Inspired Nonprofit Leadership

Sarah Olivieri

This podcast is a place for nonprofit leaders to gain insights, tips, inspiration, and encouragement to unleash their potential.

  1. 2d ago

    Your Donors Need to Feel Safe Before They Give with Sally Mildren

    Show Notes Before a donor reads a single word of your appeal, their brain has already decided whether it feels safe. Manufactured urgency, eight-paragraph emails, and messages written for everyone can all register as a threat. Once that happens, people stop reading, and you have to start over. In this episode, Sarah talks with Sally Mildren, founder and CEO of Commonwell Marketing. Sally began her career as a rehab therapist for patients with brain injuries, spinal cord injuries, and strokes. Today she uses what she learned about the brain to help nonprofits and rural health organizations earn trust and get people to act. In This Episode, You'll Learn Why the brain checks "Am I safe? Do I belong here?" before it decides to care. How a rural health system turned "We serve all women, any age, any stage of life" into three messages and booked almost 20% more appointments in three months. When urgency helps a fundraising ask and when it pushes donors away. Why one message and one call to action per email gets a better response. Who This Episode Is For • Executive Directors who want donors to read and respond to their appeals. • Leaders who want their message to reach the people most likely to give. • Development and communications staff who want emails that don't wear people out. • Anyone who wants donors to feel seen and welcome. Links from this episode • Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter: weekly tips for leading your nonprofit. • Commonwell Marketing • Sally Mildren on LinkedIn • Commonwell Marketing on Facebook • Commonwell Marketing on Instagram • Leadership Cafe: Commonwell's online community for emerging marketing leaders. • Trust Signal Checklist: send Sally a direct message with the word "Trust" on LinkedIn or Instagram and she'll send it to you. • Sarah Olivieri's website • Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication Thank you to Donorbox Thank you to Donorbox for sponsoring Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your support for the show and the nonprofit leaders who listen. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

    Your Donors Need to Feel Safe Before They Give with Sally Mildren
  2. 4d ago

    Three Questions Your Nonprofit Homepage Needs to Answer with Sarah Olivieri

    Show Notes AI can build you a good-looking website fast. It can also hand you copy that sounds confident and still doesn't get anyone to donate, sign up, or reach out. In this solo episode, Sarah goes back to her years running a marketing agency and building websites to share the framework she used to teach for planning and evaluating a homepage. It focuses on what your visitor needs to experience, so you can decide what to say. Then she puts it to work on four real websites, starting with her own. In This Episode, You'll Learn The three questions every visitor is asking, in order: Do I belong here (am I safe)? What do I get? Now what? How small details, like a page that jumps while it loads or an events page with nothing coming up, shape a visitor's sense of trust. Why "donate now" in the top section of the page can be too big an ask for someone who's just meeting you. Quick reviews of saraholivieri.com, Safe Horizon, TreeFolks, and Smile Train. Who This Episode Is For • Executive Directors who want first-time visitors to become donors, clients, or volunteers. • Leaders using AI to build or rewrite their website who want a simple way to check the messaging. • Anyone whose homepage has to speak to donors and the people they serve at the same time. Links from this episode • Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter: weekly tips for leading your nonprofit. • Your Donors Need to Feel Safe Before They Give with Sally Mildren [LINK NEEDED: Sally Mildren episode page], the conversation that inspired this episode. • Websites reviewed in this episode: Sarah Olivieri, Safe Horizon, TreeFolks, and Smile Train. • Schedule a free call with Sarah • Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication • Sarah Olivieri on LinkedIn About Your Host, Sarah Olivieri Bold, strategic, and refreshingly human… Sarah Olivieri is the go-to expert for conversations on aligned leadership, outcome delegation, and sustainable growth. She brings wit, warmth, and real-world wisdom to mission-driven founders, visionary CEOs, and change-makers who want more clarity, more joy, and more results. Most leaders hit a wall when success depends on them holding it all together. Sarah helps them change that by redefining leadership around outcomes instead of activity, empowering teams to own results that scale and freeing leaders to focus on the vision that drives them. A former director of three nonprofits and founder of five businesses, she has a rare ability to spot opportunity where others see chaos, shift stuck patterns, and build organizations that support both legacy and life. Sarah leads with the same mindset that made her an award-winning sailor: iterate on what works, stay focused in the storm, and never forget the joy of the journey. Thank you to Donorbox Thank you to our sponsor, Donorbox, for supporting Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your work removing friction from donation forms. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

