Episode 58: Defending Education, et al. v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al. Defending Education, et al. v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al., argued before Judges Scott M. Matheson, Jr., Allison H. Eid, and Kelly Harrison Rankin (Chief U.S. District Judge, sitting by designation) of the United States Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit on November 16, 2026. Argued together with Doxa Enterprises, LTD d/b/a Born Again Used Books v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al., and Committee of Five, Inc. d/b/a XX-XY Athletics, v. Aubrey C. Sullivan, et al. Argued by Paul Draper (on behalf of Defending Education), Chris Schandevel (on behalf of XX/XY Athletics and Born Again Used Books) and Janna K. Fischer (on behalf of the Colorado Civil Rights Division and all defendants). Case Summary, from the Institute for Free Speech website: Gender ideology and pronoun use are among the most contentious cultural and political debates of the day. But the First Amendment protects your right to participate in that debate, no matter which side you’re on. Colorado’s new anti-discrimination law compels speech by forcing speakers to express a message they don’t believe in by using pronouns (and other gendered language) to prevent individuals from feeling “unwelcome.” That’s why the Institute for Free Speech filed amicus briefs in three related cases before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit. In the law, the state advances its own viewpoint by mandating use of non-standard pronouns and forbidding other perspectives. As IFS’s brief states, “No government can police language to allow messages it likes, while prohibiting those it disapproves—even when the language might ‘provoke[e] offense and condemnation.’” Issues Presented, from the Appellant Opening Brief: CADA as amended by H.B. 25-1312 arguably prohibits Plaintiffs’ speech, Defendants have not disavowed enforcement, and Defendants have used CADA to punish similar speech in the past. Do Plaintiffs have standing? In the district court, Defendants declined to respond to Plaintiffs’ arguments regarding CADA’s constitutionality, so they have forfeited the merits. Thus, if the Court agrees that Plaintiffs likely have standing, should it grant a preliminary injunction? Alternatively, this Court can resolve the merits itself because CADA’s constitutionality presents a pure legal question and Colorado has declined to satisfy its burden to establish the law’s constitutionality. Does CADA likely violate the First and Fourteenth Amendments because it compels speech, discriminates based on content and viewpoint, is overbroad, and is vague? In First Amendment cases, the likelihood of success on the merits is usually the determinative factor. Do the remaining preliminary-injunction factors favor an injunction because Plaintiffs likely have standing and Defendants have forfeited the merits?Resources: Appellant Opening Brief CourtListener Docket Institute for Free Speech amicus brief Institute for Free Speech press release The Institute for Free Speech promotes and defends the political speech rights to freely speak, assemble, publish, and petition the government guaranteed by the First Amendment. If you’re enjoying the Free Speech Arguments podcast, please subscribe and leave a review on your preferred podcast platform.