'tis but a scratch: fact and fiction about the Middle Ages

Richard Abels

Talking about popular conceptions of the Middle Ages and their historical realities. Join Richard Abels to learn about Vikings, knights and chivalry, movies set in the Middle Ages, and much more about the medieval world.

  1. 1 day ago

    Reposted: Formerly Three and Now Four Medieval Ghost Stories and My One Encounter with a Ghost

    Send us Fan Mail I hope that you enjoyed my discussion of Arthurian ghost stories with Dr. Christopher Berard. Like I said, that was my second Halloween special. In case you missed it, I decided to repost the first. In it I retold three medieval ghost stories and related my one personal encounter with a “ghost.” I need to place “ghost” in quotation marks because—spoiler alert—I don’t believe I actually saw a ghost, although at the time I was literally scared stiff. That occurred on a trip that Ellen and I took to Edinburgh four decades ago. Although I don’t believe in ghosts, the image of a woman in white silently floating toward my bed stays with me to this day.   To freshen things up, I added an additional story, the tale of a priest who encountered in a dark forest on a winter’s night the Wild Hunt, a procession of recently dead sinners, some of whom were his neighbors. I start with that story so that those who have previously heard the episode can listen to this new story without having to sit through the entire episode—although you might enjoy listening to it again as we approach Halloween.  This new ghost story comes from the Ecclesiastical History of the twelfth-century Anglo-Norman monk Orderic Vitalis. Orderic assures us of its veracity, as it was related to him by the priest who experienced it. More about that later, but first the story   To celebrate my birthday—yes I was a Halloween baby—I decided to do a short episode recounting my one up-close and personal experience with a ghost. No, it was not a ghost of some one who died in the Middle Ages. In fact, I don’t know who it was.  But since ‘Tis But A Scratch” is a medieval podcast, I  start with three ghost stories from the Middle Ages.  It probably comes as no surprise that medieval people believed in ghosts, and ghost stories are scattered through medieval monastic chronicles, hagiographies, preaching manuals, and medieval literature. Ghost stories in medieval England, France, and Germany are mostly about apparitions of the sinful dead to living relatives. These began proliferating in the eleventh century, at the same time that the Catholic Church was developing its theology of Purgatory. Monks and preachers used these stories to emphasize the need to purge one’s sins, even after death. When the Church introduced the idea that the living could lessen the suffering of the dead in Purgatory by doing good deeds or contributing lands and money to monasteries and churches in return for prayers, these stories were used by preachers as fund raisers. The tradition in medieval Scandinavia was different. There the ghosts are not spirits but revenants, reanimated corpses.  I’ve chosen examples illustrating each genre. Two of them were written down around the year 1400. The first is from an Icelandic Saga, Grettir’s Saga. The second is from a collection of twelve ghost stories written by a monk of Byland Abbey, in Yorkshire. Both are about revenants, reanimated corpses, but of very different sorts.  Rounding things out is a ghost story from an earlier source, the autobiography of an early twelfth-century French Benedictine abbot, Guibert of Nogent.  I’m afraid that you might find my personal ghost story a bit dull in comparison, but I can assure you that it was anything but dull when I lived it. And just in case you are wondering: NO! I DO NOT BELIEVE IN GHOSTS!. Happy Halloween!   I used the following English translations in this podcast (each of which I emended slightly): Orderic Vitalis, Ecclesiastical History of England and Normandy, trans. Thomas Forester (1853-1856) The Ecclesiastical History of Orderic Vitalis, vol. 4, books 7 and 8, ed. and trans. Marjorie Chibnall (Oxford, 1973) Grettir’s Saga, trans. G. H. Hight (1914): https://www.sagadb.org/grettis_saga.en2 “Twelve Medieval Ghost Stories,” trans. A.J. Grant, Yorkshire Archaeological Journal, 27 (1924): 362-379, posted on the “Medieval Histories” website: https://www.medieval.eu/medieval-histories-time-travelling-to-the-middle-ages/ C.C. Swinton Bland of , The Autobiography of Guibert, Abbot of Nogent-sous-Coucy, trans. C.C. Swinton Bland (London: George Routledge: New York: E.P. Dutton, 1925), which I revised somewhat following Paul J. Archambault, trans., A Monk’s Confession: The Memoirs of Guibert of Nogent (Penn State U. Press, 2004). Bland’s translation is in the public domain and posted in its entirety at  https://sourcebooks.web.fordham.edu/basis/guibert-vita.asp The best collection of medieval ghost stories is Andrew Joynes,Medieval Ghost Stories: An Anthology of Miracles, Marvels and Prodigies (Boydell, 2006).   This episode includes a short snippet from "The Unknown," a track from KeMi's album "Shadowscapes." https://artlist.io/royalty-free-music/album/shadowscapes/13040, Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada    If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com   Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

