A woman doesn’t become wicked because she stops being convenient. She said no. Set a boundary. Asked for credit. Wanted something for herself. So how did she become the villain? It’s another Season of the Witch on the Advancing Women Podcast, and this year, we’re examining the stories that turn women’s independence into a moral problem. Inspired by Practical Magic, its sequel, and the expectations women inherit across generations, Dr. Kimberly DeSimone explores three familiar “spells”: a good woman is always available; wanting power makes her suspicious; and someone else’s discomfort means she’s done something wrong. With research, Halloween humor, and a little cauldron-side clarity, we connect the witch archetype to gendered expectations at work, at home, and in our relationships. We examine the “villain edit” that supplies sinister motives for ordinary actions—and ask whether we support women’s independence when it actually requires something of us. In this episode The rules we inherit: How expectations about being a “good woman” become so familiar that we stop questioning them. The gendered history of Witch persecution: Recognizing women’s disproportionate targeting while respecting historical complexity and the people who suffered. Availability as an obligation: Why necessary but less career-advancing work so often lands on women. The villain edit: How confidence, preparation, relationships, and even kindness can be recast as evidence against a woman. Discomfort versus wrongdoing: Why someone’s disappointment doesn’t automatically make your boundary unfair. Conditional support: “Set boundaries! Just don’t limit my access.” The haunted house inside your mind:Recognizing social conditioning in the judgments we learn to anticipate. Practical solidarity: Sharing the work, crediting contributions, respecting limits, and leaving better choices for the next woman. The Key Takeaway Before we call her wicked, let’s ask what she did. And before we ask her to keep the peace, let’s ask what that peace is costing her. Sometimes, the woman we’re calling a witch is simply the one who refuses to keep living under the spell. She hasn’t cast one. She’s broken one. Research, historical sources, and further reading Babcock, L., Recalde, M. P., Vesterlund, L., & Weingart, L. (2017). Gender differences in accepting and receiving requests for tasks with low promotability. American Economic Review, 107(3), 714–747. Research on gender differences in volunteering, receiving requests, and accepting work that offers limited advancement opportunities. Read the article. Rudman, L. A., & Glick, P. (2001).Prescriptive gender stereotypes and backlash toward agentic women. Journal of Social Issues, 57(4), 743–762. Experimental research on hiring judgments and expectations of feminine niceness. Read the article. Martin, A. E., & Flynn, F. J. (2026). Behind closed doors: The uncommunal feminine stereotype. Organization Science. Further reading on suspicion of women’s motives: a theoretical article examining how expectations of public warmth can coexist with assumptions of private manipulation. Read the article. Carter, P. (2025). Work, gender and witchcraft in early modern England. Gender & History, 37(1), 91–108. Historical scholarship examining gendered work and vulnerability to witchcraft accusations; includes an overview of women’s predominance among those tried. First published online in 2023. Read the article. Massachusetts Archives. Power & persecution: Race & gender in the Salem Witch Trials. Archival context on gender, race, social expectations, and vulnerability to accusation. Explore the collection. Movies referenced Dunne, G. (Director). (1998). Practical Magic[Film]. Warner Bros. Starring Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman as Sally and Gillian Owens. Film information. Bier, S. (Director). (2026). Practical Magic 2[Film]. Warner Bros. Pictures. Official synopsis. Ortega, K. (Director). (1993). Hocus Pocus[Film]. Walt Disney Pictures. Featuring the Sanderson sisters, played by Bette Midler, Sarah Jessica Parker, and Kathy Najimy. Official film page. Keep the conversation going What inherited expectations are you ready to question? Listen, Subscribe, Connect! The Advancing Women Podcast Instagram: @AdvancingWomenPodcast Facebook: Advancing Women Podcast LinkedIn: Dr. Kimberly DeSimone Share this conversation with someone who needs the reminder that having limits is not a character flaw. Music: Joe Jacobs Podcast logo: Heather Harris