217 episodes

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

The Creep Off The Creep Off

    • True Crime
    • 4.7 • 194 Ratings

Congratulations, you have discovered the greatest and only comedy true crime competition on the internet! Every week our hosts Karl and Vinnie go head-to-head and each make their nominations for the biggest creep in any given category. Then You the listener get to decide the points, and the loser spins the dreaded wheel of consequences. 

    Pop Rocks & Coke

    Pop Rocks & Coke

    in preparation for WATP live this weekend in Florida, Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for biggest Creep from Tampa Bay! We also meet Red-Head Meg our latest results girl contestant: In our Cop Cam segment we meet the drunkest man ever: In the Scum Parade we learn about a new law, meet the best/worst former cop and a very strict father. Florida Middle Schoolers Arrested for Allegedly Creating Deepfake Nudes of Classmates | WIREDErie County man accused of using a cattle prod to discipline his young children (cleveland19.com)Mississippi cop Michael Green forced detainee to lick up own urine off jail cell floor (nypost.com)Blaise Taylor, former Titans scout, charged in poisoning death of girlfriend, unborn child (wsmv.com)

    • 1 hr 16 min
    Tatonka

    Tatonka

    After a crazy weekend of Subreddit Surfing and Celebrating 500 episode of WATP, Vinnie slow things down with a hangover edition of the show featuring a new challenger for the results girl competition as well as a brand-new creep off song written and performed by Kristine Knowlton! Spoiler it sucksThe score is currently Vinnie 0 - Karl 1Check out today's stories: Wisconsin Man Legally Named "Deez-Nuts" Is Busted Following Domestic Fracas | The Smoking GunTwo Ohio women drove to bank with dead man's BODY in car to withdraw $900 from drive-thru before dropping corpse off at hospital | Daily Mail OnlineFlorida woman allegedly went on date with elderly man and had her ex hit him in the head, rob him | Truecrimedaily.comRoyal Caribbean cruise worker arrested on child porn charges admits to hiding under passengers' beds to capture videos of them coming out of shower | Daily Mail OnlineWoman sentenced to life imprisonment by Kerala court for killing her newborn baby (devdiscourse.com)NJ Man Throws Toddler While Walking On Dead Woman As Infant Sits In Feces: PA State Police | Adams Daily VoiceSleeping homeless man killed with ax in Seattle (kptv.com)Semen found on diaper: Pretoria man convicted of raping his 11-month-old daughter (iol.co.za)

    • 1 hr 45 min
    Slumber Party Smoothie Massacre

    Slumber Party Smoothie Massacre

    In today's episode Karl & Vinnie are joined by Bryan Johnson from Tell’em Steve Dave for a wildcard creep-off matchup: In our cop cam segment we meet a very drunk man who managed to make it home to his driveway, not that it matters: In the Scum Parade, we meet a horny Elvis impersonator, a woman with an alligator in her pants and another woman with a tampon out of her pants! We wrap up the show with Vinnie spinning the wheel of consequences. The score is currently Vinnie 0 - Karl 0, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winnerCheck out the Scum Parade stories: Florida woman sentenced to probation after pulling live alligator from her pants during traffic stop (aol.com)Hailey Bieber's sister Alaia Baldwin 'accused of throwing used tampon at bartender and assaulting employees at Georgia bar' as she is arrested following altercation at Savannah bar | Daily Mail OnlineBand severs ties with member who they say fed them estrogen-filled pre-workout drinks (nypost.com)Elvis Tribute Artist Accused of Child Sex Crimes (frontpagedetectives.com)Want to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 40 min
    Dirty Dick Hamburger

    Dirty Dick Hamburger

    In today's episode Karl & Vinnie make their nominations for creepiest Amazon Employee: We meet Danni our first contestant in tour results girl competition: In the Scum Parade, we meet a perverted millionaire, an even hornier exterminator and a black-market plastic surgeon.The score is currently Vinnie 4 - Karl 4, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winner.Check out the Scum Parade stories:  Long Island exterminator Walter Rivas arrested, accused of filming 19-year-old undress (nypost.com)Ohio mom who left toddler alone when she went on vacation pleads guilty to aggravated murder (detroitnews.com)Millionaire who led double life as twisted sex beast is jailed after drugging & raping victims in his home film studio | The SunBlack-market plastic surgeon hit with prison time for fatal butt-job (nypost.com)Want to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 10 min
    Sugar Daddy