  2. 4 days ago

    The Once and Future King, part 1: Arthurian Ghost Stories (with Dr. Christopher Berard)

    Send us Fan Mail This is the first of a two part series with Dr. Christopher Berard dealing with medieval stories about King Arthur. It's also my second Halloween special. In this episode Chris talks about medieval ghost stories that feature King Arthur and his knights. We begin with something that I had never thought of as a ghost story--King Arthur as the once and future king.  I push Chris a bit on this, and we discuss whether Arthur will return as a ghost or a revenant. Among the other stories is one in which Guinevere and Gawain encounter the ghastly ghost of Guinevere's mother in what is a medieval version of Dickens' "A Christmas Carol."  I hope you will join us. Christopher Berard is a literary scholar who specializes in Arthurian literature, medieval political culture, and Latin, Old French, and Middle English historiography (c. 1100–1400). He is the author of two monographs: Arthurianism in Early Plantagenet England: from Henry II to Edward I (Boydell, 2019) and The Alliterative Morte Arthure as Christian Epic Poetry (Boydell, forthcoming 2026). He teaches at his alma mater, Providence College, where he offers courses on Arthurian legend, Jewish and Christian romance, kingship and knighthood, and the subject of today's episode: medieval ghost stories. Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

  3. 18 Oct

    Agincourt: The Battle (with Michael Livingston)

    Send us Fan Mail In the previous episode, Michael Livingston and I talked about the historical context of Henry V's Agincourt campaign, Henry's costly siege of Harfleur, and his desperate, and ultimately unsuccessful, attempt to elude the French army as he marched to Calais. Along the way, we talked about how Shakespeare shaped how Agincourt and Henry V are remembered in the popular mind. But we never actually got to the battle. This episode does. In it, we also talk about depictions of the Battle of Agincourt in three movies, Laurence Olivier's 1944 and Kenneth Branagh's filmed versions of Shakespeare's play "Henry V," and David Michôd'a 2019 The King,  Recommended books *Michael Livingston, Agincourt: Battle of the Scarred King (Osprey, 2023) Anne Curry, Agincourt: A New History (Tempus, 2005) Anne Curry, ed., The Battle of Agincourt: Sources and Interpretations (Boydell and Brewer, 2009) Dan Jones' Henry V: The Astonishing Triumph of England's Greatest War  King is a highly readable biography and a good corrective to Shakespeare (Apollo, 2025) For those interested in individuals who fought in the Battle of Agincourt, you can click on the remarkable website The Soldier in Later Medieval England, a database compiled from administrative records by a team led by Adrian Bell and Anne Curry  https://www.medievalsoldier.org/about/the-project The episode includes snippets from  Sir William Walton's Overture to the movie Henry V (1944), Sir William Walton conducting The Philharmonia Orchestra (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0CYS5Fz5veQ) Kenneth Branagh's movie version of "Henry V" (1989) Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

  4. 14 Oct

    King Henry V and the Agincourt Campaign (with Prof. Michael Livingston)

