Almost Cooperstown

Gordon Kolier & Mark Kolier

We're a father & son who love to talk and argue about baseball!  Baseball is the professional sport that has the longest history so there is a lot to talk about.  We launched Almost Cooperstown noting that baseball contains a long history of players that, for whatever reasons, have been shunned by the electors of the Hall of Fame.  Consequently here are many 'Almost' players still waiting their turn for induction. With less than 1.5% of the now more than 23,000 players in the HOF, we feel there should be more players included. In these podcasts we also discuss current seasons & trends. Please send any messages to almostcooperstown@gmail.com.  Baseball articles can be found here: https://almostcooperstown.substack.com/publish/posts

  1. 4d ago

    MLB's Salary Cap Fight Could Change Free Agency Forever

    The 2026 MLB awards are in, and four major awards were unanimous. But while the MVP and Cy Young races produced little controversy, the National League Rookie of the Year voting certainly did. In Episode 730 Mark and Gordon discuss the winners, including Pete Crow-Armstrong, Yordan Alvarez, Cam Schlittler, and Jacob Misiorowski. They debate Sal Stewart's controversial Rookie of the Year victory over Mets outfielder Carson Benge and whether voters placed too much emphasis on home runs and RBIs. Then the conversation turns to the biggest story of the offseason: MLB's looming labor confrontation. With a potential lockout approaching, could a proposed $258 million salary cap and $180 million salary floor reshape baseball? Would a cap really improve competitive balance? And what would happen to teams like the Mets and Dodgers, whose payroll commitments could exceed the proposed limits? In this episode: The unanimous MVP and Cy Young winners and the Rookie of the Year controversy.Pat Murphy, Will Venable, and the Manager of the Year awards.Why a salary floor might accomplish more than a salary cap.Whether Shohei Ohtani's deferred compensation would work under a new system.Why owners and players may both have reasons to avoid a prolonged work stoppage.How labor uncertainty could encourage more one-year free-agent contracts.What it might take for the Mets or Dodgers to sign Tarik Skubal.Whether long-term contracts make sense when baseball's financial rules could change.Will baseball's owners and players find common ground, or is another work stoppage inevitable? Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history. Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music. Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.

    MLB's Salary Cap Fight Could Change Free Agency Forever
  2. Nov 2

    The Brewers Won It All. Will Baseball Follow Their Blueprint?

    The Milwaukee Brewers are World Series champions for the first time in franchise history! But did their victory reveal a new blueprint for winning in Major League Baseball? Mark and Gordon return to Almost Cooperstown to examine Milwaukee's dominant postseason, the disappointing performance of the Tampa Bay Rays, and whether the Brewers' combination of contact hitting, defense, pitching, and bullpen depth could challenge baseball's home run-oriented approach. The Brewers hit just 154 home runs during the regular season, ranking 28th in MLB. Yet they won it all. Is this the beginning of a change in baseball strategy, or are the Brewers an exception to the rule? We also discuss: Why Milwaukee's postseason dominance was so impressive.Jacob Misiorowski's extraordinary velocity and the challenge of sustaining success.Aaron Ashby's remarkable scoreless postseason and the difficulty of repeating as champions.Why the Dodgers fell short and whether age and injuries are catching up with their stars.How the 2026 Brewers compare with the 2015 Kansas City Royals.Our predictions for the AL and NL MVP, Cy Young, Manager of the Year, and Rookie of the Year awards.The fascinating NL Rookie of the Year debate involving Sal Stewart, Carson Benge, and JJ Wetherholt.We also remember Jerry Koosman, a key member of the 1969 Miracle Mets, following his passing at age 83. With the offseason beginning and uncertainty surrounding MLB's next labor agreement, what comes next for the Brewers and the rest of baseball? Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history. Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music. Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.

