The It Depends Podcast with Matt and Tenille

First Person Consulting
  • 5.0 (2)
  • EDUCATION
  • UPDATED FORTNIGHTLY

Each episode Matt and Tenille grapple with questions that have no clear answers. For those working in evaluation, systems change, design or complexity this is a great place for you to learn to sit with uncertainty. A podcast where the answer to each question starts with ”it depends...”

  1. 1 FEB

    #14 To Be a Good Human: Co-Design, Two-Way Learning, and Redistributing Power

    What does it really mean to do co-design well — and when might stepping back be more powerful than stepping in? Jessie Robinson is a proud Wiradjuri man and founder of Mawang Consulting. In this conversation, he challenges us to think differently about co-design — not as a process or framework, but as a fundamentally relational practice rooted in power redistribution. Jessie shares how First Nations ways of being and doing have shaped his approach, and why he believes communities often already have the solutions — they just need the resources and space to act on them. We also get into the messier side of this work: having hard conversations with commissioners, sitting in discomfort, and what it actually looks like to practise two-way learning rather than just talk about it. We cover: Co-design as power redistribution, not methodology When to resource what already exists rather than design something new Indigenous knowledge systems and what practitioners can learn from them The step before 'discovery' — sitting and sharing space with community Collaboration vs competition in how work gets commissioned What two-way learning means in practice If you like what you hear sign up for our mailing list! We share resources, publications, and other ways to learn. You can also find Matt and Tenille on LinkedIn, or visit our website. Resources Mentioned Mawang Consulting — Jessie's First Nations owned consultancy Beyond Sticky Notes — KA McKercher's book on co-design KA McKercher — co-design practitioner and author

    50 min

  2. 17/12/2025

    #13 Governance, Not Geography: Redefining What Place-Based Work Really Means with Luke Craven

    In this episode of It Depends, Matt and Tenille speak with Dr Luke Craven, CEO of PLACE Australia (Partnerships for Local Action and Community Empowerment), a first-of-its-kind effort to connect, resource, and strengthen place-based initiatives nationally. Luke shares PLACE's defining insight from engaging with 53 place-based initiatives across the country: that effective place-based work is fundamentally about governance, not geography. He outlines the three principles -subsidiarity, accountability, and partnership - that PLACE believes underpin meaningful place-based practice, and explains why being "domain neutral" allows them to act as ecosystem engineers, connecting practitioners solving similar challenges across early years, net zero transition, criminal justice, and beyond. This Episode is a thoughtful conversation about what it takes to move place-based approaches from novel to normal, and why being tight on purpose but loose on the how might be the key to lasting systems change.   If you like what you hear sign up for our mailing list! We share resources, publications, and other ways to learn. You can also find Matt and Tenille on LinkedIn, or visit our website.   Check out past episodes on Resilience in Place (#12 with Gretel Evans), Complex Adaptive Systems in Emergency Management (#8 with Todd Miller), Value for Money in Evaluation (#11 with Julian King) to explore threads that came up in this episode. Links to resources mentioned or relevant to the episode: PLACE Australia – including their Practice Framework Place Matters UK – PLACE's counterpart organisation in the United Kingdom The Good Shift – Ingrid Burkett's work on systems approaches and visual storytelling Fire to Flourish – Paul Ramsay Foundation initiative supporting community-led disaster recovery Logan Together – place-based initiative in Queensland focused on early years Regen Melbourne – place-based urban regeneration across metropolitan Melbourne

    46 min

  3. 04/12/2025

    #12 Stories, Place, and Dishwashers: Rethinking Community Resilience with Gretel Evans

