85 episodes

Eliana Johnson and Chris Stirewalt love the news business but they hate a lot of what’s happening to it these days. Using their decades of experience in print, digital and TV news they tell the story behind the stories, always on the lookout for bias, sloppy reporting and, well, just plain wretched journalism. Every week they help you to be a better, smarter news consumer.

Ink Stained Wretches Nebulous Media

    • News
    • 4.8 • 401 Ratings

Eliana Johnson and Chris Stirewalt love the news business but they hate a lot of what’s happening to it these days. Using their decades of experience in print, digital and TV news they tell the story behind the stories, always on the lookout for bias, sloppy reporting and, well, just plain wretched journalism. Every week they help you to be a better, smarter news consumer.

    The Interview: Shawn McCreesh

    The Interview: Shawn McCreesh

    Today we are joined by New York Magazine’s Shawn McCreesh. We talk to Shawn about the art of a good profile, his days at New York Times, and his connection to previous ISW interviewees. 

    If you have a story you want us to talk about, e-mail us at wretches@nebulouspodcasts.com.

    Sign up to our newsletter to receive show notes directly in your inbox

    Show Notes
    New York Magazine: Axel Springer CEO Mathias Döpfner’s Politico Ambitions 
    New York Magazine: How SBF Sweet-Talked the Media 
    NYTimes: Opinion | In My Hometown, Opioids Are Still Stealing Lives 
    New York Magazine: Get Me Risa Heller! 
    Mediate: ‘I Was So F*cking Freaked Out’: Ex-NYT Staffer Describes ‘Crying’ and ‘Bloodthirsty’ Colleagues Seeking Vengeance for Cotton Op-Ed 

    Guest Recommendations: 
    New York Magazine: Pete Hamill on the Revolt of the White Lower Middle Class 
    NY Times: Jamie Tarses' Fall, as Scheduled
    GQ: Ted Kennedy on the Rocks | GQ 
    The New Yorker: Ted Turner, the Lost Tycoon 
    Vanity Fair: OVITZ AGONISTES 
    NY Times: Woman of Mass Destruction 
    New York Magazine: The Death of (the Idea of) the Upper East Side

    • 54 min
    Ocean's 2

    Ocean's 2

    John Podhoertz, editor of Commentary Magazine, sits in for Eliana today. We’re diving deep into the media’s 2024 coverage and then jumping into a full business section with news from Buzzfeed, Politico, and more.

    Time stamps: 
    6:40 Front Page
    1:16:26 Obsessions
    1:22:58 Reader Mail 
    1:28:37 Favorite Item of the Week

    If you have a story you want us to talk about, e-mail us at wretches@nebulouspodcasts.com.
    Sign up to receive show notes directly in your inbox


    Show Notes:
    The Dispatch: Who Needs the MSM?
    Politico: Trump prepares an extensive opposition file on ‘Ron DeSanctimonious’ 
    WaPo: On the trail, freewheeling Donald Trump counters scripted Ron DeSantis
    WaPo: Much of the 2024 GOP field focuses on dark, apocalyptic themes
    Mediaite: Al Sharpton Floats His New Nickname For Anti-Woke Republicans: 'Well What's The Opposite?'
    Vanity Fair: How Rod Dreher’s Blog Got a Little “Too Weird” for The American Conservative | Vanity Fair 
    Politico: How Biden saved Silicon Valley startups: Inside the 72 hours that transformed U.S. banking 
    WSJ: Barney Frank Pushed to Ease Financial Regulations After Joining Signature Bank Board 
    WaPo: A lot of people heard what Barney Frank said about the new banking law. Few knew he works for a bank. 
    WaPo: Dafna Linzer abruptly steps down as Politico’s executive editor
    Puck: Dafna Punk 
    WSJ: BuzzFeed Encourages Reporters to Write More Stories in Attempt to Turn Profit
    Nieman Journalism Lab: The scale of local news destruction in Gannett’s markets is astonishing
    Page Six: Gwyneth Paltrow dragged on TikTok over wellness tips 
    Slate: Why Are All Action Heroes Named Jack, James, or John?
    MSNBC: Oscars 2023: Best picture nom ‘Top Gun: Maverick’ is slick, but sick 
    Deadline White House on Twiter: "If Stormy is someone they are going to look as a substantial witness for this case, I am certain that she will do a fantastic job... the facts will prevail and the facts do not benefit the former president" - @MichaelCohen212 w/ @NicolleDWallace
    MSNBC: Why Michael Cohen wouldn't be as bad a prosecution witness as some may think
    LA Times: How white and affluent drivers are polluting the air breathed by LA's people of color
    WaPo: Opinion | Gavin Newsom unfairly punishes Walgreens for its abortion pill policy 
    CBS New York: City of Newark falls for Sister City scam: "Whose job was it to do a simple Google search?"

