It's Crime Time

Emily Fisher
  • 4.5 (6)
  • TRUE CRIME
It's Crime Time

A short true crime podcast detailing the stories of solved and unsolved cases for the true crime enthusiast to get a quick fix of true crime!

  1. OCT 31

    S03E01: McKamey Manor: America's most "Extreme Haunted House"

    McKamey Manor, an extreme haunted house attraction that features survival horror-style events was founded by Russell McKamey and ran on his property in San Diego until it was moved to Tennessee in 2017. McKamey Manor has been the center of much controversy over the years due to how extreme the tours are for participants which often involves various styles of torture such as waterboarding, binding and gagging, force feeding them various unknown substances, and much much more. Participants have to sign a 40-page waiver, be 21 years old (or 18-20 with a parent's signature), and be physically and mentally cleared by a doctor before they can participate. The only entry fee for the tour is four cans of dog food or a large bag of dog food for Russ' dogs. Not only has the manor garnered negative attention, but Russ himself has for his recently dropped charges filed by his girlfriend and his video posts on YouTube and Tik Tok. Sources Monster Inside: America's Most Extreme Haunted House (Hulu Documentary) The Tennessean (2024) The Guardian (2015) WKRN (2024) Wikipedia USA Today (2019) People (2024) Audio: Son Son Genovese (YouTube)- Russ McKamey admits he tortures poeple and 3 deaths at McKamey Manor

    23 min

  2. AUG 31

    S02E31: Fed to the Pigs--The Susan Monica Story

    On January 20, 2014, Police brought 65-year-old pig farmer Susan Monica from Wimer, Oregon in for questioning after 56-year-old Robert Haney's family reported him missing. Police had discovered that Susan used Robert's EBT card in December at a local Walmart. Robert's family had not heard from him for several months before going to visit Susan's farm to see where there father was, as he had been working for her since the summer of 2013. He was nowhere to be found but his items and dog were left on the property. When police conducted a search of Susan's property, a human leg severed at the femur was located near Susan's home. Robert Haney had not been the only man to go missing on her property after answering a Craigslist ad for help around the farm, but another man, Stephen Delicino had vanished, as well. He had begun working for Susan in 2012. It was discovered that Susan had used the aid of her beloved pigs to help complete and conceal her crimes. Sources ⁠All That's Interesting (2023)⁠ ⁠Daily Mail (2024)⁠ ⁠ID Crimefeed⁠ ⁠Explore With Us (YouTube, 2023)⁠ Snapped (Season 29, Episode 2: Susan Monica) Audio (Interrogation) ⁠Explore With Us (YouTube, 2023)⁠

    28 min

  3. JUL 20

    S02E30: The Case of Gwen Amber Rose Araujo

    On the night of October 3, 2002, Gwen Amber Rose Araujo, a transgender teen from California attended a party at a home rented by Jose and Paul Merel. Michael Magidson, Jason Nabors, Jason Cazares, Emmanuel Merel, and Nicole Brown were all present at the party. Upon learning that Gwen was biologically born a male, the men became irate that they had engaged in sexual acts with her previously. This led to a brutal attack on Gwen which ultimately caused her death. Gwen's case paved the way for important legislation being passed in California which aims to eradicate the use of the gay/trans panic defense in court cases. Sources The San Francisco Standard (2022) Wikipedia Gender Public Advocacy Coalition (2003) SF Gate (2003) SF Gate (2005) SF Gate (2005)

    19 min
  4. S02E29: A Woman Scorned- The Case of Al Benitez and Elizabeth Reynolds

    JUN 22

    S02E29: A Woman Scorned- The Case of Al Benitez and Elizabeth Reynolds

    Just before 7 AM on August 9, 2003, the Kleberg County Sheriff's office in Texas received a 9-1-1 from a man saying he had been shot. When police arrived at the scene of the man's home, they realized the victim was one of their own, Albert Benitez, a former police officer and border patrol officer who now spent his time training young police officers. He had been shot six times and his girlfriend, Elizabeth Reynolds had been kidnapped and taken away in Al's stolen car by the perpetrator. As details of the case came to light and another crime almost took Al's life once again, it began to become clear who really wanted to Al Benitez dead. Sources Murder Calls- Season 1 Episode 5- Death at the Door (info and audio source) Justia-ELIZABETH REYNOLDS v. THE STATE OF TEXAS--Appeal from 105th District Court of Kleberg County Snapped- Season 6 Episode 5-Elizabeth Reynolds