    The Brewers Won It All. Will Baseball Follow Their Blueprint?
  3. Oct 19

    31 Moments That Changed Baseball: Author Phil Coffin Joins Almost Cooperstown

    What do Jackie Robinson's historic debut, baseball's first All-Star Game, Moonlight Graham, the spitball and Dave Winfield's unfortunate encounter with a seagull have in common? They're all part of baseball's remarkable history—and the stories behind them are often more surprising than the events themselves. In Episode 728, Mark and Gordon welcome author Phil Coffin to discuss his book, A Baseball Book of Days: 31 Moments That Transformed the Game. Coffin takes a different approach to baseball history, organizing 31 stories around memorable dates and uncovering the people, coincidences and unexpected circumstances that make the game endlessly fascinating. Among the stories we explore: Jackie Robinson's debut: Why the contemporary newspaper coverage and attendance at Ebbets Field might surprise today's fans.Pumpsie Green and the Red Sox: The 12-year gap between Robinson breaking baseball's color barrier and Boston finally integrating its roster.The first All-Star Games: How the American and National Leagues' 1933 exhibition and the Negro Leagues' East-West All-Star Game became major events.Baseball's strange bird encounters: Dave Winfield's arrest in Toronto and other improbable incidents involving baseballs and birds.Moonlight Graham and the one-game wonders: The players whose entire major league careers lasted a single game, sometimes without a plate appearance.The origins of the trade deadline: How wealthy New York teams helped inspire restrictions on late-season player acquisitions.The .400 hitter who wasn't: Don Padgett's extraordinary 1939 season and the circumstances that left him at .399.The spitball ban: Why baseball allowed certain pitchers to continue throwing the pitch after outlawing it in 1920.Bill Veeck and baseball's winter meetings: A look at baseball's colorful offseason past as the sport faces an uncertain future.Phil also discusses the research behind his books, his earlier work on the 1959 Topps baseball card collection and his next project exploring baseball's innovators. Whether you're a longtime student of baseball history or simply enjoy discovering the game's forgotten characters, this conversation offers plenty of stories worth remembering. Find Phil Coffin's book: A Baseball Book of Days: 31 Moments That Transformed the Game, available through McFarland Books and major booksellers. Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history. Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music. Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.

    31 Moments That Changed Baseball: Author Phil Coffin Joins Almost Cooperstown
  4. Oct 12

    Can Taking a Called Third Strike Make You a Better Hitter?

    From Little League through the major leagues, hitters are taught that striking out looking is one of the worst things they can do. But what if that conventional baseball wisdom is wrong? Cleveland Guardians catcher Austin Hedges changed his approach at the plate by becoming more willing to accept called third strikes rather than making weak, defensive swings. The results raise an intriguing question: Can being less afraid of striking out actually make someone a better hitter? In Episode 727 of Almost Cooperstown, Mark and Gordon Kolier examine the relationship between called third strikes, plate discipline, walks, and on-base percentage. Their research suggests that hitters who take a higher percentage of their strikeouts looking tend to reach base more often. But is that because they're better at recognizing pitches, or is something else at work? The conversation includes Steven Kwan, Seiya Suzuki, Elly De La Cruz, and other major leaguers, along with a memorable example of a hitter frozen by a great pitch: Carlos Beltrán facing Adam Wainwright in Game 7 of the 2006 NLCS. Also in this episode: Can the Brewers, Guardians, or Rays stop the Dodgers from winning a third consecutive World Series?What MLB's reported 154-game schedule proposal could mean for baseball's future.Why postseason bullpen games have become increasingly common.Yoshinobu Yamamoto's place among successful postseason pitchers.The surprisingly short list of catchers who have won batting titles.Sometimes the smartest swing is the one you don't take. But how do hitters know when to hold back? Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history. Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music. Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.

    Can Taking a Called Third Strike Make You a Better Hitter?
  5. Oct 5

    When Is It Time to Break Up the Band? MLB Teams Facing Big Offseason Decisions

    The 2026 MLB regular season is over, the Division Series are underway, and some teams are already facing a difficult question: When is it time to break up the band? Mark and Gordon take a look at several clubs whose familiar cores may have reached a crossroads. The Phillies still have star power, but after another disappointing finish, does bringing back essentially the same group make sense? Houston won its division, but an aging core and questions about the pitching staff create a similar dilemma. The guys also look at what comes next for the Blue Jays, Orioles, Tigers and other teams trying to determine whether they need a few changes—or something much bigger. Before getting to the offseason questions, Mark and Gordon take a tour through some of the most interesting statistical results from the 2026 regular season, including the decline of the 200-hit season, fewer doubles and triples, stolen-base leaders, saves, and a home-run race that finished without anyone reaching 50. Plus, they recap the opening of the Division Series, including a costly Yankees baserunning decision, dominant pitching, and one of the strangest potential home runs you'll see in a postseason game. In Episode 726: The unusual statistical leaders of the 2026 MLB seasonWhy nobody reached 200 hitsThe changing nature of doubles, triples and stolen basesWhy the 60-save closer may be disappearingA surprisingly modest home-run leaderboardEarly Division Series takeawaysA bizarre roof play that helped decide a postseason gameShould the Phillies break up their veteran core?Is Houston approaching the end of an era?What should Toronto and Baltimore do next?Detroit's offseason opportunityHow the possibility of a 2027 labor stoppage could complicate everythingAt some point, continuity stops being stability and starts becoming stagnation. Which MLB teams have reached that point? Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history. Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music. Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.

