All The Damn Crime

John and Joel
  • 4.7 (10)
  • True Crime
  • Updated Weekly

Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, and the unsolved. Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker, the show blends sharp storytelling with real investigative insight. Together, they break down cases from every angle. Each week we explore missing persons, cold cases, serial crimes, controversial investigations, and bizarre true crime stories from around the world. Some cases are solved, some remain mysteries, and some defy explanation entirely. Deep-dive true crime with smart-ish conversation, dark stories, and gallows humor. New episodes every week. Maura Murray, JonBenét Ramsey, Madeleine McCann, Zodiac Killer, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, John Wayne Gacy, BTK Killer (Dennis Rader), Golden State Killer (Joseph DeAngelo), West Memphis Three, O.J. Simpson case, Delphi murders, Idaho student murders, Gabby Petito, Chris Watts family murders, D.B. Cooper, Jonestown massacre, Black Dahlia murder, Laci Peterson case, Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) 

  1. 7h ago

    The Sirloin Stockade Massacre: Oklahoma’s Night of Terror

    Send us Fan Mail This week on All the Damn Crime, we're going back to Oklahoma in 1978 for one of the state's most infamous murder cases: the Sirloin Stockade murders. Roger Dale Stafford, his wife Verna, and his brother Harold robbed a Sirloin Stockade in Oklahoma City and murdered six employees as the restaurant was closing for the night. But that wasn't the beginning of the story. Just weeks earlier, the Lorenz family had been murdered after stopping to help a stranded motorist on Interstate 35. Nine people were dead. And for months, investigators didn't know the two crimes were connected. We break down what happened, how investigators finally connected the cases, the Stafford family, and the evidence that brought the killers to justice. And we'll talk about the case's renewed attention in 2026 after Verna Stafford, the last surviving perpetrator, sought parole. This is one of those Oklahoma cases that sounds almost unbelievable—until you realize it actually happened. Sirloin Stockade murders, Sirloin Stockade massacre, Sirloin Stockade Oklahoma, Oklahoma City murders 1978, Roger Dale Stafford, Verna Stafford, Harold Stafford, Roger Stafford murders, Oklahoma true crime, Oklahoma serial killer, Oklahoma mass murder, Sirloin Stockade killings, six Sirloin Stockade employees, Lorenz family murders, Melvin Lorenz, Linda Lorenz, Richard Lorenz, Oklahoma City true crime, 1978 Oklahoma murders, Oklahoma cold cases, Oklahoma murder cases, Sirloin Stockade freezer murders, Stafford family murders, Roger Stafford execution, Verna Stafford parole, Oklahoma death row, Oklahoma mass shooting history, famous Oklahoma murders, true crime podcast Oklahoma, All the Damn Crime

    The Sirloin Stockade Massacre: Oklahoma’s Night of Terror

  2. 6d ago

    Christa Pike: Days From Death Row

    Send us Fan Mail This week on All the Damn Crime, we're talking about Christa Pike, the only woman currently on Tennessee's death row, whose execution is scheduled for September 30, 2026. Pike was sentenced to death for the 1995 murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slemmer when Pike was 18. If carried out, it would be Tennessee's first execution of a woman in more than 200 years.  We break down Pike's crime, her decades on death row, her recent legal challenges and clemency request, and what's happening as her execution date approaches. Then we turn to Bryan Kohberger, who is attempting to withdraw his guilty plea in the University of Idaho murders, and revisit the infamous Slender Man stabbing, in which two 12-year-old girls lured their classmate into a Wisconsin park and stabbed her in 2014. Three very different cases—and plenty to talk about.  Christa Pike, Christa Pike execution, Christa Pike execution date, Christa Pike September 30 2026, Christa Pike death row, Christa Pike Colleen Slemmer, Christa Pike case, Christa Pike murder, Tennessee death row woman, Tennessee execution 2026, Christa Pike latest news, Christa Pike clemency, Bryan Kohberger, Bryan Kohberger latest, Bryan Kohberger guilty plea, Bryan Kohberger Idaho murders, Bryan Kohberger plea withdrawal, Bryan Kohberger appeal, University of Idaho murders, Idaho 4 murders, Slender Man stabbing, Slender Man attempted murder, Slender Man case, Slender Man girls, Payton Leutner, Morgan Geyser, Anissa Weier, Slender Man true crime, internet inspired crimes, true crime podcast, All the Damn Crime

