Network Capital

Network Capital

Network Capital’s (NC) mission is to democratize inspiration and make personalized mentoring and career guidance accessible to every person on the planet. We are a global community of more than 200,000 peer mentors from 104 countries who learn with and from each other. We are a subscription based career content and mentoring community 1. Serve as your personalized career coach in the form of global tribe of mentors. No matter what you are looking for, someone on Network Capital has done it. 2. Offer carefully curated jobs and internships 3. Access to Network Capital TV and all subgroups

  1. Jul 23

    Should university admissions be determined solely by examination performance, or should they assess the applicant as a whole?

    Harvard's holistic admissions system emerged in the 1920s, in part to reduce the number of Jewish students who had excelled under an examination-based system. "Character" and "fit" became the language through which discrimination could be exercised. That history remains the strongest argument for examinations: anyone with access to the syllabus and sufficient preparation can, in principle, compete on equal terms, and what the paper cannot see cannot be turned against the candidate. Yet examinations are difficult to defend as the sole criterion for admission. A few hours on a single day can determine a student's future, while late bloomers, unconventional thinkers, and those whose abilities are not easily captured by timed tests are overlooked. Nor are examinations immune to inequality. Years of expensive coaching can meaningfully improve performance, sustaining an industry built on converting financial resources into higher scores. Holistic admissions try to capture what exams miss: curiosity, resilience, creativity, leadership, and potential. But they also rely on subjective judgement. Essays, interviews, recommendations, and extracurricular activities are difficult to evaluate consistently, and many of the experiences that make an application stand out, from research internships to international volunteering, can be bought just as coaching for entrance exams can. What is a university for? Is it an institution that identifies those who are already exceptional, or one that cultivates potential?

5
out of 5
9 Ratings

About

Network Capital’s (NC) mission is to democratize inspiration and make personalized mentoring and career guidance accessible to every person on the planet. We are a global community of more than 200,000 peer mentors from 104 countries who learn with and from each other. We are a subscription based career content and mentoring community 1. Serve as your personalized career coach in the form of global tribe of mentors. No matter what you are looking for, someone on Network Capital has done it. 2. Offer carefully curated jobs and internships 3. Access to Network Capital TV and all subgroups