E1152: Google Analytics is one of the most widely used analytics platforms on the web, but there is a growing category of traffic it was never really designed to help you understand: bots, AI crawlers, and AI agents. I sit down with analytics consultant Jason Packer, author of Google Analytics Alternatives, to talk about what GA4 is measuring, what it can miss, and how the rise of AI is changing both analytics and SEO. We get into AI companies crawling the web, the possibility of companies such as OpenAI and Anthropic developing their own web indexes, and what that could mean if AI platforms increasingly rely on their own infrastructure rather than traditional search indexes. We also discuss a separate issue that matters to anyone using AI for SEO: detecting AI-generated content. Jason explains current approaches to identifying AI-generated text and images, including watermarking systems such as SynthID, classifiers, and emerging standards around identifying AI-generated material. We also discuss whether Google can detect AI-generated content and why simply asking whether content was written by AI may be the wrong question. The bigger question is whether the content is useful, accurate, distinctive, and reviewed by a human. Topics covered: - What traffic Google Analytics 4 may be missing - Why GA4 intentionally filters much bot traffic - Why AI crawlers and AI agents create a new analytics problem - The difference between human visitors, traditional bots, AI crawlers, and AI agents - Why identifying AI traffic from user agents is difficult - What Cloudflare data can tell us about the growth of AI crawling - Whether OpenAI and Anthropic could build their own web indexes - How an AI-owned search index could change SEO - Why ranking for an LLM may work differently from ranking in Google - Whether early AI search systems could create new opportunities for SEOs - Hidden GA4 features and reports that many users overlook - How modeled users can affect what you see inside GA4 - Using device-based reporting identity to better understand your analytics data - Creating custom GA4 insights and anomaly alerts - Using Explore and User Explorer in GA4 - Where GA4 is genuinely powerful - Why GA4 may not be the right default analytics platform for every website - Google Analytics alternatives including PostHog, Amplitude, Piwik PRO, Plausible, Fathom, and others - Whether it makes sense to build your own analytics platform with AI coding tools - How AI-generated text and images can be detected - Google SynthID and AI watermarking - Why interoperability between AI detection systems matters - Whether Google can identify AI-generated SEO content - The risks of publishing AI content at scale - Why human review still matters when using AI for SEO - How AI can be used without sacrificing usefulness, accuracy, or brand voice The conversation ultimately comes back to a problem SEOs are going to have to understand: the web is no longer being visited only by humans and traditional search-engine crawlers. AI systems are increasingly crawling, retrieving, processing, and potentially indexing web content. At the same time, publishers are using those same systems to produce more content. That creates two important questions for SEO: How do you measure AI traffic that conventional analytics tools may filter or fail to identify? And how should you use AI to create content when search engines and AI platforms are becoming increasingly capable of identifying how that content was produced? ⭐️ Jason Packer's website, Quantable - https://quantable.com ⭐️ Jason Packer's book, Google Analytics Alternatives: A Comprehensive Guide - http://gaalternatives.guide ⭐️ Jason Packer on LinkedIn - https://www.linkedin.com/in/jhpacker/ 💎 Compact Keywords - My SEO Course - Get paying customers through SEO - Clear step-by-step video breakdowns - SEO templates to be copied and adapted for your products and services: https://compactkeywords.com/ 00:00 Meet Jason Packer 01:25 GA4 Hidden Insights 02:11 Modeled Users Explained 06:52 Custom Insights Alerts 09:12 Explore Reports Tricks 12:27 Learning GA4 Fast 14:39 Ask Advisor Critique 17:21 GA4 Basics For Beginners 21:40 Attribution And UA Nostalgia 25:19 What Traffic GA4 Misses 28:48 AI Crawlers And Analytics 31:04 Cloudflare Radar Web Crawling 33:05 AI Indexes And SEO Future 38:52 Spam In New Indexes 40:35 GA4 Alternatives Framework 41:20 Best Product Analytics Tools 43:11 Simpler Web Analytics Picks 46:10 Vibe Coding Analytics Risks 48:38 What Analytics They Use 50:19 Detecting AI Text Watermarks 52:42 EU AI Act And Detection APIs 56:09 SynthID Limits And SlopGuard 01:02:40 AI SEO Best Practices 01:07:15 Human Writing With AI Assist 01:11:47 Podcast Wrap Up The Edward Show. Your daily search engine optimization podcast: https://edwardsturm.com/the-edward-show/ #digitalmarketing #googleanalytics #searchengineoptimization #seo