    Christa Pike: Days From Death Row

  3. Sep 8

    Mica Miller: The Death of the Pastor’s Wife

    Send us Fan Mail Netflix's Death of the Pastor's Wife has brought the story of Mica Miller back into the national spotlight. This week, we take a closer look at the documentary and the complicated story behind it. Mica died in April 2024 from a self-inflicted gunshot wound, but her death came after a turbulent marriage and separation from pastor John-Paul Miller. Friends and family interviewed in the documentary describe allegations of controlling and abusive behavior, while prosecutors have separately accused John-Paul of cyberstalking Mica before her death. He has pleaded not guilty.  What did the documentary uncover? What questions remain? And how much can we actually know about what happened during Mica's final months? Mica Miller documentary, Death of the Pastor's Wife, Netflix Mica Miller, Mica Miller Netflix documentary, Mica Miller case, what happened to Mica Miller, Mica Miller death, Mica Miller suicide, John Paul Miller, Mica Francis Miller, pastor John Paul Miller, Mica Miller investigation, Mica Miller controversy, Mica Miller allegations, Mica Miller stalking case, Solid Rock Church Mica Miller, Myrtle Beach true crime, Lumber River State Park, North Carolina true crime, Mica Miller documentary 2026, Netflix true crime documentary, Death of the Pastor's Wife review, Mica Miller story, Mica Miller timeline, true crime podcast, All the Damn Crime, pastor wife death, Mica Miller mystery, John Paul Miller indictment, Mica Miller case explained

    Mica Miller: The Death of the Pastor’s Wife

  4. Sep 1

    A Deadly Family Dinner and Oregon's Quintuple Homicide

    Send us Fan Mail This week on All the Damn Crime, we're covering two breaking stories involving devastating acts of violence against families. First, we head to Montana, where 44-year-old Alan Michael Smith allegedly opened fire on his own family during a gathering near Billings, killing eight relatives—including four children—before dying from a self-inflicted gunshot wound. Smith had reportedly been asked to leave his parents' home weeks earlier, but authorities have not established that as a motive.  Then we turn to Oregon, where authorities say Benjamin Parker allegedly killed his girlfriend, members of her family, and friends in a quintuple homicide before fleeing to Washington, where he was found dead from an apparent self-inflicted gunshot wound. Investigators say Parker had recently been involved in a serious fight with his girlfriend and had been told to leave the property.  And because no episode of All the Damn Crime stays in one lane, we'll also discuss some true crime-adjacent stories, including the horrific crimes of Ronald Gene Simmons and the bizarre and infamous Enumclaw horse case.  Alan Michael Smith, Alan Smith Montana, Montana family massacre, Billings Montana shooting, Montana mass shooting 2026, Montana family shooting, Montana family murders, White Star Circle shooting, Alan Smith shooting, Montana mass murder, eight family members killed, four children killed Montana, family massacre, family annihilator, Ronald Gene Simmons, Ronald Gene Simmons murders, Ronald Gene Simmons family massacre, Arkansas family massacre, Ronald Simmons Christmas massacre, Enumclaw horse case, Enumclaw Washington, Enumclaw incident, Mr Hands case, Benjamin Parker, Benjamin Parker Oregon, Oregon quintuple homicide, Oregon family murders, Forest Grove Oregon shooting, Stella Kimsey, true crime podcast, All the Damn Crime

    A Deadly Family Dinner and Oregon's Quintuple Homicide

  5. Aug 24

    The Happiest Littlest Hobo on Death Row: The Tragic Story of Joe Arridy

    Send us Fan Mail Joe Arridy was 23 years old when Colorado executed him for a murder he almost certainly did not commit. Arridy had an intellectual disability and was highly suggestible. Police obtained a confession implicating him in the rape and murder of 15-year-old Dorothy Drain, but evidence later showed serious problems with the confession and with the prosecution's case.  Even as his execution approached, Arridy's attorneys fought desperately to stop it. He received nine stays of execution before finally being killed in the gas chamber on January 6, 1939. More than seven decades later, he was pardoned by the governor of Colorado. It's a heartbreaking story about false confessions, the death penalty, and what happens when the justice system gets it catastrophically wrong. Joe Arridy, happiest man on death row, Joe Arridy execution, Colorado gas chamber, Joe Arridy confession, false confession, Dorothy Drain, Joe Arridy innocence, wrongful execution, death row innocent man, intellectual disability death penalty, Colorado murder, Pueblo murder, 1939 execution, death penalty history, wrongful conviction case, true crime history, true crime podcast, criminal justice failure, coerced confession, innocent people executed, American death penalty, historic wrongful convictions, law and crime podcast, real crime stories, Colorado true crime, murder trial history, Joe Arridy pardon, death row stories, criminal justice reform

    The Happiest Littlest Hobo on Death Row: The Tragic Story of Joe Arridy

  6. Aug 16

    The Godfather of Our Collective True Crime Obsession: The Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan Poe

