The Buck Stops Here

Kirk Buchner
  • 3.0 (4)
  • Sports
  • Updated Biweekly

The Buck Stops Here is the official podcast of NotInHallOfFame.com, where host Kirk Buchner and his rotating cast of co-hosts—including Evan Nolan and Chris Mouradian—tackle the ever-evolving world of sports legacy. From Hall of Fame snubs to underappreciated legends, this show dives deep into the stories behind the stats. Whether it’s breaking down new inductees, debating controversial omissions, or spotlighting forgotten greats, The Buck Stops Here is where sports history gets the respect—and scrutiny—it deserves.

  1. 2h ago

    The NBA Hall of Fame is Broken | Reacting to Ben Golliver's 11 Future HOFers

    Kirk and Chris dive into ESPN’s Ben Golliver’s latest article detailing 11 men’s NBA players who could be elected to the Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Fame in the next three years. (https://www.espnlacrosse.com/2026/08/14/the-11-nba-players-on-the-basketball-hall-of-fames-waiting-list/ )From first-ballot locks like Chris Paul and Russell Westbrook to borderline debates surrounding Blake Griffin, Derrick Rose, and Andre Iguodala, we break down who actually belongs in Springfield. Plus, Kirk shares his controversial theory: Is the Basketball Hall of Fame intentionally delaying men's inductions because they are BROKE and need to manufacture ticket sales for their ceremonies?We also discuss Marc Gasol’s international path, Shawn Marion’s 2011 championship resume, and why Kyle Lowry will always have a special place in Toronto Raptors history.👇 Vote at the United States Athletics Hall of Fame! 👇https://www.theusahof.comWho is the biggest snub on this list? Do you think Blake Griffin was purposely held back last year? Let us know below! 👇 Don't forget to vote for your all-time greats at the United States of Fame. Subscribe for more Buck Stops Here!If you enjoyed this breakdown, hit that subscribe button, drop a like, and tell us in the comments: Is Derrick Rose a first-ballot Hall of Famer because of his MVP, or does he need the Senior Committee?

    The NBA Hall of Fame is Broken | Reacting to Ben Golliver's 11 Future HOFers

  2. Aug 9

    Tony Romo FIRED? 😱 Lizzo's Career is OVER & WNBA Owner Suspended! | July Elevator Show

    Welcome back to The Elevator Show! 🛗⬆️⬇️Hosts Kirk Buchner and Chris Mouradian are back to evaluate who is going UP and who is going DOWN in the Hall of Fame elevator this past month. July might have been a slow month for some, but the drama, comebacks, and collapses were off the charts!This month, we break down Tony Romo’s embarrassing drunk driving incident and why CBS is likely pulling the plug on his $18M contract. We also dive into Lizzo’s massive career downfall, a miraculous comeback from MMA’s Ben Askren, and a wild WNBA controversy involving a Seattle Storm co-owner berating fans courtside. Plus, we celebrate a 27-year-old track record being shattered and some massive front-office moves in the NBA and MLB!🗳️ VOTE FOR THE HALL OF FAME!Make your voice heard and vote for your favorite athletes at the newly revamped US Athletic Hall of Fame: www.theusahof.comIn this episode:📉 Tony Romo’s "Walk of Shame" & CBS Firing📈 Josh Kerr breaks a 27-year-old Mile World Record📉 Cal Raleigh’s historic MLB collapse📈 Ben Askren’s miraculous return after a double lung transplant📈 76ers Front Office pulls off the ultimate NBA heist (LeBron & Jaylen Brown!)📈 Andrew Friedman & the Dodgers land Tarik Skubal📈 Ella Langley dominates the Billboard charts📉 Lizzo’s new album tanks amid toxic bullying allegations📉 Seattle Storm Co-Owner suspended for cursing out young fansDon't forget to LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, and hit the BELL 🔔 so you never miss an episode of The Elevator Show!Who do you think had the biggest fall from grace this month: Tony Romo or Lizzo? Let us know in the replies! 👇 And don't forget to cast your Hall of Fame votes at www.theusahof.com !

    Tony Romo FIRED? 😱 Lizzo's Career is OVER & WNBA Owner Suspended! | July Elevator Show

  3. Aug 7

    Ranking the Greatest Coaches & Managers in Sports History | Author Matthew DiBiase

