93 episodes

Dive into the dark world of true crime with us! Every week Benton & Anna review a case introduced to us by the campy world of true crime television documentaries. Watch with us as we have as much to say about the crime as we do about the production values.

Stab in the Back Stab In The Back

    • True Crime
    • 5.0 • 34 Ratings

Dive into the dark world of true crime with us! Every week Benton & Anna review a case introduced to us by the campy world of true crime television documentaries. Watch with us as we have as much to say about the crime as we do about the production values.

    Crony Bennett's Greatest Hits

    Crony Bennett's Greatest Hits

    Episode 92 is all about cover ups! Sometimes it's before an investigation can even take place. 

    First, Anna gives a small rundown on how justice can be thwarted early on, and Benton gives the details on the tragic death of Kendrick Johnson. Then, Anna tells the sordid tales of Warren G. Harding.

    Finally, the two settle in for a classic episode of Cold Case Files, profiling the death of Kimberly White.

    Our TV doc this week is the second half of Season 3: Episode 11, "The Bad Cop".

    • 1 hr 39 min
    Babes in Sex Toyland (3rd Anniversary Episode)

    Babes in Sex Toyland (3rd Anniversary Episode)

    Happy 3rd anniversary to Stab in the Back! Join Benton and Anna as they reminisce and discuss another year gone by, and invite a few special guests to share their favorite true crime stories. 

    First, we welcome back one of Anna's best friends, Casey, who relays the murder of Austin jewelry store owner Ted Shaughnessy. Then, we welcome back Benton's partner, Matt, who tells the tale of Italian politician Aldo Moro's kidnapping and assassination. 

    Also, play along to Anna's game, "Medieval torture device or new Target sex toy?", and stay for the 3rd annual Stabby Awards!

    • 1 hr 57 min
    Chef Buoyant Dee

    Chef Buoyant Dee

    Was it an accident, a suicide, or a murder? That is the theme of this week's episode, and you'd be surprised how often that question is asked.

    First, Anna shares some information about accidents and why they might fly under the radar as unexplained deaths, and Benton tells the tale of the mysterious death of Gareth Williams. Then, Anna relays the tragic tale of the puzzling death of Laura Letts-Beckett. 

    Finally, the two discuss a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the death of Janice Johnson. 

    Our TV doc this week is Season 4: Episode 9 of Forensic Files, "Accident or Murder?"

    • 1 hr 51 min
    Folie à Deux: Trois!

    Folie à Deux: Trois!

    Strap in, it's the annual Valentine's Day episode! Crimes involving folie à deux are the gifts that keep on giving, and this episode focuses on more than 2 people being in on the delusion. 

    First, Anna goes down the list of how people can develop such shared delusions, and Benton tells the tragic tale of the mass suicide of the Chundawat family. Then, Anna recounts the case of three sisters who fed into each other's religious fanaticism. Finally, the two watch an episode of Forensic Files, profiling the notorious BJ and Erika Sifrit.

    Our TV doc this week is Season 13: Episode 47 of Forensic Files, "Dirty Little Secret".

    • 1 hr 29 min
    Anne of the Thousand Slays

    Anne of the Thousand Slays

    Have you ever wondered how safe it is to work as a news anchor? Then episode 88 is for you, because they get murdered, too! 

    First, Anna and Benton discuss why news anchors might have an elevated level of danger, and Benton tells of the senseless murder of Anne Pressly. Then, Anna relays the story of thee stalking/murder of Katherine Dettman. Finally, the two watch a classic episode of Forensic Files, profiling the murder of anchorwoman Diane King.

    Our TV doc this week is Season 9: Episode 5 of Forensic Files, "News at 11".

    • 1 hr 39 min
    Alice in Murderland

    Alice in Murderland

    Have you ever had a bad neighbor? For our first show of the new year, we dive into murders in the community between people who live in close proximity with each other. 

    First, Benton tells the tale of Melanie Smith, who burned 5 members of her neighbor's family to death, and Anna relays the tragic story of the Pike County murders. Lastly, the two enjoy a classic episode of American Justice, profiling the murder of Bobby Kent.

    Our TV doc this week is Season 8: Episode 33 of American Justice, "Payback for a Bully".

    • 1 hr 37 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
34 Ratings

34 Ratings

caaaroline ,

Love it

The hosts are so funny and genuine. The stories are interesting and well-researched. I love that they discuss true crime episodes! Fun but also disturbing at times, I love it!!

cristinaphelps ,

magic bottled into a podcast

These two hosts are effortlessly hilarious, witty, and engaging. The latest episode “simply the breast” had me rolling on the floor laughing with the hamburger bun murder (and my hips just can’t support this sort of outward display of joy as I’m currently 107 years old and my boyfriend who’s 18 needs me to stay limber and supple. Seriously- this podcast delivers !!! Check it out y’all! You won’t regret it. Also just ordered a small T-shirt but would love to know when XS is in stock for my boy toy to wear. Love you guys to bits ! Cristina Phelps

Mimi Face ,

These timeless beings are so profesh

Not just 2+ good true crime stories with good audio quality. You also get themed cocktails, punny jokes, Bubbles the chimp updates, and grotesque presents concealed in a box and foisted onto Anna.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Dateline NBC
NBC News
CounterClock
audiochuck
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
Blood is Thicker: The Hargan Family Killings
CBS News
20/20
ABC News

You Might Also Like

The Adventure Zone
The McElroys
My Brother, My Brother And Me
The McElroys
Sawbones: A Marital Tour of Misguided Medicine
Justin McElroy, Dr. Sydnee McElroy
The Besties
Chris Plante, Griffin McElroy, Justin McElroy, Russ Frushtick
My Favorite Murder with Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark
Exactly Right Media – the original true crime comedy network
Criminal
Vox Media Podcast Network