You Can't Make It Up

Eric Todisco
  • 4.7 (27)
  • Society & Culture
  • Updated Weekly

"You Can't Make It Up" is a new podcast hosted by entertainment journalist Eric Todisco. Each week, Eric welcomes a guest to share a wild story that you just can't make up. Then, Eric and his guest get into "Pop Talk" — where they discuss pop culture headlines, reality/scripted television shows they're watching, and much more. New episodes weekly! 

Episodes

  1. 02/21/2025

    I'm In A Full-Blown Feud With A Scammer

    WE'RE BACK. The podcast has returned and Eric has a GOOD story to share about the danger of strangers. Two visitors showed up at his doorstep and it did NOT end well for anyone involved. He recaps the incident with his friend, Alison. Then, they discuss their current TV obsessions and celeb hot topics during Pop Talk. We are SO back, b*tches.  Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 10m

  2. 08/15/2024

    I Auditioned For A Scam Acting Job

    You’re going to Hollywood!… NOT. Eric once excitedly auditioned for an acting job, thinking his big break was here — only to learn the whole thing was a SCAM. He recaps the incident with his friend, Jewel. During Pop Talk, they review ‘Deadpool 3’ and are joined by Jewel’s sister-in-law, Mili, to discuss ‘It Ends With Us’ and the Blake Lively/Justin Baldoni drama.  Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 8m

  3. 08/06/2024

    We're Going Off The Rails For RHONJ

    An incredible #RHONJ finale calls for the first Pop Talk-only episode – AND the first returning guest. Nicole Jablonski comes back to the podcast to recap the end of #RHONJ as we know it. Dolores exploded, Jackie was exposed, and Marge got the last laugh… or did she? Eric and Nicole go off the rails mentioning it all. Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 15m

  4. 07/24/2024

    Her Party Guest Went Missing In The Woods For 2 Days

    911, I'd like to report a missing person please! Eric's friend, Anita, once threw a NYE afterparty that didn't end well for one guest. Anita explains it all on the podcast. During Pop Talk, we dissect her journey watching all 13 (!) seasons of #RHOBH in 3 months. We also predict who's getting fired from #RHONJ and who the killer is on #PresumedInnocent.  Anita's story: 2:00 - 20:21 Pop Talk: 20:50 - end Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    59 min

  5. 06/26/2024

    She Faked A Concussion For A Guy's Attention

    The things we do for love. Eric's friend, Meg O'Neill, joins the podcast and looks back on the night she faked a concussion solely to get attention for a guy. What happened after will SHOCK you. Then comes Pop Talk, where Eric and Meg vent about the Kardashians. FLOP ERA! They also talk 'Summer House' and 'The Valley.' Hey Jesse Solomon — Meg is single!  Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 1m

  6. 06/19/2024

    I Quit A Frozen Yogurt Job After 2 Days

    Summer is the perfect time for some frozen yogurt. Well, you won't catch Eric at 16 Handles, since he worked there for two days — and then quit. His friend, Jacey Romola,  joins the podcast to hear about the shortest job that ever was. Eric does a live reading of the email where he announced he was quitting — as well as his boss' angry response. During Pop Talk, Eric and Jacey chat about Justin Timberlake's DWI arrest and their favorite shows at the moment including 'Summer House' and 'The Boys.' Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 1m

  7. 06/11/2024

    We've Got Stories About Bravo, Bravo, F**king Bravo

    If you're a Bravo fan, this is the episode for you. Eric is joined by his friend and fellow entertainment journalist, Molly Goddard, to talk about Bravo, Bravo, f**king Bravo! They're spilling all the tea about the Bravo events they've been to and the Bravolebs they've met. You'll learn who's bored them to tears during interviews, who told them about banging an iconic TV star, and much more. Eric and Molly talk more Bravo during Pop Talk, including the success of 'The Valley' and the many problems with 'RHONJ.'  Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 8m

  8. 05/22/2024

    She Made Out With A Random British Man On A Plane

    It's a real-life 'Bridgerton' love story! Eric's friend, Nicole Jablonski, reveals she had an unexpected make out session with a complete stranger on a flight to London. British men... gotta love 'em. Then, we discuss the new season of 'Bridgerton' (how fitting!) as well as 'Vanderpump Rules,' 'The Valley,' 'RHONJ,' and 'Summer House' during Pop Talk.  Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 6m

  9. 05/08/2024

    We Went To Oktoberfest & It Was A Shitshow

    Have you ever been to Oktoberfest in Germany? Eric has — and it was a complete shitshow. On this week's episode, Eric and his friend Faye look back on that chaotic day. From reporting their friend missing, to a lie involving hypothermia, everything that went down in Munich will be revealed. Then comes Pop Talk, where Eric and Faye put their judging caps on to discuss the best and worst looks at the 2024 Met Gala.  Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 9m

  10. 04/30/2024

    She Got Sucker Punched By Cinderella

    Eric's friend, Gaby Mendez, joins the show to tell a tale as old as time... when she was punched in the face by Cinderella during a play.  She was playing Snow White, by the way.  Then, Eric and Gaby share their thoughts on The Tortured Poets Department, Challengers, and Baby Reindeer during Pop Talk.  3:47 Gaby's Cinderella story  30:09 Pop Talk Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    1h 2m

  11. 04/18/2024

    My Roommate Tried To Kill Me

    Happy premiere episode! Eric reveals that his college roommate tried to kill him with a knife.  You cannot make this up.  The Pop Talk topics include Taylor Swift's new album, Gypsy Rose Blanchard's messy divorce, and Ronnie and Sammi's 'Jersey Shore' reunion. Eric's guest is his friend, Emily Dellavalle, who has a big reaction to the story of attempted murder.  Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/youcantmakeituppod/ Follow "You Can't Make It Up" on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@youcantmakeituppod Follow Eric Todisco on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/erictodisco/

    47 min
  • 11 Episodes

4.7
out of 5
27 Ratings

About

"You Can't Make It Up" is a new podcast hosted by entertainment journalist Eric Todisco. Each week, Eric welcomes a guest to share a wild story that you just can't make up. Then, Eric and his guest get into "Pop Talk" — where they discuss pop culture headlines, reality/scripted television shows they're watching, and much more. New episodes weekly! 

Information

  • Creator
    Eric Todisco
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2025
  • Episodes
    11
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 You Can't Make It Up
  • Show Website
    You Can't Make It Up