5 episodes

Have you ever stayed up later than you meant to as you tried to solve the murder of Jonbenet Ramsey from your own bed? Ever have a conversation at a party take a sharp, dark, unexpected turn to Jeffrey Dahmer? Are you outraged at the police 100% slacking on the cases of Mitrice Richardson and Kenneka Jenkins? Do you fall asleep to the sweet, sweet sounds of true crime podcasts in your ear buds each night? Then our love of true crime has brought us together, friend.

This podcast is for the true crime lovers who yearn to see murders solved and missing persons found. As a mom and lifelong lover of crime, I share weekly mysteries (with a content guide for little listeners!) that have kept me company as I weather the long days and nights of parenting. Together we’ll play armchair detective and dig into chilling, real-life stories of human behavior.

Milk and Murder Bethany Roach

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 94 Ratings

Have you ever stayed up later than you meant to as you tried to solve the murder of Jonbenet Ramsey from your own bed? Ever have a conversation at a party take a sharp, dark, unexpected turn to Jeffrey Dahmer? Are you outraged at the police 100% slacking on the cases of Mitrice Richardson and Kenneka Jenkins? Do you fall asleep to the sweet, sweet sounds of true crime podcasts in your ear buds each night? Then our love of true crime has brought us together, friend.

This podcast is for the true crime lovers who yearn to see murders solved and missing persons found. As a mom and lifelong lover of crime, I share weekly mysteries (with a content guide for little listeners!) that have kept me company as I weather the long days and nights of parenting. Together we’ll play armchair detective and dig into chilling, real-life stories of human behavior.

    Murdered Cheryl Coker

    Murdered Cheryl Coker

    Dayton, OH mom Cheryl Coker goes missing after dropping her daughter off at school. She posts a few posts on Facebook, her phone pings a few times around the house, and then she’s never seen alive again. Surveillance footage in a grocery store parking lot shows a mysterious person dropping off her car and walking away, leaving nothing but questions and devastation. 
    View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary:
    Episode Guide: Murdered Cheryl Coker
    Support the Show: 
    patreon.com/itwasthehusband

    • 24 min
    Murdered Jim and Tina

    Murdered Jim and Tina

    Jim Wright and Tina Combs were leaning into their newly blooming long-distance friendship when they decided to meet for the very first time. However, what should have been an exciting new adventure ends up being the most gruesome crime the town of Kyle, TX has ever seen. 
    View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary:
    Episode Guide: Murdered Jim & Tina
    Support the Show: 
    patreon.com/itwasthehusband
     

    • 21 min
    Murdered Cassie Cotta

    Murdered Cassie Cotta

    Cassie Cotta was a force of nature from Fort Smith, Arkansas. She was well-loved and resilient, bouncing back after some unexpected life setbacks. When she goes outside of her routine by missing a work shift and not posting on social media, her loved ones embark on a search for her that turns their worlds upside down.
    View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary:
    Episode Guide: Murdered Cassie Cotta
    Support the Show: 
    patreon.com/itwasthehusband

    • 25 min
    Kidnapped Bizzy Bone

    Kidnapped Bizzy Bone

    Before his rise to fame as Bizzy Bone of Bone Thugs-n-Harmony, Bryon Anthony McCane was abducted as a 4-year-old. His kidnapper told him his mom was dead and drove him over 1,000 miles away. This is the story of how the infamous disappearance and murder of Adam Walsh sparked the creation of America's Most Wanted, the show that brought Bizzy home.
    View the Content Guide, Sources, and a Case Summary:
    Episode Guide: Kidnapped Bizzy Bone
    Support the Show: 
    patreon.com/itwasthehusband

    • 21 min
    Missing ShyShy Pate

    Missing ShyShy Pate

    8-year-old Shy'Kemmia Shy'Rezz (ShyShy) Pate went missing in September 1998. Though her mom calls 911 right away, the police make a critical mistake that leads to a colossal delay in the search. When they finally do begin to look for her, there is one thing standing in the way of her case getting the attention it deserves: her race.

    Show notes, content guide, and sources can be found at:  www.milkandmurder.com/episodes/missing-shyshy-pate

    • 26 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
94 Ratings

94 Ratings

RebekkahRosewood ,

Better than Milk and Cookies

A kind heart, beautiful voice, and well-researched content make this podcast one of the absolute best out there. Absolutely recommend, and suggest you hit that follow/subscribe button right now.

cyclone_erin ,

LOVE!

I love learning about lesser known cases, and I love hearing about the victims more than the murderers. And Bethany has an amazing voice, which makes listening even more enjoyable!

Curlytopk ,

Can’t wait for more

Your heart and kindness have me in tears. I’m hooked. #FindShyShy

Top Podcasts In True Crime