    Sugar Daddy

    In today's episode Karl & Vinnie get back to normal and make their nominations for creepiest City Council Member: in our cop cam segment we witness an officer lose their job in real time: In the Scum Parade we meet a man at the tail end of a 20-year panty raid, a man who rekindled the fire in his relationship and the worst in-laws everWe also say goodbye to Jess who is leaving the show to take a new job in a bank. We wish her nothing but the best! If you want to be our new results girl shoot us an email at thecreepoffpod@gmail.com The score is currently Vinnie 4 - Karl 3, visit thecreepoff.com to vote and decide this week’s winnerCheck out the Scum Parade stories: Pervert arrested in Bangkok after 2 decades of underwear theft | Thaiger (thethaiger.com)Family jailed after woman poisoned and doused in corrosive substance | Crime | The GuardianBrian Early Johnston admits to setting wife on fire (nypost.com)Nurse 'cut off sleeping husband's penis with kitchen knife' over fears he cheated - Daily StarWant to support the show? Find us on Patreon, Supercast & Backed.by to get exclusive merch an extra bonus episode every week! Don’t forget you can leave us a voicemail at 585-371-8108

    • 1 hr 7 min
    Changing Ashley’s Diaper

    Changing Ashley’s Diaper

    In this episode Karl is joined by Blind Mike for a Scum Parade and the unveiling of our latest letter from Mathew Lewinsky the “Podcast Hitman”. And because Karl cannot help himself there is some spicy SJ in Atlantic City talk. Check out the Scum Parade stories:    https://nypost.com/2024/02/06/news/parents-of-lacey-fletcher-woman-found-melted-to-couch-plead-no-contest-to-manslaughter/Homeless man stole dummies from babies' mouths and used them to 'soothe himself' - Daily StarTerrifying photo shows wide-eyed perv caught masturbating outside mum's window - Daily StarBrazilian man, 39, took selfie lying down next to his wife's corpse and sent it to her family after killing her | Daily Mail OnlineMother of severely disabled Utah woman, 31, who cannot talk and is the size of eight-year-old catches daughter's stepdad raping her after setting up cameras in room to capture seizures | Daily Mail OnlineHorrific Incident: Mentally challenged man sets hut on fire, throws boy (5) inside | My Zimbabwe NewsMum shares bed with husband's corpse for 4 years and tells kids to 'keep mouths shut' - Daily StarSex noises from San Diego massage parlor interrupt church services, lead to prostitution bust: report (nypost.com)

    • 1 hr 15 min

Customer Reviews

4.7 out of 5
194 Ratings

194 Ratings

Yahhhlonduh ,

Arby’s

3 Pepper sauce is where it’s at

Arby200014 ,

Drive to Detroit

Join Vinny and Karl as they laugh like school girls over the deaths of school girls and other grizzly crime stories.

chidenorms ,

I pulled my Patreon support, and you should too

I pulled my support for the creep off Patreon and the WATP Patreon when Karl decided to start shilling for cops. He’s not a podcaster anymore, just a full time bootlicker. Back the blue, until it happens to you. Carl is in a band and for sure drinks and drives when they play gigs (if he doesn’t he’s a pozer), he has also mentioned on numerous occasions that he uses controlled substances every once and awhile. Only a matter of time before his luck runs out and the same cops who he invests so much time running PR cover for bring their boot down on him. And he deserves it too.

P.s. Vinny is a talentless hack and total NPC who only has the most obvious normie takes about everything. Totally incapable of being funny, interesting, unpredictable, or healthy and will be a victim of heart disease undoubtedly meeting his demise before he’s 50 but, hey, pizza is yummy yummy yummy! Right guys? Useless eater.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Three
Wavland
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
20/20
ABC News
SERIALously
10 to LIFE

You Might Also Like

Who Are These Socials?
Karl Hamburger
Who Are These Podcasts?
WhoAreThese.com
SubReddit Surfing
Sub Reddit Surfing
The Dick Show
Dick Masterson
The Biggest Problem in the Universe
Dick Masterson
The Blind Mike Project
Blind Mike