    Three Questions Your Nonprofit Homepage Needs to Answer with Sarah Olivieri
  3. Nov 12

    How to Show the Real Impact of Your Volunteers with Houston Goodwin

    Show Notes Volunteers do about a third of nonprofit work, yet less than a quarter of a percent of funding supports them. The work is already happening. What's missing is making that impact visible to leadership and the board. In this episode, Sarah talks with Houston Goodwin, CEO and Co-Chairman of Better Impact, about what he's learned from executives and volunteer coordinators and how to remove the friction that keeps people from getting involved. In This Episode, You'll Learn The gap between how much work volunteers do and how little funding supports them. How to weigh the time and talent spent on spreadsheets and paper sign-ups against the cost of software. Why busy, working-age adults need easier ways to sign up, like a QR code or a mobile app. How one email filled 75 empty volunteer spots in about 45 minutes after a corporate partner backed out. Who This Episode Is For • Executive Directors who want their leadership team and board to see what volunteers actually contribute. • Leaders who want to recruit volunteers beyond college students and retirees. • Volunteer leaders who want to spend less time on scheduling and more time on the mission. • Development teams who want better volunteer stories to share with donors. Links from this episode • Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter: weekly tips for leading your nonprofit. • Better Impact • Houston Goodwin on LinkedIn • Better Impact 2026 Volunteer Management Hybrid Conference • Better Impact Webinar Library: free recorded sessions for people who lead volunteers. • 500 Million Hours of Good podcast: Houston's podcast sharing stories from volunteer leaders and volunteers. • State of Volunteer Growth report: Better Impact's free report from a 12-month study of active volunteers. • Sarah Olivieri's website • Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication Thank you to Donorbox Thank you to Donorbox for sponsoring Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your support for the show and the nonprofit leaders who listen. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

  4. Nov 9

    Should Your Nonprofit Use Volunteers? with Sarah Olivieri

    Show Notes Volunteers can add a lot to a nonprofit. They can also drain your time when they're brought in to fill a role that really needs a paid person, or when nobody has the time to lead them. In this solo episode, Sarah takes on the question that comes before volunteer management: should your organization be using volunteers at all, and for what? She explains why a volunteer is both a donor and an unpaid member of your team, why that relationship needs care, and the two mistakes she sees most often. In This Episode, You'll Learn Why a volunteer is both a donor giving time and expertise, and an unpaid team member who needs to be a good fit How to tell when a role needs a paid person, especially when the job has to be someone's top priority What a board that seems disengaged can tell you about staffing and funding How your size and goals change the answer, from a local sailing club to a food pantry facing unmet need What happens when onboarding, guidance, and coordination for volunteers and interns get under-resourced Who This Episode Is For Executive Directors deciding whether volunteers can cover work they can't afford to pay for yet Leaders who want volunteers to stay, do the work that's needed, and bring others along with them Executive Directors who wish the board would carry more of the load and want to understand what's really going on Links from this episode Join the Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter for weekly nonprofit leadership tips How to Show the Real Impact of Your Volunteers with Houston Goodwin, the next episode. Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication About Your Host, Sarah Olivieri Bold, strategic, and refreshingly human… Sarah Olivieri is the go-to expert for conversations on aligned leadership, outcome delegation, and sustainable growth. She brings wit, warmth, and real-world wisdom to mission-driven founders, visionary CEOs, and change-makers who want more clarity, more joy, and more results. Most leaders hit a wall when success depends on them holding it all together. Sarah helps them change that by redefining leadership around outcomes instead of activity, empowering teams to own results that scale and freeing leaders to focus on the vision that drives them. A former director of three nonprofits and founder of five businesses, she has a rare ability to spot opportunity where others see chaos, shift stuck patterns, and build organizations that support both legacy and life.   Sarah leads with the same mindset that made her an award-winning sailor: iterate on what works, stay focused in the storm, and never forget the joy of the journey. Thank you to Donorbox Thank you to our sponsor, Donorbox, for supporting Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your work removing friction from donation forms. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

    Should Your Nonprofit Use Volunteers? with Sarah Olivieri
  5. Nov 5

    How to Build a Culture of Excellence at Your Nonprofit with Dr. Rachel Pappert Docekal

