Hallmark Mysteries & More

Eric Rutin & Andrea Claassen
  • 4.6 (59)
  • TV REVIEWS
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

The podcast Sleuthers can’t stop talking about. If you love Hallmark’s cozy whodunnits, sharp sleuths, and slow-burn romances, you’ve found your new favorite podcast. Hallmark Mysteries and More is the only podcast dedicated entirely to Hallmark’s beloved mystery movies and series, including fan-favorites like Mystery 101, Aurora Teagarden, Curious Caterer, The Cases of Mystery Lane, Signed, Sealed, Delivered, and beyond. Hosted by real-life mystery buffs Andrea and Eric, each episode delivers smart, funny, and passionate deep dives into new releases and classic Hallmark mysteries. Expect honest reviews, character breakdowns, fan theories, behind-the-scenes trivia, and the kind of banter that feels like you’re sleuthing with friends. 🎥 Plus, we bring you exclusive interviews with Hallmark stars, directors, writers, and producers, giving fans rare access to the creative minds behind the mysteries. Whether you’re a longtime Sleuther or brand-new to the genre, Hallmark Mysteries and More is your weekly escape into the warm, suspenseful world of Hallmark mysteries. 🕵️‍♀️ New episodes every week. Available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube. 📱 Follow us on Instagram & TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore 🎧 Subscribe now and join thousands of mystery fans who never miss a clue. Note: This podcast is fan-created and is not affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or Hallmark Media.

  1. Star Gazing vs. Farm Chores: We Rank This Week’s Hallmark Movies!

    3D AGO

    Star Gazing vs. Farm Chores: We Rank This Week’s Hallmark Movies!

    Send a text Are you wondering if Stars Between Us or Romance at Hope Ranch should be on your weekend watchlist? Eric and Andrea dive deep into these two Hallmark features to see if they deliver the "Happily Ever After" we crave—or if they’re just plain "Meh." In this episode of Hallmark, Mysteries, and More, we get honest about the lack of chemistry in Stars Between Us, despite the stunning celestial backdrop. Then, we head over to New Mexico for Romance at Hope Ranch, where we discuss the odd timelines, the scene-stealing chicken, and whether the "Giddy Up Gala" lived up to its name. We also touch on our favorite PBS shows, the reality of daylight savings, and why the goat cheese balls at Vanderpump’s restaurant are... controversial. Don't forget to like and subscribe for more unfiltered Hallmark reviews! Video Chapters: 00:00 Intro: The Daylight Savings Struggle & Basketball Season02:03 The Vanderpump Experience: Goat Cheese Balls & "Wolf" Restaurant04:18 PBS Favorites: All Creatures Great and Small vs. Reality TV07:44 Stars Between Us (2026) Movie Review: Cosmic Connection?11:51 The "Not a Rom-Com" Critique: Lack of Chemistry & Fast Timelines14:38 Romance at Hope Ranch (2026) Movie Review: Farm Chores & Chickens17:35 The Hope Ranch Timeline Mystery: Was there a secret child?19:10 The "Underwhelming" Giddy Up Gala & Rating the Movies21:05 Final Rankings: Love-uary Movies Ranked Top to Bottom23:00 Next Week: Sugar and Vice: A Hannah Swensen MysteryFollow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    24 min
  2. Aurora Teagarden: Haunted by Murder Review

