The Missing Middle Podcast

Cara Stern, Mike Moffatt, and Meredith Martin

Welcome to the Missing Middle, a podcast about why the middle class in Canada is disappearing. We hope to help you understand why life is becoming unaffordable for so many in this country, and what can be done to reverse course.

  1. 21h ago

    Are “Safe” University Degrees Actually the Riskiest Choice?

    Are young Canadians really choosing “useless” degrees, or is playing it safe the biggest risk of all? In this episode of DemograFix, Cara Stern and Mike Moffatt dig into why recent university graduates are struggling to find work, even though more students than ever are studying so-called practical fields. They look at the numbers behind the youth job crunch, from unemployment among young bachelor’s degree holders at levels not seen since the early nineties (outside the pandemic), to nearly five unemployed people for every job posting that requires a degree. And they unpack why the share of degrees in health sciences, engineering, business and computer science has climbed from 42 percent to more than 60 percent since the early 1990s. They also explore how high housing costs and grade-driven admissions push students to avoid risk, why the trades aren’t the guaranteed safe bet they’re made out to be, and why funnelling a whole generation into the same handful of majors, some of them now among the most exposed to AI, makes the job market more fragile. So what if the pressure to play it safe is actually the riskiest move of all? And how do we give young people permission to explore? Chapters: 00:00 - What If Playing It Safe Is the Real Risk? 00:39 - The Grim Job Numbers for Young Grads 04:21 - Blame Boomers, Not Gen Z, for the “Useless Degree” Myth 02:22 - “Practical” Degrees Went From 42% to 60% 03:18 - Are the Trades Really the Safe Bet? 06:11 - Why Nobody Can Afford to Explore 07:26 - Grades, Scholarships and the Fear of Failing 10:48 - The Weightlifting School That Skipped Leg Day 13:15 - Learn to Code? The “Safe” Majors Most Exposed to AI 14:47 - How Do We Fix It? 16:26 -  Risk aversion is rational Research/links: Ford tells students to not pick 'basket-weaving courses' in wake of OSAP cuts https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/doug-ford-osap-cuts-9.7094009 Pushed to pursue safe degrees, students are shunning the humanities. At what cost? https://www.theglobeandmail.com/investing/personal-finance/article-university-degrees-humanities-business-engineering-youth-employment/ DeSantis is taking aim at ‘zombie studies’ on the campaign trail. It’s a real thing https://www.cnbc.com/2023/09/06/desantis-is-talking-about-zombie-studies-on-the-campaign-trail.html Credits: Mike Moffatt https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt https://bsky.app/profile/mikepmoffatt.bsky.social Cara Stern https://x.com/carastern https://bsky.app/profile/carastern.bsky.social Meredith Martin https://twitter.com/meredithmartin https://bsky.app/profile/meredithmartin.bsky.social Sean Foreman @seanegertonforeman https://bsky.app/profile/seanforeman.bsky.social Canadian Civil youtube.com/CanadianCivil Co-op Student Francis Gabriel Carmona linkedin.com/in/francisgabrielcarmona/ Hosted by Mike Moffatt & Cara Stern & Sabrina Maddeaux Produced by Meredith Martin Edited by Sean Foreman and Canadian Civil

    Are “Safe” University Degrees Actually the Riskiest Choice?
  2. 2d ago

    Carney’s Immigration Numbers Don't Add Up. Here's Why

    At first glance, Ottawa’s latest immigration plan looks steady and predictable. Look closer, however, and you’ll find a masterclass in creative accounting that hides the real numbers from Canadians. In this episode of Classonomics, Sabrina Maddeaux and Mike Moffatt dig into the numbers behind the headline target, including one-time conversion measures that could push actual permanent resident admissions to an estimated 660,000 next year. They examine why immigration targets can be misleading, how temporary foreign worker rules are changing amid 6.7% unemployment, and what it all means for housing affordability, infrastructure capacity, and young Canadians struggling to find work.  Plus, they discuss Andrew Coyne’s take on Canada’s immigration debate and what gets lost when the politics overshadow the numbers. Chapters: 00:00 The Hidden Numbers in Canada’s New Immigration Plan 00:55 Why Carney’s Immigration Math Is Like a Jackson Pollock Painting 01:44 The "One-Time" Loophole Pushing PR Numbers to 660,000 04:16 Breaking the 1% Cap & Long-Term Infrastructure Promises 05:29 The "They’re Already Here" Defence: Why Net Population Still Grows 08:08 The 5% Temporary Resident Target "Accounting Trick" 09:45 Fact-Checking Andrew Coyne’s Globe and Mail Column 14:11 Who Actually Pays the Price for Unplanned Population Growth? 17:34 Ottawa Loosens Temporary Foreign Worker Rules Amid 6.7% Unemployment 21:09 How to Fix Canada’s Immigration & TFW System 23:15 Final Thoughts: Transparency, Trust & Creative Accounting Research/links: Sabrina Maddeaux: Carney’s immigration accounting is so creative, it should qualify for the new artist tax break (National Post) The real immigration ‘fib’? Far fewer migrants are entering Canada than official figures say (The Globe and Mail) Canadian public opinion about immigration and refugees – Fall 2025 (Environics Institute) Longer stays, new exemptions in foreign worker overhaul (CTV News) New Immigration Levels Plan adds upside to population growth outlook (RBC Economics) Report Of The Bank of Canada on Monetary Policy; Mark Carney, April 23, 2013, 09:25:37 Hosted by Mike Moffatt & Cara Stern & Sabrina Maddeaux Produced by Meredith Martin Edited by Sean Foreman and Canadian Civil

