All About Capital Campaigns: Nonprofits, Fundraising, Major Gifts, Toolkit

Capital Campaign Pro

All About Capital Campaigns is your weekly source for nonprofit fundraising advice. Each week hosts Andrea Kihlstedt and Amy Eisenstein, co-founders of Capital Campaign Pro (capitalcampaignpro.com) and special guests, provide practical tips about raising more money for your nonprofit organization. Topics include capital campaigns, feasibility studies, working with your board, donors, major gifts, volunteers, and more. This is a great resource for nonprofit Executive Directors/CEOs, Development Directors, Board Members, or others looking to learn about nonprofit fundraising.

  1. 3d ago

    How to Solicit Your Board for Capital Campaign Gifts

    A pledge form tucked into a board packet may feel like the easiest way to ask for campaign gifts. It can also leave you with unanswered forms, smaller-than-expected gifts, and no clear next step. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt explain how to build a thoughtful, one-on-one process for soliciting board members. Board members are among the people closest to your organization, and their campaign gifts can help set the pace for others. But board giving looks different at every organization. There’s no standard percentage of a campaign goal that every board should contribute, and a collective board goal shouldn’t be divided evenly among members. A useful goal reflects your board’s makeup and what meaningful giving looks like for its members. Amy and Andrea walk through the steps that help make board solicitations more effective: agree on a collective giving goal, plan the process with the board and campaign chairs, train the people who will make the asks, and prepare an appropriate ask amount for each board member. They also explain why one-on-one conversations give board members a chance to discuss their role, hear the case for support, ask questions, and consider a gift that fits their circumstances. The conversation covers how to set expectations before solicitations begin, establish a clear timetable, and track both board participation and progress toward the collective goal. Amy and Andrea also discuss how campaign giving can sit alongside annual giving, why board members may consider multi-year pledges or gifts from assets, and how a board can celebrate reaching its goal. A capital campaign may be new territory for your board. A clear, respectful process can help board members understand what’s being asked of them and give them a meaningful way to take part. For more board engagement tips, be sure to download our free Board Member’s Guide to Capital Campaign Fundraising - https://capitalcampaignpro.com/board-members-guide. It answers the questions board members most frequently ask, or wish they could ask. Episode chapters 00:00 — Why board campaign gifts need a thoughtful plan05:42 — Setting a collective board giving goal08:03 — Planning one-on-one solicitations09:42 — Training solicitors and preparing ask amounts11:56 — Why board giving may look like a diamond, not a pyramid14:24 — Preparing board members for campaign gifts16:43 — Setting a timetable and tracking progress19:30 — Why board members should accept a solicitation meeting22:06 — Closing thoughts and next steps #Fundraising #Nonprofit #CapitalCampaign

    How to Solicit Your Board for Capital Campaign Gifts
  2. Nov 10

    How One Community Foundation Built a $100 Million Endowment Campaign

    What does a $100 million endowment campaign look like when there is no building to name and the real impact will unfold over generations? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein talks with Claire Tobin, Senior Director of Philanthropy and Community Impact at The Denver Foundation, about the foundation’s centennial campaign, which has raised more than $116 million through current gifts and estate intentions. The Denver Foundation had never run a campaign before. Claire explains how a 2023 feasibility study helped test the campaign idea and its ambitious goal, and how the foundation connected its 100-year anniversary to a forward-looking case for support. The team showed how endowed gifts can sustain community grantmaking and support changing needs in Denver over time. Claire shares how the campaign included both the foundation’s permanent endowment and donor-created funds, why the campaign counted documented estate intentions toward its goal, and what the final mix of current gifts and planned gifts looked like. About 56% of the $116 million came in current gifts, while 44% came through estate intentions. One-quarter supported the Fund for Denver, and three-quarters went to donor-created funds. She also describes the campaign committee’s role in strengthening relationships and advocating in the community without taking on direct solicitation. The conversation gets into donor response, too: why donors who declined the endowment ask still mattered, how campaign conversations opened the door to larger estate commitments and increased annual giving, and why a “no” does not have to end a relationship. Claire reflects on the internal work behind the campaign, including CEO and board leadership, cross-department buy-in, and a seven-person fundraising team that took on campaign work without hiring additional staff. If your nonprofit is considering an endowment campaign, planned giving, or a first capital campaign, this case study offers practical lessons in testing a goal, making the case for long-term impact, engaging existing donors, and preparing the whole organization to take part. CHAPTERS 00:00 A $100 million endowment campaign00:42 Meet Claire Tobin and The Denver Foundation01:32 Building a case for an endowment campaign03:29 Testing the idea and goal in a feasibility study07:12 Counting estate intentions toward the goal09:35 Campaign results: $116 million raised11:23 Donor-created funds and the Fund for Denver15:14 Making endowment meaningful to donors16:35 Leadership, board engagement, and campaign success18:53 Engaging existing donors and campaign committee members23:13 What a “no” can teach you25:39 Why the whole organization needs to be on board27:17 Team structure and staffing for a $100 million campaignTo see if your organization is ready for a capital campaign, download the free Readiness Assessment: https://capitalcampaignpro.com/assess Follow @CapitalCampaignPro for more capital campaign guidance. #Fundraising #Philanthropy

