All The Damn Crime

John and Joel

Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, and the unsolved. Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker, the show blends sharp storytelling with real investigative insight. Together, they break down cases from every angle. Each week we explore missing persons, cold cases, serial crimes, controversial investigations, and bizarre true crime stories from around the world. Some cases are solved, some remain mysteries, and some defy explanation entirely. Deep-dive true crime with smart-ish conversation, dark stories, and gallows humor. New episodes every week. Maura Murray, JonBenét Ramsey, Madeleine McCann, Zodiac Killer, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, John Wayne Gacy, BTK Killer (Dennis Rader), Golden State Killer (Joseph DeAngelo), West Memphis Three, O.J. Simpson case, Delphi murders, Idaho student murders, Gabby Petito, Chris Watts family murders, D.B. Cooper, Jonestown massacre, Black Dahlia murder, Laci Peterson case, Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) 

  1. 10h ago

    The Godfather of Our Collective True Crime Obsession: The Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan Poe

    Send us Fan Mail Edgar Allan Poe spent his career writing about murder, madness, mysterious deaths, and detectives searching for answers. Then, in 1849, Poe himself became the subject of a mystery no detective has ever solved. He disappeared during a trip to Baltimore and resurfaced days later in a state of severe distress. He was taken to a hospital, where his condition deteriorated. His doctors couldn't establish a clear cause of death, and Poe never provided a coherent explanation of what happened to him. One of the most intriguing theories is cooping, a form of 19th-century election fraud in which people could be kidnapped, intoxicated, beaten, disguised, and forced to vote repeatedly. Poe was found on Election Day near a polling place—a coincidence that has fueled the theory for generations.  Edgar Allan Poe, Edgar Allan Poe death, Edgar Allan Poe murder, who killed Edgar Allan Poe, Poe death mystery, Edgar Allan Poe mystery, Edgar Allan Poe theories, Poe was murdered, Edgar Allan Poe Baltimore, Edgar Allan Poe 1849, Poe final days, Edgar Allan Poe cooping, cooping theory Poe, Poe Election Day, Edgar Allan Poe cause of death, Poe unsolved mystery, Edgar Allan Poe true crime, Edgar Allan Poe conspiracy, mysterious death of Edgar Allan Poe, Edgar Allan Poe missing days, Poe Baltimore mystery, Edgar Allan Poe hospital, John Moran Poe, Gunner's Hall Poe, Edgar Allan Poe death theories, Poe murder theory, Edgar Allan Poe cold case, famous unsolved mysteries, literary mysteries, true crime podcast

    The Godfather of Our Collective True Crime Obsession: The Mysterious Death of Edgar Allan Poe

  2. 5d ago

    The Serial Killer Cop?

    Send us Fan Mail  James Aren Duckett was convicted of one horrific murder—but investigators believed there may have been more. After Teresa McAbee was found dead in 1987, evidence led police to the officer who had been the last person seen with her. Duckett was convicted and sentenced to death, while investigators later connected him to the deaths of other women and girls. He was never charged in those additional cases, leaving a disturbing question: How many victims could James Aren Duckett have had? We examine the evidence, the unanswered questions, and the case of a police officer who became a convicted murderer—and a suspected serial killer.  James Duckett execution, James Aren Duckett death row, James Duckett 2026, Teresa McAbee murder, Florida death row inmate, police officer death row, death penalty Florida, DNA testing death penalty, inconclusive DNA results, James Duckett innocence claim, Florida true crime, former cop murderer, child murder case, suspected serial killer, Jeanifer Weldon, Florida cold case, true crime podcast, murder investigation, criminal justice, death penalty controversy

    The Serial Killer Cop?

