Why do investors miss billion-dollar companies, even when they’re in plain sight? Shopify is a great example of this. It wasn’t some obscure, hard-to-access startup. It was right there: powering thousands of websites, showing up as that small green logo across the internet. If you were paying attention, you could see it everywhere. And yet, for years, most people didn’t understand what it was becoming. It sat in the public markets, traded in the $3–5 billion range, kept executing, kept growing… but never quite got the credit for what was actually happening underneath. In this episode, Amish Jani, Partner at FirstMark Capital, breaks down how they spotted Shopify early, not because they had more data, but because they connected a few simple ideas: publishing had already been democratized, and commerce was about to follow. We also get into how venture really works in practice. What it actually means to operate in a power-law business, why one company can return an entire fund, and why consistency is what separates great investors from everyone else. Inside the episode: * Why Shopify was visible to everyone and still ignored * The “tiny signal” that hinted at a massive shift in commerce * Why some of the best investments aren’t driven by data * Why the biggest companies don’t look big early * How venture investors think about conviction vs consensus * The reality of power laws * Why the best companies don’t actually need investors * What separates a great founder from a good one * The uncomfortable truth about venture: luck vs skill * Why consistency in venture is harder than success itself * Why SaaS isn’t dead * The future of pricing models Watch Full Episode on YouTube About Amish Jani Amish Jani is a Co-Founder and Partner at FirstMark, where he focuses on investments across the cloud landscape, including Enterprise Applications, Commerce Infrastructure, Vertical Software and more.He has led early investments in industry-defining companies including Shopify (NASDAQ:SHOP), Frame.io (acquired by Adobe), Zilla Security (acquired by CyberArk), Pendo, Tracelink, Gravie, Loop, IMImobile (LSE: IMO, acquired by Cisco), Schoology (acquired by PowerSchool), Boomi (acquired by Dell), Aveksa (acquired by EMC), and more.Amish has been recognized by CB Insights and the New York Times as a Top 100 Venture Capitalist globally, and named to Business Insider’s The Seed 100 (best early-stage investors) and 50 Most Important VCs in New York lists multiple times. He is Co-Founder of CloudNY, New York’s preeminent annual summit for the world’s top Cloud CEOs, and leads the FirstMark Founders Guild — a private community for New York’s most promising seed-stage Founders.Connect with Amish Jani:https://www.linkedin.com/in/amishjani/ https://x.com/amishjani Connect with Nilanjana Bhowmik:https://www.linkedin.com/in/nilanjanabhowmik/ Converge VC Website:https://converge.vc/ This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit postmoneypodcast.substack.com