    FEB 26

    Aurora Teagarden: Haunted by Murder Review

    Send a text In this episode, we dive deep into the 2022 Hallmark classic, Aurora Teagarden Mysteries: Haunted by Murder. As the final film featuring Candace Cameron Bure in the titular role, we explore whether this "spooky" installment lived up to the hype or leaned a little too far into Scooby-Doo territory. We break down the intricate plot involving a cold case from Aurora and Sally’s teenage years, the return of the Real Murders Club, and the eerie atmosphere of the Lawrence house. Plus, we discuss the heartwarming (and fun) inclusion of Candace Cameron Bure and Lexa Doig’s real-life daughters playing their younger selves! Whether you love the supernatural vibes and the "ghost finding" subplots or you're a skeptic like Eric, we cover all the bases—from the romantic dynamics to the technical trivia behind the scenes. In this episode, we discuss: The "Haunted" atmosphere and effective use of horror tropes in a Hallmark setting.The mystery of the Lawrence house and the 30-year-old cold case.Behind-the-scenes trivia, including the reason behind Niall Matter’s rugged beard.A comparison to Murder, She Wrote and other cozy mystery staples.Chapters 00:00 – Hallmark News: Mistletoe Murders 3 & PBS Passport 04:15 – Eric’s Vegas Magic Show Adventures & The Blueberry Cereal Mystery 11:20 – Hallmark App vs. Streaming Struggles 14:45 – Aurora Teagarden: Haunted by Murder – Plot Synopsis & First Impressions 16:30 – Atmospheric Spooks: The Dolls, The Basement, & The Ghost Hunter 19:40 – The "Scooby-Doo" Critique: Is it Too Zany? 22:50 – Mystery Minute: Dissecting the Twists, The Treasure, & The Killer 26:15 – Romance Roundup: Marriage Vibes & Separate Bedrooms? 29:00 – Character Corner: Lillian Tibbett’s Time to Shine 31:10 – Hallmark Trivia: Real-Life Daughters & The 28-Stitch Beard 33:45 – Final Ratings & Recommendations Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    35 min
  3. The Way to You and Because of Cupid Rec]view

    FEB 19

    The Way to You and Because of Cupid Rec]view

    Send a text Is February 2026 the best month in Hallmark history? In today’s episode of The Way to You Podcast, Eric and Andrea dive deep into two of the biggest releases of the month: the New York City subway romance "The Way to You" and the mystical mixology of "Because of Cupid." We break down why one of these films earned a rare 5-star rating and is already being called a "Hallmark Hall of Fame" contender, while the other left us wanting more "zany" energy despite its magical premise. Whether you’re a fan of high-chemistry New York stories or you're curious if a magic love potion can actually save a movie, we’ve got the full breakdown. We also touch on our favorite past Valentine's Day classics, the "one-note" acting struggle in mystery series, and what's coming next for Aurora Teagarden. In this episode, you’ll learn: Why "The Way to You" is the gold standard for modern Rom-Coms.Our honest critique of the chemistry and plot in "Because of Cupid".Which Hallmark leads are officially in the "Upper Echelon" of acting.A sneak peek at the future of Aurora Teagarden and Hannah Swensen mysteries.Subscribe for weekly Hallmark movie reviews, mystery breakdowns, and banter! Chapters 00:00 – Intro: Is February Better Than January?01:54 – Big News: The Way Home Release Date Update03:12 – Movie Review 1: "The Way to You" (The 5-Star Masterpiece)06:14 – NYC as a Character: Subway Blackouts and Authentic Vibes10:10 – Why the Ending of "The Way to You" Actually Worked11:58 – Re-watching the Classics: The Secret Ingredient & Lost Valentine14:38 – The "Dash of Love" Debate: Does Popularity Equal Quality?16:45 – Movie Review 2: "Because of Cupid" (Love Potions & Mocktails)18:50 – Missed Opportunities: Why We Wanted More "Zany" Energy21:10 – The Highlight of the Film: Yoga Classes & Secondary Characters24:40 – Why Mocktails are the New Hallmark Trend27:54 – Looking Ahead: Aurora Teagarden: Haunted by Murder29:15 – The "One-Note" Acting Debate: Kim Matula vs. Candace Cameron Bure31:30 – Mystery Rumors: Is Curious Caterer Cancelled?33:57 – Wrap Up & Final Valentine's WishesFollow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    36 min
  4. Aurora Teagarden: The Julius House Review

