Destination Discourse

Destination Discourse

Destination Discourse is the essential podcast for DMOs and travel industry professionals who want to stay ahead in destination marketing, stewardship, and management. Hosted by industry experts Stuart Butler and Adam Stoker, each episode delves into the key issues and trends shaping the future of tourism. From cutting-edge innovations to the complex challenges of destination management, we offer thought-provoking insights, honest debates, and practical takeaways. Part love letter to the industry, part therapy session, and part user manual, Destination Discourse is your trusted source for real talk and expert advice. Join us to explore inspiring campaigns, hear from leading voices, and gain the insights you need to elevate your destination strategies.

  1. 1D AGO

    75: Has Destination Marketing Been Gentrified? (Katy Livingston and Matt Stiker)

    Destination marketing has a sameness problem, and this episode tackles it head-on. Stuart Butler and Adam Stoker are joined by Matt Steiker and Katy Livingston of Madden Media for a conversation about why so much destination advertising feels interchangeable, what “destination gentrification” looks like in practice, and why safe, committee-friendly marketing often leads to forgettable work. Before diving in, the episode opens with a classic bit of Destination Discourse chaos: Adam joins from his phone after a brutal travel delay, his computer fails him, and the jingle takes a very unexpected turn. From there, Stu’s News focuses on OpenAI’s upcoming GPT-5.4 updates and what larger context windows, better reasoning, and fewer hallucinations could mean for the future of agentic AI. The group agrees that while average DMO users may not feel every update immediately, the bigger lesson is clear: AI keeps improving, and destinations can’t afford to give up on it just because it didn’t work perfectly the first time. The heart of the episode centers on a sharp idea raised by Katy and Matt: too many destinations look, sound, and market themselves the same way. When every place talks about hidden gems, local breweries, great food, and off-the-beaten-path experiences, the work becomes generic. The result is marketing that may be polished, but rarely memorable. The group digs into why that happens. Fear plays a major role. Fear of stakeholders. Fear of elected officials. Fear of backlash. Fear of losing your job. Adam argues that many DMOs are stuck in “marketing by committee,” while Stuart pushes back that the real issue is not the committee itself, but the fear surrounding it. They also unpack the agency-client dynamic and whether agencies should be pushing destinations beyond their comfort zone. The consensus: absolutely yes. But the relationship is often set up in a way that rewards safe execution instead of bold thinking, especially through the RFP process. A few key themes emerge: • Great destination marketing needs a distinct point of view. • Emotional resonance matters more than a checklist of amenities. • Unique experiences are the true differentiator, not generic features and benefits. • DMOs need to protect and preserve what makes their communities different, or they will eventually have nothing original left to market. • The industry needs more outside perspective and should learn from brands beyond tourism. There’s also an important conversation about stewardship. Stuart makes the case that the DMO’s role is increasingly about being a convener, collaborator, and advocate for the long-term health of the destination, not just a promoter of hotel rooms and attractions. If economic development, placemaking, workforce, and tourism are all connected, DMOs need a seat at those tables. The episode closes with practical advice:Matt says fortune favors the bold, especially in a market where travelers are looking for genuine, distinctive experiences.Katy says the cure for boring marketing is a clear point of view rooted in authentic, emotional, real-world experiences.Adam says job security is often an illusion, and marketers need to stop letting fear keep them from doing the right work.Stuart says success starts with stronger relationships: with stakeholders, boards, elected officials, local businesses, and partner organizations across the community. This one is a candid, challenging conversation about creativity, courage, and why destinations that want to stand out can’t keep sounding like everyone else.

    58 min
  2. MAR 26

    74: Why Aren’t DMOs and Vacation Rentals Working Together? (Alex Husner and Annie Holcombe)

