90 episodes

Too Close To Home sticks its nose into every creepy orifice on this crazy planet we call home. With foul mouths, dark humor, and irresistible charm, Jenn and Becky cover the true crime of now and yore, the supernatural, and the unknown terrors which could be lurking near your very doorstep. Stay safe, keep your head on a swivel, and don't bring it Too Close To Home!

Platforms and Social Media:
https://linktr.ee/TooCloseToHome
Merch:
https://www.bonfire.com/store/too-close-to-home/

Too Close to Home Too Close to Home

    • True Crime
    • 4.7 • 19 Ratings

Too Close To Home sticks its nose into every creepy orifice on this crazy planet we call home. With foul mouths, dark humor, and irresistible charm, Jenn and Becky cover the true crime of now and yore, the supernatural, and the unknown terrors which could be lurking near your very doorstep. Stay safe, keep your head on a swivel, and don't bring it Too Close To Home!

Platforms and Social Media:
https://linktr.ee/TooCloseToHome
Merch:
https://www.bonfire.com/store/too-close-to-home/

    88: Cambyses II - Older Than Methuselah

    88: Cambyses II - Older Than Methuselah

    We are going way back in time for a cautionary true crime tale, y'all... one that involves an ancient king, a corrupt judge, and the ultimate "f*#$ around and find out" symbolic punishment! In this short and sweet episode, we will divulge a little background on Cambyses II, some of the controversies surrounding his reign (which may or may not be truthful), and the event, memorialized in painting, which shows his penchant for truth, justice, and the Persian way... and "leather" upholstery. Karma is truly a bitch, and anyone who sits upon the chair will dutifully remember that.

    • 34 min
    87: Herb Baumeister and Fox Hollow Farm, Part 2 - There’s A Portal In My Toilet

    87: Herb Baumeister and Fox Hollow Farm, Part 2 - There’s A Portal In My Toilet

    As we begin part 2 of this series, we see the firsthand account provided by Tony Harris concerning Herb Baumeister's modus operandi, and how old Herb's life gets turned upside down (but not in a fresh prince sort of way). While Herb's metaphorical and literal "skeletons in the woods" are discovered, he takes fate into his own hands in the woodlands of Canada. In the second half of this episode, we look at the Graves family's anecdotal evidence surrounding the haunting of Fox Hollow Farm, and perhaps also what drew paranormal investigators (including certain controversial dude bro's) to the location. Is there a portal in the swimming pool? Are there dark entities within the woods of Fox Hollow Farm? Grab your digital recorder and find out!

    • 53 min
    86: Herb Baumeister and Fox Hollow Farm, Part 1 - When Tolerance Breeds A Serial Killer

    86: Herb Baumeister and Fox Hollow Farm, Part 1 - When Tolerance Breeds A Serial Killer

    How can one improve upon the thrift shop business model? What is the taste of human urine? These are important questions asked by Herbert the Pervert... suspected serial killer and future owner of Fox Hollow Farm. With his fascination with urophilia, multiple mental disorders, and levels of bizarre behavior matched only by his work ethic, it's little surprise there were eventually skeletal remains found in his backyard. But what is the story behind these murders? How do we know if he was the perpetrator or not? Was he the unidentified I-70 Strangler? There are more questions than answers, and in part 1 of this series on Herb Baumeister and Fox Hollow Farm, we see if we can't separate the fact from fiction.

    • 1 hr 1 min
    85: The Final Fantasy 7 Cult- This Guy Are Sick

    85: The Final Fantasy 7 Cult- This Guy Are Sick

    Today we are going a bit off the rails and looking into a different flavor of cult: one that is not based on faith, but on one of the most popular video games of all time... Final Fantasy 7! After providing some background on the video game franchise and the story-beats/characters of the 7th installment, we explore a bizarre tale of manipulation, abuse, and "soulbonding" which infamously made waves on the internet in the early 2000's. Brandish your Buster Sword and equip your finest Materia, because we are about to do battle with Jenova; not Final Fantasy 7's extra-terrestrial calamity from the skies, but Jennifer Cornett from State College, Pennsylvania... the elusive and glittery human who twisted an innocent fandom into a living nightmare.

    • 1 hr 4 min
    84: Kelly's Correction Corner And The Jersey Devil

    84: Kelly's Correction Corner And The Jersey Devil

    In this hilarious and different episode, we bring in a very special guest: Jenn's little sister... the rainbow agent of chaos herself... Kelly! In the first half, the librarian brings her own little fun facts and corrections to past episodes. To finish out, she educates us on the brief history of the screeching swole lord of the Pine Barrens: The Jersey Devil! Is it the cursed 13th child of Mother Leeds? What is it's association with Benjamin Franklin? Did Napolean Bonaparte's elder brother actually see the devil? It is time for a little GTL in southeast New Jersey.

    This episode is dedicated in loving memory of Jenn and Kelly's father, Ernest Strickland. May he enjoy that everlasting safety meeting in the sky.

    • 44 min
    83: Gary Heidnik, Part 2 - Stocks And Bondage

    83: Gary Heidnik, Part 2 - Stocks And Bondage

    In part 2 of our story on the intelligent and evil "Monster Preacher" Gary Heidnik, we see the events that transpire in a true basement of horrors. A series of kidnappings is followed by terrible physical, psychological, and sexual abuse, and that does not even count the atrocities performed inside the hand-dug hole in the basement floor. Beware what's cooking in the kitchen, because it may not actually be pot roast.

    We apologize for the delay, Jenn lost her father to a terminal illness this past week. We can’t thank you enough for your patience and support!

    • 55 min

Customer Reviews

4.7 out of 5
19 Ratings

19 Ratings

BAFriend12 ,

Loving it!

This is my new favorite podcast to listen too! These ladies are hilarious and I love the content they cover. While I love true crime sometimes I need a break. I love the cryptids and historical episodes. Give them a listen but only if you want to become addicted 🤣

Shunda823 ,

Perfect Show to get through the work day

Started listening and realized I was 3 episodes in before its time to clock out and go home from work . This show is funny and the content is great! It's not many podcasts I can listen too for more than an episode or two but this is now one of my favorites

CanMarie33 ,

Love this!

Love this podcast! The topics are great and the hosts are so funny! Highly recommend you listen and enjoy! It’s like listening to your 2 best friends!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Blood is Thicker: The Hargan Family Killings
CBS News
Ransom
KSL Podcasts
CounterClock
audiochuck
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Dateline NBC
NBC News
White Devil
Campside Media