The Valley Verdict

The Valley Verdict
  • 5.0 (5)
  • SPORTS
  • UPDATED DAILY

The Valley Verdict delivers the final word on everything happening in the Arizona sports world. ​This is the only podcast completely devoted to passionate, full coverage of the major Phoenix market teams, including the Arizona Cardinals, Phoenix Suns, Arizona Diamondbacks, and ASU football and basketball. ​Hosted by David Murphey, broadcasting from the land of the Big Sky in Billings, Montana, we offer in-depth analysis, game breakdowns, and a unique perspective on the teams that matter most to the Valley of the Sun. If it’s happening in Arizona sports, we’ve got the verdict.

  1. 6H AGO

    Don't Buy The May Hype

    Mainstream sports media wants to crown rookies in May based on zero-contact football, but the Arizona Cardinals coaching staff just pulled back the curtain on why unpadded evaluations can be a total illusion. Tonight, we bypass the surface-level training camp hype tracks and dive deep into the real mental and physical chess match of NFL offseason training. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome: The Grand Jury Manifesto Establishing a brand-new era for the show. Moving forward, you aren't just listeners—you are The Grand Jury. We lay down the blueprint for a community of gritty, hard-working, blue-collar people who look at the raw evidence, demand excellence, and act as an immediate economic force for the local businesses that back us. 16:47 - Cardinals: Slicing Open the OTA Tape A full strategic breakdown of the Cardinals' first OTA session. We analyze the coaching staff's warning regarding "t-shirt and shorts" superstars and address a high-IQ devil's advocate challenge from Avis regarding young quarterback Carson Beck's remote playbook install versus the speed of real physical duress. The Memorial Day Bounty Challenge Wrapping up the session with an urgent update on our active $50 Mooyah Gift Card Bounty. The holiday weekend has wrapped up and the card is still sitting on the studio console—we lay down the mandate for the first fast-moving local fan in Billings to step off the sidelines and claim the stake before it turns into a double-drop for the 4th of July. Follow The Valley Verdict: YouTube: @TheValleyVerdict Facebook: @TheValleyVerdict Instagram: @TheValleyVerdictPodcast

    46 min

  2. MAY 16

    The 100-Pitch Masterclass — Kelly Dominates the Rockies

    Merrill Kelly put on an absolute clinic in efficiency against the Rockies, throwing a complete game on exactly 100 pitches. This episode bypasses the surface-level box scores to dive deep into the advanced analytics behind a masterpiece of weak contact and defensive lockdown. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome: The Art of Precision Reacting to the raw emotion of the 9th inning as Merrill Kelly secures a rare complete game on exactly 100 pitches with zero walks. 04:48 - D-backs: Slicing Open the Data Tables A full breakdown of the 9-run, 13-hit offensive avalanche that backed up our ace. Plus, we address a direct challenge from Avis regarding "luck" vs. execution by introducing a microscopic .111 BABIP stat that proves just how locked down the Arizona defense really was. Follow The Valley Verdict: YouTube: @TheValleyVerdict | Facebook: @TheValleyVerdict | Instagram: @TheValleyVerdictPodcast

    19 min

  3. MAY 12

    The Valley Blueprint — From Rookie Mini Camp to the Randy Bennett Era

    As the Suns close the book on their season, the rest of the Valley is just getting started. We’re tracking the first steps of the Cardinals' 2026 draft class and the seismic shift in Tempe as ASU basketball officially ushers in the Randy Bennett era. From the trenches of rookie mini-camp to the "miracle" staff assembly at ASU, we are breaking down the new faces of Arizona sports. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome: The Villain at the Table Opening the show with the "Sighting of the Week"—Dillon Brooks courtside at Lakers/Thunder. We discuss the energy he brings to the Suns and how that sets the tone for the offseason. 10:36 - Cardinals: The New Foundations A full breakdown of the introductory press conferences for the 2026 class. We analyze the fit and the logic behind the picks: The Trenches: Chase Bisontis and Jayden Williams. The Playmakers: Carson Beck and Reggie Virgil. The High-Motors: Kaleb Proctor and Karson Sharar. Mini-Camp Reports: Thoughts from OC Mike LaFleur and Jeremiyah Love as the rookies hit the grass for the first time. 1:43:25 - ASU Basketball: The Randy Bennett Era Begins Covering the long-awaited introduction of the Sun Devils' new leader five weeks after the hire. The Presser: Randy Bennett’s "Mayo Clinic Miracle" and his "Retention over Recruitment" philosophy. The Rivalry: Dr. Michael Crow’s message to the "barking dog to the south." The Scrum: Key takeaways from the post-presser media scrum with Randy Bennett and Graham Rossini regarding the Big 12 transition and the 12-man roster built by the staff. The "Betting on Yourself" Teaser A quick look at a major development involving a high-level athlete's journey to the ACC and what it means for the future of the brand. Follow The Valley Verdict: YouTube: @TheValleyVerdict | Facebook: @TheValleyVerdict | Instagram: @TheValleyVerdictPodcast