    In this episode of Destination Discourse, Stuart Butler and Adam Stoker are joined by Alex Husner and Annie Holcombe from the Alex & Annie Podcast for a candid conversation about the evolving relationship between DMOs and the vacation rental industry. They start with Stu’s News and a timely discussion about Google building agentic AI directly into Chrome, using travel booking as one of the headline examples. That sparks a broader conversation about how quickly AI is moving from theory to reality, what “agentic” AI actually means, and why this shift could fundamentally change how travelers research, plan, and book trips. The group explores what happens when consumers stop visiting dozens of websites and instead rely on AI tools to surface options, make decisions, and potentially complete bookings on their behalf. From there, the conversation shifts into the main topic: vacation rentals, short-term rentals, and why they are still too often misunderstood or underrepresented in destination marketing. Alex and Annie explain the distinction they see between traditional vacation rentals in established leisure destinations and the broader short-term rental category that has exploded in urban markets. They also dig into how Airbnb has shaped public perception of the sector, often overshadowing the professionally managed operators that have long been part of many destination ecosystems. The discussion explores why so many DMOs and vacation rental operators are not working together more intentionally, even though both ultimately want the same thing: more visitors having a better experience in the destination. The group talks through the challenges of fragmentation, the lack of a unified voice for the vacation rental industry, and the tendency for destinations to lump all rentals together based on the behavior of a minority of bad actors. Along the way, they make the case that vacation rentals are not just another lodging category. In many destinations, they are essential to affordability, family travel, sports tourism, group travel, and the overall diversity of the lodging mix. The conversation also highlights the role DMOs can play in better representing that inventory, opening communication with operators, and advocating for fair, common-sense standards that protect both visitors and communities. It’s a lively episode about AI, tourism, representation, and why vacation rentals deserve a more intentional seat at the table. What you’ll hear in this episode:AI’s move into mainstream travel planning through Google ChromeA practical explanation of what agentic AI actually isWhy AI may reduce friction but not necessarily reduce stressHow traveler behavior could shift if websites matter lessThe difference between short-term rentals and vacation rentalsWhy Airbnb has shaped perception of the entire categoryHow professionally managed vacation rentals differ from casual hostsWhy DMOs and vacation rental operators often miss each otherThe role vacation rentals play in sports tourism, affordability, and group travelWhy better communication, representation, and advocacy could benefit the whole destination Check out the Alex & Annie Podcast to hear more conversations on vacation rentals, tourism, and the changing travel landscape.

    53 min
  3. MAR 19

    73: Are DMOs Facing an Identity Crisis? (Christian Mengel)

    This episode of Destination Discourse starts in the most on-brand way possible: with Christian Mengel joining live from the Kansas City airport, turning the conversation into a truly mobile edition of the show. After a quick round of banter and Stu’s News on Apple’s latest promises around Siri, the conversation shifts into a much bigger question for the destination industry: what is the real role of a DMO now? Christian brings three predictions for 2026, including more mergers and acquisitions, a growing importance of earned media, and a bigger conversation around how DMOs define their purpose. That opens the door to a candid discussion about whether destination organizations should think beyond traditional marketing and play a more active role in shaping experiences, supporting development, and filling gaps in their communities. The conversation gets especially interesting when the group wrestles with questions like:How far should a DMO go in helping create tourism product?Where is the line between promotion and participation?What happens when an industry can measure more than ever before, but still struggles to explain its value clearly? Throughout the episode, Stuart, Adam, and Christian explore the tension between relevance, risk, politics, and public trust. They talk about why so many DMOs feel like they are being targeted, why mission and values matter more than ever, and why communities are more likely to defend a DMO when they can clearly see the tangible benefits tourism brings to everyday life. A few major themes stand out:DMOs need to do a better job articulating not just what they do, but why they exist.Data matters, but stories are often what actually move stakeholders.The industry still lacks a shared blueprint for what a DMO should fundamentally be.If DMOs are not at the table when the future of a destination is being discussed, they risk being left out entirely. This is one of those episodes that asks more big questions than it answers, but that is exactly the point. It is an honest conversation about an industry in transition and a challenge to destination leaders to stop playing defense, get clearer on their purpose, and help shape what comes next.

    1h 4m
  4. MAR 12

    72: Should DMOs Be Responsible for Visitor Safety? (Jason Holic)

