59 episodes

A history podcast about the craziest, nuttiest, weirdest, creepiest, downright strange tales from around the globe - basically, the kind of stories that make you think someone must have totally made them up.

You Totally Made That Up You Totally Made That Up

    • History
    • 5.0 • 24 Ratings

A history podcast about the craziest, nuttiest, weirdest, creepiest, downright strange tales from around the globe - basically, the kind of stories that make you think someone must have totally made them up.

    What's Going On Down There

    What's Going On Down There

    Episode #45: Nash & special guest Phil cover the unbelievable story of that time some people in America lost their ever-loving minds & had themselves a vampire-related meltdown. (New England Vampire Panic, American Vampire Panic)  

    .  

    | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

    | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

    | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | 

    | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

    | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: youtotallymadethatup@gmail.com |  

    • 1 hr 12 min
    Pools And Pits (Part Two)

    Pools And Pits (Part Two)

    Episode #44: Join Nash & Tiff as they continue to talk about some bizarre catastrophes that devastated homes & lives - disasters that were far from natural (the Centralia Pennsylvania fires)

    .

    | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |

    | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |

    | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast |

    | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |

    | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: youtotallymadethatup@gmail.com |

    • 58 min
    Pools And Pits (Part One)

    Pools And Pits (Part One)

    Episode #43: Join Nash & Tiff as they talk about some bizarre catastrophes that devastated homes & lives - disasters that were far from natural. (Boston's Great Molasses Flood)

    .  

    | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

    | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

    | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | 

    | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

    | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: youtotallymadethatup@gmail.com |  

    • 58 min
    Randompalooza

    Randompalooza

    Episode #42: Nash & Tiff collected some bonus content for their faithful listeners - outtakes, sidebars, and stuff that wouldn't fit in the regular episodes. There's also rants, complaints, and general wittiness. (PS: If you're new, start somewhere else, because none of this will make any sense *wink*)    

    .  

    | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

    | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

    | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | 

    | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

    | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: youtotallymadethatup@gmail.com |  

    • 1 hr 17 min
    Spooky Snack 14: Unsolicited Meat

    Spooky Snack 14: Unsolicited Meat

    Mini-Episode #14 - Tiff tells Nash a true story about a time meat fell from the sky. No, really. (Hosts' Choice: the Kentucky meat shower)  

    .  

    Spooky Snacks are bite-sized episodes based upon listener submissions of their personal, family, or hometown stories, as well as suggestions for topics they'd like to hear us discuss, and sometimes things we want to talk about that aren’t long enough for a regular episode.  

    .  

    | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

    | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

    | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | 

    | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

    | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: youtotallymadethatup@gmail.com |  

    • 35 min
    Something Suddenly Came Up

    Something Suddenly Came Up

    Episode #41: Nash & Tiff once asked you to join them as they talked about what could be hiding in the snow. Now they ask you to come along as they revisit one of those stories, because as you'll see, they just can't let it go. That was a bad joke. But seriously, did the movie "Frozen" really solve the Dyatlov Pass Mystery? Let's find out. (Dyatlov Pass, Frozen)  

    .  

    | Show Notes, Credits, and more at our blog |  

    | Tumblr @youtotallymadethatup |   

    | Twitter @YTMTUpodcast | 

    | Instagram @youtotallymadethatup |  

    | We want to hear your personal & local crazy tales! Email us: youtotallymadethatup@gmail.com |  

    • 1 hr 10 min

Customer Reviews

5.0 out of 5
24 Ratings

24 Ratings

sk1885 ,

Love it

Great information and history!! Very fun to listen to and easy to understand and follow!! Highly recommended!!

amberautomatica ,

A refreshing take on the supernatural/paranormal

While I totally consider myself a believer in the supernatural/paranormal/strangeness, it’s nice to have someone voice the fact that some of it is completely ridiculous, too. Nash and Tiff are hilarious, have wonderful chemistry and present their stories in such a compelling, funny, smart way that you’ll be sad once you catch up, like I was.

Tamara tilthebreakof Dawn ,

Great show

This is such a unique and entertaining show! The host have great chemistry and are hilarious. It’s so fun hearing their reactions to the stories that they share. Definitely worth you subscribing and listening!

Top Podcasts In History

History's Secret Heroes
BBC Radio 4
The Rest Is History
Goalhanger Podcasts
American Scandal
Wondery
Dan Carlin's Hardcore History
Dan Carlin
American History Tellers
Wondery
Everything Everywhere Daily
Gary Arndt | Glassbox Media