    Carney’s Immigration Numbers Don't Add Up. Here's Why
  3. Nov 13

    Why Toronto Settles for Mediocre Transit | Not Just Bikes

    Toronto’s new LRT lines have large, clean, accessible stations. So why are they so slow? In this episode of DemograFix, Cara Stern talks to Jason Slaughter, creator of the YouTube channel Not Just Bikes, about how Toronto’s new Finch West and Eglinton Crosstown LRTs compare with light rail in Copenhagen, Amsterdam and even Kitchener-Waterloo. They discuss who’s to blame for the slow trains, why LRTs crawl through intersections, and what real transit signal priority looks like compared with Toronto’s half version. We also look at why Kitchener-Waterloo’s ION runs the same trains so much better, why Toronto squanders a streetcar network other cities would kill for, why Canadians don’t complain more about mediocre transit, and Ontario’s bike lane law. Plus: does Jason worry that people will think he just hates North America? Chapters: 00:00 Introduction 00:55 How Toronto's LRTs compare 03:21 Whose fault: Metrolinx or the TTC 05:20 Why LRTs slow down at intersections 08:55 What signal priority is 10:52 Toronto's half version of signal priority 15:58 The cost of retrofitting 17:45 Kitchener-Waterloo's ION runs better 19:19 Streetcars and subway slow zones 23:55 Why transit riders don't complain 27:27 Ontario's bike lane law 30:49 The suburban vote and driving downtown 35:12 Too negative about North America 38:50 How people get into urbanism Research/links: Jason Slaughter, Not Just Bikes How can a NEW Transit Line be THIS BAD!? (Finch West LRT) This Small City’s LRT is so Good it Made me Angry North America Will Never Be the Netherlands - Interview with Not Just Bikes They Finally Built Good Transit!? Credits: Mike Moffatt https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt https://bsky.app/profile/mikepmoffatt.bsky.social Cara Stern https://x.com/carastern https://bsky.app/profile/carastern.bsky.social Meredith Martin https://twitter.com/meredithmartin https://bsky.app/profile/meredithmartin.bsky.social Sean Foreman @seanegertonforeman https://bsky.app/profile/seanforeman.bsky.social Canadian Civil youtube.com/CanadianCivil Co-op Student Francis Gabriel Carmona linkedin.com/in/francisgabrielcarmona/ Hosted by Mike Moffatt & Cara Stern & Sabrina Maddeaux Produced by Meredith Martin Edited by Sean Foreman and Canadian Civil