    A new (intentionally terrible) Stu’s News jingle makes its debut, January downloads surge, and Jason Holic of Experience Kissimmee shares how his team is stepping into water safety as part of destination stewardship. This episode moves beyond traditional demand generation and asks a bigger question: What is a DMO actually responsible for? ⸻ What You’ll Hear in This Episode • A brand-new Stu’s News jingle (British rapper vibes, Star Wars references, and mixed reviews). • January already surpassing December’s record downloads, with a 30-day run rate up 48% (per Stuart). • A listener comment sparks debate: Should DMOs try to own the travel decision-making cycle—even if they don’t control the transaction? • Stuart’s evolving view of the DMO as not just the “fuel,” but possibly the “mechanic” of the tourism engine. • Adam’s counterpoint: the job is to get attention and build trust—without chasing endless side quests. • Jason’s water safety initiative and what stewardship looks like in practice. ⸻ The Big Question: What Is a DMO’s Role? The conversation explores whether DMOs should: • Stick to demand generation. • Expand into experience and destination impact. • Take a more active role in long-term tourism vision. • Or simply focus on maximizing attention and converting it into trust. Public safety becomes the real-world test case for that debate. ⸻ Experience Kissimmee’s Water Safety Initiative Jason shares how the idea originated from a community conversation and evolved into a formal task force including: • Department of Health • Fire Rescue / EMS • Sheriff’s Office • School district • Vacation rental partners • A hotel partner • A water park The goal: address water safety proactively before it becomes a reputational crisis. The Framework: The ABCs of Pool Safety Jason references the traditional ABCs of pool safety: • A: Adult supervision • B: Barriers • C: Classes (swim lessons) The campaign focuses specifically on A and B, since swim classes aren’t realistic during a vacation stay. How They’re Delivering It • A short, simple PSA-style video. • Hosted on a landing page. • Visitors who complete the video can enter their email to receive exclusive offers from local attractions and restaurants. • Distribution primarily happens through vacation rental management companies via pre-arrival emails and text messaging. No heavy paid media. No large ad spend. Mostly partner collaboration and owned channels. ⸻ Myrtle Beach’s Water Safety Activation Stuart shares how Myrtle Beach approached water safety through: • Bringing in the world’s largest rubber duck during Water Safety Week. • Partnering with kid-focused creator Handyman Howe for a water safety video that generated significant viewership. • Creating a media-friendly hook to amplify the message. The takeaway: safety messaging can be serious—but it doesn’t have to be boring. ⸻ Other Themes from the Episode • The California Gold Rush analogy: maybe DMOs don’t “own the gold,” but they can add value along the journey. • The tension between measuring ROI and measuring impact in safety initiatives. • The importance of convening stakeholders—even if you don’t lead every initiative. • The idea that DMOs should be humble conveners rather than credit-seeking champions.

    57 min
  5. MAR 5

    71: Are You Committing the Three Deadly Sins of Board Governance? (Bill Geist)

    In this episode of Destination Discourse, Stuart Butler and Adam Stoker welcome back industry legend Bill Geist for a no-nonsense masterclass on DMO board governance. The conversation starts with Stu’s News, exploring what OpenAI’s new ChatGPT Health product—and Google pulling back on AI health recommendations—signals about trust, adoption, and the future of AI verticals, including travel. Then Bill delivers his core thesis: every major DMO problem can be traced back to the board—and most boards struggle because they commit the same three deadly sins. Together, they break down: Why poor succession planning creates echo chambers How weak or nonexistent board orientation undermines advocacy Why overly choreographed meetings kill engagement and trust This episode is a must-listen for destination leaders navigating board dynamics, governance reform, political pressure, and the growing need for trust in a post-truth world. What you’ll hear in this episode Why trust is becoming the core currency for destinations How AI adoption mirrors what’s coming next for travel planning The three deadly sins of DMO boards—and how to fix them What an effective board orientation actually looks like Why healthy boards debate, not rubber-stamp How much conversation should happen in a board meeting When (and how) elected officials should be involved in governance The ideal board size for a destination organization

    58 min
  6. FEB 26

    70: Are Silos Holding DMOs Back? (Danielle Hollander)