    How One Community Foundation Built a $100 Million Endowment Campaign
  3. Nov 3

    Top-Down, Inside-Out: A Capital Campaign Strategy for Major Gifts

    A campaign can raise millions and still stall if the team approaches donors in the wrong order. Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt explain how a top-down, inside-out strategy can build donor confidence and campaign momentum from the start. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy and Andrea break down a core principle of capital campaign fundraising: begin with the largest potential gifts and the people closest to your organization. They explain how these two priorities work together, why the order of solicitation matters, and how a clear campaign plan can help donors see a path to success. “Top-down” means following your gift range chart from the largest gift down. For a $10 million campaign, that might mean starting with a potential $2.5 million gift. When a mid-level donor is asked early, before the campaign has secured its lead gifts, even a generous $50,000 commitment can feel like a small contribution to a very large goal. Once several major gifts are in place, the same donor can see that the campaign is gaining traction and understand the role their gift can play. Amy and Andrea discuss why campaigns that begin with scattered solicitations may reach a few million dollars and then lose momentum. They share an example of a founder who expected to raise campaign gifts from the same friends who had supported the organization at its start. As the team developed a clear plan, it identified other potential lead donors: families whose lives had been touched by the organization’s services. “Inside-out” means beginning with people who already have a close connection to the organization. Board members, founders, volunteers, clients, patients, and others served may all belong in those first circles. Their gifts can vary in size. What matters is their commitment and connection to the mission. Amy and Andrea describe how to think about the people who are both major gift prospects and insiders, and why board members should make their commitments before they speak publicly about the campaign. The two strategies work together: pursue the largest gifts while building participation among the people closest to the organization. That gives campaign leaders a process they can explain and return to at every meeting. Instead of trying to reach the broader community too soon, the team can build confidence and momentum before widening the circle of solicitations. If your organization is planning a capital campaign or feels stuck partway through one, visit Capital Campaign Pro to learn how our team can help you understand the strategy and plan your next steps. Topics covered: 00:00 The “top-down, inside-out” campaign principle02:03 How a gift range chart shapes solicitation strategy04:42 Why to begin with the largest potential gifts06:49 How early campaign progress affects donor confidence08:44 Why campaigns can stall without an order of solicitation10:51 A founder’s shift from familiar donors to a clear plan13:07 What “inside-out” means14:18 Starting with board members and close supporters16:04 When a donor is both an insider and a major gift prospect17:24 Why insiders should commit before speaking publicly19:43 Putting both strategies into a campaign plan20:32 Where to get help with campaign planningFollow @CapitalCampaignPro for more guidance on capital campaign planning and fundraising. #CapitalCampaign #Fundraising #Nonprofit

    Top-Down, Inside-Out: A Capital Campaign Strategy for Major Gifts
  4. Oct 27

    The Fundraising Metric Every Nonprofit Leader Should Know

    A simple question can reveal whether an organization is ready to plan for a major campaign: How much does it raise from philanthropy each year? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt discuss why nonprofit leaders need to know their organization’s annual fundraising numbers, where that information comes from, and how to build a steady habit of reviewing it. They explain how a clear picture of current fundraising can inform capital campaign planning and help leaders feel more prepared to talk with donors about significant gifts. You don’t need an elaborate dashboard or a sophisticated major gifts program to get started. You do need a reliable baseline: how much came in last year, which sources contributed, and whether this year’s fundraising is on track. Amy and Andrea suggest working with the people who manage your books or donor records, then setting a recurring monthly meeting to review the same measures consistently. Looking at the numbers month after month can feel uncomfortable, especially when a month or two goes poorly. But regular review helps leaders see longer-term trends, work through challenges together, and ask for help when needed. A capital campaign can bring structure, strategy, and training to major gift fundraising, but it cannot magically repair an ongoing operating deficit. Stronger awareness of your current fundraising gives your organization a more grounded starting point. Whether you’re an executive director, development director, board chair, or campaign volunteer, this episode offers a practical first step: know what your organization raises, how it raises it, and how the results are changing over time. Follow @CapitalCampaignPro for more conversations and practical guidance on capital campaign fundraising. Episode chapters 00:00 The question every nonprofit leader should be able to answer01:54 Why leaders avoid looking closely at fundraising05:04 How annual fundraising connects to campaign planning06:42 You don’t need a major gifts program to run a campaign09:11 Establishing a baseline and reviewing it monthly10:38 Why consistent measures help reveal trends12:34 When a campaign can’t solve an operating deficit14:00 Building a clear, simple system for tracking fundraising

