6 episodes

When a woman is found dead in a pool during a swank West Hollywood party, her friends become the suspects. But without physical evidence or a confession, the case quickly goes cold. Ten years later, on the heels of one suspect's bid for mayor, host K.C. Casey is ready to heat the case back up with an investigation into the group originally accused of talking, laughing and loving their friend to death.

Who Killed Jenny Schecter? Grace Perry and Erin Sullivan

    • After Shows
    • 5.0, 50 Ratings

When a woman is found dead in a pool during a swank West Hollywood party, her friends become the suspects. But without physical evidence or a confession, the case quickly goes cold. Ten years later, on the heels of one suspect's bid for mayor, host K.C. Casey is ready to heat the case back up with an investigation into the group originally accused of talking, laughing and loving their friend to death.

    Episode Six: Answers

    Episode Six: Answers

    At long last, K.C. Casey gets some answers about Jenny Schecter’s gruesome fate.

    Created by: Grace Perry and Erin Sullivan

    Edited by: Lauren Klein

    Starring: Stephanie Ritter, Sophie Neff, Tien Tran

    • 8 min
    Episode Five: Alice

    Episode Five: Alice

    Was K.C. Casey’s former boss, Alice Pieszecki, capable of killing? K.C. meets with a crystal healer and medium named Opulence in search of answers.

    Created by: Grace Perry and Erin Sullivan

    Edited by: Lauren Klein

    Starring: Stephanie Ritter, Anne Lane, Grace Perry, Tien Tran

    • 10 min
    Episode Four: Shane

    Episode Four: Shane

    Could Shane McCutcheon have murdered her girlfriend? K.C. Casey talks with Tyler Shrimp, the former 12-year-old skater boy upon whom Shane based her entire aesthetic and personality. And, K.C. meets Cherie Jaffe’s straight daughter, Hannah — and finds a little love along the way.

    Created by: Grace Perry and Erin Sullivan

    Edited by: Lauren Klein

    Starring: Stephanie Ritter, Michelle Badillo, Tien Tran

    • 12 min
    Episode Three: Bette & Tina

    Episode Three: Bette & Tina

    What exactly happened at Bette Porter’s house? Bette’s straight neighbors take a break from playing cornhole to tell K.C. Casey about the night Jenny Schecter died. Then, K.C. sits down for an illuminating interview with Nannette St. Yves, Tina Kennard’s personal, in-home poncho weaver.

    Created by: Grace Perry and Erin Sullivan

    Edited by: Lauren Klein

    Starring: Stephanie Ritter, Grace Perry, Sophie Neff, Tien Tran

    • 12 min
    Episode Two: Jenny

    Episode Two: Jenny

    Who, exactly, was Jenny Schecter? To answer that, K.C. Casey meets Santa Monica Pet Rescue volunteer Dani-Stace, who provides shocking details of Jenny’s history with dogs. Then, Jenny’s former PA — who would like us to make clear is polyamorous — tells K.C. what Schecter was like as a boss.

    Created by Grace Perry and Erin Sullivan.

    Edited by: Lauren Klein

    Starring: Stephanie Ritter, Emily Fightmaster, Brittany Ashley, Erin Sullivan, Tien Tran

    • 11 min
    Episode One: The Killing

    Episode One: The Killing

    Host K.C. Casey investigates the decade-old murder of writer, producer, director and carnival fetishist Jenny Schecter. First stop: The Planet in West Hollywood, California, where K.C. digs up dirt on a suspicious gaggle of gays.

    Created by: Grace Perry and Erin Sullivan

    Edited by: Lauren Klein

    Starring: Stephanie Ritter, Grace Perry, Kelley Quinn, Tien Tran

    • 11 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
50 Ratings

50 Ratings

LauraG1992 ,

The best dramatized lesbian true crime podcast out there!

Hilarious and bingeable. Laughed out loud throughout every episode, from both the plot AND the spoof ads. MUST LISTEN!

LVthedog ,

Very funny!

I’ve never seen the L word but thought this podcast was hilarious! Each character made me laugh out loud. Definitely recommend!

Bsdogbones ,

Amazing

Absolutely fantastic absurdist humor. I would recommend it even if you haven’t seen the L word! A spoof on true crime and the lesbian show we know and kind of reluctantly love.

Top Podcasts In After Shows

Listeners Also Subscribed To