Murder, but Dinner First

Matt and Rae

Join us as Matt cooks a delicious meal while Rae serves up a chilling true crime story. Between bites, cocktails, and conversation, you'll hear the twists, secrets, motives, and mysteries behind real-life murder cases—all from the comfort of their dinner table. From infamous crimes to lesser-known cases that deserve attention, Murder, But Dinner First blends dark storytelling with good food, sharp humor, and the kind of dinner conversation your mother probably warned you about. So grab a plate, pull up a chair, and remember: the murder can wait...

Episodes

  1. 2d ago

    The Black Widow of Florida

    It's not all sunshine and beaches in Florida. Judy Buenoano not only had dark secrets hidden in her medicine cabinet, but something in the trunk of her car as well.

  2. Aug 10

    Serial Killer Keith Gibson

    Keith Gibson killed multiple people in two states, but what if he could have been stopped before more innocent lives were lost? Listen now to hear the story. But don't forget, dinner first.

  3. Aug 3

    The Lynching of Charles Lockwood

    This weeks dinner is filling and not at all suspicious like our dear friend Charles Lockwood. Join us for delicious dinner from Connecticut and story that will have you wondering, what really happened and who is telling the truth.

  4. Jul 27

    The Weightlifting Killer

    This murderer can bench press more weight then the amount of crimes he committed...maybe. Listen now to hear the story of Marvin Gayle Gray and his criminal career. But first, hear about another meal Matt has cooked up for us.

  5. Jul 24 ·  Bonus

    Ladles Belong in the Kitchen

    Rae shares how to not get murdered while traveling and the best weapon of defense, then tells you a murder bedtime story that will have you checking to make sure your door is locked. Get your snack and your favorite blanket and listen to this bonus episode that will take you down a rabbit hole.

  6. Jul 20

    The Neighbor from Hell

    A couple in California buys their dream home and starts their life with their family, but the neighbor has other plans.

  7. Jul 17 ·  Bonus

    Bonus Episode: Devil's Den Double Homicide

    Can't sleep? Neither can we. Here is one more bedtime murder story before you tuck yourself in. Don't forget to lock the door.

  8. Jul 13

    The Phantom Killer

    This unsolved killing spree will keep you up at night wondering if the Phantom Killer is still up in the night looking for his next victim. Listeners lock your doors and join us for dinner as we share the story.

  9. Jul 6

    The Remorseless Murderer

    Join us for dinner inspired by Arizona. Then sit back and listen to a murder case that will leave you hungry and filled with questions we may never get the answers to. Good thing there are plenty of leftovers.

  10. Jun 29

    The Butcher Baker

    Tonight's dinner (and murder) is brought to you by Alaska. Pull up a chair and join us at the table to hear about The Butcher Baker.

  11. Jun 22

    The Samson Massacre

    Join us for a delicious home cooked Alabama meal while listening to the store of a deadly murder spree.

  • 11 Episodes

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
4 Ratings

About

Join us as Matt cooks a delicious meal while Rae serves up a chilling true crime story. Between bites, cocktails, and conversation, you'll hear the twists, secrets, motives, and mysteries behind real-life murder cases—all from the comfort of their dinner table. From infamous crimes to lesser-known cases that deserve attention, Murder, But Dinner First blends dark storytelling with good food, sharp humor, and the kind of dinner conversation your mother probably warned you about. So grab a plate, pull up a chair, and remember: the murder can wait...

Information

  • Creator
    Matt and Rae
  • Years Active
    2026
  • Episodes
    11
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Matt and Rae
  • Show Website
    Murder, but Dinner First