Five's A Crowd Podcast

Five's A Crowd

Five friends. Unbelievable stories. Very different opinions. Join Austin, Cam, Chris, Tony, and Zach as we debate Reddit drama, revisit '90s nostalgia, and dig into strange stories and real-world mysteries—with the laughs and tangents of a late-night hangout. Pull up a chair, pick a side, and thank you for being part of this crowd!

  1. Nov 9

    Superstitions: Good Luck, Bad Luck, and Why We Still Care

    Are superstitions just harmless habits, or do they still get in our heads? We're talking good luck, bad omens, childhood warnings, and the strange little rules we keep following—even when we know how ridiculous they sound. With Friday the 13th on the table, we compare familiar rituals and some much stranger folklore, then ask whether luck changes anything or just changes how we feel. Before that, we're catching up on travel, turning 40, unfinished hobbies, and teaching our kids to drive. Pull up a chair, tell us which superstition you still follow, and thank you for being part of this crowd! Timestamps: 00:00 - Start! 04:32 - Travel Stories and Family Catch-Up 12:24 - Hobbies, Obsessions, and Unfinished Projects 15:48 - Family Updates and Tangents 29:40 - Turning 40 and Feeling Your Age 35:41 - Getting Motivated to Work Out 42:56 - Going Gray 45:38 - Teaching Teens to Drive and Movie Detours 54:32 - Our First Freeway Experiences 57:48 - A Rough Landing 01:00:25 - Superstitions We Still Follow 01:09:18 - Good Luck, Bad Luck, and Familiar Rituals 01:18:55 - Unlucky Numbers and Friday the 13th 01:24:17 - Is Luck All in Your Head? 01:25:13 - Unusual Superstitions and Strange Folklore 01:33:14 - Your Superstitions and Goodbye #Superstitions #FridayThe13th #FivesACrowd #Podcast What's one superstition you KNOW sounds ridiculous... but still follow just in case? Tell us the rule—and who taught it to you. 👇 Reddit - Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd - Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcast Follow Our Personal Accounts Austin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomer Cam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/ Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/ Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/ Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/ Hashtags #JoinTheCrowd #HitTheBell #Podcast P.O. Box **Please no packages, letters only** Five's A Crowd Podcast 1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041

  2. Oct 19

    Was Halloween Actually Better in the '90s?

    Was Halloween actually better in the '90s—or do we just miss being kids? We're revisiting homemade costumes, pillowcases full of candy, classic Halloween specials, and the neighborhood traditions we'd bring back. Plus, we debate trunk or treat, where pranks cross the line, and finish with two-sentence horror stories that get darker than expected. Tell us which Halloween tradition deserves a comeback—and thank you for being part of this crowd! #Halloween #90sNostalgia #FivesACrowd #HalloweenNostalgia #TwoSentenceHorror 00:00 - Start! 01:19 - Childhood Halloween and homemade costumes 10:52 - Plastic masks and school Halloween 12:16 - The daylight saving time detour 22:04 - Trunk or treat vs. door-to-door 27:50 - Candy hauls and neighborhood pranks 37:01 - Halloween TV we grew up watching 47:05 - Old-school decorations and Halloween cartoons 51:58 - Candy buckets, pillowcases, and candy checks 56:03 - Sweet treats and fall food debates 01:07:44 - Mischief night and unusual Halloween treats 01:14:02 - The traditions we'd bring back 01:18:17 - Two-sentence horror stories 01:25:48 - Vampires or werewolves? 01:27:46 - Wrapping up Halloween night Reddit - Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd - Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcast Follow Our Personal Accounts Austin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomer Cam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/ Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/ Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/ Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/ P.O. Box **Please no packages, letters only** Five's A Crowd Podcast 1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041

  3. Oct 12

    Scary Stories From The Depths of Reddit..

    Welcome back to the table! Today, we are kicking off spooky season with a chilling challenge: reading 10 terrifying internet stories from the depths of Reddit and guessing which ones are actually true and which ones are completely made up... Timestamps: 00:00 - Start! 00:20 - The Scary Story Challenge Explained 00:57 - Why We Love Scaring the Neighbors 03:06 - Story 1: The Unplugged Baby Monitor 07:32 - Story 2: The Green Woman 08:23 - The Bloody Mary Tangent 10:46 - Story 3: The Water Meter Camera 13:49 - Story 4: The Voice in the Woodshed 16:21 - Story 5: The Apartment Above 4B 20:15 - Story 6: Woman on the Highway 22:04 - Story 7: The Last Passenger 24:12 - Story 8: Closing the Tudor Hall 25:41 - Story 9: The Missing Minute 28:03 - Story 10: The Boy Who Knew 29:50 - The Reveal: Which Stories Are Actually Real? 34:21 - The Missing Minute Debate 38:00 - Final Scores & Outro Hashtags: #ScaryStories #RedditStories #TrueScaryStories #Paranormal #CreepyStories #LetsNotMeet #Storytime #Podcast #FivesACrowd #Halloween BOO!👻 Which of these stories gave you the biggest chills?? Reddit - Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd - Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcast Follow Our Personal Accounts Austin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomer Cam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/ Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/ Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/ Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/ Hashtags #JoinTheCrowd #HitTheBell #Podcast P.O. Box **Please no packages, letters only** Five's A Crowd Podcast 1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041

  4. Oct 5

    Utah Tornado Danger, Drained Lake, & Other Weird News!

