Illegitimate Scholar

Samuel Urban
  • 4.8 (20)
  • SOCIETY & CULTURE
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Our culture is in crisis and I don’t trust woke universities and authoritarian governments to give us the solution. I examine modern culture through history and anthropology, as well as other sources like indigenous knowledge and common sense. This is a show for those who love academics but hate academia, and want to learn about social studies without the constraining limits of woke universities. Reach me on Discord, https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj and other sites: https://pod.link/1650280020, If you have any thoughts you'd like to share please email me: IllegitimateScholar@gmail.com

  1. 08/24/2025

    079 - Mysteries of Ancient Civilizations w/ Michael Button

    Exploring Ancient History with Michael Button: Lost Civilizations, Mainstream Archeology, and Alternative Theories In this episode of Illegitimate Scholar, we delve into the fascinating world of ancient history and alternative theories with Michael Button, a YouTuber known for his content on lost civilizations and the debate surrounding mainstream archeology. He was recently on the Joe Rogan experience podcast (JRE) discussing his ideas with Joe Rogan (this episode was recorded before that). Michael discusses his educational background in ancient history, his disillusionment with traditional teaching methods, and his journey into making YouTube videos. He discusses inspirations in Graham Hancock and Randall Carlson and their views on lost ancient civilizations and the story of our past The conversation covers a wide range of topics, including the significance of sites like Gobekli Tepe, the impact of natural disasters on human civilization, and the role of myths in understanding our past. Michael also shares his views on the accusations of racism in the alternative history space and emphasizes the importance of allowing speculation and open interpretation in historical discussions. Michael's Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@MichaelButton1 Housekeeping: Sorry for the delay. Personal Issues. Should be back on track now.  00:00 Clips 00:34 Michael Button 01:56 Discovering Alternative History 04:32 UK vs USA Academics 07:31 Impact of the Catastrophe Course 14:25 Megafauna Extinction Theories 21:19 What makes an advanced civilization? 23:12 Gobekli Tepe 35:27 Interconnected Ancient Societies 37:26 Hunter-Gatherer Complexity 41:55 Egyptian Civilization and Zep Tepi 50:11 The Role of Myth in History 57:01 Modern Interpretations and Controversies 01:04:01 Racism and Alternative History Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    1h 11m

  2. 04/27/2025

    078 - Christian Mysticism is the Solution to Modern Problems

    Patreon so I can keep doing this: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar  Scott Manion on Philosophy, Spirituality, and Modern Corruption In this episode of Illegitimate Scholar, Scott Mannion joins me. Scott is a former Australian filmmaker and director to discuss Christian Mysticism. He discusses how he left his former job based on the issues he saw in modern life, the west, and in Hollywood. We discuss the differences between Christian Mysticism and Evangelicals, Eastern philosophies and beliefs, and other comparisons. We discuss a Christian Theocracy in the future and how else to solve the issues of the modern world. Ill Scholar Patreon:  Scott's Website: https://scottmannion.com/ Scott's Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@ScottMannion 00:00 Scott Mannion 00:41 Intro 02:14 Woke Hollywood 03:50 Philosophical Exploration 07:44 The Role of Values and Morality 12:49 The Crisis of Modernity 21:04 The Intersection of Technology and Tradition 39:15 Christian Mysticism and Spiritual Practices 44:16 Spiritual Phenomena and Symbolic Communication 48:15 Grace and Mysticism in Christian Practice 51:33 Loss of Value in Modernity 57:30 Shamanism and Mysticism 01:08:15 Evangelical Christianity and Modernity 01:14:04 Christian Theocracy 01:17:21 Religion and the Second Renaissance 01:19:33 Collective Unconscious and the Renaissance 01:23:28 Paganism and the Will to Power 01:28:19 The Role of Christ and Spiritual Practices Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    1h 37m

