31 episodes

A True Crime Comedy Podcast: Each week, Broadway stars Jennifer Simard and Jessica Vosk interview celebrities from Broadway & beyond about their love of true crime and discuss one infamous case from their guest's home state!

Killing It On Broadway Killing It On Broadway

    • True Crime
    • 4.9 • 162 Ratings

A True Crime Comedy Podcast: Each week, Broadway stars Jennifer Simard and Jessica Vosk interview celebrities from Broadway & beyond about their love of true crime and discuss one infamous case from their guest's home state!

    Charles Manson with J & J

    Charles Manson with J & J

    In the Season One Finalé, Jenn & Jess bookend as they started, sharing an episode between the two of them and one of the most infamous murderers in history.

    • 53 min
    JOHN LENNON with Julia Murney

    JOHN LENNON with Julia Murney

    Broadway star and NYC native Julia Murney joins J & J this week to discuss the case that still haunts fans worldwide. As an upper west sider, Julia shares her long personal history not only to the neighborhood but to this beloved, global icon. 

    • 51 min
    Martha Wise - The Borgia Of America with Sally Wilfert

    Martha Wise - The Borgia Of America with Sally Wilfert

    Broadway diva, singing star & BFF Sally Wilfert joins Jenn & Jess this week to discuss one of the oldest female serial killers from the state of Ohio.

    • 41 min
    The Long Island Lolita with Marissa Rosen

    The Long Island Lolita with Marissa Rosen

    Broadway Beltress and BFF Marissa Rosen joins Jess & Jenn this week to discuss her personal connection to the case that took place in her hometown in Long Island. 

    • 40 min
    The Disappearance of Susan Powell with Claybourne Elder

    The Disappearance of Susan Powell with Claybourne Elder

    Broadway/TV Star and Utah native Claybourne Elder joins Jenn & Jess this week to do discuss this tragic and confounding case.

    • 53 min
    Michael Peterson with Beth Leavel

    Michael Peterson with Beth Leavel

    Tony Award Winner and North Carolina native Beth Leavel joins Jenn & Jess for their silver anniversary episode to discuss the case made famous by the documentary "The Staircase"

    • 50 min

Customer Reviews

4.9 out of 5
162 Ratings

162 Ratings

workitmama007 ,

Brilliant

They are at the top of their game for a reason. Love love! Sharing with all my friend. Jenn. Jess. Let’s party!!! Y’all are AWESOME.

Mroot100 ,

Love this

A show that combines my love of Broadway and my weird fascination with murderers? Yep, here for it. I listen to each new episode the day it comes out, and will continue to!

Sleepy Girl Saved ,

Unique Twist on a Cultural Topic

I have been a fan of Jessica since I saw her in Wicked and met her. As a lover of true crime, I was excited to hear about a new true crime podcast. Listening to this podcast will definitely not disappoint. With the unique twist of having other Broadway stars talking about true crimes from their home states, it’s a sure fire curtain call of wit, information and pure comedic genuis(as much as can be with the subject matter). JessiCAH and JenniFAH are a dynamic duo. I hope these podcasts continue for a long time.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Status: Untraced
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy
Beyond All Repair
WBUR
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Dateline NBC
NBC News
The Price of Paradise
Wondery
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery

You Might Also Like