    The Fundraising Metric Every Nonprofit Leader Should Know
  5. Oct 20

    What Does a Successful Capital Campaign Really Look Like?

    Could reaching your capital campaign goal mean your organization is leaving an opportunity on the table? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, co-hosts Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt explore what campaign success really means, and why it may be bigger and more flexible than one fundraising number. For many organizations, success sounds simple: set a goal, raise that amount, and celebrate. But what if your donors are ready to give more? What if project costs change, the building plan shifts, or new prospects emerge? Amy and Andrea make the case that a successful capital campaign raises all the money an organization can for its project or vision at that time. They explain how organizations develop a preliminary campaign goal, test it through a campaign planning study or feasibility study, and refine it based on what they learn from their largest potential donors. As a campaign moves forward, donor feedback, changing project costs, and new opportunities may all affect what is possible. In many campaigns, organizations end up raising more than they originally planned. Momentum can build as more donors become engaged and want to be part of the effort. The conversation also looks at what happens when a project changes during a campaign. A building plan may shift, a different property may become available, or the organization may discover a better way to carry out its mission. Staying in touch with donors helps keep them engaged as plans evolve and can create opportunities to raise more for the work the organization hopes to do. Amy and Andrea also address the difficult question of what to do when a campaign is unlikely to reach its original goal. They discuss options such as using other funding sources, adjusting the project’s scope, or giving the campaign more time. Extending the timeline can make sense when there are additional prospects to cultivate and solicit, but it requires a clear reason and a plan. Campaign success reaches beyond dollars raised. A well-planned campaign can strengthen board engagement, help staff become more effective at major gift fundraising, sharpen the organization’s message, and deepen donor relationships. Donors may make larger gifts than ever before, and thoughtful stewardship can help those increased gifts continue beyond the campaign. Whether your organization is setting a campaign goal, entering the quiet phase, deciding whether to keep fundraising after reaching goal, or reassessing a project, this conversation offers a more useful way to think about progress and possibility. Amy and Andrea explain how campaign strategy gives leaders room to refine their definition of success while staying focused on the mission and the project donors want to support. Subscribe to All About Capital Campaigns for more conversations about capital campaign planning, major gift fundraising, donor engagement, and nonprofit leadership. Follow @CapitalCampaignPro for more campaign guidance and resources. Episode topics: 00:00 — What does campaign success mean?03:07 — Raising all that’s possible for the project04:10 — Testing and revising the goal06:59 — Momentum and changing project plans10:35 — Whether to keep fundraising after reaching goal12:16 — Adjusting the project when fundraising falls short13:25 — The lasting effects of a campaign16:35 — How campaign strategy helps refine success19:57 — Changing the goal or timeline21:45 — When extending the timeline makes sense #Fundraising #Nonprofit #Nonprofits

    What Does a Successful Capital Campaign Really Look Like?
  6. Oct 13

    The Executive Director’s Role in a Capital Campaign: 4 Essential Responsibilities