    FEB 12

    Aurora Teagarden: The Julius House Review

    Send a text Is The Julius House truly the peak of the Aurora Teagarden Mysteries, or are we just blinded by nostalgia? In today’s episode, Andrea and Eric dive deep into the fourth installment of the iconic Hallmark series. We’re breaking down everything from the "shady" backgrounds in our own studios to the questionable acting choices of Candace Cameron Bure. We discuss the 12-year (or was it 4-year?) time jump, the baffling common sense of the villains, and why the Real Murders Club continues to outshine the lead characters. Plus, we debate the "1950s vibes" of the romance and find out why a certain contractor might actually be a vampire. Whether you're a die-hard Hallmark fan or just here for the snarky commentary, grab your mystery-solving hat and join us! In this episode, we discuss: The actual location of the Julius House.Yannick Bisson’s crossover into Murdoch Mysteries.The athletic prowess of Aurora in a closet fight.Why leaving bodies in a house you're trying to sell is a bad business move.The "going steady" romance milestones.Subscribe for more Hallmark mystery deep dives and honest reviews! Chapters 0:00 - The "Fake" Julius House Background 1:32 - Yannick Bisson & Murdoch Mysteries Trivia 2:54 - Private Eyes & The Diagnosis Murder Void 4:05 - The Julius House Plot & The 12-Year Discrepancy 6:45 - Rating the Movie: Is it a 3.5/5? 8:10 - Honesty Time: Candace Cameron Bure’s Acting 11:24 - Aurora’s Action Scenes & The CIA Husband 14:55 - Mystery Minute: Obvious Hints & Wigs 17:40 - The Darkest Hallmark Ending Ever? 19:15 - Why Leave the Bodies in the House? 21:50 - Romance Roundup: 25 Dates to "Go Steady" 24:35 - Character Corner: Why We Love Sally & John 27:10 - Hallmark Trivia & Hidden House Crossovers 30:20 - Final Thoughts & What's Coming Next Week Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    32 min
  5. Rescued by Love and Missing the Boat Reviews

    FEB 5

    Rescued by Love and Missing the Boat Reviews

    Send a text Andrea and Eric are back to break down the final waves of the Hallmark Channel Winter Escapes programming event! In this episode, we dive deep into the hit Missing the Boat, starring Kristoffer Polaha and Emilie Ullerup. Was the chemistry as electric as we hoped, or did this Italian cruise romance sink in the Aegean? We also discuss the surprise "mystery" rom-com Rescued by Love starring Rachael Leigh Cook and Luke Macfarlane. We also rank the entire January slate, discuss the recent news regarding Hallmark's unscripted programming, and look ahead to a massive March filled with new mysteries. Plus, stick around for our "Bold Predictions" where we discuss the potential return of fan-favorites like Garage Sale Mystery and Mystery 101. In this episode: Deep Dive Review: Missing the Boat and the Polaha/Ullerup chemistry.The Rom-Com Mystery: Our thoughts on Caught by Love with Rachael Leigh Cook and Luke Macfarlane.January Rankings: We crown the winner of the Winter Escapes month.Mystery News: Updates on Sugar and Vice and Nelly Knows Mysteries.The Future of Hallmark: Bold predictions for March 2026 and the return of legacy mystery stars.Chapters 0:00 – Intro & The "Cozie Murder" Craze 2:15 – New Mystery News: Sugar and Vice & Nelly Knows 5:50 – Hallmark’s Unscripted Programming Shift 8:45 – Review: Caught by Love (Rachael Leigh Cook & Luke Macfarlane) 14:10 – Review: Missing the Boat (Kristoffer Polaha & Emilie Ullerup) 21:30 – Ranking the Winter Escapes: From Best to Worst 25:00 – Sneak Peek: The Way to You 28:45 – Bold Predictions: The Return of Garage Sale Mystery? 33:02 – Outro Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    33 min
  6. Kristoffer Polaha Dishes on Missing the Boat, His Career, and of course, Mystery 101

    JAN 30

    Kristoffer Polaha Dishes on Missing the Boat, His Career, and of course, Mystery 101

    Send a text In this conversation, the "King of Hallmark" himself, Kristoffer Polaha, sits down to discuss his expansive career, his artistic philosophy, and the future of the fan-favorite series, Mystery 101. Kris dives deep into his approach to acting, explaining why he treats every Hallmark script with the same intensity as a Martin Scorsese film. He shares the "secret sauce" behind his on-screen chemistry with co-stars like Jill Wagner and Amelia Dell, and provides a rare look into his directorial debut with the indie thriller, Mimics. Whether you're a die-hard "Polaha-holic," a mystery buff, or an aspiring actor, this conversation offers profound insights into the entertainment industry and the importance of storytelling in a divided world. Kris also opens up about his family, his son Caleb’s rising music career, and why he views Hallmark movies as "holistic entertainment" for the soul. Key Topics Include: The status of Mystery 101 and the infamous cliffhanger.Working with Meghan Markle in Dater's Handbook.The transition from stage acting (Eugene O’Neill) to television.Behind-the-scenes stories from Jurassic World: Dominion and Wonder Woman 1984.The making of his new movie, Mimics.Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    1h 20m
  7. A Melbourne Match and Love on the Amazon