    Send us Fan Mail Edgar Allan Poe spent his career writing about murder, madness, mysterious deaths, and detectives searching for answers. Then, in 1849, Poe himself became the subject of a mystery no detective has ever solved. He disappeared during a trip to Baltimore and resurfaced days later in a state of severe distress. He was taken to a hospital, where his condition deteriorated. His doctors couldn't establish a clear cause of death, and Poe never provided a coherent explanation of what happened to him. One of the most intriguing theories is cooping, a form of 19th-century election fraud in which people could be kidnapped, intoxicated, beaten, disguised, and forced to vote repeatedly. Poe was found on Election Day near a polling place—a coincidence that has fueled the theory for generations.  Edgar Allan Poe, Edgar Allan Poe death, Edgar Allan Poe murder, who killed Edgar Allan Poe, Poe death mystery, Edgar Allan Poe mystery, Edgar Allan Poe theories, Poe was murdered, Edgar Allan Poe Baltimore, Edgar Allan Poe 1849, Poe final days, Edgar Allan Poe cooping, cooping theory Poe, Poe Election Day, Edgar Allan Poe cause of death, Poe unsolved mystery, Edgar Allan Poe true crime, Edgar Allan Poe conspiracy, mysterious death of Edgar Allan Poe, Edgar Allan Poe missing days, Poe Baltimore mystery, Edgar Allan Poe hospital, John Moran Poe, Gunner's Hall Poe, Edgar Allan Poe death theories, Poe murder theory, Edgar Allan Poe cold case, famous unsolved mysteries, literary mysteries, true crime podcast

    The Godfather of Our Collective True Crime Obsession: The Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan Poe

  7. Aug 10

    The Serial Killer Cop?

    Send us Fan Mail  James Aren Duckett was convicted of one horrific murder—but investigators believed there may have been more. After Teresa McAbee was found dead in 1987, evidence led police to the officer who had been the last person seen with her. Duckett was convicted and sentenced to death, while investigators later connected him to the deaths of other women and girls. He was never charged in those additional cases, leaving a disturbing question: How many victims could James Aren Duckett have had? We examine the evidence, the unanswered questions, and the case of a police officer who became a convicted murderer—and a suspected serial killer.  James Duckett execution, James Aren Duckett death row, James Duckett 2026, Teresa McAbee murder, Florida death row inmate, police officer death row, death penalty Florida, DNA testing death penalty, inconclusive DNA results, James Duckett innocence claim, Florida true crime, former cop murderer, child murder case, suspected serial killer, Jeanifer Weldon, Florida cold case, true crime podcast, murder investigation, criminal justice, death penalty controversy

    The Serial Killer Cop?

  8. Jul 26

    The Yorkshire Witch and The Prophetic Chicken

    Send us Fan Mail Long before modern scams, Mary Bateman mastered the art of deception. Claiming supernatural powers, she manipulated families into believing their lives depended on her rituals and remedies. What followed was a trail of fraud, forged documents, and murder by poison that made her one of England's most infamous criminals. This episode dives into the myths, the murders, and the truth behind the Yorkshire Witch.  Original Yorkshire Witch, Mary Bateman case, Yorkshire Witch murders, poison killings, historical fraud, English criminal history, fake psychic, fortune teller murder, arsenic killer, Leeds true crime, British crime stories, historical true crime podcast, murder mystery, criminal deception, law and crime podcast, female serial killer, poison case, historical murders, notorious women, dark history, podcast discovery, British justice history, execution history, real crime stories, criminal psychology, Victorian crimes, England murder case, historical investigation, crime podcast, famous poisoners

    The Yorkshire Witch and The Prophetic Chicken
See All (89)

4.7
out of 5
10 Ratings

About

Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, and the unsolved. Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker, the show blends sharp storytelling with real investigative insight. Together, they break down cases from every angle. Each week we explore missing persons, cold cases, serial crimes, controversial investigations, and bizarre true crime stories from around the world. Some cases are solved, some remain mysteries, and some defy explanation entirely. Deep-dive true crime with smart-ish conversation, dark stories, and gallows humor. New episodes every week. Maura Murray, JonBenét Ramsey, Madeleine McCann, Zodiac Killer, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, John Wayne Gacy, BTK Killer (Dennis Rader), Golden State Killer (Joseph DeAngelo), West Memphis Three, O.J. Simpson case, Delphi murders, Idaho student murders, Gabby Petito, Chris Watts family murders, D.B. Cooper, Jonestown massacre, Black Dahlia murder, Laci Peterson case, Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) 

Information

  • Creator
    John and Joel
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2026
  • Episodes
    89
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 All The Damn Crime
  • Show Website
    All The Damn Crime

You Might Also Like