Monday Morning Cubs Show

Carl + Mahoney
  • 5.0 (180)
  • Sports
  • Updated Weekly

A show every Monday morning about the Chicago Cubs from Carl and Mahoney.

  1. 1d ago

    If You Believe In PCA Then You Have To Go All In

    The Cubs are doing something that should change how we talk about the deadline: they’re sitting in the top tier of MLB offenses by team OPS while also playing elite, mistake-resistant defense. That is not a “rebuild” profile. That is a team that can win playoff games, right now, if the pitching side gets real support. I walk through why Pete Crow-Armstrong’s season matters so much to the front office calculus. When you have a player tracking like a true difference-maker in center field, the responsible move is to ask what gives him the best October runway. For me, that points straight at starting pitching at the top of the market. I lay out the high-end fantasy of Tarik Skubal, why it’s probably unrealistic with Detroit competing, and why I’d still consider paying a painful prospect price if the opportunity somehow exists. Then we get into what’s more realistic at the MLB trade deadline: how I think about Joe Ryan versus Freddie Peralta, and why “good starter” is not the same thing as “Game 1 Wild Card starter at Wrigley Field.” We also hit the bullpen problem, including why a name like Mason Miller is so hard to acquire and why the better path might be creative, under-the-radar reliever adds that actually fit October usage. If you’ve been wondering whether the Cubs should buy, how aggressive they should be, and what a smart buy even looks like, this is the roadmap. Subscribe, share the show with a Cubs fan, and leave a review, then tell me which pitcher you’d target and what you’d give up for him. Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

  2. Jul 13

    1st Half Recap w/ Special Guest CB: The Cubs Can Still Win The Division

    The Cubs hit the All-Star break with a record that should feel safe, but nobody watching this team feels relaxed. We’re five back in the NL Central, sitting in the playoff mix, and still arguing every morning about what the Cubs actually are. So we brought CB back to help us do a real first-half reset, from the emotional swings to the numbers that matter and the roster flaws that won’t stay hidden forever.  We start with the biggest storyline in Chicago: Pete Crow-Armstrong. We lay out why PCA’s defense, power, speed, and improved approach put him in the National League MVP conversation, and why the “with or without him” test makes the Cubs look like a completely different club. From there we get into the hard stuff: the Alex Bregman contract, what $35M per year needs to buy you, and how the Cubs can’t keep living with a pitching staff that gives up too many home runs.  Then we go straight at the MLB trade deadline. Is one ace enough to make a run in October, or do the Cubs need multiple starters plus real bullpen upgrades? We talk medical risk, prospect cost, and what the front office should prioritize if the offense keeps forcing the issue. We also give Seiya Suzuki his flowers, touch on the Cubs MLB Draft approach, and close with a fast mailbag on division goals, sellers, and second-half expectations.  Subscribe, share the show with a friend, and leave a review. What’s your No. 1 move you want the Cubs to make before the deadline? Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

  3. Jul 10

    Why Craig Counsell’s Anger Might Be Good News For The Cubs

    Something feels different with the Chicago Cubs right now, and it isn’t a single box score. It’s the heat. When Craig Counsell looks genuinely furious after a loss, when the frustration is visible and specific, it tells me the wins and losses are starting to matter in a sharper way again and that’s a big deal heading into the All-Star break and the MLB trade deadline. We talk through the Orioles series, the temptation to blame umpires, and why that’s a dead end when you score two runs. Then we get into what I actually care about: urgency, buy-in, and the hard truth that a lot of major league players become emotionally numb over time. I break down why a manager showing “breaking points” can be healthy, how clubhouse culture changes when losses sting, and why the edge isn’t always found in the cleanest spreadsheet comparison. From there, we look forward: what Jed Hoyer needs to do to upgrade the bullpen and add proven arms, what the Cubs should aim for in the final series before the break, and how we should be thinking about trade packages and real roster costs. I also get into a Cubs broadcast rant, what the best broadcasters have always done for fans, and why that matters more than people admit. If you’re watching this season closely and trying to figure out whether the Cubs are building toward something real, hit play. Subscribe, share the show with a Cubs fan, and leave a rating or review so more people can find us. Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

