Murder, Not Murdering: Mary Ashford, Trial by Battle & the Cindy James Mystery This week on Murder, Not Murdering, we’re serving up two true crime stories where the justice system, and the truth, slipped through the cracks. First, Erin takes us back to 1817 and the death of Mary Ashford, a young woman found dead in a pit of water after a night of dancing. The man accused, Abraham Thornton, invoked a centuries-old legal loophole: trial by battle. Yes, really. Erin breaks down how this medieval practice worked, why it was still on the books, and how the case led to its abolition. Then comes the eerie part. In 1974, Barbara Forrest was found in a ditch on the edge of Pype Hayes Park in Erdington, Birmingham, the same area where Mary Ashford died. The men accused in both cases were named Thornton, and both were acquitted. Two murders 157 years apart, one park, and a list of coincidences that’s hard to shake. Then Autumn dives into the unsolved case of Cindy James, a Vancouver woman who lived in constant fear. Strange attacks, threatening messages, and escalating terror followed her for years before her death. Was she being stalked by someone real, or was something else going on? Autumn walks through the evidence, the theories, and the questions that still linger. In this episode: The death of Mary Ashford and the trial by battle that followedWhy trial by battle was still legal in 1817The Barbara Forrest case and its strange echoes of 1817Cindy James’s years of fear, the attacks, and the investigationThe theories that still divide armchair detectivesFollow us and join the conversation: 📸 Instagram: @murdernotmurdering 🎵 TikTok: @mnm.pod Listen, follow, and subscribe wherever you get your podcasts, and leave us a rating and review if you enjoyed it. Content note: this episode discusses violent crime, sexual violence, and death. Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Personal Updates02:59 Current Events in True Crime05:57 The Case of Mary Ashford12:02 The Night of the Dance18:00 Discovery of the Body24:04 The Trial of Abraham Thornton29:54 Public Outcry and Retrial34:59 Trial by Battle: A Historical Absurdity37:57 The Aftermath of a Bizarre Case39:44 Victim Blaming: The Case of Mary Ashford40:43 Uncanny Coincidences: A Dark Connection43:09 Cindy James: A Life of Fear54:33 The Investigation: A Twisted Path01:02:38 The Inquest: Unraveling the Mystery01:09:23 The Unanswered Questions of Cindy James