It Just Makes Sense

Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
  • 4.4 (43)
  • SOCIETY & CULTURE
  • UPDATED BIWEEKLY

Welcome to “It Just Makes Sense!” the podcast by two easily distracted higher educated former lovers that explores all of the unpopular opinions, conspiracy theories and cult leaders that make you want to scream “THAT JUST MAKES SENSE!”

  1. 2000s Worship Nostalgia and Easter Reconciliation

    3D AGO

    2000s Worship Nostalgia and Easter Reconciliation

    Rarely does one episode pack in a hotel epiphany, a twerking contest, and a Summer House betrayal all in the same breath. This week's conversation covers a genuinely chaotic stretch of life, and it's hard to look away from any of it. The episode opens with a deep dive into 2000s worship music, including a memorable discovery of "He Will Raise You Up on Eagle's Wings" during a hotel stay in Cleveland. From there, things get personal fast. Cameron keeps coming home late on Fridays without warning This week's episode also included a trip to Hamilton, Canada for a Cardi B concert with Miles, a cooking class where tiramisu was made with Chef Camille, and Easter dinner featuring prosciutto-spinach-provolone stuffed chicken. The week was full, genuinely full. Tune in for the whole story.

    50 min
  2. Chit Chat 196 Coffee at Home and Strip Club Athletics: A Week of Buffalo Adventures

    APR 3

    Chit Chat 196 Coffee at Home and Strip Club Athletics: A Week of Buffalo Adventures

    Rarely does a single conversation cover airport runs at 3 a.m., stomach bugs, Easter Markets, and a spontaneous strip club visit, but here we are. This episode is a genuine slice of life, messy and entertaining in equal measure. Honestly, the week described here is a lot. Sam drove Cameron to the airport before dawn, then spent hours scrubbing down the bathroom after a stomach bug. Meanwhile, Jeff was recovering from a suspicious roast beef sandwich at Wagner's in Lockport that caused some serious digestive regret. Between a hockey game with a $55 all-you-can-eat buffet, a birthday ice cream cake debate (double chunk espresso versus vanilla, the real conflict), and a surprisingly impressive night out at a strip club, there is genuinely something for everyone here. What does it say about us when the most memorable part of a week involves Trader Joe's dumplings and RuPaul's Drag Race Season 11? (Nina West gets a well-deserved shoutout, by the way.) The conversation also touches on "Inside the Manosphere," a documentary the speakers strongly recommend for exposing how male influencers manufacture outrage for profit. If you want a warm, funny, and completely unfiltered look at real friendship and everyday life, press play.

    40 min
  3. Chit Chat 195 New Headsets and New Management: Jeff's Big Career Move

    MAR 27

    Chit Chat 195 New Headsets and New Management: Jeff's Big Career Move

    After a two-week hiatus, Sam and Jeff are back with some big news that's about to shake things up. Jeff just accepted a management position in banking starting April 20th, his first time leading a team after nearly nine years with his company. (The nerves are real when it comes to those one-on-ones and performance reviews.) Between scheduling conflicts and social exhaustion, these two have been living their best chaotic lives. From a disappointing 3 hour bingo event that only featured four actual games, to the darkly comedic musical "Kimberly Akimbo" about a teenager with a rare aging disease, their entertainment choices ran the gamut. The show earned five Tony Awards, though their companion found it confusing while Sam loved every minute. What happens when you attend a Buffalo fundraiser and your $10 donation gets publicly displayed next to much larger contributions? The Great Buffalo Debate brought spirited arguments about whether sponge candy or chicken wings represent peak Buffalo innovation. Meanwhile, their weekend spiraled into indulgence territory with full Philly cheesesteaks, regrettable tailgate beers, and ice cream that nobody could finish. Tune in to hear about their media binges, including thoughts on Netflix's age-guessing show and the controversy surrounding a canceled Bachelor season. Read Less

    43 min

  4. MAR 13

    Chit Chat 194 Rude Movie Theaters, Hockey Games, and Bakery Mishaps

    What happens when you order two half-sheet cakes without knowing their actual size? You'll end up sending guests home with massive amounts of leftovers (which is exactly what happened at this birthday celebration). This week's conversation covers everything from questionable movie theater encounters to the most exciting 8-7 hockey game featuring multiple fights and power play goals. The Sabres' impressive turnaround under returning coach Lindy Ruff gets discussed, along with deep cleaning discoveries like smudged walls and dusty cabinet floors that somehow go unnoticed for months. There's also the bizarre turkey pot pie incident at West End Inn in Hamburg, imagine ordering pot pie and receiving spicy soup with pita bread instead. The kind waitress agreed it looked disgusting and offered to remove it from the menu entirely. The speakers also share their weekend activities, including a haul from Palette Bros in Hamburg where everything costs just five dollars on special days, watching Paradise with Shailene Woodley, and dealing with persistent dog accidents requiring enzymatic carpet treatment. They touch on reading The Testaments by Margaret Atwood, starting a new podcast called The Great Vine, and watching Heart Stoppers, a British series about LGBTQ+ youth that hits them emotionally. Tune in for all the entertaining details and relatable weekend chaos.