  3. Jul 26

    The Yorkshire Witch and The Prophetic Chicken

    Send us Fan Mail Long before modern scams, Mary Bateman mastered the art of deception. Claiming supernatural powers, she manipulated families into believing their lives depended on her rituals and remedies. What followed was a trail of fraud, forged documents, and murder by poison that made her one of England's most infamous criminals. This episode dives into the myths, the murders, and the truth behind the Yorkshire Witch.  Original Yorkshire Witch, Mary Bateman case, Yorkshire Witch murders, poison killings, historical fraud, English criminal history, fake psychic, fortune teller murder, arsenic killer, Leeds true crime, British crime stories, historical true crime podcast, murder mystery, criminal deception, law and crime podcast, female serial killer, poison case, historical murders, notorious women, dark history, podcast discovery, British justice history, execution history, real crime stories, criminal psychology, Victorian crimes, England murder case, historical investigation, crime podcast, famous poisoners

    The Yorkshire Witch and The Prophetic Chicken

  4. Jul 23

    53 Days of Terror: America's Deadliest Killing Couple

    Send us Fan Mail During the summer of 1984, Alton Coleman and Debra Brown launched a 53-day crime spree that terrorized the Midwest. Crossing six states, the pair kidnapped, raped, tortured, robbed, and murdered victims ranging from young children to elderly couples. Their crimes shocked the nation and resulted in one of the largest multi-state manhunts in FBI history. This episode follows the trail of violence, the hunt that finally ended their reign of terror, and the disturbing relationship that fueled one of America's most notorious killer duos.  Midwest killing spree, Alton Coleman murders, Debra Brown serial killer, serial killer duo, crime spree America, FBI wanted fugitive, Ohio death penalty, Wisconsin murders, Indiana killings, Michigan victims, true crime podcast, murder spree, criminal psychology, law and crime podcast, serial murder case, violent offenders, American killers, homicide investigation, criminal investigation, real crime stories, podcast discovery, crime history, FBI capture, death row case, notorious criminals, dark true crime, murder documentary, serial killer history, crime storytelling, criminal behavior

    53 Days of Terror: America's Deadliest Killing Couple

  5. Jul 12

    The "Standing Man" of Muskegon Lake: The Todd Geib Mystery

    Send us Fan Mail A crowded party. A series of frantic phone calls. A disappearance that launched one of Michigan's largest volunteer searches. When Todd Geib's body was finally found, investigators faced a troubling question: how did he end up in a location that had already been searched? This episode examines the timeline, the evidence, the official findings, and the lingering mysteries that continue to divide investigators and armchair detectives alike.  Todd Geib mystery, Todd Geib missing, Michigan disappearance, Casnovia party case, mysterious drowning Michigan, Ovid Hall Lake case, Michigan cold case, missing man Michigan, Todd Geib explained, unsolved disappearance, Smiley Face Killers, true crime podcast, law and crime podcast, real crime stories, unexplained death, criminal investigation, missing persons, bizarre cold case, forensic evidence, Michigan mysteries, cold case podcast, podcast discovery, rural Michigan crime, mysterious phone call, standing body mystery, unsolved death, crime storytelling, missing person investigation, dark true crime, criminal psychology

    The "Standing Man" of Muskegon Lake: The Todd Geib Mystery

  6. Jul 5

    John Cannan and the Mystery of Suzy Lamplugh

    Send us Fan Mail John Cannan terrorized women across England with a series of violent sexual assaults before being convicted of murder. But his notoriety grew even further when police identified him as the leading suspect in the disappearance of Suzy Lamplugh. This week, we examine Cannan's known crimes, the investigation that followed him for decades, and the unanswered questions surrounding one of Britain's most infamous missing persons cases.  John Cannan, John Cannan crimes, Suzy Lamplugh disappearance, Suzy Lamplugh suspect, British serial killer, UK true crime, John Cannan murderer, cold case Britain, missing estate agent, unsolved disappearance, serial rapist UK, true crime podcast, law and crime podcast, British murder cases, criminal psychology, real crime stories, cold case investigation, homicide investigation, notorious British criminals, podcast discovery, unsolved mystery, violent offender, crime documentary, criminal profiling, British crime history, missing persons UK, infamous UK crimes, serial offender, justice system, crime storytelling