  4. Jul 6

    Dansby Swanson’s Surge And The Cubs’ Second-Half Blueprint

    A perfect Cubs week doesn’t exist, but this one comes close to capturing the whole experience: a monster win, a brutal loss, a Cardinals series that swings your mood every inning, and just enough momentum to make you believe again. We’re back on the Monday Morning Cubs Show after a July 4th break and a real-life disaster at home, then we get right into what actually matters for the second half: how good can this team be when the best version of its core shows up at the same time? Dansby Swanson is the heartbeat of the conversation. We break down the hottest two-week run you’ll see from any hitter, and the stat that makes it even stranger: eight home runs and 26 RBI over 51 plate appearances with zero walks. That turns into a deeper Cubs hitting discussion about approach, timing, and how pitchers were stealing easy early-count strikes against him earlier in the season. We also talk John Mallee, what “it clicked” can really mean for a veteran, and why Swanson’s high-end outcomes change the ceiling for the entire lineup. Then we zoom out to the standings, the All-Star break, and the trade deadline. We make the case for Pete Crow-Armstrong as the lone Cubs All-Star, why we love that he’s skipping the Home Run Derby, and what “Wild Card team” actually means when your starting pitching is hanging on. Finally, we wrestle with the big one: would you trade Matt Shaw to land an ace like Tarik Skubal if the goal is October baseball, not just chasing the Brewers? If you’re riding with the Cubs right now, subscribe, share the show with a fellow fan, and leave us a review so we can keep building this Monday routine together. Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

  5. Jun 29

    THE CUBS ARE BACK

    A road series in Milwaukee can either expose you or announce you, and the Cubs just delivered the kind of weekend that makes the division race feel alive again. We walk through how this team climbed out of a rough start to that soft stretch of the schedule, why the last 15 games matter more than any single headline, and how a gritty extra-inning win can change the whole tone of a clubhouse. If you’re tracking the NL Central standings and asking whether the Cubs are real contenders, this conversation is built for you.  Then we get into the stuff fans actually argue about: effort and leadership. We go all-in on the Alex Bregman baseline jog and why it hits a nerve when you’re paid like a centerpiece. It’s not about sprinting like you’re chasing a record, it’s about setting a standard in games decided by one bobble, one extra 90 feet, one moment of pressure.  From there it’s pure Cubs baseball analysis. We give Seiya Suzuki his flowers for the weekend’s biggest swings, break down what the Cubs offense seems built to do, and talk pitching realities. David Peterson’s debut leads into a wider trade-deadline lesson on why June deals take time, plus how a ground-ball starter fits better behind a top-tier Cubs defense. We also face the bullpen injury carousel head-on, shout out Jordan Wicks for a season-shifting moment, and preview the Padres and Cardinals at Wrigley as the first half closes.  If this gave you hope or fired you up, subscribe, share the show with a fellow Cubs fan, and leave a review so more Monday morning maniacs can find us. What’s your biggest takeaway from the Brewers series win? Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