    If you’ve ever felt like your DMO is five different organizations wearing the same logo… this episode will feel very familiar. Stuart and Adam welcome Danielle Hollander from Visit Orlando for her first appearance on Destination Discourse. After a slightly unhinged (and very “letter M”) opening, the conversation settles into something deeply practical: why DMOs so often feel siloed—and what it actually takes to fix that. Stu’s News: Travel didn’t crash—it just felt harder Stuart kicks things off with a Bank of America report using Visa spend data showing that 2025 travel softened slightly compared to the post-pandemic highs, but is still stronger than 2019. So why did it feel rough? • Adam connects it to the labor market shift. When jobs feel less secure, people protect PTO and travel budgets. • Danielle points to return-to-office realities. Fewer “work from anywhere” trips means travel requires more planning and tradeoffs. • Stuart zooms out: the important signal is that travel is still prioritized, even if expectations need recalibration after the chaos of 2022–2023. The real conversation: DMOs don’t have one business model—and that’s the problem Danielle lays out something most DMOs feel but rarely say out loud:We’re marketing organizations, sales organizations, membership organizations, community organizations—and sometimes all at once. That complexity is exactly why silos form. She shares how Visit Orlando works intentionally against that: • A strategic plan that’s actually used, not just approved. • An annual theme (like “collaboration”) that becomes part of daily behavior. • Internal “Collaborama” sessions where teams explain what they do and how it affects everyone else. • Cross-functional planning where marketing, sales, events, and leadership hear the same strategy before tactics ever start. Strategy is making a comeback (thanks, AI) Adam argues that we’re in the middle of a strategic reset. As AI makes tactics easier and cheaper, the real differentiator is no longer execution—it’s thinking. His agency’s biggest unlock in 2025?Assigning a clear initiative owner for major work—someone responsible for the outcome, not just their slice of the process. The result: better work, less confusion, and people discovering leadership potential they didn’t know they had. How Orlando keeps everyone focused on the same win Stuart asks the key question: How do different teams know they’re winning together? Danielle walks through Visit Orlando’s approach: • A small set of org-level goals approved by the board. • Incentives tied to those goals—from the C-suite down. • Team goals that clearly ladder up. • Monthly reviews that force honest conversations about what’s working and what’s not. Agencies aren’t vendors—they’re part of the system One of the most practical parts of the episode is Danielle’s breakdown of how Visit Orlando evaluates agencies: • Input from multiple internal departments. • Agency self-evaluations. • Required written justification for scores. • Formal feedback, improvement plans, and documentation that stands up in audits. The takeaway: no surprises, no finger-pointing, and no silos—internal or external. 2026 focus: Elevate by doing less, better For Danielle, the goal this year isn’t more innovation—it’s more discipline: • Clear ownership using RACI. • Fewer tactics (“pick three”). • Built-in recaps so learning doesn’t disappear. • More time for teams to think instead of react. Her litmus test?If you can’t explain the initiative like an award entry, you probably don’t understand it well enough yet. The big takeaway Breaking silos isn’t about org charts.It’s about shared strategy, clear ownership, honest scorecards, and treating partners like part of the same team. And as Danielle puts it: the real competition isn’t the destination down the road—it’s the couch. Resources mentioned in this episode Agency Evaluation ScoresheetA cross-functional framework for evaluating agency performance across strategy, communication, operations, and accountability.https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Z6Sdo4339Yu53kxP6pZ2W0BwgnyBFON2/edit Universal Project Brief (Visit Myrtle Beach)A strategic alignment tool used to define the “why,” success metrics, and ownership before work begins, inspired by the “write the press release first” approach.https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OrYwuR-irFtm6VWeLG5hU7_ClstjpkzZ/edit Resources mentioned in this episode Agency Evaluation Scoresheet A cross-functional framework for evaluating agency performance across strategy, communication, operations, and accountability. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Z6Sdo4339Yu53kxP6pZ2W0BwgnyBFON2/edit Universal Project Brief (Visit Myrtle Beach) A strategic alignment tool used to define the “why,” success metrics, and ownership before work begins, inspired by the “write the press release first” approach. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OrYwuR-irFtm6VWeLG5hU7_ClstjpkzZ/edit Resources mentioned in this episode Agency Evaluation Scoresheet A cross-functional framework for evaluating agency performance across strategy, communication, operations, and accountability. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Z6Sdo4339Yu53kxP6pZ2W0BwgnyBFON2/edit Universal Project Brief (Visit Myrtle Beach) A strategic alignment tool used to define the “why,” success metrics, and ownership before work begins, inspired by the “write the press release first” approach. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OrYwuR-irFtm6VWeLG5hU7_ClstjpkzZ/edit Resources mentioned in this episode Agency Evaluation Scoresheet A cross-functional framework for evaluating agency performance across strategy, communication, operations, and accountability. https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Z6Sdo4339Yu53kxP6pZ2W0BwgnyBFON2/edit Universal Project Brief (Visit Myrtle Beach) A strategic alignment tool used to define the “why,” success metrics, and ownership before work begins, inspired by the “write the press release first” approach. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1OrYwuR-irFtm6VWeLG5hU7_ClstjpkzZ/edit

    54 min
  7. FEB 19

    69: Are We Built for What’s Coming in Tourism? (Live at SC GovCon)