    Send us Fan Mail In the previous episode, I chatted with Kelly DeVries about Joan of Arc as a military leader. One of her greatest contributions to the ultimate victory of France in the Hundred Years War was to restore French morale, which, after fourteen years, had still not recovered from the crushing defeat the French had suffered at Agincourt in 1415. In the next two episodes, I will be discussing Henry V's Agincourt campaign and battle with Professor Michael Livingston, Kelly's cohost on Medievalists.net's excellent podcast about medieval military history, "Bow and Blade." Mike is Citadel Distinguished Professor at The Citadel. He is the author of eight books analyzing medieval battles. Today he will be telling us what he learned while researching his prize winning book, Agincourt: Battle of the Scarred King (Osprey Publishing, 2023). Today's episode looks at Henry V's experiences in war as prince, including being struck in the face with an arrow as a 16-year old in the Battle of Shrewsbury, the rationale behind his decision to undertake the Agincourt Campaign, and the unexpectedly long and costly siege of Harfleur. (We get to the Battle in the next episode.)  And, of course, one cannot talk about Henry V and Agincourt without also talking about Shakespeare, and we do. This episode includes  A musical snippet from the early fifteenth-century Agincourt Carol, played by organist Geoff Olson (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gLi-zfZKwic) The St. Crispin's Day speech from Kenneth Branagh's "Henry V" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dyvUemTqJRk) Henry V's ultimatum to the defenders of Harfleur from Branagh's "Henry V" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jGf_h8VD1Ow) Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth's announcement of "Project Agincourt" in his "State of the Force" address to junior officers and NCOs on Sept. 30, 2026 (https://www.gettyimages.de/detail/video/secretary-of-war-pete-hegseth-says-today-the-nachrichtenfilmmaterial/2297989181) "History Hit" has a nice short video showing how doctor John Bradmore removed the arrowhead buried six inches into Prince Hal's face (https://www.youtube.com/shorts/aob59Qu0OEI) Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

  5. 29 Sept

    Joan of Arc: Military Commander or Holy Cheerleader?

    Send us Fan Mail Today’s episode concerns one of the most celebrated medieval people, Joan of Arc. She is among the best-known saints of the Middle Ages, especially among non-Catholics, and one of the most unusual. She is the only saint to my knowledge to have been condemned by the Church as a heretic and turned over to secular authorities to be burnt at the stake. That took place in 1431. It wasn’t until 1920 for the Catholic Church to formally recognize her sanctity. She is also an atypical female medieval saint in terms of her actions. Her fame owes less to her personal sanctity, theological insights, or defense of the faith than to her military and political accomplishments that led to France’s ultimate victory in the Hundred Years War.   In this episodes we will examines Joan's military exploits. Was this illiterate seventeen year old peasant girl an actual military commander, or was she more of a holy cheerleader or even sacred mascot.  I am fortunate to have as my cohost the historian best suited to answer this question, Dr. Kelly DeVries, author of Joan of Arc: A Military Leader (Sutton Publishing: 1999).  DeVries, professor emeritus of History at Loyola University Maryland,  is one of the most prominent historians of medieval warfare of my generation. The author of 35 books and more than 80 articles on medieval military history and the history of military technology, DeVries has appeared on more than 40 shows for PBS, History, History International, Military History, National Geographic, HBO, and Vanity Fair Channels. He and Mike Livingston host the popular medievalist.net podcast, Bow and Blade.. Today, Kelly returns to the question of Joan of Arc as military commander. Together he and I will be exploring the nature of warfare in the latter decades of the Hundred Years War and Joan’s contribution to France’s ultimate victory. Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

  6. 19 Sept

    Thucydides' Melian Dialogue: "the strong do what they can and the weak suffer what they must"