  3. 03/27/2025

    077 - Uncovering European Origins | Yamnaya, Celts, Vikings w/ Survive the Jive

    Origins of European Cultures & History Behind 'Survive the Jive' |  Interview with Tom Rowsell Tom Rowsell, from the Youtube Channel: 'Survive the Jive' joins us on Illegitimate Scholar. He delves into the history of European peoples primarily during the pre-Christian era. He discusses the origins and significance of horse domestication, the evolution of pastoral societies, and the Indo-European cultural expansions.We compare  Tom explains the background of his YouTube channel, 'Survive the Jive,'. He provides insights into various historical periods, ancient rituals, and social dynamics, including the impacts of different technological advancements and cultural exchanges. Tom also touches upon his personal heritage and the interconnection between media influence, philosophical inquiry, and ancestral religion. Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar $5/MONTH  Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholar Survive the Jive Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/@Survivethejive/featured Tom Rowsell X: https://x.com/Tom_Rowsell 00:00 Intro 00:48 Survive the Jive 01:30 Early Youtube 04:09 History of European Peoples 16:47 Horse Domestication Changing Culture 21:28 Bride Stealing 24:19 Value in Different Cultures 33:26 Technological Advancements and Cultural Shifts 37:19 Feuding Cultures and Honor Societies 39:48 Anatolian Farmers in Europe 40:53 Scandinavian Hunter-Gatherers 43:14 Hunter-Gatherers Meeting Farmers 47:34 Norman Influence & the Commons 49:41 Irish, British, Ancestry 56:15 Scots-Irish in America 58:26 Ulster Scots vs Scots-Irish 01:03:00 Home Counties to Devon 01:06:14 Cornish and Devonian Traditions 01:20:49 Bronze Age Trade  01:25:40 Philosophy and Paganism Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    1h 30m

  4. 03/11/2025

    076 - The Psychology of Group Interactions

    Exploring Group Dynamics and Organizational Culture with Brent Elwood and Aan Moore Brent Elwood, and Aodhan Moore join me on Illegitimate Scholar Podcast episode 76 to discuss group dynamics, organizational culture, and the influence of mythic archetypes on human interactions. They discuss their book, 'God Heroes and Groups Relational Dynamics Through Mythic Archetypes,' and the impact of Carl Jung's, Joseph Campbell's, and other thinkers' work on their studies. The conversation touches on projection, empathy, crisis compulsion in organizations, and how recognizing these dynamics can transform leadership and group interventions. This insightful episode is essential for anyone interested in the deeper psychological and cultural aspects of group interactions. Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar $5/MONTH  Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholar https://www.groupdynamicslab.com/ "Gods, Heroes and Groups: Relational Dynamics through Mythic Archetypes" Book: https://firingthemind.com/product/9781800132870/ Aodhán Moran X: https://x.com/aodhanpmoran Brant Elwood X: https://x.com/TheGroupLens 00:00 Brent Evans 01:12 Aodhan Moore 01:51 'God, Heroes, and Groups' 03:54 Group Relations Examples 05:30 The Role of Archetypes in Modern Culture 13:32 Religion, Culture, and Archetypes 18:37 The Decline of Religious Practice and Its Consequences 27:23 Group Dynamics and Social Justice 38:25 Franz De Waal's Work 38:56 Bonobo Society and Infanticide 40:16 Human Monogamy and DNA Testing 41:50 Leadership and Power in Groups 44:15 The Influence of Small Groups in Politics 47:55 Group Dynamics in Conferences 49:03 The Mythic Application in Leadership 55:51 Coursework and Practical Applications 01:10:25 The Crisis Compulsion in Organizations Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    1h 18m