    • 1 hr 34 min
    Womyn in the Nyews

    Womyn in the Nyews

    We’re celebrating Herstory this week! Listen in to hear stories from AND about Semafor, updates on Fox News, and Eliana has insights into Politico’s new style.

    Time Stamps:
    3:31 Front Page
    50:06 Obsessions 
    1:00:30 Reader Mail
    1:03:31 Favorite Item of the Week

    If you have a story you want us to talk about, e-mail us at wretches@nebulouspodcasts.com.
    Sign up to receive show notes directly in your inbox

    Show Notes:
    NYT: Inside the Panic at Fox News After the 2020 Election
    Dispatch: Bill Sammon, the Deer Hunter
    Mediaite: Bret Baier Airs Report Questioning Tucker Carlson's Jan. 6 Coverage, Features McConnell Saying Fox News Made 'A Mistake' 
    Semafor: Conflict of Interest at the Post 
    Axios: Semafor partners with Chinese Communist Party-linked think tank 
    Mediaite: 'Not a Concept I Support': DeSantis Calls Out Media Using His Picture for 'More Clicks' on Blogger Registration Bill He Doesn't Advocate 
    WaPo: Baseball can no longer ignore Ron DeSantis's culture wars 
    Politifact: What does it mean to be ‘woke’? 
    CBS: 2 women leading the sports and business sides of the Miami Marlins are making history
    NYT: For Women in Afghanistan, the War’s Terror Gives Way to New Fears
    NYT: The Dirty Little Secret of Credit Card Rewards Programs 
    WaPo: Nearly everyone is exposed to unhealthy levels of tiny air pollutants, study says
    DailyMail: Democrat FTC boss turns screws on Elon Musk by demanding he hand over information on layoffs 
    Neil Chilson on Twitter: I've looked at (and revised, even) dozens of consent orders. Douglas provides a standard description of why the FTC has consent orders and how enforces them through demand letters. 
    JoshKraushaar on Twitter: Some personal news: Excited to announce that I will be the new editor-in-chief for @J_Insider starting at the end of the month. I’m thrilled to be working with @melissaeweiss in her new role as JI executive editor. 
    I Might Be Wrong Substack: Announcing the "Wrongthink" Podcast! Featuring Me and a Far-Better-Known Dude!
    Obsessions: 
    The Spectator: Revealed: Politico’s banned words
    NYPost: I pretended to be a 14-year-old boy on TikTok — what I saw terrified me 
    Kicker:
    WSJ: How Sexual Assault Allegations Against a U.S. Chess Grandmaster Went Unaddressed for Years
    AP: Video captures dramatic moment SUV slams into Houston cafe

    • 1 hr 6 min
    Fox’s Bruh Moment

    Fox’s Bruh Moment

    Today, we’re going deep into Fox’s horrible, bad, no-good week. We’re also looking at the Wuhan Lab leak coverage, The View (unfortunately), and the AP’s constipation clarification. Hit it, baby!

    02:37 Front Page
    40:27 Obsessions
    46:43 Reader Mail
    48:21 Favorite Item of the Week

    If you have a story you want us to talk about, e-mail us at wretches@nebulouspodcasts.com.

    Sign up to receive show notes directly in your inbox: https://nebulouspodcasts.com/shows/in...