    3h 9m

  4. MAY 9

    The Path Forward: 2025-26 Suns Exit Interviews & Season Review

    After a 45-win season and a first-round exit, the Phoenix Suns transition into a critical offseason. We are reviewing the exit interviews from the locker room to the front office to understand where this team stands and what the leadership expects moving forward. From the tactical adjustments made during the postseason to the "alignment" of the organization, we are breaking down the reflections of the players and the vision for the future of the Suns. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome & The State of the Verdict Opening the show with a look at the rhythm of the podcast and the focus for the upcoming offseason. 06:02 - Suns Season Review: Player & Front Office Perspectives Initial Reflections: Breaking down the post-game thoughts from Coach Jordan Ott, Devin Booker, and Jalen Green. We look at the takeaways from the postseason series and the reality of the talent gap in the Western Conference. The Core Contributors: Analyzing the season-end comments from Dillon Brooks and Colin Gillespie. We discuss the impact of Brooks’ identity on the team culture and Gillespie’s historic shooting season. Rotation Analysis: Reviewing the perspectives of Grayson Allen and Oso Ighodaro. We examine the tactical challenges faced during the year and the lessons learned by the younger core. The Organizational Vision: Closing with the interviews from General Manager Brian Gregory and Majority Owner Mat Ishbia. We discuss the philosophy of continuity, the impact of injuries on the season's outcome, and the plan to build on this year's foundation. Avis Stands on the Table: Avis highlights the one player whose approach sets the standard for the roster heading into next season. Follow The Valley Verdict: YouTube: @TheValleyVerdict Facebook: @TheValleyVerdict Instagram: @TheValleyVerdictPodcast

    3h 19m

  5. MAY 8

    Kurt Warner’s Verdict: Is Carson Beck the Future? | 2026 Cardinals Draft Recap

    Can a single draft class erase years of identity crisis, or did the Cardinals just buy a Ferrari without checking the engine? We’re breaking down the blueprints of the Monti Ossenfort era. From the emotional "Ground Zero" of the Jeremiyah Love selection to the polarizing "Beck Paradox," we’re analyzing whether Arizona just built a championship foundation or a house of cards. With a masterclass breakdown from Hall of Famer Kurt Warner, we’re delivering the Verdict on the 2026 Rookie Class. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome & The Mooyah Bounty Redemption The hunt is over. We officially crown the winner of the $50 bounty in Billings—congratulations to Dawn! We discuss why persistence pays off and how to stay locked in for the next drop as the Mooyah new hours take effect. 25:26 - The Cardinals 2026 Draft: Blueprint for a Dynasty? The Bell Cow Philosophy: Why Jeremiyah Love (#4) is more than just a speedster. We hear from Monti Ossenfort, Mike LaFleur, and a moving perspective from Jeremiyah’s father on what it means to be the new heart of the Bird Gang. The Beck Paradox: The "Miami Swagger" vs. The Hall of Fame Eye. We take a hard look at Carson Beck (#19). Is he the "Natural" thrower Kurt Warner sees on film, or does the game-day attitude suggest a glitch in the leadership system? Avis Stands on the Table: Why Avis is looking past the skill players to highlight #57 Chase Bisontis. We discuss why SEC-tested "infrastructure" is the real home run of this draft. Scouting the Sleepers: From the vertical threat of Reggie Virgil to the small-school motor of Kaleb Proctor, we analyze the Dave Sears logic of finding value in every round. Follow The Valley Verdict: YouTube: @TheValleyVerdict Facebook: @TheValleyVerdict Instagram: @TheValleyVerdictPodcast

    2h 18m

  6. APR 24

    The Phoenix Folktale & The WWE Whistle

    What if one decision in a sweltering Phoenix summer created a championship dynasty for a rival and a "ghost story" for the Valley? Tonight, we’re opening the forensic files on the 2018 NBA Draft. This isn't just about a missed pick—it’s about the "Original Sin" of the Robert Sarver era that fundamentally broke the Suns' currency and gift-wrapped the future to Oklahoma City. From the "Eugene Illusion" to the WWE-style officiating in Game 2, we’re delivering the Absolute Verdict on how the Suns became the architects of their own destruction. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome & MOOYAH Bounty Update Checking the tag on the $50 bounty in Billings. We discuss why the prize is still out there and how you can claim it before the window closes. 06:30 - The Absolute Verdict: A Phoenix Folktale The Eugene Illusion: Why the Suns chose Ayton over Luka to "save" a backcourt they would eventually sabotage anyway. The Shadow in the War Room: The moment Robert Sarver overruled the basketball minds and left Shai Gilgeous-Alexander on the table. The Broken Currency: How the SGA miss forced the Suns into the "Star-Hunting" cycle, leading to the gutting of the roster for KD and Beal. The Three-Franchise Fire: Why the OKC Thunder as we know them today shouldn't exist. 18:08 - Suns/Thunder Game 2 Recap Analyzing the 100-77 collapse. We look at the talent gap, the missing depth, and the reality of the 0-2 deficit as the series heads back to Phoenix. 23:48 - Who’s Got The Beef? (Presented by MOOYAH Billings) The Target: Official James Williams. The Receipt: Devin Booker calls out the officiating by name and questions the "WWE" integrity of the league. The Caruso Factor: Why Alex Caruso was effectively coaching the officials on when to blow the whistle. Follow The Valley Verdict: YouTube: @TheValleyVerdict Facebook: @TheValleyVerdict Instagram: @TheValleyVerdictPodcast #TheValleyVerdict #Suns #OKCThunder #NBAWhatIf #SGA #RobertSarver #JamesWilliams #WWE #MooyahBillings #PhoenixSuns