    Why Toronto Settles for Mediocre Transit | Not Just Bikes
  4. Nov 11

    How Every Gift Card Is an Interest-Free Loan to a Corporation

    Gift cards might feel like free money or a clever budget hack, but they are really interest-free loans to stores that make billions in profit when you forget to spend them. In this episode of Classonomics, Sabrina Maddeaux and Mike Moffatt break down whether holiday gift card deals and self-budgeting hacks actually save Canadians money or simply hand retailers interest-free loans, how corporate balance sheets turn billions in forgotten balances and "breakage" into pure profit, the mechanics of why the Starbucks app holds more customer deposits than a typical community bank, what happened when Hudson's Bay’s creditor protection left shoppers as empty-handed unsecured creditors, and why the behavioural psychology of "treat money," friction, and inflation makes holding onto gift cards a losing financial bet. Chapters: 00:00 - Every Gift Card Is a Loan 00:55 - How Much Canadians Spend on Gift Cards 02:09 - Why People Buy Gift Cards for Themselves 04:27 - Accounting 101: Your Gift Card Is the Store's Debt 05:30 - Breakage: How Forgotten Balances Become Profit 07:34 - The Bank of Starbucks 11:37 - The $27 Billion Junk Drawer 12:29 - Why We Don't Spend Our Gift Cards 15:02 - Mall Cards, Visa Cards & Other Friction Traps 16:51 - Gift Cards vs. Inflation 17:54 - Are Gift Card Deals Actually a Good Deal? 19:12 - Why Parking Money on a Card Costs You 20:39 - Hudson's Bay: When Your Gift Card Becomes Worthless 21:49 - What Protections Do Canadians Have? 23:11 - Who Really Wins Gift Card Season Links/Research: Retail Council of Canada Reports on Holiday Spending  Canadians Keep Gift Spending Steady — and Push Deal-Hunting to New Heights - Retail Council of Canada  Canada Gift Card Business Report 2026: An $11.18 Billion  With Their Eyes on Affordability, Consumers Increasingly Gift Themselves, Blackhawk Finds – Digital Transactions  Gift Cards and Mental Accounting: Green‐lighting Hedonic Spending - Helion - 2014 - Journal of Behavioral Decision Making - Wiley Online Library  While Most (72%) Canadians Give and Receive Gift Cards Each Year, Many Are Tossing Away Cash by Not Using Card's Full Value | Ipsos  https://sherwood.news/business/starbucks-could-use-a-cio-to-invest-the-usd2-2b-float-from-its-rewards/  https://thedailyeconomy.org/article/your-starbucks-balance-is-working-harder-than-you-think/  https://www.bankrate.com/f/102997/x/c53caa68d4/gift-card-survey-press-release.pdf  Hosted by Mike Moffatt & Cara Stern & Sabrina Maddeaux Produced by Meredith Martin Edited by Sean Foreman and Canadian Civil

    How Every Gift Card Is an Interest-Free Loan to a Corporation
  5. Nov 6

    Is It Time to Abolish Property Tax Deferrals?

    Are property tax deferral programs really helping struggling seniors, or are they subsidizing wealthy homeowners at everyone else's expense? In this episode of DemograFix, Cara Stern and Mike Moffatt unpack the hidden costs of senior property tax deferrals and why these well-intentioned programs may be making housing affordability worse for younger generations. They explore how property tax breaks can become low-interest loans for multimillion-dollar homeowners, why some of the seniors most vulnerable to poverty don't qualify for these benefits, and how taxpayers end up footing the bill through higher property taxes and reduced municipal services. They also dig into British Columbia's controversial program, where homeowners with multimillion-dollar properties could defer their entire property tax bill at heavily discounted interest rates, effectively turning a senior benefit into an investment opportunity for the wealthy. So who really benefits from these programs? And why are governments subsidizing homeowners to stay in expensive family-sized houses while young families struggle to find homes they can afford? Chapters: 00:00 - The Boomer Tax Break Bankrolled by Young Renters 01:45 - "House Rich, Cash Poor" is Just an Excuse 03:59 - The Hidden Incoherence Killing Family Neighborhoods 06:19 - B.C.’s Multi-Millionaire Tax Deferral Loophole 08:49 - Reverse Robin Hood: The Big Wealth Transfer 11:56 - Why Politicians Are Terrified to Fix This 14:13 - Real Solutions vs. The Downsizing Trap 18:50 - How to Expose the True Cost to Voters Research/links: How B.C.'s property tax system delivers big benefits to multimillionaires, and why some say it needs to change How a Tax Break for Struggling Seniors Became a Billionaire Subsidy Low income statistics by age, gender and economic family type Underused Ontario schools could be sold by Ford government for housing in new education bill Credits: Mike Moffatt  https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt https://bsky.app/profile/mikepmoffatt.bsky.social Cara Stern  https://x.com/carastern https://bsky.app/profile/carastern.bsky.social Meredith Martin  https://twitter.com/meredithmartin https://bsky.app/profile/meredithmartin.bsky.social Sean Foreman @seanegertonforeman https://bsky.app/profile/seanforeman.bsky.social Canadian Civil youtube.com/CanadianCivil University Of Ottawa Co-op Student Francis Gabriel Carmona, https://www.linkedin.com/in/francisgabrielcarmona/ Hosted by Mike Moffatt & Cara Stern & Sabrina Maddeaux Produced by Meredith Martin Edited by Sean Foreman and Canadian Civil