    Send us Fan Mail Caveat auditor!. Listener beware! This episode is NOT about the Middle Ages, although it does touch upon medieval massacres toward the end. Rather, it focuses on a text I taught for years at the U.S. Naval Academy, the “Melian dialogue” in Thucydides’ "History of the Peloponnesian War".  If you are not interested in Classical Greek warfare, Thucydides, or political theory, you may want to give this a pass.  Otherwise, please join Ellen and me as we explore one of the most traumatic events in the history of Classical Greece, the Athenian destruction of the island city-state of Melos in the year 416 BCE, and how Thucydides’ treatment of that event has resonated down to our day. The "Melian Dialogue," translated by Richard Crawley, read by Peter Dann for LibriVox (https://dn710207.ca.archive.org/0/items/historyofthepeloponnesianwar2_2603_librivox/historyofthepeloponnesianwar_17_thucydides_128kb.mp3) This episode also includes audio snippets from Euripides, "The Trojan Women," trans. Gilbert Murray: Poseidon's speech, recited by Martin Geeson, posted by Audiobook Heaven (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TW0AnHCvDGM) Kenneth Branagh's 1989 film version of William Shakespeare's "Henry V" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UyEnDwmtrZc) Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

  7. 10 Sept

    The Bayeux Tapestry: History and Interpretations

    Send us Fan Mail As our regular listeners know, I am an Anglo-Saxon historian. Previously, I did several episodes with my good friend Dr. Jennifer Paxton on the Norman Conquest of my beloved Anglo-Saxon England. In them we mentioned one of the most famous sources for that event, the so-called Bayeux Tapestry. Today marks the opening of the British Museum’s exhibition of the Bayeux Tapestry, the culmination of eight and a half years of intense negotiations with the Bayeux Museum.  British newspapers and well as American make it sound almost like a royal visit. There is no doubt that it has sparked the interest of the British public. The British Museum reported that thousands flocked to see it today and that tickets are sold out for the remainder of 2026. In all, it is expected that about a million visitors will see it over the course of its 10 month showing in London.  Although ‘Tis But A Scratch is an audio podcast and the Tapestry is, of course, very much visual, I thought that this would be a good time to provide my listeners with the history of the most famous artworks of the Middle Ages. Fortunately, the Bayeux Museum has placed a panorama of the entire Bayeux Tapestry online, photographed in high resolution. You can scroll through it scene by scene—and I highly recommend that you do that as a prelude to listening to this podcast. Given that Jenny Paxton, my cohost for our episodes on the Norman Conquest, has been promoted to Vice Provost at the Catholic University of America and is now swamped with decanal duties—and, yes, decanal is the adjective for dean—I decided to do this as a solo effort. Bayeux Museum: https://www.bayeuxmuseum.com/en/the-bayeux-tapestry/discover-the-bayeux-tapestry/explore-online/ Jan Messent's suggested reconstruction of the missing last panel(s) of the Bayeux Tapestry: http://anglo-saxon.archeurope.com/bayeux-tapestry-reconstruction-of-the-end/ In the late 19th century, a group of Victorian embroiderers decided to create an exact reproduction of the Bayeux Tapestry in full. Their work is housed at the Reading Museum where it is advertised as "Britain's own Bayeux Tapestry": https://www.readingmuseum.org.uk/bayeux-tapestry Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

  8. 18 Aug

    The Evolution of Castles and Siege Warfare in medieval Britain, part 2 (conversation with Paul Remfry)