    Welcome back to The Buck Stops Here, the official program of NotInHallOfFame.com and the United States Athletics Hall of Fame!Today, host Kirk Buchner sits down with sports historian, SABR member, and acclaimed author Matthew DiBiase. Matthew is the groundbreaking author behind a series of books that mathematically rank the greatest coaches and general managers across the four major North American sports.In this episode, we dive deep into his latest release, Patriarchs of the Dugout, which makes history by integrating Negro League managers into the official MLB rankings using a unique "plus/minus" metric system. Matthew also shares some shocking reveals from his upcoming NBA coaching book, Men in the Huddle, and explains why legendary managers like Bobby Cox and Tony La Russa missed his Top 10 cut.📚 Check out Matthew DiBiase’s Books (Available on Amazon):• Bench Bosses: The NHL's Greatest Coaches• The Art of the Dealers: The NHL's Greatest General Managers• Lords of the Gridiron: College Football's Greatest Coaches• Lords of the Gridiron Two: Pro Football's Greatest Coaches• Patriarchs of the Dugout: Baseball's Greatest Managers• Men in the Huddle: Pro Basketball's Greatest Coaches (Coming October 1st!)🗳️ VOTE NOW for the USA Athletics Hall of Fame!Help shape Class Number 4 of the greatest American athletes of all time. Your vote counts!👉 Vote here: www.theusahof.com🔗 Connect with the Show:Website: www.NotInHallOfFame.com

    Ranking the Greatest Coaches & Managers in Sports History | Author Matthew DiBiase

  4. Jul 23

    MLB Midseason Awards, World Cup Final Thoughts & NFL HOF Ballot Preview

    Kirk Buchner and Dave Whitlock are back for another episode of The Buck Stops Here! Fresh off the All-Star break, the guys break down the MLB midseason awards, debating the MVP and Cy Young races, and building their ultimate All-MLB Team 1. Plus, they share their unfiltered thoughts on the World Cup Final and the debate over sporting event halftime shows.To wrap things up, Kirk previews the upcoming changes the the Not In Hall of Fame Football list, discussing first-time eligibles like Ben Roethlisberger and Cam Newton, along with heavyweights like Richard Sherman, Antonio Brown, and Rob Gronkowski.🗳️ Vote for the United States Athletics Hall of Fame! Head over to theUSAHOF.com to cast your ballot and help shape the next class of inductees.🔗 Check out all our updated lists and content at NotInHallOfFame.com.👍 If you enjoyed the episode, please LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, and leave a review!

    MLB Midseason Awards, World Cup Final Thoughts & NFL HOF Ballot Preview

  5. Jul 9

    Jim Thorpe’s Granddaughters Reveal the Untold Truth About America's Greatest Athlete

    The legend of Jim Thorpe is known worldwide, but the personal stories of the man behind the medals are kept alive by his family.In this special episode of The Buck Stops Here, host Kirk Buchner sits down with Anita, Mary, and Teresa Thorpe—the granddaughters of the legendary first-ballot inductee of the United States Athletics Hall of Fame, Jim Thorpe.Kirk presents the ceremonial plaque for Jim Thorpe's induction to the USAHOF's First Class and together they dive deep into the untold stories of the greatest athlete of the 20th century. From winning two Olympic gold medals in mismatched shoes, to his "wild spirit" that included standing up to Al Capone and helping Native American actors in Hollywood, the Thorpe women share the heart, humility, and incredible bloodline of the man who paved the way for Indigenous athletes everywhere.We also discuss the bizarre history of how the town of Jim Thorpe, PA got its name, the racist archaic rules that led to his Olympic medals being stripped (and eventually restored), and the Jim Thorpe Memorial Foundation in Oklahoma that preserves his only home.🏆 Vote for the 4th Class of the United States Athletics Hall of Fame! Cast your vote for athletes, coaches, contributors, and commentators at: theusahof.com🏛️ Support the Jim Thorpe Memorial Foundation:Learn more and support the preservation of Jim Thorpe’s legacy at: https://www.jimthorpememorialfoundation.org/🎙️ Follow Kirk Buchner & Not In Hall of Fame: Website: NotInHallOfFame.com“Wherever you are or if you may be, make today count because it never comes again.”What is your favorite Jim Thorpe story or athletic achievement? Let us know in the comments below!🔔 Don't forget to SUBSCRIBE for more incredible conversations with the legends of sports history.🗳️ Have your say: Head over to theusahof.com right now to cast your vote for the 4th Class of the United States Athletics Hall of Fame!

    Jim Thorpe’s Granddaughters Reveal the Untold Truth About America's Greatest Athlete

  6. Jul 8

    Country Music Hall of Fame Predictions: Seismic Jumps, Controversies & Crossover Hits

    Welcome back to The Buck Stops Here, the official podcast of NotInHallOfFame.com! Host Kirk Buchner is joined by Aaron Edward Freeman, the mastermind and curator behind the Country Music Hall of Fame prediction list.In this episode, Kirk and Aaron break down the latest seismic shifts in the Country Music HOF rankings. Find out why Trisha Yearwood and The Chicks are making massive jumps, why "The Voice" Vern Gosdin is the new #1 in the Veterans category, and how off-stage controversies involving Garth Brooks, Morgan Wallen, and Bailey Zimmerman are impacting Hall of Fame trajectories. Plus, they discuss the current state of country music, Ella Langley's historic crossover success, and share some hilarious Canadian nostalgia.🗳️ Vote for the Class of 2026! Help decide who goes into the United States Athletics Hall of Fame at www.theUSAHOF.com. You can vote every day!📊 Check out the Predictions: See Aaron’s full, updated Country Music Hall of Fame prediction lists (Modern & Veterans) at www.NotInHallOfFame.com.👍 Support the Show: If you enjoyed the episode, please Like, Comment, Subscribe, and let us know who YOU think deserves to be in the Country Music Hall of Fame!

