34 episodes

A podcast to help you fall in love with movies all over again. Each week, Conrad Rothbaum and his co-host ShwinnyPooh come on to "Make the Case" -- that is, to put forth a hot take, argument or simply a new perspective -- about a movie they love. For questions or comments please email us at makethecasepodcast@gmail.com and we might read your email on the air! You can also call us and leave us a voicemail at (818) 538-4966 -- we want to hear from you, and may play your voicemail on the podcast! Follow the show on Twitter at @makethecaseshow. Co-hosts Conrad and Shwin are also on Twitter as @csroth and @shwinnypooh respectively, but if you follow them, be prepared for many, many tweets about the New York Knicks on your feed.

Make the Case Make The Case Podcast

    • TV & Film
    • 5.0 • 9 Ratings

A podcast to help you fall in love with movies all over again. Each week, Conrad Rothbaum and his co-host ShwinnyPooh come on to "Make the Case" -- that is, to put forth a hot take, argument or simply a new perspective -- about a movie they love. For questions or comments please email us at makethecasepodcast@gmail.com and we might read your email on the air! You can also call us and leave us a voicemail at (818) 538-4966 -- we want to hear from you, and may play your voicemail on the podcast! Follow the show on Twitter at @makethecaseshow. Co-hosts Conrad and Shwin are also on Twitter as @csroth and @shwinnypooh respectively, but if you follow them, be prepared for many, many tweets about the New York Knicks on your feed.

    Episode 33: The Best Films of 2023 with Rebecca Goldstein, Dylan Visvikis and Simon Schiller

    Episode 33: The Best Films of 2023 with Rebecca Goldstein, Dylan Visvikis and Simon Schiller

    Join Conrad, Shwin and special guests Rebecca Goldstein, Simon Schiller and Dylan Visvikis as they break down their favorite films of the year. We laughed! We cried! We blew up a pipeline.

    Please note that while we try to avoid specific spoilers, if you want to go into these films completely fresh, you may want to wait to listen to this pod or to avoid the specific segment on the film in question.

    Below is a list of of the films we discussed with handy timestamps so that you may skip around:

    May December 00:03:54

    Beau is Afraid 00:12:09 

    Killers of the Flower Moon 00:18:55 

    Priscilla 00:30:08

    Wonka 00:36:38

    Oppenheimer 00:46:52 

    Poor Things 00:58:02 

    How to Blow Up a Pipeline 01:04:35 

    Zone of Interest 01:12:07 

    Satlburn 01:28:43 

    Honorable Mentions 01:35:50 
    (Past Lives, Shortcomings, Theater Camp, Bottoms, Sanctuary, The Holdovers, Monster, Juwan, Landscape with Invisible Hand, Missing, I Have To Do This)

    Other Things We Liked This Year 01:42:29 
    (Succession, The Last of Us, Jury Duty, I'm a Virgo, The Bear, Game Theory with Sam Vecenie, Troye Sivan's "One of Your Girls," Spider-Man 2 (the video game), The Corrections by Jonathan Franzen)

    • 1 hr 50 min
    Episode 32: Kubrick Part III: Dr. Strangelove

    Episode 32: Kubrick Part III: Dr. Strangelove

    ...OR HOW I LEARNED TO STOP WORRYING AND LOVE THE POD!

    Today, we make this pod short and sweet, as we talk Stanley Kubrick's nuclear panic satire, DR. STRANGELOVE!

    Topics include: 1) What is the corollary today for fear of nuclear war in 1965; 2) Are we more  afraid of atom bombs or bodily fluid theft; 3) did we want Peter Sellers to play a fourth role? (Of course we did).

    If you liked this podcast, please rate and review it (5 stars please), and click the subscribe button to get next week's episode!

    • 37 min
    Episode 31: Kubrick Part II: Spartacus and Lolita

    Episode 31: Kubrick Part II: Spartacus and Lolita

    THEY TRAINED THEM TO PODCAST FOR THEIR PLEASURE...  BUT THEY TRAINED THEM A LITTLE TOO WELL!! // HOW DID THEY EVER MAKE A PODCAST OF LOLITA?

    In this episode, we continue our analysis of Kubrick's career with the "Least Kubrick" of Kubrick's films: Kirk Douglas' SPARTACUS and Vladimir Nabokov's LOLITA! 

