Ope, it's Murder

Lindsey and Libbie

Behind every small town is a story. Some are darker than others. Two Midwest best friends digging into shocking murders, forgotten cold cases, and unsettling mysteries from Wisconsin and beyond. Fueled by strong coffee, investigative curiosity, and a belief that every victim's story matters.

  1. 2d ago

    A Trip to the Swimming Hole, A Chilling Discovery, A Murder That Haunts Wauwatosa — The Buddy Schumacher Case

    In 1925, eight-year-old Arthur “Buddy” Schumacher Jr. disappeared from Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, after heading out with friends. His disappearance sparked a desperate search, but days later, the discovery of his body turned a missing child investigation into a heartbreaking murder mystery. More than a century later, Buddy's murder remains unsolved. In this episode of Ope, It's Murder, Lindsey and Libbie explore the events surrounding Buddy's disappearance, the investigation that followed, the suspects, and the unanswered questions that have lingered for generations. Special thanks to author Paul Hoffman, whose book helped bring Buddy's story back into the spotlight. Season 2 Coffee Sponsor: Terra Verde Organic Coffee Fuel your true crime obsession with delicious organic coffee! Use code OPE10 when ordering.  Sources & References Paul J. Hoffman, Murder in Wauwatosa: The Mysterious Death of Buddy Schumacher (2012). A detailed examination of Buddy's disappearance, the investigation, suspects, and unanswered questions. Special thanks to author Paul Hoffman for providing us with his book. https://paulhoffmanauthor.com/about-my-books/the-book/about-the-book/OnMilwaukee: Murder in Wauwatosa: Hoffman Recounts a Tragic Murder Close to Home https://onmilwaukee.com/articles/buddyschumacherWauwatosa Now: Hermit Endures Scrutiny of Slain Boy's Friends in 1925, by Paul Hoffman. https://archive.wauwatosanow.com/news/99954044.html/Shepherd Express: Murder in Wauwatosa, Book Review https://shepherdexpress.com/culture/books/murder-wauwatosa-mysterious-death-buddy-schumacher-history-press-paul-hoffman/Marquette University, Children in Urban America Collection: Historical Milwaukee Sentinel coverage of Buddy Schumacher's murder, published August 1, 1937. https://www.marquette.edu/cgi-bin/cuap/db.cgi?ID=1139&mh=1&uid=default&view=SearchSend us Fan Mail Support the show https://www.buzzsprout.com/2627188/supporters/new

  2. Oct 31

    A Body in the Ashes, an Axe & a Century-Old Crime — The Kellnersville Murder.

    In 1926, a devastating fire in Kellnersville, Wisconsin, uncovered something far more sinister than anyone could have imagined. Among the ashes was the body of Mrs. Yohanek, and what initially appeared to be a tragic fire would become a chilling murder investigation involving an axe, unanswered questions, and a small community shaken by violence. What followed was a disturbing investigation into the circumstances surrounding Mrs. Yohanek's death and the events that led to that fateful night. In this episode, Lindsey and Libbie uncover the chilling details of the 1926 Kellnersville murder, the evidence surrounding the case, the investigation that followed, and the devastating impact on a small Wisconsin community. Was the fire meant to conceal a brutal crime? And what really happened to Mrs. Yohanek before her body was discovered among the ashes? A special thank-you to our episode sponsor, Guillette Photography, for supporting Ope, It's Murder! Check out their work at https://guillettephotography.mypixieset.com/ Listener discretion is advised. This episode contains discussions of graphic violence and homicide. Send us Fan Mail Guillette PhotographyReady to transform everyday moments into timeless memories?Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.Support the show https://www.buzzsprout.com/2627188/supporters/new

    A Body in the Ashes, an Axe & a Century-Old Crime — The Kellnersville Murder.
  3. Oct 12

    A Winter Night, A Body Beneath the Snow, 35 Years Without Answers — The Murder of Traci Hammerberg

    In December 1984, 18-year-old Traci Hammerberg disappeared after a night out in Wisconsin. Hours later, her body was discovered beneath the snow near a driveway in Ozaukee County. For more than three decades, Traci’s murder remained unsolved. Investigators never gave up. And 35 years later, advances in forensic science and genetic genealogy finally gave them the break they had been waiting for. This week on Ope, It’s Murder, Lindsey and Libbie walk through Traci’s final hours, the investigation that followed, the evidence that remained preserved for decades, and the technology that ultimately helped investigators identify her killer. This episode is sponsored by Fiddleheads Coffee Roasters. A Wisconsin favorite keeping us caffeinated while we dig into another Midwest case. This episode is also sponsored by Dakota Spotlight: Call Me Shelly. The documentary follows the decades-long search for answers in the 1994 disappearance of Michele “Shelly” Julson from Bismarck, North Dakota. Lindsey and Libbie will also be attending a screening of the film! Primary reporting and supporting sources used for this episode include: Ozaukee Press reporting on the identification of Philip Cross and the decades-long investigationOzaukee Press retrospective reporting on the investigationFOX6 Milwaukee reporting on the 2019 genetic-genealogy breakthroughWisconsin Public Radio reporting on the forensic-genealogy investigationABC News coverage of the identification of Philip CrossNBC News coverage of the caseAdditional background material and archival reporting supplied during episode researchVideo sources supplied during episode researchSend us Fan Mail FiddleheadsBrewing Excellence.Dakota SpotlightTrue Crime Done DifferentlyDisclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.Support the show https://www.buzzsprout.com/2627188/supporters/new