    Show Notes Free or low-cost services often get treated as if they can't also be the best. That belief shows up in worn-out buildings, stretched staff, and people walking in the door feeling like they don't deserve better. Leaders who refuse that tradeoff make excellence the standard for everyone they serve, and they fund it on purpose. Sarah sat down with Dr. Rachel Pappert Docekal, CEO of Hanley Foundation, one of the largest behavioral health continuums in the country, to talk about how she builds and protects that culture. Hanley Center has 83 beds and about 270 staff on a 14-acre campus in West Palm Beach, Florida, and Rachel walks through what excellence looks like day to day, from the flower beds to the night shift. In This Episode, You'll Learn How Rachel keeps her focus on "generational decisions" instead of getting pulled into the ditch. Why Rachel believes culture makes or breaks an organization. How Hanley puts every extra dollar back into staff, facilities, and scholarships. Hanley's two-part approach to hiring: a standardized team interview process and "growing our own." What a late-night pizza visit taught Rachel about listening to the night shift. How a new board member's question led to Hanley's first board orientation. Who This Episode Is For • Executive Directors who want their programs to be the best in their field. • Leaders who want to spend less time putting out fires and more time on long-term decisions. • Executive Directors who want to hire and keep great staff. • Leaders who want their team to feel seen and appreciated. Links from this episode Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter: weekly tips for leading your nonprofit. Hanley Foundation Dr. Rachel Pappert Docekal on LinkedIn Dr. Rachel Pappert Docekal on Instagram Dr. Rachel Pappert Docekal on Facebook Get help from Hanley Center: if you or someone you love needs help, call Hanley at 561-841-1000. Their team answers every call and makes sure every person gets help, even if it isn't at Hanley. Sarah Olivieri's website Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication Thank you to Donorbox  Thank you to Donorbox for sponsoring Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your support for the show and the nonprofit leaders who listen. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

    How to Build a Culture of Excellence at Your Nonprofit with Dr. Rachel Pappert Docekal
  6. Nov 2

    Episode 468: Too Busy Running Your Nonprofit to Think About Where It's Going? with Sarah Olivieri

    When your calendar is full, a walk through the building or an afternoon with a book can feel like something you'll get to someday. Executive Directors who keep their organizations headed in the right direction treat that time as part of the job. Sarah goes solo to work through why unstructured time to observe, read, and think is some of the most important work an Executive Director or CEO does, drawing on the chart of core organizational functions she uses with clients in the Impact Method®. In This Episode, You'll Learn What a CEO walkabout looks like, from coffee in hand to sitting in on programs Why setting direction is the function an Executive Director typically owns How direction and pace pull against each other, and why larger organizations split them What a sample week looks like with walkabouts, thinking time, team meetings, and donor time How Sarah thinks about noticing the opportunities that are already around you Who This Episode Is For • Executive Directors who want real time to think about where the organization is going • Leaders who laugh at the idea of an unscheduled hour because the week is already too full • CEOs of growing organizations who want to focus on vision while someone else keeps operations on pace Links from this episode • Join the Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter for weekly nonprofit leadership tips • Talk with Sarah about operations and strategy support so you can focus on direction • Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication About Your Host, Sarah Olivieri Bold, strategic, and refreshingly human… Sarah Olivieri is the go-to expert for conversations on aligned leadership, outcome delegation, and sustainable growth. She brings wit, warmth, and real-world wisdom to mission-driven founders, visionary CEOs, and change-makers who want more clarity, more joy, and more results. Most leaders hit a wall when success depends on them holding it all together. Sarah helps them change that by redefining leadership around outcomes instead of activity, empowering teams to own results that scale and freeing leaders to focus on the vision that drives them. A former director of three nonprofits and founder of five businesses, she has a rare ability to spot opportunity where others see chaos, shift stuck patterns, and build organizations that support both legacy and life. Sarah leads with the same mindset that made her an award-winning sailor: iterate on what works, stay focused in the storm, and never forget the joy of the journey. Thank you to Donorbox Thank you to our sponsor, Donorbox, for supporting Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your work removing friction from donation forms. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

    Episode 468: Too Busy Running Your Nonprofit to Think About Where It's Going? with Sarah Olivieri
  7. Oct 26