    Show Notes:
    NYT: Murdoch Acknowledges Fox News Hosts Endorsed Election Fraud Falsehoods
    Puck: Will Rupert Make a “Blood Sacrifice”?
    WaPo: Opinion | Democrats finally seem ready to wage war on Fox News
    Semafor: 'Non-Person' Donald Trump faces 'soft ban' at Fox
    Reason: Global Disinformation Index, Inform Thyself
    Slow Boring Substack: Misinformation isn’t just on the right
    HuffPost: 'The View' Host Joy Behar Scorches Trump On East Palestine Train Derailment
    Deadline: ‘Dilbert’ Cartoon Dropped From Many News Outlets Over Creator Scott Adams Racial Remarks
    Vanity Fair: How Newsmax’s Cable-Fee Fight Spiraled Into the Right’s Latest “Censorship” Crusade
    Puck News: Zaz’s “Equity Story” & Credit Suisse’s Demise
    AP: Constipation does not kill more people than rifles in the US
    D Magazine: Dallas Morning News Fires Reporter for Calling Mayor 'Bruh' on Twitter
    Axios: Scoop: Jonathan Capehart quits WaPo editorial board, leaving no people of color
    TV Tech: FCC Asks Administrative Law Judge to Rule on Aspects of Tegna Deal
    WSJ: Upward Mobility Is Alive and Well in America
    Favorite Items of the Week:
    NYT: Jaromir Jagr, The 51-Year-Old Hockey Star Who Won’t Quit
    NL Times: Amsterdam murder suspect caught with bag of meat at Lisbon Airport, fueling cannibal rumor
    The Fifth Column: Ep #396 w/ Chris Stirewalt "Fired by Fox, Fixing the News, Eating a McRib”

    Check out exclusive nebulous media content:
    Website - http://bit.ly/3UzEGRT
    Instagram - http://bit.ly/3O3kLIT
    Twitter - http://bit.ly/3ttBStP
    YouTube - https://youtu.be/kmgZeXXWi1s

    • 52 min
    At Fox and CNN, Talent Runs Amok

    At Fox and CNN, Talent Runs Amok

    Cable news currently has its hands full with Tucker Carlson and Don Lemon. Tune in to get the latest on the New York Times outrage, Ron Desantis and this week’s George Santos.  

    If you have a story you want us to talk about, e-mail us at wretches@nebulouspodcasts.com.
    Receive show notes directly in your inbox, subscribe to the newsletter here.

    Watch this episode on YouTube

    Time Stamps: 
    2:42 Front Page
    47:27 Obsessions
    55:18 Reader Mail 
    57:36 Favorite Items

    Show Notes: 
    NYT: Uproar Hits CNN as Don Lemon Is Rebuked for Comments About Women 
    Daily Mail: EXCLUSIVE: 'If Don doesn't go, we will!': Angry female staffers at CNN issue ultimatum over Lemon's sexist Nikki Haley comments and threaten to quit if he stays on-air
    WaPo: Opinion | Does Don Lemon's punishment at CNN fit the crime?
    Axios: Exclusive: Kevin McCarthy gives Tucker Carlson access to massive trove of Jan. 6 riot tape 
    News Channel 5: Businessman, economist, cop, international sex crimes expert? The stories of Congressman Andy Ogles
    Vanity Fair: Ron DeSantis Shouldn’t Be Covered Like Just Another Republican
    The Dispatch: DeSantis Is (Almost) Right About Libel Law
    WaPo: Republicans use ‘wokeism’ to attack left — but struggle to define it
    NewsMax: Sen. Tuberville: Newsmax Targeted to Silence Conservatives 
    NYT: ‘Chernobyl 2.0’? Ohio Train Derailment Spurs Wild Speculation.
    NBC News: Supreme Court rejects Ohio man’s bid to sue police over arrest for Facebook parody
    NYT: James O’Keefe Leaves His Post as the Leader of Project Veritas
    Mediaite: Upcoming Oscars Ceremony Will Be Equipped With 'Crisis Team' in the Event of Another Will Smith-Style Stunt
    Obsessions: 
    Mediaite: ‘I Was So F*cking Freaked Out’: Ex-NYT Staffer Describes ‘Crying’ and ‘Bloodthirsty’ Colleagues Seeking Vengeance for Cotton Op-Ed 
    NYPost: Censorship of Roald Dahl is more akin to China's cultural revolution than supposed democracies 
    Favorite Items of the Week: 
    The Athletic: Rosenthal: Remembering Tim McCarver, the ideal teammate in broadcasting and baseball 
    NYT: In a First, a Woman Issues a Thunderstorm Watch, Officials Say 

    • 59 min
    Polly Want A Crisis?