    When Is It Time to Break Up the Band? MLB Teams Facing Big Offseason Decisions
  6. Sep 29

    The 2026 MLB Playoffs Are Here: Which Teams Survive the Wild Card Round?

    The 2026 MLB regular season is over, and the postseason is here. Mark and Gordon look back at a season filled with surprises before breaking down the Wild Card matchups and making their picks. The White Sox completed a remarkable turnaround and reached the postseason. The Astros won the AL West despite finishing 81-81. Tampa Bay captured the AL East, while the National League playoff field looks considerably more familiar. In Episode 725, we also look at some of the season's notable individual performances and milestones, including Yordan Alvarez's batting title, Colson Montgomery setting the single-season strikeout record, Pete Alonso's huge season in Baltimore, and an emotional possible farewell for Justin Verlander. Then it's time for the playoffs: • Yankees vs. Red Sox — Does New York's pitching and power give the Yankees the edge in another chapter of baseball's biggest rivalry? • Phillies vs. Braves — Philadelphia survived to reach October, but now has to go through Atlanta. • Cubs vs. Padres — Chicago's offense and defense were among baseball's best, but can the Cubs' pitching survive October? • White Sox vs. Astros — Chicago is one of baseball's best stories, while Houston became an unlikely division champion at 81-81. Which team can take advantage? Plus: Which division winners are most vulnerable once the Division Series begins, and are we headed toward Dodgers-Brewers and Yankees-Rays championship series? The regular season took 162 games. Now three games can end everything. Welcome to October baseball. Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history. Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music. Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.

    The 2026 MLB Playoffs Are Here: Which Teams Survive the Wild Card Round?
  7. Sep 7

    PCA vs. Yordan Alvarez: Who Would Be MLB’s Overall MVP?

    Major League Baseball awards separate MVPs in the American and National Leagues, but what would happen if there were only one award for the entire sport? The leading candidates present a fascinating contrast. Pete Crow-Armstrong offers elite defense, speed, power and enormous all-around value. Traditional value measurements such as WAR make a compelling case that the Chicago Cubs center fielder has been the most valuable player in baseball. Yordan Alvarez presents a different argument. The Houston Astros slugger may not match Crow-Armstrong’s defensive value, but his bat changes games. Measures such as Win Probability Added give Alvarez credit for delivering in the moments that have most directly affected whether his team wins or loses. That raises a larger question: What should “most valuable” actually mean? Should the award go to the player who accumulates the greatest overall value across hitting, defense and baserunning? Or should greater weight be given to the player whose biggest performances come in the most important moments? In Episode 723 of Almost Cooperstown, Mark and Gordon compare Pete Crow-Armstrong and Yordan Alvarez and consider what WAR, WPA and other measurements reveal—and sometimes fail to reveal—about player value. They also discuss whether clutch performance should influence MVP voting, whether a designated hitter can overcome the value contributed by an elite defensive center fielder and whether one statistic should ever settle an MVP debate. If Major League Baseball selected only one overall MVP, would you vote for PCA or Yordan Alvarez? Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history. Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music. Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.

    PCA vs. Yordan Alvarez: Who Would Be MLB’s Overall MVP?

Ratings & Reviews

4.6
out of 5
19 Ratings

About

We're a father & son who love to talk and argue about baseball!  Baseball is the professional sport that has the longest history so there is a lot to talk about.  We launched Almost Cooperstown noting that baseball contains a long history of players that, for whatever reasons, have been shunned by the electors of the Hall of Fame.  Consequently here are many 'Almost' players still waiting their turn for induction. With less than 1.5% of the now more than 23,000 players in the HOF, we feel there should be more players included. In these podcasts we also discuss current seasons & trends. Please send any messages to almostcooperstown@gmail.com.  Baseball articles can be found here: https://almostcooperstown.substack.com/publish/posts

You Might Also Like