    17 min
  5. S02E28: The Disappearance and Murder of Evelyn Boswell

    MAY 19

    S02E28: The Disappearance and Murder of Evelyn Boswell

    15-month-old Evelyn Boswell was reported missing by her maternal grandfather, Tommy Boswell, Sr. in February of 2020. He stated he had not seen Evelyn since November of 2019. An Amber alert was issued on February 19, 2020. Other accounts say she had been missing since December 10-11 of 2019 which is the last time her babysitter had seen her. Her mother, 18-year-old, Megan Boswell had made a series of contradictory statements to police and the media regarding the whereabouts of her daughter. Megan was later arrested for false reporting, and while in custody, police located the remains of missing Evelyn Boswell on the Boswell property on March 6, 2020. The investigation was far from over as detectives had to sift through the tangled web of lies spun by Megan to determine what really happened to little Evelyn. Sources: USA Today (2020) WVLTV 8 (2020) Knox News (2022) Tennessee Lookout (2022) Oxygen (2022) People (2022) WJHL 11 (2022) WJHL 11 (2022) Audio WATE 6 On Your Side (YouTube) | Press Conference: Sullivan Co. Sheriff, TBI hold media briefing re. Evelyn Boswell case March 6, 2020.

    37 min
  6. S02E27: Marlene Warren and the Florida Killer Clown

    MAR 2

    S02E27: Marlene Warren and the Florida Killer Clown

    On the morning of May 26, 1990, 40-year-old Marlene Warren was preparing breakfast for her son and his friends when she heard the door bell ring. Upon answering the door, she was greeted by a person dressed in a clown costume holding two foil balloons and a basket of carnations for her. When she reached for the gifts, the clown shot Marlene in the face and fled in their white Chrysler LeBaron. For 27 years, Marlene's case remained unsolved, despite having obvious suspects. With the advancements in DNA technology, Marlene's killer finally faced justice in 2017. Sources CBS News (2023) CBS News (2023) Chilling Crimes (2021) WPTV (2017) The US Sun (2023) Killer Queens Podcast

    28 min
  7. S02E26: The Mysterious Disappearances of Andre Bryant, Christopher Dansby, and Shane Walker

    FEB 10

    S02E26: The Mysterious Disappearances of Andre Bryant, Christopher Dansby, and Shane Walker

    During 1989, three unrelated African American baby boys went missing under mysterious circumstances from New York. Andre Bryant, a one month old baby boy disappeared from Brooklyn, and his mother, Monique Rivera was found murdered the next day. He has never been located. Christopher Dansby, a 2-year-old baby boy went missing from a park located near the Martin Luther King, Jr. apartment complex in May 1989. Three months after Christopher went missing, 18-month-old Shane Walker went missing from this same park under eerily similar circumstances. Sources International Missing Persons Wiki The Charley Project Uncovered Unsolved Mysteries Wiki Uncovered Unsolved Mysteries Wiki Uncovered

    31 min
  8. S02E25: The Crimes of the Knights of the Crystal Blade-Doomsday Cult

    JAN 13

    S02E25: The Crimes of the Knights of the Crystal Blade-Doomsday Cult

    In 2016, John Coltharp and his best friend founded a doomsday cult loosely based on the teachings of the FLDS. It is important to note that the FLDS had no idea about this cult nor did it condone their behavior. In September of 2017, John’s estranged wife, Micha Coltharp went to the Utah police department to report that John had taken their children and she could not locate him nor contact him. Thinking this would be a routine domestic dispute that could easily be resolved, police started to investigate but what they discovered was far worse than they initially imagined as the children along with John Coltharp, his parents Catherine and Keith Coltharp, and his second-in-command in the cult, Samuel Shaffer had packed up and left to create a commune in the deserts of Lund, Utah.

    34 min
See All (63)

4.5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

A short true crime podcast detailing the stories of solved and unsolved cases for the true crime enthusiast to get a quick fix of true crime!

Information

  • Creator
    Emily Fisher
  • Years Active
    2019 - 2024
  • Episodes
    63
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Emily Fisher
  • Show Website
    It's Crime Time

To listen to explicit episodes, sign in.

Stay up to date with this show

Sign in or sign up to follow shows, save episodes, and get the latest updates.
Select a country or region

Africa, Middle East, and India

Asia Pacific

Europe

Latin America and the Caribbean

The United States and Canada