    JAN 22

    A Melbourne Match and Love on the Amazon

    Send a text Are you suffering from the winter blues? We certainly are. In this episode, Eric and Andrea sit down to escape reality and review two very different international Hallmark adventures: A Melbourne Match and Love on the Amazon. We start by discussing the current state of streaming, including rumors about Hallmark+ removing classic mystery shows and how hard it is to keep up with the changing platforms. Then, we dive into the reviews: ✈️ A Melbourne Match: We absolutely loved the chemistry between Mallory Jansen and the "Game of Thrones guy" (Ryan Corr). We discuss the refreshing lack of a "fake boyfriend" trope, the realistic conflict resolution, and why the Australian setting worked so well. 🐬 Love on the Amazon: Was this movie a dreamy escape or a slow boat ride to nowhere? Andrea rates this one a 2-star "snooze fest," admitting she zoned out halfway through. We debate the existence of "Pink Dolphins" (spoiler: they are real!), the acting style of Jaicy Elliot, and why having a satellite phone would have solved the entire conflict in five minutes. Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    26 min
  8. Love in Paradise Review

    JAN 12

    Love in Paradise Review

    Send a text Hallmark January movies are usually where joy goes to die, but  Lost in Paradise just changed the game. Hallmark stranded Lacey Chabert and Ian Harding on a tropical island in Fiji, and somehow, it resulted in the best banter I’ve heard in years! In this review, we’re breaking down why this is Hallmark’s perfect apology for years of disappointing January releases (looking at you, Love on the Right Course). We discuss the undeniable chemistry between Lacey and Ian, the surprisingly smart character writing for Sofia, and the most ridiculous "survival" details that I just couldn't stop laughing at. From the "Hallmark-style" plane crash to the pristine island fashion, find out why this movie is the perfect escape—and why we need Ian Harding in every Hallmark movie from now on. 👇 Don't miss out on the new merch! Grab your "Real Men Watch Hallmark Movies" gear and more at the official shop: https://hallmarkmysteriesandmore.com Use code JAN26 for 15% off your order! In this video: Movie: Lost in Paradise (2025)Stars: Lacey Chabert & Ian HardingSetting: Fiji (and a very clean deserted island)Verdict: A must-watch for banter lovers!Follow us on social media: Instagram and TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore Youtube Or visit our website. This podcast was created by fans for fans and is NOT affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or the Hallmark Channel.

    11 min
See All (252)

Trailer

4.6
out of 5
59 Ratings

About

The podcast Sleuthers can’t stop talking about. If you love Hallmark’s cozy whodunnits, sharp sleuths, and slow-burn romances, you’ve found your new favorite podcast. Hallmark Mysteries and More is the only podcast dedicated entirely to Hallmark’s beloved mystery movies and series, including fan-favorites like Mystery 101, Aurora Teagarden, Curious Caterer, The Cases of Mystery Lane, Signed, Sealed, Delivered, and beyond. Hosted by real-life mystery buffs Andrea and Eric, each episode delivers smart, funny, and passionate deep dives into new releases and classic Hallmark mysteries. Expect honest reviews, character breakdowns, fan theories, behind-the-scenes trivia, and the kind of banter that feels like you’re sleuthing with friends. 🎥 Plus, we bring you exclusive interviews with Hallmark stars, directors, writers, and producers, giving fans rare access to the creative minds behind the mysteries. Whether you’re a longtime Sleuther or brand-new to the genre, Hallmark Mysteries and More is your weekly escape into the warm, suspenseful world of Hallmark mysteries. 🕵️‍♀️ New episodes every week. Available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube. 📱 Follow us on Instagram & TikTok: @hallmarkmysteriesandmore 🎧 Subscribe now and join thousands of mystery fans who never miss a clue. Note: This podcast is fan-created and is not affiliated with or sponsored by Hallmark or Hallmark Media.

Information

  • Creator
    Eric Rutin & Andrea Claassen
  • Years Active
    2023 - 2026
  • Episodes
    252
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 Hallmark Mysteries & More
  • Show Website
    Hallmark Mysteries & More

You Might Also Like