    Can a dishwasher be an indicator of community resilience? In this episode of It Depends, Matt speaks with historian and social researcher Dr Gretel Evans about the powerful intersections between storytelling, place, disaster, and community resilience. Drawing on her work in oral history, migration, and environmental history, Gretel shares how her research into floods and bushfires led her into large-scale, place-based recovery through the Fire to Flourish program at Monash University. Gretel touches on the upcoming Community Disaster Resilience Capability Framework, outlining six key capabilities that support stronger, more connected communities before, during, and after disaster. The conversation explores why community resilience is collective, not individual, and how unexpected infrastructure - like community dishwashers- can play a vital role. The conversation also dives deep into the role of storytelling and oral history in understanding resilience. Gretel reflects on the ethical dimensions of interviewing, data ownership, trauma, and the potential for community-owned story archives as a future pathway. This is a rich and thoughtful conversation about how history, memory, and lived experience shape the way communities recover, adapt, and imagine their futures—and why numbers alone can never tell the full story.   If you like what you hear sign up for our mailing list! We share resources, publications, and other ways to learn. You can also find Matt and Tenille on LinkedIn, or visit our website.   Check out past episodes on Indigenous Data Sovereignty (#3 with Skye Trudgett) and Complex Adaptive Systems in Emergency Management (#8 with Todd Miller) to explore threads that came up in this episode.   Links to resources mentioned or relevant to the episode: Oral History and Folklore collection at the National Library of Australia Oral History Australia - if you want to learn more about oral history  Fire to Flourish Knowledge Centre - the Toolkit and other materials will be posted here when they are publicly available A systematic review on co-design, place-making and social capital that Gretel contributed towards.

    48 min

  4. 26/11/2025

    #11 Foxes, Hedgehogs and Helpful Robots in the World of Evaluation with Bianca Montrosse-Moorhead

    We talk a lot about what evaluation is. Methods, models, frameworks, competencies. All the pieces we use to make sense of complex systems. But what about the people doing the work. How do we think, learn, and navigate the field, especially at a time when artificial intelligence is influencing how knowledge is created, interpreted, and judged. In this episode, Dr Bianca Montrosse Moorhead helps us look beneath the surface of evaluation practice. We explore the classic fox and hedgehog metaphor and what it reveals about how evaluators operate, why our tendencies matter, and how identity shapes the judgments we make. From training the next generation of evaluators to working with the rapid rise of AI, Bianca brings a grounded and thoughtful perspective on where the field is heading and what it asks of us. Tenille is on leave this week, so Matt is flying solo. Thankfully Bianca is here to keep him company as the two wander through philosophy, practice, technology and the big questions about value and purpose in evaluation.   If you like what you hear sign up for our mailing list! We share resources, publications, and other ways to learn. You can also find Matt and Tenille on LinkedIn, or visit our website.   Resources from the episode: Evaluation Foundations Revisited: Cultivating a Life of the Mindful Practitioner by Thomas A Schwandt Evaluation Essentials: From A to Z by Marvin C Alkin, Anne T Vo and Christina A Christie Core Concepts in Evaluation: Classic Writings and Contemporary Commentary edited by Lori Wingate, Ayesha Boyce, Lyssa Wilson Becho and Kelly Robertson Evaluation Criteria for Artificial Intelligence by Bianca Montrosse Moorhead And keep an eye out for Using Generative AI in Evaluation Practice edited by Carrie Bruce, Valentine Gandhi and Stephan Bony - it's not yet released but will be coming soon and will be open-access.

    52 min

  5. 07/11/2025

    #10 From Authority to Authenticity: Young Voices in Suicide Prevention Research with Maria Michail

    Suicide prevention is one of the most complex challenges in public health - but what happens when we stop treating it as an individual issue and start seeing it as a system? In this episode of It Depends, Matt and Tenille speak with Dr Maria Michail, Associate Professor at the University of Birmingham, whose pioneering work bridges psychology, systems science, and participatory research. Together we unpack what it means to move “from authority to authenticity”, exploring how authentic approaches to working with young people in research, systems modelling, and new ways of thinking can reshape how we understand and respond to complexity. Featuring insights from research innovative work, this conversation challenges the assumptions of safety, power, and expertise - and invites us to rethink how complex problems are best approached.   If you like what you hear sign up for our mailing list! We share resources, publications, and other ways to learn. You can also find us on LinkedIn, or visit our website.   Below are some of the papers that Maria references in the episode: An evaluation of the feasibility, value and impact of using participatory modelling to inform the development of a regional system dynamics model for youth suicide prevention Youth partnership in suicide prevention research: moving beyond the safety discourse Unleashing the Potential of Systems Modeling and Simulation in Supporting Policy-Making and Resource Allocation for Suicide Prevention