    Polly Want A Crisis?

    Rough week for NYT while the attempt to course correct on multiple fronts. We’re also looking at how the inflation is being interpreted amongst various publications and WaPo’s attempt at creating the next George Santos.

    If you have a story you want us to talk about, e-mail us at wretches@nebulouspodcasts.com.

    Receive show notes directly in your inbox, subscribe to the newsletter here.

    Watch this episode on YouTube

    Time Stamps: 
    2:08 Front Page
    50:15 Obsessions 
    1:00:30 Reader Mail
    1:06:56 Favorite Item of the Week

    Show Notes:
    Mediaite: NYT Edits Article Calling John Fetterman Health Needs ‘Special' 
    Hollywood Reporter: Judd Apatow, Gabrielle Union, Tommy Dorfman Accuse The New York Times of “Dangerous Inaccuracies” in Coverage of Trans People 
    John Hirschauer on Twitter: “The New York Times is bending over backwards to avoid saying the word “Chiefs.”
    Mediaite: WATCH: ESPN’s Chris Berman Ties ‘Abe Lincoln’s Birthday’ to the Historic Two Black QBs Who Started in the Super Bowl
    Reuters: Fox News must face Smartmatic's lawsuit over election-rigging claims
    The Hill: GOP senators push back at Biden’s FCC nominee during third hearing
    CNBC: Inflation rose 0.5% in January, more than expected and up 6.4% from a year ago 
    WaPo: US inflation slows to 6.4%, but price pressures re-emerge
    WSJ: To Save Money, Maybe You Should Skip Breakfast 
    WaPo: California fires widen the gap between rich and poor 
    Vox: Russia, climate, inflation: Are we headed toward a “polycrisis”? The buzzword at Davos, explained.
    WaPo: These women journalists were doing their jobs. That made them targets. 
    WaPo: The Hunter Biden laptop and claims of ‘Russian disinfo’
    Washington Examiner: Disinformation Inc: State Department bankrolls group secretly blacklisting conservative media 
    NyMag: The Only Success Story in Right-Wing Social Media 
    NyMag: Trump Insult ‘Meatball Ron’ Is Better Than ‘DeSanctimonious’ 
    The Onion: Adam Schiff Seeks Diane Feinstein’s Endorsement By Playing Into Delusion He’s High School Sweetheart Who Died In WWII
    DW: German director suspended after critic smeared with dog poo 
    Wapo: Anna Paulina Luna rose to Congress on a compelling life story. It surprised some who knew her.
    National Review: What’s going on with the Ohio train crash
    A Newspaper Taught Hemingway to Write
    Puck: Licht’s Rebound Play

    • 1 hr 10 min

Customer Reviews

4.8 out of 5
401 Ratings

401 Ratings

Anne HW ,

The Best

I happen to be listening to Chris and John Podhoretz this evening, and it’s one of the best political/entertainment podcasts ever!

That’s not to take anything away from Eliana Johnson, a wonderful cohost in her own right. I just happen to think Podhoretz is the best fill in guests out there.

hsames ,

Love This Podcast

They do a great job of poking fun at the sanctimonious and biased news media. Both sides get skewered but it is done without malice.

Boilingrug ,

I wanna like it

At 1st I really enjoyed. Now they sound like bratty children who can’t believe (you know the tone) some paper/reporter X doesn’t blah blah blah.

Top Podcasts In News

The New York Times
NPR
The Daily Wire
Crooked Media
Cumulus Podcast Network | Dan Bongino
CNN