    41 min
  5. Chit Chat 193 Seattle Chaos: Power Outages, Oversized Luggage, and Ferry Rides

    MAR 6

    Chit Chat 193 Seattle Chaos: Power Outages, Oversized Luggage, and Ferry Rides

    Ever wondered what happens when gelato meets a Ferris wheel? Sam and Jeff are back after their Seattle adventure, and honestly, this trip had everything. They nearly missed their 5:30 flight thanks to an airport power outage and an overly chatty 3 a.m. Uber driver who couldn't stop talking about San Francisco rent prices. (Trust me, not the conversation you want at that hour.) In Seattle, they hit Pike Place Market for Beecher's mac and cheese and Greek gelato with exotic flavors, toured Lumen Field home of the Seattle Seahawks, and explored the Pop Culture Museum's impressive collections. The Chihuly Gardens featured stunning glass sculptures, and the Space Needle shot them up in just thirty-eight seconds. Their ferry ride to Bainbridge Island proved delightful and relaxing with beautiful views. But let's talk about that Ferris wheel incident—one speaker's indulgent food choices created an increasingly uncomfortable situation over multiple rotations that required an urgent exit. They also caught a Disney Villains brunch at a queer bar, enjoyed espresso martinis throughout the day, and dealt with a birthday party host who refused to share cake. The chaos, the food, the mishaps—it's all here. Listen to find out which moment almost derailed the entire trip.

    46 min
  6. Chit Chat 192 Seattle Trip Planning and Weekend Adventures

    FEB 27

    Chit Chat 192 Seattle Trip Planning and Weekend Adventures

    Sam and Jeff are heading to Seattle and they're buzzing with anticipation. They've been researching Pike Market, debating whether to try clams and oysters, and considering a true crime tour. (Though they joke they'll probably be asleep by 10 PM anyway.) The conversation weaves through Nancy Grace's return to cover a missing person case and America's Most Wanted, before landing on their bigger plan: a trip to Pigeon Forge, Tennessee. Sam's planning to visit Dollywood, a True Crime Museum with six floors covering everything from medieval crime to serial killers, plus a Titanic Museum and Noah's Ark Museum. Between weekend stories about disappointing beer festivals and awkward comedy fundraisers, they share their struggle through an intense hot yoga class that left them repeatedly retreating to child's pose. One of them discovered they get faint when consuming cannabis while meal prepping, which led to ordering Alibaba Kebabs instead of cooking. Sam's been watching Love is Blind and questioning why contestants with ideal partners keep pursuing others, critiquing Stranger Things for making magical abilities contingent on coming-out storylines, and expressing outrage over Tyra Banks's handling of serious incidents on America's Next Top Model. Ready for some honest takes on travel plans, reality TV drama, and weekend adventures?

    54 min
  7. Chit Chat 191 Crowdfunding Controversies and Stolen Phones: A Week of Unexpected Lessons

    FEB 21

    Chit Chat 191 Crowdfunding Controversies and Stolen Phones: A Week of Unexpected Lessons

    What happens when the people we're supposed to trust break their promises? This week's episode dives into some uncomfortable truths about crowdfunding culture. The conversation kicks off with James Van Der Beek's trust-funded ranch purchase and a professional football player soliciting donations despite earning millions, both examples of wealthy people exploiting public generosity. (Because apparently having money doesn't mean you want to spend it.) The discussion gets particularly heated around a Buffalo business called Biker Bar, which raised significant funds before relocating to Miami without fulfilling orders. Beyond the crowdfunding drama, there's also talk about stolen phones at fitness classes, Valentine's Day dinner at Prescott's Provisions, and a touching memorial for a woman who dined out seven nights a week just to be around people. The speakers also share their thoughts on The 'Burbs remake, which they found disappointing, and their take on the new season of Love is Blind.

    46 min
  8. Chit Chat 190 Cabo Wedding Chaos and Comedy Club Disasters

    FEB 13

    Chit Chat 190 Cabo Wedding Chaos and Comedy Club Disasters

    Sam and Jeff dive into a wildly entertaining catch‑up session that spans a destination wedding in San José del Cabo, unexpected yacht drama, surprise LGBTQ plot twists, and a weekend full of sun, whales, karaoke, and chaos. Their stories weave through bar mishaps, awkward encounters, hidden hotel romances, and a hilariously tense cab ride—all while one friend navigates sobriety with grace and grit. Back home, the conversation spirals into comedy‑club disasters, rugby‑bar mayhem, Super Bowl reactions, celebrity gossip, conspiracy theories, book recs, and even a drunken Dawson’s Creek tattoo. It’s a fast, funny, and delightfully unhinged recap of travel, friendships, pop culture, and the strange ways life keeps surprising them.

    53 min
See All (384)

4.4
out of 5
43 Ratings

About

Welcome to “It Just Makes Sense!” the podcast by two easily distracted higher educated former lovers that explores all of the unpopular opinions, conspiracy theories and cult leaders that make you want to scream “THAT JUST MAKES SENSE!”

Information

  • Creator
    Samantha Smith and Jeffrey Siefert
  • Years Active
    2020 - 2026
  • Episodes
    384
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 It Just Makes Sense
  • Show Website
    It Just Makes Sense

You Might Also Like