    466: Three Things to Say When You Delegate with Sarah Olivieri

    Show Notes You hand off a task. It comes back half done, or not at all, and now you're redoing the work and wondering why you bothered. Delegating well does give you time back, though sometimes not the first time. It also builds your team's skills, trust, and confidence along the way. In this bonus episode, Sarah Olivieri shares the DAD method, a simple way to remember the three things to communicate every time you delegate: Desired Result, Available Resources, and Delegated Decisions. She walks through a grant application example, explains why she sometimes names herself as the known obstacle, and closes with the difference between delegating a task and distributing leadership decisions across your organization. In This Episode, You'll Learn Why the first round of delegating may not save you time, and why it still pays off. How to describe what done looks like, including critical elements and known obstacles. Which resources to name, from a budget limit to an old spreadsheet in the shared drive, and when to say you are not available. How to decide which decisions to hand off and which to keep, using a grant application as the example. How delegating a task differs from distributing leadership decisions. Who This Episode Is For Executive Directors who want to hand off work without having to redo it. Leaders who want their team to become more skilled and independent. Anyone who has delegated a task and gotten back something different from what they pictured. Links from this episode Join the Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter for weekly nonprofit leadership tips. How to Get Follow-Through Without Micromanaging with Gina Cotner. Schedule a call with Sarah about distributing leadership decisions. Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication About Your Host, Sarah Olivieri Bold, strategic, and refreshingly human… Sarah Olivieri is the go-to expert for conversations on aligned leadership, outcome delegation, and sustainable growth. She brings wit, warmth, and real-world wisdom to mission-driven founders, visionary CEOs, and change-makers who want more clarity, more joy, and more results. Most leaders hit a wall when success depends on them holding it all together. Sarah helps them change that by redefining leadership around outcomes instead of activity, empowering teams to own results that scale and freeing leaders to focus on the vision that drives them. A former director of three nonprofits and founder of five businesses, she has a rare ability to spot opportunity where others see chaos, shift stuck patterns, and build organizations that support both legacy and life.   Sarah leads with the same mindset that made her an award-winning sailor: iterate on what works, stay focused in the storm, and never forget the joy of the journey. Thank you to Donorbox Thank you to our sponsor, Donorbox, for supporting Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your work removing friction from donation forms. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

    466: Three Things to Say When You Delegate with Sarah Olivieri
  8. Oct 26

    467: How to Get Follow-Through Without Micromanaging with Gina Cotner

    Show Notes When you delegate work and it doesn't get done, a lot of nonprofit leaders either let it slide or take it back and do it themselves. The leaders who get real follow-through hand over full ownership, let people set their own deadlines, and check in with curiosity instead of blame. Sarah invited Gina Cotner, founder and CEO of Athena Executive Services, whose team of executive assistants takes ownership of key processes and projects for busy leaders, to unpack how nonprofit leaders can get staff and volunteers to follow through on what they promised without hovering over them or doing the work themselves. In This Episode, You'll Learn How Gina now runs her firm working 10 to 15 hours a week. What Gina says right after handing off a project so the other person owns it. How letting people set their own deadline leads to better follow-through. What to do first when a deadline passes and the work isn't there. How Gina holds volunteers to the same standards as paid staff. Who This Episode Is For • Executive directors who end up doing the work themselves. • Leaders who want follow-through without constant reminders. • Anyone who skips follow-up to avoid a confrontation. • Executive directors who want their time back. Links from this episode • Inspired Nonprofit Leadership Newsletter: weekly tips for leading your nonprofit. • Athena Executive Services • Gina Cotner on LinkedIn • Athena Executive Services on Instagram • Athena Executive Services on Facebook • Schedule a free call with Athena's client advisor • Book Gina to speak or lead a workshop • Listener offer: five additional hours of service in your second month when you hire Athena and mention Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. • Sarah Olivieri's website • Sarah Olivieri's Substack publication Thank you to Donorbox Thank you to Donorbox for sponsoring Inspired Nonprofit Leadership. We appreciate your support for the show and the nonprofit leaders who listen. Follow Donorbox on YouTube, LinkedIn, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.

    467: How to Get Follow-Through Without Micromanaging with Gina Cotner
4.9
out of 5
99 Ratings

About

This podcast is a place for nonprofit leaders to gain insights, tips, inspiration, and encouragement to unleash their potential.

You Might Also Like