    Your capital campaign needs an executive director who can steady the team, stand up to the board, and secure the resources to succeed. In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Capital Campaign Pro co-founders Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt discuss four essential responsibilities for nonprofit CEOs and executive directors leading a capital campaign. Drawing on a recent conversation with nonprofit leaders, they explain how the person at the top sets the tone for campaign confidence, board engagement, staff morale, and the investment needed to raise more money than the organization has ever raised before. First, Amy and Andrea explore what it means to project confidence when the outcome still feels uncertain. Capital campaigns can bring sleepless nights, tough decisions, and anxiety for everyone involved. Leaders need a deep commitment to what the campaign will accomplish for their community, backed by preparation, donor conversations, a feasibility study, and access to experienced campaign counsel. That combination helps them communicate a clear sense of direction while doing the work required to make the campaign successful. Next, they address a responsibility that can be uncomfortable to discuss: protecting fundraising staff from destructive board behavior. When a board member publicly criticizes or embarrasses a development director, the executive director needs to address the behavior and create a better setting for legitimate concerns. Amy and Andrea also discuss the positive side of this role: recognizing staff contributions, encouraging the team, and making sure the people doing difficult campaign work feel appreciated. The conversation then turns to board communication and the influence that often operates outside formal meetings. The loudest person in the room may not be the person others listen to most. Executive directors need to know who holds influence, build relationships with those board members, and discuss important decisions before they reach the board agenda. Amy and Andrea consider how virtual board meetings have changed the informal conversations that once happened in parking lots, and why intentional outreach matters. Finally, they explain why the CEO must advocate for an adequate capital campaign budget. Campaign planning requires a realistic investment in staffing, expertise, and support over the life of the effort. They discuss including campaign expenses in the fundraising goal, planning ahead rather than revisiting every expenditure, and responding when board members assume existing staff can simply take on the campaign. One example brings that challenge into focus: a small organization hired its first development professional, then was surprised when that person recommended bringing in campaign counsel. Amy and Andrea explain why even capable fundraisers may need specialized support for a campaign they have never led before. Whether you are an executive director preparing for your first capital campaign, a development director seeking stronger leadership support, or a board chair helping your organization plan, this episode offers practical guidance for building a more confident, supported campaign team. Share this episode with your CEO, executive director, or board chair to start a conversation about the leadership your campaign needs. To see if your organization is truly ready for a capital campaign, download this free Readiness Assessment https://capitalcampaignpro.com/assess - This guide will help you evaluate six aspects of your organization, including the board and your case for support. #Fundraising #Nonprofit #Leadership CHAPTERS 00:00 The executive director’s role in a capital campaign01:40 Leading with confidence05:26 Protecting and encouraging fundraising staff08:53 Communicating with influential board members13:22 A Board Member’s Guide to Capital Campaign Fundraising14:24 Advocating for the campaign budget18:29 Four leadership responsibilities to remember

    The Executive Director’s Role in a Capital Campaign: 4 Essential Responsibilities
  7. Oct 6

    How to Track Capital Campaign Progress and Show Your Board a Path to Goal

    What if your next campaign update was already there when you needed it, with your progress, major gift prospects, and path to goal in one place instead of scattered across reports and spreadsheets?  In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, co-founder Andrea Kihlstedt talks with Capital Campaign Pro’s Director of Engagement and Technology, Steven Shattuck, about a challenge familiar to development directors: tracking a capital campaign and explaining its progress in a way that builds confidence. A campaign total tells only part of the story. Your organization might have raised $3 million toward a $5 million goal, but board members will still want to know where the remaining $2 million will come from. Which prospects could make the lead gifts? Where are they in the solicitation process? What happens if an expected gift comes in smaller than planned, or does not come in at all? Answering those questions often means pulling information from a nonprofit CRM, updating a separate spreadsheet, and building yet another presentation for a meeting. Andrea shares the story of Alexandra O’Connor, a development director whose sophisticated spreadsheet helped campaign leaders see several possible paths to success. Steven explains how that idea became the Capital Campaign Pro Major Gift Dashboard, an online tool for tracking campaign goals, gift ranges, prospects, and progress. They discuss how a clear view of the numbers can help fundraising staff decide what to do next and help board members understand the plan behind the goal. You’ll hear why so many nonprofits turn to spreadsheets when they begin a capital campaign, even if they already have a CRM. Andrea and Steven also discuss the time spent maintaining those files, the risks of relying on a spreadsheet stored on one computer, and the value of giving campaign leaders a shared place to see current information. The dashboard works alongside an organization’s existing CRM; the conversation focuses on the select group of prospects and gifts that will determine the campaign’s outcome. The discussion goes beyond reporting. Andrea describes how development directors can use different gift scenarios to explore the consequences of a prospect’s decision and identify their next steps. Steven explains how a clearer view of the remaining gift ranges and prospects can make a difficult board conversation more productive. Instead of simply reporting what has been raised, a fundraiser can show who may help close the gap and how the team plans to move those relationships forward. They also cover access to the dashboard, its use across different types of campaigns, and where to see it in action. If you are preparing for a campaign committee meeting, managing major gift prospects, or trying to give your board a more useful progress update, this episode offers a practical way to think about the numbers and the decisions behind them. Explore the Major Gift Dashboard: https://capitalcampaignpro.com/dashboard Follow @CapitalCampaignPro for more guidance on capital campaign planning and fundraising. #NonprofitFundraising #Fundraising #Nonprofit Episode chapters: 00:00 Why campaign progress can be hard to explain01:18 The spreadsheet that inspired the dashboard04:00 Turning campaign data into a clearer path to goal06:31 Why campaigns end up in spreadsheets09:25 Showing the board how to close the remaining gap11:13 Using gift scenarios to decide what comes next12:24 Saving time on campaign reporting15:03 Who can use the dashboard and where to find it

