Send us Fan Mail This video is about My Feedback can be difficult to hear, especially when it conflicts with how you see yourself. You believe you are confident, but someone describes you as dismissive. You consider yourself collaborative, yet colleagues experience you as closed off. You think you are being decisive, but your team sees you as unwilling to listen. That disconnect may feel unfair. However, it can also reveal one of the most important factors affecting your leadership growth: the gap between what you intend and what other people experience. In this episode of The Mid-Career GPS Podcast, I examine how the leadership perception gap can influence your reputation, professional relationships, promotion opportunities, and career advancement. I am recording this episode after delivering the closing keynote at NextUp’s Rising Stars Conference, where participants used feedback from a 360 assessment to strengthen their leadership development. That experience reinforced something I see repeatedly in my coaching and speaking work. Most mid-career professionals do not lack skill, experience, or commitment. What they often lack is accurate, actionable feedback from people they trust. Why Self-Awareness Matters for Career Advancement Leadership is not defined solely by what you intend. It is also defined by what other people experience when they work with you. You may intend to challenge your team, but they experience you as overly critical. You may intend to give people autonomy, but they experience a lack of support. You may intend to demonstrate confidence, but others experience you as unwilling to consider different perspectives. Your intentions matter, but they do not erase the impact of your behavior. This is why leadership self-awareness is essential for anyone seeking a promotion, greater influence, or a more strategic role. You cannot close a perception gap you are unwilling to examine. Why “You’re Doing Great” Can Stall Your Career Some of the most limiting feedback mid-career professionals receive sounds positive. “You’re doing great.” “Keep doing what you’re doing.” “You’re reliable.” “We can always count on you.” These statements may be sincere, but they do not necessarily help you grow. Being reliable, trusted, and busy does not automatically mean you are viewed as influential, strategic, or ready for the next level of leadership. Vague praise can prevent you from identifying the behavior changes required to advance your career. In this episode, I explain how to look beneath general compliments and ask better questions about your leadership effectiveness, visibility, and readiness for greater responsibility. How to Process Difficult Feedback Without Becoming Defensive Tough feedback can trigger embarrassment, frustration, anger, or self-doubt. It is easy to dismiss the feedback, question the other person’s motives, or immediately defend your intentions. Instead, I share a practical process for evaluating feedback more objectively: Pause before responding.Treat the feedback as a data point rather than an absolute truth.Separate your emotional reaction from the information being offered.Look for patterns across different people and situations.Identify what the behavior may be costing you.Choose one specific behavior to change. One person’s opinion may be an outlier. When several people describe a similar experience, however, you have a pattern worth examining. The goal is not to change everything about yourself. The goal is to identify one behavior that could improve your leadership presence, relationships, credibility, or promotion readiness. How to Get 360-Style Feedback Without a Formal Assessment You do not need access to a formal 360 leadership assessment to receive valuable feedback. You can begin by having intentional conversations with your manager, peers, direct reports, mentors, former colleagues, and trusted professional contacts. The key is to speak with people who will offer honest insight rather than simply validate what you already believe. Consider asking questions such as: What is one leadership strength I should continue using?What is one behavior that may be limiting my effectiveness?When have you seen me at my best as a leader?What do I do that may make it harder for people to work with me?What would I need to demonstrate for you to see me as ready for the next level? Do not collect feedback merely to prove that you are doing well. Use it to understand how others experience your leadership and where a small change could create a meaningful difference. In This Episode, You Will Learn: Why unclear feedback can create confusion and stall leadership developmentHow 360 assessments reveal leadership strengths and perception gapsWhy leadership is shaped by what people experience, not only by what you intendHow positive but vague feedback can quietly limit career advancementWhy reliability, trust, and busyness are not the same as influence and strategic valueHow defensiveness and poorly delivered feedback prevent meaningful growthHow to decode vague praise that may signal a leadership limitationA step-by-step process for responding to difficult feedbackHow to identify patterns instead of overreacting to one person’s opinionHow to gather honest, 360-style input without using a formal assessmentHow changing one behavior can improve your leadership reputation and career opportunities Build the Leadership Reputation You Want The feedback that frustrates you most may contain the insight you need most. You do not have to agree with every comment you receive. You do need to remain curious about the patterns shaping how others experience you. When you learn how to separate intention from impact, you can make more strategic decisions about how you communicate, lead, and show up at work. That self-awareness can help you strengthen your professional relationships, increase your influence, and position yourself for your next career opportunity. Listen to this episode and identify one perception gap that may be affecting how you are seen when you are not in the room. Bring This Conversation to Your Organization I speak to organizations and professional associations about career advancement, leadership effectiveness, communication, and how we SHOW UP at work. If you know an organization that is looking for a keynote speaker or workshop facilitator, I would appreciate an introduction. I design engaging and practical experiences that help mid-career professionals and leaders increase their self-awareness, strengthen their influence, and lead more impactfully. To discuss a keynote, workshop, or facilitated leadership development program, connect with me through the information in the show notes, on LinkedIn, or email me at john@johnneral.com. Remember, how you SHOW UP matters. Support the show If this episode resonated with you and you want more support in how you SHOW UP for your career and life, I want to invite you to join the SHOW UP Leadership Lab. This is my group membership program where you'll get the clarity and support you need to SHOW UP more impactfully and effectively in your life and career. Visit https://johnneral.com/showup to join. Please leave a rating and review on Apple Podcasts here. Connect with John on LinkedIn here. Get John's New Mid-Career Journal on Amazon here. Follow John on Instagram @johnneralcoaching. Subscribe to John's YouTube Channel here.