    Send us Fan Mail This is the second episode of a two-part series on the evolution of castle-building and siege warfare in Britain from the Norman Conquest through the fifteenth century. My very special guest for both is Paul Remfry, a world renowned expert on castles whom Ellen and I met during a Scholarly Sojourn tour of castles associated with the Albigensian Crusade. Part one concluded with two sieges that marked the reign of King John: his loss of Richard the Lionheart's great Norman castle of Chateau Gaillard, and and his successful siege of Rochester castle in 1215 during the First Barons War. This episode begins with a less well know but equally important siege, the siege of Kenilworth Castle, from June 21 to December 13, 1266, the longest and largest siege in English history. We then turn to King Edward I's great Welsh castles, a subject on which Paul Remfry has published extensively, and to Edward I's siege of Stirling Castle in Scotland, which involved the use of massive trebuchets and even gunpowder. Paul concludes by considering the impact of gunpowder artillery on siege warfare and castle building, focusing on three siege of Harlech castle. I hope that you will join us. (I would also want to let you know that our next episode will be a very special one: an interview with New York Times bestselling author Bernard Cornwell about historical fiction writing. I hope you will join us for that too!) For images and details about the castles mentioned in this episode: Wikipedia entry for "Kennilworth Castle" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kenilworth_Castle Criccieth Castle, Wales (check out the picture of the arrow loops): https://www.castlewales.com/criccth.html For Edward I's Welsh castles, see Paul Remfry's wepage on "The Castles of Wales" website: https://www.castlewales.com/remfry.html For Stirling castle, see StoneKeep Atlas webpage: https://stonekeepatlas.com/castles/stirling-castle/ This episode includes a musical snippet from "Ja Nus Hons Pris" by Richard the Lionheart - Renaissance Lute - Edward Foster #medievalmusic #lute (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tURvt-uOnKg) Arrow loop: https://www.castlewales.com/arrow.html GLOSSARY OF TERMS FOR CASTLES AND SIEGE WARFARE Arrow-slit. A vertical slit in the castle wall, used by archers. Also referred to as an arrow-loop.  Barbican. A fortified outward extension of a gateway, used to provide additional defense in depth.  Battlements are the defensive features of the parapet (i.e. the low protective wall along the outer edge of the ramparts of castle walls). The most common form is crenellation, a defensive scheme alternating low stone blocks (merlons) and openings (embrasures or crenelles) extending along and over the parapet, giving the battlement its “saw-tooth” appearance. Archers use the crenelles to shoot and then duck behind the merlons for protection. Concentric castle. An advanced form of castle-building featuring two concentric rings of walls, in which the inner wall is usually higher than the outer. The gates are not aligned.  Attackers who breach the outer wall are caught in the narrow space between the walls, exposed to archers on all sides.  The earliest concentric castles are found in the Latin Crusading states of the Levant. The earliest example of a concentric castle in Britain is Dover, which became a concentric castle when outer curtain walls were added in the late twelfth century by King Henry II and by King John and King Henry III in the thirteenth century.  Curtain wall. The heavy defensive wall encircling and enclosing a courtyard (bailey) and tower (keep). Hoarding. A wooden balcony, often temporary, built over the edge of crenellations and providing a form of machicolations. Also called a bretache. Machicolation. A gap in the base of crenellations along a parapet, used to drop stones or other material on attackers below. Portcullis. A heavy gate within a castle’s gateway that is raised and closed vertically by windlass or a counterweight mechanism. The portcullis typically takes the form a lattice (i.e. an open mesh) grid of wood, iron, or both, that makes it more resistant to battering rams and allows defenders within to fire arrows at the attackers. The bottom of a portcullis would have metal spikes designed to make it more difficult for attackers to lift it off the ground and which would impale a man or a horse caught beneath it. The roof over the space between the outer gate and the portcullis would be equipped with “murder holes,” through which defenders could drop stones or boiling water on attackers. A large castle might have a series of portcullises. Trebuchet. A type of siege engine designed to throw large stone projectiles or incendiaries. A trebuchet was a giant lever, consisting of a heavy, triangular timber frame that anchors