107 episodes

*Unlock the unknown* with the gang on the Mystery Inc Podcast—your go-to source for real-life mysteries that defy explanation. Hop into our *Mystery Machine Tesla* as we hit the road, diving deep into the enigmas that leave even the skeptics questioning reality. From haunted hideaways to unsolved crimes, each episode is a riveting journey through the baffling and the bizarre.

*The mystery is out there; are you in?*

Mystery Inc Black Label

    • Comedy
    • 4.3 • 121 Ratings

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Requires subscription and macOS 11.4 or higher

*Unlock the unknown* with the gang on the Mystery Inc Podcast—your go-to source for real-life mysteries that defy explanation. Hop into our *Mystery Machine Tesla* as we hit the road, diving deep into the enigmas that leave even the skeptics questioning reality. From haunted hideaways to unsolved crimes, each episode is a riveting journey through the baffling and the bizarre.

*The mystery is out there; are you in?*

Listen on Apple Podcasts
Requires subscription and macOS 11.4 or higher

    51: Frozen in Fear: The Legend of Moll Dyer

    51: Frozen in Fear: The Legend of Moll Dyer

    In this spine-tingling episode, we dive deep into the misty lore of colonial Maryland, where the eerie tale of Moll Dyer has been a chilling bedtime story for generations. Accused of witchcraft in the freezing winter of 1697, Moll Dyer was an outcast, known for her herbal remedies and reclusive lifestyle. Legend says after being chased from her home by a fearful mob, she was found frozen to a rock, her handprints eerily etched into the stone—a somber monument to her tragic end. Today, the rock still exists in Leonardtown, and the strange occurrences around it have not diminished with the passage of time.

    Armed only with their curiosity and a few trusty flashlights, our intrepid investigators venture into the town, where the whispers of the past loom as large as the shadow of the rock itself. The local tales are filled with ghostly sightings and inexplicable cold spots that challenge the bravest of hearts. As our heroes unravel the tangled threads of history and myth, they must discern truth from legend, facing not just the supernatural forces at play but also the historical truths buried beneath centuries of lore. Get ready for a journey filled with chills and thrills, as this episode promises to keep you guessing—and maybe even a little spooked—until the very end!

    50: Blast from the Past: The 1920 Wall Street Bombing

    50: Blast from the Past: The 1920 Wall Street Bombing

    In this gripping episode, we delve into the chaos and mystery of the Wall Street Bombing of 1920. On the sunny afternoon of September 16, 1920, a horse-drawn wagon packed with 100 pounds of dynamite and 500 pounds of heavy sash weights exploded in the financial heart of New York City, just outside the J.P. Morgan bank at 23 Wall Street. The blast claimed 38 lives and injured hundreds more, leaving a scene of devastation and sparking a frenzy of fear that gripped the nation. As smoke cleared, the question of who was behind this horrific act haunted the streets of Manhattan.

    Diving into the details, we explore the immediate aftermath of the explosion, the historical context of labor unrest and political radicalism, and the flurry of investigations that followed. Initial suspicions pointed towards anarchists or communists, reflecting the Red Scare that was sweeping through America at the time. Yet, despite the best efforts of law enforcement, including the legendary J. Edgar Hoover, the case remained shrouded in mystery, with no one ever officially charged for the attack. In this episode, we piece together the evidence and testimonies, exploring various theories that have emerged over the decades. Tune in as we attempt to unravel a century-old puzzle, shedding light on a moment that shaped the security measures of the financial district and left an indelible mark on American history.

    Unmasked: Episodes 50&51

    Unmasked: Episodes 50&51

    Join Shane, Josh, and Producer Kim on this Unmasked premium episode to hear more from them on this episode's topic - and other life topics! You will want to listen to the full episode first before enjoying this Unmasked episode.

    Unmasked: Episodes 48&49

    Unmasked: Episodes 48&49

    Join Shane, Josh, and Producer Kim on this Unmasked premium episode to hear more from them on this episode's topic - and other life topics! You will want to listen to the full episode first before enjoying this Unmasked episode.

    49: The Mystery of the Moonlit Maidens

    49: The Mystery of the Moonlit Maidens

    In this hair-raising episode of Mystery Inc., fasten your seatbelts as we time-travel to the 18th century, landing smack in the heart of New Orleans with a tale that's as mysterious as it is chilling. Enter the legend of the Casket Girls, a group of young women who arrived from France with casket-shaped chests, rumored to carry more than just their belongings. The townsfolk whispered of shadows lurking around the corners and strange occurrences that began to unfold with the girls' arrival.
    As our intrepid investigators dive into the heart of the French Quarter, they find themselves untangling a web of myths, vampires, and secrets kept for centuries. Could these casket chests hold the key to New Orleans' oldest and darkest mysteries?


    Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

    Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    • 52 min
    48: The Eerie Encounter in Exeter

    48: The Eerie Encounter in Exeter

    Zoinks! Gather 'round, gang, for a spooky tale from the small, quiet town of Kensington, New Hampshire. It's the wee hours of September 3, 1965, and young Norman Muscarello is hitchhiking home to Exeter after a date. Suddenly, he spots something that makes his hair stand on end—flashing bright red lights in the sky, but these ain't no ordinary emergency lights. This mysterious object, silent and vast, hovers above, bathing everything in an eerie red glow. Imagine Norman's fright as he dashes to a nearby house, only to find the occupants too spooked to open the door!
    The plot thickens when Norman races to the police, and Officers Toland and Bertrand join the scene, only to encounter the baffling sight themselves—a gigantic, dark object with red flashing lights, hovering silently in the night. Despite their bravery (and Officer Bertrand's ready revolver), the trio can't muster the courage to confront the silent visitor. As the mystery deepens, so does the intrigue. It's a classic Scooby-Doo setup, minus the meddling kids and their Great Dane, but with all the chills, thrills, and head-scratching mystery of a real-life UFO encounter. So, grab your Scooby Snacks, and let's dive into the Exeter Incident—where the truth is out there, and it's spookier than you think!
    Visit us online at itsmysteryinc.com
    Join Unmasked at Patreon.com/itsmysteryinc


    Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands

    Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy

    • 36 min

Customer Reviews

4.3 out of 5
121 Ratings

121 Ratings

Essa9540! ,

Thank you Jesus! 🙌

I look forward to hanging out with my best friends that I’ve never met, each week. Everyone has the best sense of humor and the best laughs. Love all the banter and obviously the stories… but mostly the fun banter. Bless your hearts. ~ Kat

Savannah Marchione ,

awesomeness

one of my favorite podcast. i love the back and forth between everyone and the laughing and giggling. i love hearing about kims daughter and shane and joshs grandmother, and i love hearing about their childhood stories. i love hearing all the stories and yalls take on it. keep up the great work guys, and Kim i love hearing your voice on the podcast.
Savannah Marchione

Bugdootle ,

So funny!!

I love these three!! They enjoy each other so much it’s like listening to friends!!

Top Podcasts In Comedy

The Joe Rogan Experience
Joe Rogan
Call Her Daddy
Alex Cooper
SmartLess
Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, Will Arnett
The Lonely Island and Seth Meyers Podcast
The Lonely Island & Seth Meyers
Wiser Than Me with Julia Louis-Dreyfus
Lemonada Media
Pretty Sure I Can Fly with Johnny Knoxville & Elna Baker
SmartLess Media

You Might Also Like

Foul Play: Crime Series
Shane L. Waters, Wendy Cee, Gemma Hoskins
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
Unseen
Unseen
SERIALously
10 to LIFE
Odd Trails
Andy Tate and Brandon Lanier