  5. 03/01/2025

    075 - Anthropologist Exposes How Activists took over Anthropology

    Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Dr Weiss's Book (On the Warpath: My Battles With Indians, Pretendians, and Woke Warriors): https://amzn.to/3EZktCf Dr Weiss on X: https://x.com/eweissunburied Controversy in Anthropology: Elizabeth Weiss on Repatriation, Academic Freedom, and Identity Politics In this episode, Elizabeth Weiss, a physical anthropologist and Professor Emeritus at San Jose State University, discusses her experiences with academic freedom, repatriation laws, and the impact of woke ideology on anthropology. She details her legal battle with her university based on her research and statements. Those statements about sex differences in skeletons and views on repatriation under NAGPRA were once acceptable but became not. Weiss provides insights into the ethical and scientific challenges posed by the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA). She explores how current identity politics are influencing the field of Anthropology and gives examples. The discussion also touches on the controversy surrounding the Kennewick Man and other paleo-Indian remains. Weiss shares her views on the importance of preserving academic freedom and scientific integrity in anthropology. 00:00 075 Elizabeth Weiss 00:41 Dr. Elizabeth Weiss 01:53 NAGPRA 04:07 Repatriation Ideology 13:47 The Kennewick Man Case 26:27 Race & Gender by Skeletal Remains 34:43 Skull Measuring Then vs Now 39:54 Political Leanings in Anthropology 42:28 Academic Freedom & Risk 46:07 Consequences of Lawsuit 50:08 Repatriation Law Changes 2024 52:57 Dealing with the SAA 57:38 Issues with Modern Anthropology 01:03:48 Use of Skeletal Remains Changing Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    1h 15m

  6. 02/12/2025

    074 - Red Tail Hawk - Ancient Knowledge

    Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar $5/MONTH  Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholar Red Tail Hawk Talks Reincarnation, Ancient Apocalypse, and Serpent Symbolism | Illegitimate Scholar Podcast In Episode 74 of the Illegitimate Scholar Podcast, Red Tail Hawk shares his profound journey that began with an encounter with a Pascua Yaqui medicine man. He delves into the significance of his name, his experiences in 2018, and the powerful phenomenon he encountered. The conversation explores the Pascua Yaqui culture, reincarnation research, and Case Study evidence from the University of Virginia. Red Tail Hawk discusses spiritual awakening, the interconnectedness of ancient wisdom traditions, and the symbolism of serpents across cultures. The episode also examines geomagnetic pole shifts, ancient lost civilizations like Mu, and the fascinating theories surrounding megastructures and megaliths. This comprehensive discussion intertwines ancient philosophies, esoteric knowledge, and modern scientific findings. 00:00 Introduction to Red Tail Hawk 00:08 Pascua Yaqui Medicine Man 05:39 Journey Through Different Faiths 14:11 Reincarnation Research and Case Studies 33:59 Ancient Civilizations and Cataclysmic Events 58:10 Magnetic Forces and Polar Shifts 59:13 Galactic Current Sheet Impact 01:03:04 Cataclysmic Floods and Evolution 01:18:53 Genesis and Cataclysmic Events 01:35:51 Lost Civilizations and Ancient Languages 01:59:31 Exploring Qi Energy Centers 02:00:24 Medicine Man and the Aura 02:03:06 Ancient Energy Healing Traditions 02:07:13 Kundalini and Chakra Activation 02:12:10 Serpent Symbolism Across Cultures 02:46:30 Megaliths and Geopolymers Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    2h 55m