    A Winter Night, A Body Beneath the Snow, 35 Years Without Answers — The Murder of Traci Hammerberg
  4. Sep 14

    A Night of Violence, A Manhunt Across Southeast Wisconsin, A Community Left Searching for Answers—The Murder of Victoria “Vikki” Truss

    A quiet Shorewood neighborhood. A mother whose life was taken. And a violent manhunt that ended in a high-speed chase and shootout with police. In Episode 6, Lindsey and Libbie tell the story of Victoria “Vikki” Truss, a 34-year-old mother whose murder in July 2025 shook the Milwaukee-area community—and raised difficult conversations about domestic violence and the warning signs that came before her death. This episode is sponsored by Stone Creek Coffee out of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Use code OPE10 for 10% off your next order. Primary and supporting sources used for this episode: FOX6 Milwaukee — July 2025 Shorewood shooting coverage and January 2026 release of police dashcam/bodycam footageWISN 12 — Victoria Truss family interview and vigil coverageCBS 58 — initial Shorewood shooting coverage, vigil coverage, and January 2026 Glendale Police bodycam/dashcam releaseMilwaukee Journal Sentinel — reporting on Vikki's May 11 police call, search-warrant records, Griffin's prior arrest/referral history, and family/community remembranceTMJ4 — Shorewood officer bodycam footage and identification/background reportingSearch-warrant information reported by local Milwaukee news organizationsGoFundMe organized by Antonio Truss — family-provided information about Vikki and support for her sonStone Creek Coffee — company history and informationAdditional video and social-media materials supplied during researchPRODUCTION NOTE: Because Michael Griffin died on July 3, 2025 and was never tried for Victoria Truss's murder, retain attribution such as “according to investigators,” “according to court filings,” and “Vikki's family said” wherever the underlying fact depends on those sources rather than a criminal conviction. Send us Fan Mail Stone Creek CoffeeDisclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.Support the show https://www.buzzsprout.com/2627188/supporters/new

    A Night of Violence, A Manhunt Across Southeast Wisconsin,  A Community Left Searching for Answers—The Murder of Victoria “Vikki” Truss
  5. Aug 31

    A Date Gone Wrong, A Twisted Web of Lies, A Life Taken Too Soon — The Murder of Sydney Loofe

    A date arranged through Tinder. A young woman who never made it home. And a case that would uncover a disturbing web of lies, manipulation, and murder. In Episode 5 of Ope, It’s Murder, we tell the story of 24-year-old Sydney Loofe and the investigation that led authorities to Bailey Boswell and Aubrey Trail. As their stories began to unravel, investigators uncovered disturbing allegations and evidence surrounding Sydney’s final days. This episode is proudly sponsored by Chet Hardin, author of The Vampire’s Cult, an in-depth look at the twisted case surrounding Sydney’s murder. Primary and supporting sources used for this episode: Sydney Irene Loofe obituary — Snider Memorial Funeral HomeState v. Trail — Nebraska Supreme CourtState v. Boswell — Nebraska Supreme CourtNebraska Public Media — coverage of Aubrey Trail's sentencingCBS News / Associated Press — coverage of Trail's appealWOWT — coverage of the Nebraska Supreme Court decision affirming Boswell's convictionCourthouse News Service — coverage of Boswell's sentencingThe Vampire's Cult — Chet HardinAdditional background/timeline research supplied for this episodeHost note: When discussing the alleged cult, witchcraft, torture, sexual practices, or plans to kill, continue using language such as "according to testimony," "prosecutors argued," "the State alleged," or "Trail claimed." Trail gave multiple contradictory accounts of Sydney's death, so his statements should not be presented as independently established facts unless corroborated by the court record. Send us Fan Mail The Vampire's Cult-Chet HardinThe Untold Story of Obsession, Control, and a Shocking Small-Town Murder.Disclaimer: This post contains affiliate links. If you make a purchase, I may receive a commission at no extra cost to you.Support the show https://www.buzzsprout.com/2627188/supporters/new

    A Date Gone Wrong, A Twisted Web of Lies, A Life Taken Too Soon — The Murder of Sydney Loofe

Trailers

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
4 Ratings

About

Behind every small town is a story. Some are darker than others. Two Midwest best friends digging into shocking murders, forgotten cold cases, and unsettling mysteries from Wisconsin and beyond. Fueled by strong coffee, investigative curiosity, and a belief that every victim's story matters.

You Might Also Like