    John Cannan and the Mystery of Suzy Lamplugh

  7. Jun 30

    Murder at Disneyland

    Send us Fan Mail Disneyland is known as "The Happiest Place on Earth," but in 1981, it became the scene of its first homicide. Eighteen-year-old Mel C. Yorba was fatally stabbed during a private event after a confrontation with another guest. What happened afterward sparked decades of speculation. Instead of calling paramedics to the scene, Disney employees transported Yorba to a nearby hospital in an unmarked company van, a decision that led to a wrongful death lawsuit and helped fuel the enduring myth that "no one dies at Disneyland." In this episode, we separate fact from fiction as we examine the murder, the investigation, the courtroom battle, and the urban legend that refuses to die.  Mel C. Yorba, Mel Yorba, Disneyland murder, Disneyland stabbing, no one dies at Disneyland, Disneyland urban legend, James O'Driscoll, Disneyland homicide, Disneyland true crime, Disneyland death, Anaheim murder, Disney conspiracy, Happiest Place on Earth murder, wrongful death lawsuit Disney, Disneyland security controversy, true crime podcast, California true crime, murder at Disneyland, Disneyland myths, Disney cover up, urban legends, real crime stories, law and crime podcast, homicide investigation, 1981 Disneyland, Disney park history, shocking true crime, podcast discovery, crime storytelling, Disney mystery

    Murder at Disneyland

  8. Jun 21

    The "Littlest" Civil Rights Figure was a Cop Killer

    Send us Fan Mail In 1974, 20-year-old Joan Little was jailed in North Carolina when she claimed a white jailer sexually assaulted her at knifepoint. Little fought back, killing the jailer and escaping custody. What followed became one of the most significant trials of the Civil Rights era, drawing national attention from activists, civil rights leaders, and women's rights organizations. This episode explores the events inside the jail, the murder trial that followed, and how Joan Little became a symbol of self-defense, racial justice, and women's rights.  Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, the unbelievable, and the unsolved. Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker and comedian, the show blends sharp storytelling with real investigative insight. Together, they break down cases from every angle—what happened, how it happened, and what doesn’t add up. Each week we explore missing persons, cold cases, serial crimes, controversial investigations, and bizarre true crime stories from around the world. Some cases are solved, some remain mysteries, and some defy explanation entirely. Deep-dive true crime with smart conversation, dark stories, and just enough humor to keep it human. New episodes every week.  Maura Murray, JonBenét Ramsey, Madeleine McCann, Zodiac Killer, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, John Wayne Gacy, BTK Killer (Dennis Rader), Golden State Killer (Joseph DeAngelo), West Memphis Three, O.J. Simpson case, Delphi murders, Idaho student murders, Gabby Petito, Chris Watts family murders, D.B. Cooper, Jonestown massacre, Black Dahlia murder, Laci Peterson case, Long Island Serial Killer (LISK)  Joan Little, Joan Little trial, Joan Little case, Civil Rights movement, North Carolina murder trial, self defense case, women's rights history, racial justice case, jailer murder case, Clarence Alligood, 1970s criminal trial, civil rights activism, Black women history, true crime podcast, historic court case, criminal justice history, self defense law, landmark trial, legal history podcast, law and crime podcast, racial inequality justice system, women's movement history, courtroom drama, real crime stories, North Carolina true crime, criminal law history, civil rights era, famous murder trials, justice system reform, historic true crime

    The "Littlest" Civil Rights Figure was a Cop Killer
See All (84)

4.7
out of 5
9 Ratings

About

Welcome to All The Damn Crim — a weekly true crime podcast covering the gruesome, the obscure, and the unsolved. Hosted by John, a defense investigator, and Joel, a documentary filmmaker, the show blends sharp storytelling with real investigative insight. Together, they break down cases from every angle. Each week we explore missing persons, cold cases, serial crimes, controversial investigations, and bizarre true crime stories from around the world. Some cases are solved, some remain mysteries, and some defy explanation entirely. Deep-dive true crime with smart-ish conversation, dark stories, and gallows humor. New episodes every week. Maura Murray, JonBenét Ramsey, Madeleine McCann, Zodiac Killer, Ted Bundy, Jeffrey Dahmer, John Wayne Gacy, BTK Killer (Dennis Rader), Golden State Killer (Joseph DeAngelo), West Memphis Three, O.J. Simpson case, Delphi murders, Idaho student murders, Gabby Petito, Chris Watts family murders, D.B. Cooper, Jonestown massacre, Black Dahlia murder, Laci Peterson case, Long Island Serial Killer (LISK) 

Information

  • Creator
    John and Joel
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2026
  • Episodes
    84
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 All The Damn Crime
  • Show Website
    All The Damn Crime