the axle and supports the entire weight of the machine under intense operational stress; a pivot beam, that is a long asymmetric wooden lever arm balanced on a central axle. The pivot point is placed close to one end, splitting the arm into a short, heavy section and a long, light section; a sling pouch, that is a rope pouch attached to the tip of the long end of the throwing arm, which acts as a double pendulum, adding velocity on release. Early trebuchets were traction devices, equipped with ropes that men pulled on to draw back the pivot beam, and then release. In the early thirteenth century, traction trebuchets were replaced with the more effective counterweight trebuchet. In a counterweight trebuchet propulsion is provided by a counterweight, a massive basket at the short end of the pivot beam filled with rocks. rubble. and melted lead. For maximum range, the counterweight needed to be one hundred times the weight of the projective. The counterweight of a large trebuchet would be ten to fifteen tons. The largest counterweight trebuchets could throw stone projectiles weighing 100-300 pounds a distance of up to 300-350 yards. The adoption of the counterweight trebuchet was a gamechanger in medieval siege warfare.   DEVELOPMENT IN GUNPOWDER ARTILLERY IN LATE MIDDLE AGES Technical innovations:  POWDER MILL.  Bt 1400 recipes of gunpowder close to ideal proportions of saltpetere (75%), sulphur (12%), and charcoal (13%) came into use, though by 1450 most powder makers preferred less efficient mixtures. The reason why was a new technique of powder making that made powder far more powerful. By 1400/1420 powder was beginning to be ‘engrained’ or ‘corned’: mixed together when wet and alowed to dry into kernels.  New ‘corned powder-grains’ no longer disintegrated into components (sulphur, saltpetre and charcoal), so could be prepared in advance. (Before this powder had to be mixed on the field.) Corned powder was also more efficient, because the burning between powder grains permitted a more rapid transformation of the solid into gas.  Advances in FOUNDING cannon (bronze, brass, sometimes iron). In 14th century cannons were made by beating together strips of forged iron. The result was that such cannons often exploded. By early 15th century cannons were made along the same lines as bells (and by bell-founders), by founding iron, pouring it in molten form into moulds and then boring with a steel tipped drill to insure regularity of the bore     METALLURGICAL INNOVATION: new process of iron smelting made the production of iron less expensive (addition of limestone ‘to the flux during the ore refinement process increased temps necessary so that iron could only be smelted in blast forges, invented c.1340, but changed structure of slag from 2FeO.SiO2 to CaO.SiO2. This meant increased output as less atoms of iron were wasted from each molecule of slag.   LONGER BARRELS. Barrels were lengthened. 1400 ratio of barrel length to diameter of ball was about 1.5:1.   By 1430 it was 3:1. Result was to increase accuracy and velocity of shot because it increased amount of time over which pressure of the exploding gunpowder accelerated shot. Kinetic energy is function of square of velocity, so major increase in effectiveness of guns.    RATE OF FIRE This also permitted more rapid firing. In early 15th cent loading a gun was elaborate process involving three chambers to allow the building up of pressure: needed to fill rear three fifths of chamber with powder. Next fifth left empty, and last fifth filled by wood plug fitted into barrel with soft wood wedges. This was covered with mud and straw and allowed to dry. The powder would then be ignited and pressure would build up until the plug popped out like a champagne cork.  Rogers 268: ‘This elaborate procedure so slowed down the firing process that one master gunner, who achieved the remarkable feat of firing his bombard three times in a single day and hitting different targets each time, was forced to make a pilgrimage from Metz to Rome, because it was thought he ‘could only have been in league with the devil’. Maximum rate of fire: 6-8 shot from short barreled bombards. By late 15th century switch to tight fitting caliber iron shot allowed movement away from separate chambers and plugs.   TRANSPORT: In mid 15th centu Listen on Podurama   https://podurama.com                                                                     Intro and exit music are by Alexander Nakarada If you have questions, feel free to contact me at richard.abels54@gmail.com

Ratings & Reviews

3.4
out of 5
5 Ratings

About

Talking about popular conceptions of the Middle Ages and their historical realities. Join Richard Abels to learn about Vikings, knights and chivalry, movies set in the Middle Ages, and much more about the medieval world.

You Might Also Like