    This week at the table we dive into the wildest local and global stories. From surviving a massive Utah tornado and golf-ball-sized hail, to the shocking secrets uncovered at the bottom of the drained Pineview Reservoir, things get crazy. We also discuss a leaked audio recording regarding 3D-printed meat in your soup, the massive FBI data hack, and the discovery of what might be Noah's Ark. Plus, Tony explains why he can't handle realistic horror anymore.. Timestamps: 00:00 - Start! 00:40 - The New "In The News" Format 02:13 - Kids Driving and First Jobs 07:20 - Why Tony Can't Handle Realistic Gore 12:23 - The Reality of Getting Older 19:30 - Jess's Neck MRI & Potential Surgery 23:14 - The 3D-Printed Meat Conspiracy 25:05 - Starving on the Survival Show "Alone" 26:59 - The Campbell's VP Leaked Audio 30:50 - Surviving the Utah Tornado & Hail 34:48 - Uncovering Secrets in the Drained Pineview Reservoir 41:07 - Exonerated After 41 Years on Death Row 43:05 - Did They Discover Noah's Ark? 46:13 - The Massive FBI Data Hack 48:52 - The Lindsey Clancy Juror Controversy 52:59 - Strange But True: Aggressive Squirrels 56:43 - Good News: Organ Donor Saves 5 Lives 58:20 - Critics Corner: Movie & TV Reviews 1:05:42 - The "Buddy" Horror Parody 1:08:27 - Ranking the Spider-Man Multiverse 1:13:42 - Final Jokes & Outro Hashtags: #PineviewReservoir #UtahTornado #StrangeNews #FivesACrowd #Podcast #NewsPodcast #ComedyPodcast #MovieReviews What was the wildest news story for you this week? Are you buying the 3D-printed meat conspiracy, or are you more shocked by what they found at the bottom of the lake? Let us know below! 👇 Thank you for being part of this crowd! You've got burning questions, we've got answers! Call or Text us for the worst advice imaginable, and we may feature it on an upcoming podcast! ** 801-513-3373 ** P.O. Box **Please no packages, letters only** Five's A Crowd Podcast 1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041

  5. Sep 28

    She Stole HER Best Friend's Wedding Trip for a Secret Bali Affair!

    Today we dive into some of the most unhinged end-of-summer horror stories and Reddit AITA posts on the internet! The absolute craziest story of the week: a woman who sued her best friend for skipping her destination wedding in Bali, only to uncover a secret affair! Grab a seat at the table and join the conversation! 00:00 - Start! 00:12 - Coneheads & Border Fences 01:15 - Yo Mama Jokes & Welcome to the Table 02:21 - Grouse Hunting & Weird Animal Facts 05:00 - Reddit Story 1: Labor Day Waterpark Family Drama 12:41 - The Waterpark Verdict 13:14 - AskReddit: High School Teachers Brawl in the Bathroom! 17:15 - Reddit Story 2: Refusing to Care for a Disabled Sister 24:42 - Reddit Story 3: Mother Abandons Daughter at Funeral Because of Ghosts 34:42 - Ouija Boards & Paranormal Experiences 37:49 - Reddit Story 4: The Bali Betrayal (Stolen Wedding Trip!) 41:44 - The $2,400 "Emotional Support" Invoice 44:07 - Exposed! Catching the Bali Affair on Instagram 48:55 - Outro & Wrap-Up #RedditStories #AITA #Podcast #RelationshipDrama #Storytime #FivesACrowd #ComedyPodcast Reddit - Our Subreddit: https://www.reddit.com/r/FivesACrowd - Our Account: https://www.reddit.com/user/FivesACrowdPodcast Follow Our Personal Accounts Austin - https://allmylinks.com/austinspomer Cam - https://www.instagram.com/effinburch/ Chris - https://www.instagram.com/thechrishummel/ Tony - https://www.instagram.com/theonlytonyc/ Zach - https://www.instagram.com/zvanbeekum/ Hashtags #JoinTheCrowd #HitTheBell #Podcast P.O. Box **Please no packages, letters only** Five's A Crowd Podcast 1123 N Fairfield Rd #1373 Layton, UT 84041

4.9
out of 5
106 Ratings

About

Five friends. Unbelievable stories. Very different opinions. Join Austin, Cam, Chris, Tony, and Zach as we debate Reddit drama, revisit '90s nostalgia, and dig into strange stories and real-world mysteries—with the laughs and tangents of a late-night hangout. Pull up a chair, pick a side, and thank you for being part of this crowd!

You Might Also Like