  6. Jun 26

    Brewers Scouting Report + David Peterson Trade Breakdown

    The Cubs finally feel fun again, and the timing could not be more intense: three games in Milwaukee against a Brewers team that plays ruthless, disciplined baseball and runs out the kind of pitching that can erase your best plans by the second inning. We’re coming off a 10 and 4 stretch, the offense is cooking, and the fan base is right back on that knife edge between realism and belief. That’s exactly where a good season lives.  We talk through why this Brewers series matters so much, starting with what has actually changed for Chicago. Pete Crow Armstrong has turned the leadoff spot into gasoline, getting on base, creating pressure and looking more and more like a real superstar. At the same time, the Cubs rotation is in crisis: Justin Steele is not coming back, the injuries keep stacking, and the front office cannot afford to wish its way to innings. That context is why the David Peterson trade is worth a deeper look, including advanced pitching metrics like FIP, the role of ground balls, and why moving from the Mets defense to an elite Cubs defense could change his results fast.  Then we pivot to the opponent and the problem: Milwaukee wins without homers, scores a ton of runs anyway, and prevents runs with pitching, strikeouts and clean execution. We dig into what makes Pat Murphy’s group a machine, why Jacob Mizorowski’s triple digit fastball changes how you have to approach at bats, and what the Cubs must do to survive this weekend. If you like smart Cubs talk with real edge, subscribe, share the show with a friend, and leave a quick review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

  7. Jun 22

    The 2026 Cubs Can't Waste Pete Crow-Armonstrong

    A cycle can be a party trick, or it can be a signal flare. Pete Crow-Armstrong’s cycle at Wrigley Field sparks a bigger question for us: are the Chicago Cubs treating PCA like the engine of the team, or are they sleepwalking through the clearest franchise player moment they’ve had in years? We start with the emotional reality of being a Cubs fan right now. One night you see 16 runs and think the offense is turning a corner. The next night the bullpen melts down and the whole week feels fragile. That swing is why we dig into the Cubs’ identity struggle, why “just add another bat” can be a distraction, and why the pitching staff, especially the late innings, decides the team’s ceiling. We also talk about the value of raw postgame honesty, but why quotes do not save you when the same leaks keep happening. From there we get practical: Matt Shaw’s case for everyday reps, the roster math that makes Moises Ballesteros getting optioned make sense, and why a player like Justin Dean can matter when you only have a few bench spots to work with. We also put guardrails around the hope of injured arms returning, including Matthew Boyd, and explain why smaller moves like the Jaden Murray trade can quietly reveal how thin pitching depth really is. Finally, we preview the Mets series with a simple mindset: play clean, avoid late-inning disasters, and stack wins before Milwaukee. Subscribe for more Cubs talk, share the show with a fellow fan, and leave a rating and review if you want us to keep building these Monday mornings. What’s your biggest priority right now: bullpen help, a starter, or lineup stability? Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

  8. Jun 19

    Cody Delmendo Interview + Are The 2026 Cubs Buyers Or Sellers?

    Pete Crow-Armstrong is forcing a different conversation about the Chicago Cubs. When a center fielder is playing like an MVP and leading the league in WAR, you stop treating the season like a slow drift and start asking harder questions: are we buying at the MLB trade deadline, or are we wasting a rare window? We bring on Cody Delmendo from the Off The Ivy podcast and get brutally specific about what’s broken and what’s still real. We argue through the deadline “sell vs buy” debate, then put the blame where it belongs when a roster built to contend plays like it’s stuck in neutral. Alex Bregman’s struggles come up for a reason: money, expectations, and the way Matt Shaw’s rise makes every quiet Bregman night feel like a spotlight. We also talk Dansby Swanson, why defense still matters, and why fans lose sleep when league-average offense disappears. On the pitching side, we dig into Ben Brown’s growth, what it means when he can survive without his best stuff, and why the Cubs can’t treat injuries as background noise anymore. We also map out what “smart buying” looks like: add pitching without lighting the farm system on fire unless the Cubs actually look like a World Series team. If you’re a Cubs fan trying to balance rage with hope, this one is for you. Subscribe on Apple or Spotify, share it with your group chat, and leave a review if you want to help the show grow. What would you do at the deadline: buy, hold, or sell? Thanks for tuning in!  - Carl & Mahoney

See All (123)

5
out of 5
180 Ratings

About

A show every Monday morning about the Chicago Cubs from Carl and Mahoney.

Information

  • Creator
    Carl + Mahoney
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2026
  • Episodes
    123
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 Monday Morning Cubs Show
  • Show Website
    Monday Morning Cubs Show

You Might Also Like