    Topics include: SPARTACUS' tangled web of inconsistent subtext; the historical significance of SPARTACUS in breaking Hollywood's communist blacklist; an unexpected analysis of Brad Pitt's legacy; if there was  a good reason (besides $$$) to make a movie of LOLITA; alternate  Humbert Humbert casting ideas (including Marlon Brando and Matthew McConaughey), and a Hitchcock movie ranking.

    If you liked this podcast, please rate and review it (5 stars please), and click the subscribe button to get next week's episode!

    • 1 hr 8 min
    Episode 30: Kubrick Part I: The Killing & Paths of Glory

    Episode 30: Kubrick Part I: The Killing & Paths of Glory

    IN ALL ITS FURY AND VIOLENCE… LIKE NO OTHER PODCAST SINCE “BLANK CHECK” AND “THE BIG PICTURE”!

    This week, we kick off our most ambitious series yet: a retrospective on the films of Stanley Kubrick, one by one, from the very beginning, INCLUDING BARRY LYNDON (that sound you just heard was Shwin crying in anguish). We start with Kubrick’s first two studio pictures, THE KILLING and PATHS OF GLORY.
    Topics include: the historical context in which Kubrick came to self-actualize as an “auteur;” which directors and films were inspired by The Killing’s non-linear, cerebral approach to a pulpy crime plot (we’re looking at you, Nolan and Tarantino),  and whether or not Paths of Glory should be considered a satire.

    If you liked this podcast, please rate and review it (5 stars please), and click the subscribe button to get next week's episode!

    • 1 hr 20 min
    Episode 29: JFK

    Episode 29: JFK

    HE'S A PODCAST CO-HOST. HE WILL RISK HIS LIFE, THE LIVES OF HIS FAMILY, EVERYTHING HE HOLDS DEAR FOR THE ONE THING HE HOLDS SACRED... THE TRUTH.

    This week, we finish off our Oliver Stone trilogy with his operatic paranoiac JFK. Released in 1991, this film tells you that if you think Lee Harvey Oswald acted alone, you're just not asking the right questions. Who benefits from the most epic conspiracy theory propaganda ever propagated by Hollywood? You, the consumer of course!!

    Topics include: What exactly did Oliver Stone make up, and what were his intentions with the film? What is the appeal of Kevin Costner? And did the guy Joe Pesci is based on really look like that? We find out live!

    If you liked this podcast, please rate and review it (5 stars please), and click the subscribe button to get next week's episode.

    • 1 hr 10 min
    Episode 28: Primer

    Episode 28: Primer

    WHAT HAPPENS IF IT ACTUALLY PODS?

    This week, we loop back to the 2004 cult classic time travel drama from Shane Carruth, PRIMER. Famously shot for $7000 (we have some thoughts about that) and supposedly containing enough information to articulate its own plot (we have some more thoughts about that), the film is a taut, psychological thriller about the deterioration of a friendship, and we go back to interrogate its existence.

    Did we understand this movie? Maybe? Did you? Why are you asking so many questions? Is it because this movie is so confusing? Is that your double standing behind you?

    If you liked this podcast, please rate and review it (5 stars please), and click the subscribe button to get next week's episode.

    • 1 hr 4 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
9 Ratings

9 Ratings

AdamF NYC ,

Fun, conversational pod

Conrad and Shwin play off each other well. They do their homework, and are okay with letting each other cook on their respective pet subjects.

A fun film watchers pod, though the episodes aren’t usually about making specific cases. Probably nitpicky, I guess.

ChazLyon ,

Make The Case

Great movie podcast! Very good analysis, interesting and a fun listen!

MBCinNYC ,

Godfather II MAKE THE CASE

Fantastic podcast! I felt like I experienced seeing Godfather II all over again on a much deeper and richer level. I found myself googling a lot of the scenes referenced and picked up nuances that I’ve missed. I will definitely need to watch Godfather I and II again and I’ve seen them three times already.

Top Podcasts In TV & Film

Watch What Crappens
Ben Mandelker & Ronnie Karam | Wondery
Who Killed the Video Star: The Story of MTV
Audacy Studios
Not Skinny But Not Fat
Dear Media, Amanda Hirsch
The Rewatchables
The Ringer
Give Them Lala
Lala Kent | Cumulus Podcast Network
Pretty Little Liars: True Crime
PodCo