    38 min

  7. APR 23

    Draft Eve Intel & ASU Spring Wrap-Up

    On this all-football edition of The Valley Verdict, we go from the final whistle of spring ball in Tempe to the high-stakes decisions facing the Cardinals in Glendale. We’re breaking down the chemistry building at ASU and the scouting reports on the potential future of the Cardinals' backfield. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome & MOOYAH Bounty Update Checking the tag on the $50 bounty in Billings. We discuss why the prize is still out there and how you can claim it before the window closes. 09:44 - ASU Football: Spring Finality Analyzing the final day of spring practice and the outlook for the program heading into the summer. The Coaches: Takeaways from Kenny Dillingham and Marcus Arroyo. The QB Room: Breaking down the development of Cutter Boley, Jake Fette, Cam Dyer, and Mikey Keene. The Backfield: Marquis Gillis on his transition and the physical style of play in the running back room. 45:02 - Arizona Cardinals: Draft Eve Breakdown The Front Office: Analyzing the recent comments from Monti Ossenfort and Mike LaFleur ahead of Thursday night. The Tillman Intel: We catch up with Stephen and Heath from Tillman’s Corner Sports Talk for a deep-dive scouting report on Alabama QB Ty Simpson. We look at his high football IQ, the contrast in playing styles compared to Kyler Murray, and whether the rumors of the Cardinals trying to land both Simpson and Jeremiah Love make sense for the roster. Follow The Valley Verdict: YouTube: @TheValleyVerdict Facebook: @TheValleyVerdict Instagram: @TheValleyVerdictPodcast #TheValleyVerdict #ASU #SunDevils #AZCardinals #NFLDraft #TySimpson #JeremiahLove #MooyahBillings #AlabamaFootball

    1h 42m

  8. APR 21

    Playoff Reality Checks & D-backs Series Review

    The Standard is set. On this episode of The Valley Verdict, we break down a massive weekend of high-stakes sports. From a brutal postseason opener in Oklahoma City to a defining series win for the Diamondbacks, we’re looking at the numbers, the discipline, and the connectivity of these rosters as the pressure turns up. In this episode: 00:00 - Welcome & MOOYAH Bounty Update Starting the show with a look at the $50 gift card that remains unclaimed in Billings. We go over the rules, the handwritten details on the card, and exactly what you need to do to claim the prize before someone else beats you to the punch. 07:21 - Phoenix Suns: Playoff Reality in OKC Analyzing the 119-84 loss to the Thunder. The Discipline Gap: Breaking down the 34-to-2 discrepancy in points off turnovers. Injury Report: Jordan Goodwin’s calf injury and the impact on the bench depth. The Veteran View: Devin Booker on facing the defending champs. 34:34 - Arizona Diamondbacks: Series Review vs. Toronto Game 1 (6-3 Win): Michael Soroka earns his 4th win of the season. Plus, Nolan Arenado joins Mark Grace and Walsh postgame, and Torey Lovullo speaks to the media. Game 2 (6-2 Win): The Corbin Carroll grand slam. Corbin joins the postgame crew to talk through the 8th-inning heroics. Game 3 (10-4 Loss): Analyzing the Sunday slide and Torey Lovullo’s final takeaways from the series. 1:03:30 - ASU Football: Culture & Recruiting Maroon & Gold Scrimmage: Coach Kenny Dillingham on the locker room chemistry and the "culture" win of seeing thirty guys hanging out on an off-night. The Big Twelve Leap: Can a Top 15 recruiting rank handle a brutal upcoming schedule? #TheValleyVerdict #Suns #Dbacks #ASU #MooyahBillings #BeTheHammer #ArizonaSports #MLB #NBA

    1h 20m
See All (670)

Trailer

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
5 Ratings

About

The Valley Verdict delivers the final word on everything happening in the Arizona sports world. ​This is the only podcast completely devoted to passionate, full coverage of the major Phoenix market teams, including the Arizona Cardinals, Phoenix Suns, Arizona Diamondbacks, and ASU football and basketball. ​Hosted by David Murphey, broadcasting from the land of the Big Sky in Billings, Montana, we offer in-depth analysis, game breakdowns, and a unique perspective on the teams that matter most to the Valley of the Sun. If it’s happening in Arizona sports, we’ve got the verdict.

Information

  • Creator
    The Valley Verdict
  • Years Active
    2021 - 2026
  • Episodes
    670
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © The Valley Verdict
  • Show Website
    The Valley Verdict