    In this episode of Destination Discourse, Stuart Butler (Visit Myrtle Beach) and Adam Stoker (Brand Revolt) record live at the South Carolina Governor’s Conference on Tourism. Instead of a traditional presentation, they brought the podcast format to the stage. No slides.No scripted panel.Just live audience polling and an open conversation about what’s really happening in the tourism industry. It’s a different environment than it was just a few years ago. Consumer behavior is evolving. Expectations are rising. Technology and AI are reshaping how travelers discover and choose destinations. At the same time, communities are asking harder questions about growth and impact. So Stuart and Adam started by asking the room to weigh in. Through live polling, attendees voted on: • The biggest challenges facing tourism professionals right now • What’s shifting in their communities • The issues that aren’t being talked about enough • The capabilities destinations will need moving forward The top responses shaped the rest of the session. What followed was a candid, unscripted discussion with real input from operators, destination leaders, and public officials in the room. This episode isn’t about bold predictions or polished answers. It’s about where the industry stands right now — and what it will take to navigate what’s ahead. If you work in destination marketing, hospitality, attractions, or public leadership, this conversation is for you.

    1h 3m
  8. FEB 12

    68: Are DMOs Treating Long-Term Assets Like Short-Term Expenses? (Eddie Kirsch)

    Stuart Butler and Adam Stoker kick off the episode shaking off post-holiday rust with their signature mix of self-awareness, banter, and big-picture thinking. A deliberately terrible German intro, a mistranslated last name, and a few early laughs set the tone before welcoming Eddie Kirsch from Visit St. Pete Clearwater—a guest who sits at the intersection of storytelling, data, and performance. The conversation opens with Stu’s News, sparked by Amazon’s move to introduce a chat-based version of Alexa. Stuart frames it as another signal that the AI landscape is fragmenting fast, while Adam argues that being first to market rarely means being the long-term winner. With Google, Amazon, and others embedding AI directly into tools people already use every day, the group questions whether ChatGPT can realistically hold dominant market share over time. Eddie brings the discussion down to earth for DMOs, noting that destinations redesigning websites today must plan for how people will interact with information in 2027 and beyond—not just how they search right now. That naturally leads into a spirited detour on the upcoming World Cup. Eddie shares both excitement and frustration as a lifelong soccer fan, particularly around pricing and access. Stuart doesn’t hold back, calling the ticketing process broken and warning destinations against overhyping long-term economic impact—something the industry has done repeatedly with mega-events. Adam pushes back slightly, citing record demand and arguing the World Cup won’t be a flop, even if projections should be treated cautiously. The segment ends with a surprisingly important question: what will be America’s cultural “export” to global soccer—our version of the vuvuzela? The heart of the episode centers on Eddie’s core idea: if a DMO were built from scratch with no legacy constraints, it would likely look far more like a media production company than an advertising buyer. He challenges the industry’s obsession with short-term attribution and KPIs, arguing that content’s real value often compounds over time in ways traditional models fail to capture. Social platforms, YouTube, and long-form content increasingly shape traveler decisions, yet DMOs still struggle to measure—and therefore justify—serious investment in them. Adam connects that tension to funding structures and annual budget cycles, which reward immediate proof over long-term “cathedral thinking.” He outlines his evolving framework—attention plus trust plus circumstances equals action—and argues that destinations should focus less on proving direct bookings and more on earning attention and trust over time. Stuart builds on that by reframing content as the tool for attention, experience as the driver of trust, and data as the context that makes both effective. The episode closes with one of its spiciest takes: Stuart and Eddie largely agree that generic travel influencers are often a poor investment for DMOs. Instead, they argue destinations should partner with creators outside the travel space—people with loyal, niche audiences—and invite them to bring their existing content style to the destination. The result, they suggest, is more differentiated storytelling, less competition for attention, and content that continues to drive impact long after the campaign ends. As always, the conversation doesn’t land on a neat conclusion—and that’s the point. This episode is about surfacing real tensions DMOs face right now: short-term accountability versus long-term relevance, measurement versus meaning, and advertising versus storytelling.

    59 min
5
out of 5
8 Ratings

About

Destination Discourse is the essential podcast for DMOs and travel industry professionals who want to stay ahead in destination marketing, stewardship, and management. Hosted by industry experts Stuart Butler and Adam Stoker, each episode delves into the key issues and trends shaping the future of tourism. From cutting-edge innovations to the complex challenges of destination management, we offer thought-provoking insights, honest debates, and practical takeaways. Part love letter to the industry, part therapy session, and part user manual, Destination Discourse is your trusted source for real talk and expert advice. Join us to explore inspiring campaigns, hear from leading voices, and gain the insights you need to elevate your destination strategies.

You Might Also Like