    42 min

  6. 27/10/2025

    #9 Co-Design and the Guiding Role of "Purpose" with Emma Blomkamp

    We throw the word co-design around a lot. It’s become shorthand for collaboration, participation, even goodwill — a prefix that promises inclusion. But what does that little “co-” really mean? In this episode, we explore the shades of co-design: how far collaboration can go, when it works, when it doesn’t, and how systems thinking and design intersect in practice. Drawing on years of work at the intersection of social innovation, facilitation, and capability-building, Emma Blomkamp helps us unpack the language, myths, and maturity of co-design — and reminds us that it all comes back to one thing: purpose. Whether you’re a practitioner, policymaker, or just someone curious about what genuine collaboration looks like in complex systems, this episode offers both reflection and practical guidance on doing co with intent.   If you like what you hear sign up for our mailing list! We share resources, publications, and other ways to learn. You can also find us on LinkedIn, or visit our website. Resources from the episode: Emma Blomkamp's New Know How and specifically the Co-Design Maturity Model and Quiz KA McKercher's Beyond Sticky Notes - a great resource! The Impact Policy Podcast episode with Jessie Robinson titled "Co-design Collaboration and Community Engagement) Co-Design practitioner Dr Tristan Schultz's website

    45 min

  7. 13/10/2025

    #8: Have a Cup of Tea: Bridging Complexity in Emergency Management with Todd Miller

    In this episode of It Depends, Matt and Tenille sit down with Todd Miller, Associate Director of Resilience at Auckland University of Technology (AUT) and creator of the Complex Adaptive Disaster and Emergency Management (CADEM) Framework - a systems-based rethink of how we prepare for, respond to, and recover from disasters. Todd brings a deeply relational take to emergency management. Drawing from years in the Army, firefighting, and the National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA), he reflects on how our ability to respond well in moments of crisis depends less on command and control - and more on the quality of the relationships that connect people, organisations, and communities before disaster strikes. His key tip? Invest time building trust over a cup of tea - it might be the most powerful hidden preparedness strategy we have.   Thanks for listening to the It Depends Podcast! You can find out more about First Person Consullting on our website, follow us on LinkedIn, or sign up to our semi-regular newsletter. Resources mentioned in the episode include: Todd's paper proposing the CADEM Framework The toolkit built off the paper, which includes templates and processes for use by organisations and communities Todd's methodological paper on Constructivist Networked Grounded Theory

    35 min

  8. 29/09/2025

    #7 Press Pause: Rethinking Systems and Evaluation with Emily Gates

    In this episode of The It Depends Podcast, Matt and Tenille sit down with Associate Professor Emily Gates from Boston College. Emily is an evaluator, educator, and systems thinker whose work bridges theory and practice, with a focus on how evaluation can better reflect the realities of large-scale systems change. Their conversation ranges from the limits of outcomes-focused evaluation to the importance of boundaries, perspectives, and stewardship in systems practice. Together, they explore what it means to evaluate systemic change, the role of commissioners and funders, and why evaluators may need to act less like neutral judges and more like facilitators of critical deliberation. Emily invites us to pause, self-critique, and think differently about how evaluation can contribute to meaningful, lasting change. Whether you’re an evaluator, commissioner, or just curious about how change happens in complex systems, this conversation will spark reflection, raise challenging questions, and—of course—leave you with the reminder that sometimes the only answer is: it depends.   Thanks for listening to the It Depends Podcast! You can find out more about First Person Consullting on our website, follow us on LinkedIn, or sign up to our semi-regular newsletter.   These are links to the resources mentioned in the episode: Emily's new book co-written with Pablo Vidueira - Evaluative Inquiry for Systemic Change Thomas Schwandt's Evaluation Foundations: Cultivating a Life of Mind for Practice The Omidyar Group's Systems Practice Workbook And while we didn't mention it in the episode, Emily shared afterwards that she routinely goes back to Nora Bateson's book: Small Arcs of Larger Circles: Framing Through Other Patterns (here's an excerpt) for inspiration and new layers of insight.

    58 min
See All (16)

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
2 Ratings

About

Each episode Matt and Tenille grapple with questions that have no clear answers. For those working in evaluation, systems change, design or complexity this is a great place for you to learn to sit with uncertainty. A podcast where the answer to each question starts with ”it depends...”

Information