    How to Track Capital Campaign Progress and Show Your Board a Path to Goal
  8. Sep 29

    Should Consultants Interview Your Donors? Rethinking the Capital Campaign Feasibility Study

    What if the most valuable part of a feasibility study is the donor conversation your consultant never has? In this episode of All About Capital Campaigns, Capital Campaign Pro co-founders Amy Eisenstein and Andrea Kihlstedt challenge a longstanding assumption about capital campaign feasibility studies: that an outside consultant should conduct confidential interviews with your largest donors. Traditionally, a consultant meets with prospective donors, gathers their opinions about a proposed campaign, and returns with a report and recommended fundraising goal. Amy and Andrea explain why they began questioning that approach and what happened when they tried a different model. In a guided feasibility study, nonprofit leaders meet with donors themselves after receiving training and support from an experienced campaign advisor. The advisor helps them prepare for the conversations, interpret what they hear, and use the findings to shape a realistic campaign plan. The change raises understandable questions. Will donors speak candidly to an executive director or board leader? Can staff listen without trying to sell the project? Where will nonprofit leaders find time to meet with 30 potential campaign supporters? Amy and Andrea take each concern seriously and share what they have learned from years of guiding organizations through these conversations. They also discuss what a confidential interview can leave out of the process. If a donor raises a concern with a consultant, the organization may receive an anonymous summary without knowing whom to follow up with or how to repair the relationship. When leaders hear feedback directly, they can ask better questions, understand the context, and carry the conversation forward. That firsthand knowledge can help them assess the campaign goal and make more informed decisions before asking for gifts. For Amy and Andrea, these interviews do more than test whether a campaign is feasible. They invite major donors to help shape the plan while giving nonprofit leaders practice in having thoughtful, strategic conversations about money and mission. A leader who has listened to a donor’s hopes, questions, and concerns is also better prepared for a future solicitation. The relationship continues from a real conversation instead of beginning again after a consultant hands over a report. Andrea shares what donors told her about their preference for speaking directly with the organizations they support. Amy recounts an executive director’s experience of having unusually open conversations with donors after 15 years in the role. Together, they make the case for treating donors as partners in campaign planning and for using the feasibility study to build skills that will serve your team throughout the campaign and beyond. If your organization is considering a capital campaign, choosing a feasibility study model, or wondering how to engage major donors before making an ask, this conversation will help you think through who should be in the room and what your team could learn by being there. Episode chapters: 00:00 Why revisit the traditional feasibility study?01:13 How consultant-led interviews became the standard04:35 Will donors speak candidly to nonprofit leaders?09:15 Can staff conduct interviews without bias?10:53 Finding time for conversations with major donors13:15 What changes when leaders conduct the interviews14:34 What donors prefer16:29 Transparency and firsthand feedback19:01 Using early conversations to prepare for the ask21:44 Building lasting major gift fundraising skills23:43 Closing thoughts and next stepsLearn more about guided feasibility studies and capital campaign planning at https://capitalcampaignpro.com/. Follow @CapitalCampaignPro for more practical campaign guidance. #Fundraising #Nonprofits

    Should Consultants Interview Your Donors? Rethinking the Capital Campaign Feasibility Study
4.9
out of 5
34 Ratings

About

All About Capital Campaigns is your weekly source for nonprofit fundraising advice. Each week hosts Andrea Kihlstedt and Amy Eisenstein, co-founders of Capital Campaign Pro (capitalcampaignpro.com) and special guests, provide practical tips about raising more money for your nonprofit organization. Topics include capital campaigns, feasibility studies, working with your board, donors, major gifts, volunteers, and more. This is a great resource for nonprofit Executive Directors/CEOs, Development Directors, Board Members, or others looking to learn about nonprofit fundraising.

You Might Also Like