we, Shel? Shel Holtz: Yeah, we have a couple. Philippe Borremans, our friend, said, “Thanks for covering the CIPR and Institute of Directors handbook. It was a great collaboration with colleagues, and I think the final result is really worth a look.” And Jane Wilson said, “Love the line, ‘You can’t communicate your way out of a crisis you behaved your way into.’ I use a similar line: you can’t communicate out of a crisis while the fire is still burning. There needs to be operational behavior, resolution, or a plan to resolve. For comms to do our jobs. And I agree wholeheartedly, it’s a governance issue.” And Neville, you had a reply to Jane. You wrote, “Deepwater Horizon is such a powerful illustration of this point. No amount of carefully crafted messaging could change the reality that oil kept pouring into the Gulf, and Hayward’s remark just compounded an already disastrous situation. It’s a reminder that what leaders say matters enormously, but what the organization actually does matters even more. Which brings us right back to governance and accountability, long before anyone starts drafting a holding statement.” Neville Hobson: Good comments Jane made, I thought. So in FIR 530, on the fifth of October, we discussed a Financial Times report claiming that the volume of AI slop appearing as thought leadership on LinkedIn has led to a surge in interest in human ghostwriters. And this is the one that attracted quite a few comments, right, Shel? Shel Holtz: This attracted 14 comments. This one really seemed to strike a nerve with people. It’s too much to read all of the comments as they were written, but we do have a summary. Chris Norton kicked things off. He was hosting a GEO/AEO event the week after he shared his post, and has been talking with SEOs and copywriters. One of them ran a 300-person SEO and copywriting agency and just closed it because the market vanished. Chris still believes people want taste and human authenticity in 2026. We’ll accept some automation, he says, but we’d still rather talk to a human at the co-op checkout than pack our own bags. And Neville, you replied that the scarce commodity may no longer be words at all, but judgment, taste, and genuine perspective, and that those become more valuable as AI makes competent content effortless. Dennis Howlett uses Claude to draft his FOIAs and his posts. He trained it on the Diginomica library for style, then edits everything, often rewriting. He runs it through Grammarly, then passes it back to Claude for a legal check. It makes him more efficient. Jeff DeCanya says it definitely matters. Working with a human ghostwriter isn’t the same as feeding a prompt to an algorithm. Neville, you called that the strongest argument on the other side, since the human process involves challenge, interpretation, and a real relationship with the subject. Mac Worsham offered a useful test for any byline: could the named author explain the prompt and why each point is there? If so, the drafting tool matters less than critics fear. If not, a human ghostwriter wouldn’t fix it either. He also commented on a different post. Neville, you posted and I posted, and he commented on both of our posts sharing the episode. He said the line about not being able to communicate your way out of a crisis you behaved your way into is maybe the most powerful sentence in the profession right now. That’s actually from the previous episode; I don’t know why he left it on this one, but well. It treats crisis communication as governance and moves the question upstream, to the gap between what an organization says and what it does. He sees the fake expert story, that previous story, as the same lesson from the other side. Back to this episode. Sherilyn Starkey wondered whether calligraphers had the same debate when Gutenberg unveiled movable type, asking whether it had really done the thinking. Authenticity, she says, has always had a technology problem. Megan Thomas says ghostwriting for leaders who give zero input always feels wrong to her, and she sees no difference between that and using AI with no input or care. She’s fine with AI used responsibly and with appropriate human attention, and she loves that authentic comms are back in demand, “ums,” “ahs,” and typos included. Rita Zonia says AI helps enormously with the mechanics of writing, but tends to stay skin-deep on its own. She finds it amusing that a lot of organizations thought they could decimate comms teams and let AI pick up the work, only to discover the tool is only as good as its operator. So great comms people are making a comeback. Experienced writers and ghostwriters know how to get beneath what someone says, ask the extra questions, and spot the little odd comment that’s actually the story. Finding what’s worth saying, and saying it authentically and succinctly, is still a very human ski

4.4
out of 5
25 Ratings

About

Subscribe to receive every episode of every show on the FIR Podcast Network

You Might Also Like