    Country Music Hall of Fame Predictions: Seismic Jumps, Controversies & Crossover Hits

  7. Jul 6

    Wes Welker's HOF Case & The Eli Manning Debate!

    Welcome back to The Buck Stops Here! In this special episode, Kirk is joined by regular guest and Long Island native Robert Dobek to step away from baseball and tackle the gridiron and the ice.First, Kirk breaks down some breaking news and "shady" optics surrounding the 2026 Hockey Hall of Fame class and Brian Burke’s induction. Then, Rob takes the floor to make a passionate Hall of Fame case for New England legend Wes Welker. Kirk and Rob debate the evolution of the slot receiver, compare Welker to Julian Edelman, and discuss the "Super Bowl bias" that keeps greats like Logan Mankins and Marshawn Lynch on the outside looking in.Later, Rob (a Giants fan) gives his unfiltered take on Eli Manning’s Hall of Fame chances, and the guys settle the debate on who is the greatest goalie in NY Rangers history: Mike Richter or Henrik Lundqvist. Finally, Kirk teases a massive new grassroots project to redo the Baseball Hall of Fame starting in 1909, ensuring Negro League legends are honored in real-time.If you love deep-dive sports debates, Hall of Fame arguments, and unfiltered takes, you’re in the right place!🎙️ Join the Debate: Do you think Wes Welker deserves a Gold Jacket? Is Eli Manning a Hall of Famer? Let us know in the comments below!🗳️ Vote for the Greatest: Head over to theUSAHOF.com to cast your votes for the United States Athletic Hall of Fame. We just mailed out Bonnie Blair’s plaque, and we want your help deciding the next class of legendary athletes, coaches, and contributors!🔔 Subscribe & Review: If you enjoyed this episode, please hit that subscribe button, leave a 5-star review, and share it with a friend.

    Wes Welker's HOF Case & The Eli Manning Debate!

  8. Jun 25

    Bergeron, Price & Tkachuk Make HHOF + The Brian Burke Committee Controversy

    Welcome back to Season 7, Episode 9 of The Buck Stops Here! Kirk Buchner and Evan Nolan are back to break down the newly announced 2026 Hockey Hall of Fame class. We celebrate first-ballot legends like Patrice Bergeron, Carey Price, and Keith Tkachuk, but we also take the HHOF selection committee to task. Kirk breaks down the lack of transparency surrounding Brian Burke’s induction and Evan compares it to a "Cheney Committee."Plus, we talk FIFA World Cup 2026! Kirk shares his incredible experience watching the USMNT in Seattle, the amazing cultural mashup in the city, and the unbelievable mental fortitude of the Iranian National Team. Finally, we pay our respects to the legends we lost in June and give you everything you need to know about voting for the United States Athletics Hall of Fame.Make today count, because it never comes again!🗳️ VOTE FOR THE UNITED STATES ATHLETIC HALL OF FAME:Your voice matters! Head over to theUSAHOF.com to cast your votes, see the rankings, and help decide the next class of inductees. There are no secret committees here—just pure democracy!🏈 VISIT THE UPTON BELL COLLECTION:If you are in the UMass Lowell area, check out the Upton Bell Collection featuring the new United States Athletics Hall of Fame plaque, including NFL legend Bert Bell!👍 SUPPORT THE SHOW:If you enjoyed the episode, please Like, Subscribe, Hype and leave a comment below! Let us know who you think should be in the Hockey Hall of Fame next year, or share your thoughts on the World Cup.

    Bergeron, Price & Tkachuk Make HHOF + The Brian Burke Committee Controversy
See All (626)

Ratings & Reviews

3
out of 5
4 Ratings

About

The Buck Stops Here is the official podcast of NotInHallOfFame.com, where host Kirk Buchner and his rotating cast of co-hosts—including Evan Nolan and Chris Mouradian—tackle the ever-evolving world of sports legacy. From Hall of Fame snubs to underappreciated legends, this show dives deep into the stories behind the stats. Whether it’s breaking down new inductees, debating controversial omissions, or spotlighting forgotten greats, The Buck Stops Here is where sports history gets the respect—and scrutiny—it deserves.

Information

  • Creator
    Kirk Buchner
  • Years Active
    2020 - 2026
  • Episodes
    626
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © Kirk Buchner
  • Show Website
    The Buck Stops Here