Thanksgiving is often celebrated as a day of food, family, and gratitude—but at its heart, it may be something deeper: an invitation to humility. Reflecting on Abraham Lincoln’s call for thanksgiving during the darkest days of the Civil War, Stephen considers how gratitude can transcend religious, political, and cultural divides. In a fractured moment, perhaps giving thanks offers us a chance to lower our defenses, recognize our shared dependence, and rediscover the common ground beneath our differences. Transcript: Over the years I’ve heard many persons say that as far as holidays are concerned, Thanksgiving is their favorite. They cite the general lack of obligations and trappings other than an over-supplied feast attended by some friends, neighbors and family--gratitude in the honor seat. They say it evokes memory, a longing for community and a chance even for cynics and curmudgeons to acknowledge their various dependencies for the sustaining of their lives. It’s an odd holiday, though, as holidays go; established by presidential proclamation to accomplish a spiritual purpose in a land that supposedly prides itself on the separation of the state and institutional religion. There’s no small tension here because who is to say whose God is being addressed in such a common undertaking? Around our tables we shouldn’t be too glib with believing that all Americans worship at the same altar. That would diminish rather than strengthen the truthful bonds of our unity. No one person or religious persuasion owns the grounding virtue of gratitude. It’s bigger, more elemental than any tradition having spontaneously welled up from the deep mystery that gave all of us life and breath in the first place. When Abraham Lincoln re-established the practice of summoning the nation to a day of Thanksgiving on the fourth Thursday of November, our country was at the bloody nadir of our protracted civil war about which Lincoln would write that parties in the north and the south “both read the same Bible and pray to the same God; and each invokes His aid against the other…. The prayers of both could not be answered; that of neither has been answered fully. The Almighty has His own purposes.” It’s not lost to me that in these confounding days prayers of every sort are being flung heavenward to win the support of favored deities in our land and in lands spread everywhere covering our globe. It was the peculiar genius of Lincoln to see the merit in calling the tortured nation to look up from graveyards, hospitals and rifle barrels aimed at implacable enemies to see a larger purpose, and to regain national bearing in a grander, if not completely transparent, vision. Pausing for Thanksgiving then was a kind of moratorium, disarmament, if only for a moment, to acknowledge that one’s prayers are always dwarfed by God who causes the rain to fall on the just and the unjust unlike, and whose purposes are indeed often inscrutable, if paradoxically everywhere in evidence. In this way Thanksgiving is a holiday rooted in humility. One cannot express authentic gratitude if it’s not wrapped in humility. My Christian heart tells me Jesus favors such thing. And he doesn’t favor it for my sake only. He favors it for the sake of my neighbor and even for my enemy. Friends from other traditions (or no tradition) experience something similar, expressed through different words and rituals. We share a world, a genetic heritage, and essential needs, so it’s no surprise that gratitude offers us common ground as our foundational spiritual condition. I am deeply grateful that this nation attempts to provide a non-coercive environment for the free expression of my faith. It doesn’t do this perfectly or consistently, but having recently taken time to think about it, I find I’m more thankful than usual. This despite (or because of?) our raucous cultural/political moment. The humility necessary for honest gratitude leads to acknowledgment of human frailty and moral culpability. Since the US is the colossus that bestrides the world, the power we hold must be held in check by our most cherished values. Gathered around Thanksgiving tables provides a seemingly modest, but meaningful opportunity for recognizing the enormity of the gifts we share despite our various corruptions. I’m awed by the blessed station of our lives, wholly, utterly underserved. Offering humble thanks among friends, neighbors and family provides perspective on these matters; allows us to accept one another despite our many and sometimes sharp differences; honors the dignity of everyone present and solidifies a common purpose. In this spirit I hope that as November’s fourth Thursday comes round, you’re able to let the barriers down and allow gratitude win the day. Well, why not let it win at least the whole weekend... Get full access to Living in the Meantime at livinginthemeantime.substack.com/subscribe