  7. 01/06/2025

    073 - Central European History, Academia, & the Modern World

    Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar ONLY $2/MONTH Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholar Central-European History, Academia, and a Personal Postcard Collection Stephan Sander-Faes X: https://x.com/sksanderfaes Postcard Collection Substack: https://espc.substack.com/ A Deep Dive into Central-European History, Academia, and a Personal Postcard Collection In this episode of the Illegitimate Scholar Podcast, I am joined by Stephan, a historian of European history, currently a tenured associate professor at the University of Bergen, Norway. We explore a wide range of topics including the performative absurdities in academia, the historical intricacies of the Balkans, and how language shapes identity. We also delve into Stefan's unique personal project of preserving vintage postcards from his grandfather's collection, covering places and eras now lost to time. This episode offers a deep, multifaceted look into European history, academic culture, and the personal stories carried through generations. 00:00 Clips 01:13 Intro 02:04 Geographical and Cultural Comparisons 04:21 Academic and Professional Journeys 09:02 Historical Insights and Naval History 11:59 Tourism and Cultural Reflections 34:46 Cruise Tours and Scenic Journeys 35:46 Norwegian Commutes and Waterborne Transport 41:15 Historical Reflections and Academic Tributes 47:33 Religious Conflicts and Cultural Preservation 01:25:09 The Rise of the Austrian Institute of Science and Technology 01:26:35 Gaming the Academic System 01:27:05 University Rankings and Funding 01:30:27 Personal Anecdotes and Academic Experiences 01:38:41 The Lost Art of Postcards and Family History 02:11:00 Discussing Grandfather's Surrender and POW Camps 02:13:09 Grandfather's Post-War Life and Career 02:15:35 Reflections on Sharing War Experiences 02:20:38 Academic Career and Historical Research 02:25:48 Cultural and Political Observations Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    2h 60m

  8. 12/14/2024

    072 - Graham Hancock: Ancient Civilizations & Academia

    Graham Hancock Fact Checking Flint Dibble Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PEe72Nj-AW0 Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar ONLY $2/MONTH  Axios Fitness: https://axios-remote-fitness-coaching.ck.page/scholar Exploring Ancient Mysteries and Alternative Histories with Graham Hancock In this episode, acclaimed author and researcher Graham Hancock joins me on the Illegitimate Scholar Podcast (Cannot believe I just typed that) delves deep into the discussion about ancient civilization, the legacy of shamanistic practices, and the vitriolic response of mainstream academia, specifically archaeology to his ideas. Hancock shares his thoughts on the limitations of archaeological interpretations and the potential for a lost advanced civilization that has left behind a significant legacy. The conversation also explores themes such as the importance of spiritual traditions, the loss of shamanism and spirituality in the West, the precision of ancient astronomical observations, and the position of psychedelics in human history. Hancock provides a comprehensive look at why questioning established narratives is crucial for a more inclusive understanding of our past 00:00 Intro 00:45 Setting Up 00:59 Graham Hancock's Background 01:52 Scottish & Irish Independence 03:47 Archaeological Monopoly on the Past 08:34 Methods of Controlling Narrative 13:35 Ancient Sites & Who Gets Access 19:34 Hancock's Response to Lies 23:23 Evidence Archaeology Ignores 38:23 The Clovis First Paradigm 47:50 Ancient Ideas in Modern Structures 53:56 Ad 54:53 Shamanism and Altered States of Consciousness 59:21 Astronomy & Ancient Cultures 01:06:40 Psychedelics in the Past & Today 01:30:11 Rapa Nui: Pilgrimage Site? 01:35:18 Concluding Thoughts and Season Two Highlights Discord: https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/IllegitimateScholar Audio Podcast: https://pod.link/1650280020 Twitter.com: https://twitter.com/ill_scholar Youtube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRH77S0fVLmAZU4xLnAxuvw

    1h 38m
See All (106)

Trailer

4.8
out of 5
20 Ratings

About

Our culture is in crisis and I don’t trust woke universities and authoritarian governments to give us the solution. I examine modern culture through history and anthropology, as well as other sources like indigenous knowledge and common sense. This is a show for those who love academics but hate academia, and want to learn about social studies without the constraining limits of woke universities. Reach me on Discord, https://discord.gg/KhJgpMj6Jj and other sites: https://pod.link/1650280020, If you have any thoughts you'd like to share please email me: IllegitimateScholar@gmail.com

Information

  • Creator
    Samuel Urban
  • Years Active
    2022 - 2025
  • Episodes
    106
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © 2025 Illegitimate Scholar
  • Show Website
    Illegitimate Scholar

You Might Also Like