    Is It Time to Abolish Property Tax Deferrals?
  6. Nov 4

    Is Alberta Killing Its Housing Advantage? | Interview with Millennial Moron

    Can Alberta keep its title as Canada's housing affordability champion, or is it about to become its own worst enemy? In this episode of Classonomics, Mike Moffatt and Millennial Moron dig into Alberta's growing housing battles. Why is Danielle Smith stepping in to overrule municipal zoning decisions in Calgary and Edmonton? How did the humble eightplex become a controversial, compromise-filled housing option? And why can it take years of red tape, parking rules and neighbourhood opposition to get new homes built? From the politics of infill to the hidden costs of endless approval delays, we explore what's standing in the way of more housing, and whether Alberta is putting its biggest affordability advantage at risk Is Alberta showing the rest of Canada how to build more homes, or how to get in its own way? Chapters: 00:00 - Alberta's Housing Model Under Pressure 03:36 - Construction Timelines: Alberta vs. Ontario 06:29 - Why Edmonton’s Infill Reforms Sparked Provincial Pushback 09:14 - The Flawed Design of Modern Multiplexes 11:43 - The Political Contradictions of Housing Deregulation 14:41 - Neighborhood Pushback & The Myth of Suburb Capacity 20:04 - Immigration, Housing Crises & Federal CMHC Loans 23:28 - Calgary’s Office-to-Residential Conversion Playbook 26:43 - How to Fix Community Engagement for Better Housing 31:07 - Danielle Smith and the Battle Over Parking Minimums 33:38 - Presumptive Upzoning: A Market-Based Solution 36:40 - Canadian Real Estate Listings vs. European Castles 40:35 - An Applied Math Approach to the Housing Bubble  Research: 2025 Provincial HOMES Report Card https://www.missingmiddleinitiative.ca/p/2025-provincial-homes-report-card Millennial Moron https://www.youtube.com/@MillennialMoron Hosted by Mike Moffatt & Cara Stern & Sabrina Maddeaux Produced by Meredith Martin Edited by Sean Foreman and Canadian Civil

    Is Alberta Killing Its Housing Advantage? | Interview with Millennial Moron
  7. Oct 30

    Parking Is Ruining Our Cities. Here’s Why | Henry Grabar

    Why is housing so expensive? Parking might be part of the answer. In this episode of DemograFix, Cara Stern talks to Henry Grabar, author of Paved Paradise: How Parking Explains the World, about how parking minimums, parking costs and car dependency have shaped our cities and made housing more expensive. We discuss why developers build so much parking, how parking requirements can delay or block new housing, what happens when cities eliminate parking minimums, and whether making parking harder is actually a good way to get people out of their cars. Plus: why are there at least three parking spaces for every car in America? Pick up Henry's book, Paved Paradise: How Parking Explains the World, wherever you get your books. #Parking #Housing #urbanplanning  Chapters: 00:00 Parking vs. Housing: The Real Cost 01:28 The "Free Parking" Fallacy 03:18 Ridiculous Zoning Laws 05:15 How Parking Drives Up Your Rent 07:58 Why SimCity Left Out Parking 11:09 Why NIMBYs Fight New Housing 15:33 Why Carrots Don't Work on Drivers 18:33 The Dark Side of Parking Fines 20:29 How Parking Kills Small Towns 24:43 Why American Cities Look Empty Research/links: Paved Paradise http://www.penguinrandomhouse.ca/books/634461/paved-paradise-by-henry-grabar/9781984881151 Henry Grabar https://www.henrygrabar.com/ Not-So-Free Parking https://www.harvardmagazine.com/2023/08/paved-paradise-grabar America, Land of the Free Parking https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/10/books/review/paved-paradise-henry-grabar.html The Edmonton Exception https://2067journal.ca/the-edmonton-exception/ Credits: Mike Moffatt  https://twitter.com/MikePMoffatt https://bsky.app/profile/mikepmoffatt.bsky.social Cara Stern  https://x.com/carastern https://bsky.app/profile/carastern.bsky.social Meredith Martin  https://twitter.com/meredithmartin https://bsky.app/profile/meredithmartin.bsky.social Sean Foreman @seanegertonforeman https://bsky.app/profile/seanforeman.bsky.social Canadian Civil youtube.com/CanadianCivil Co-op Student Francis Gabriel Carmona Hosted by Mike Moffatt & Cara Stern & Sabrina Maddeaux Produced by Meredith Martin Edited by Sean Foreman and Canadian Civil

    Parking Is Ruining Our Cities. Here’s Why | Henry Grabar

Ratings & Reviews

4.2
out of 5
5 Ratings

About

Welcome to the Missing Middle, a podcast about why the middle class in Canada is disappearing. We hope to help you understand why life is becoming unaffordable for so many in this country, and what can be done to reverse course.

You Might Also Like