PROXY COUNTDOWN

Free Float Media, Inc.

In the style of ESPN, The Proxy Countdown is an American pre-game show broadcast by Free Float as part of the company's coverage of the the executives and directors who control the corporate world. The show spotlights important CEO transitions, features contentious boardroom battles, and highlights shareholder votes at the alternative democracy of annual corporate shareholder meetings. Because unlike athletes, investors can get in the game.

  1. 4d ago

    Finding the next Nvidia

    This is Proxy Countdown. Welcome to the big show for the week of November 9, 2026 alongside my tag team partner Matt Moscardi. I'm Damion Rallis. On today’s countdown: NVIDIA retires its leather jacket A Costco director rides the blue wave John Chevedden keeps screaming into the void Ethan Allen shows how corporate governance actually works And on the Big Vote, Matt dissects the NVIDIA clownshow Trade Wire Top Stories: 100 Filings since October 21st The headlines Nvidia NVIDIA’s board has accepted the resignation of CEO/Chair/director Jen-Hsun Huang, effective immediately. Colette Kress, who has been CFO since 2013, has been named interim CEO while the Board conducts a search for a new CEO. She will pull triple duty: interim CEO, CFO, and face of the apology tour. The board also appointed Harvey Jones as the new Chair. Harvey is a member of the original brat pack, having served for three decades alongside Jensen, Tench Coxe, and Brooke Seawell. Why Harvey and not Lead Director Stephen Neal, who at least appears to be independent from Jensen and notably appears to have the perfect background to represent this mess, reading from the bio in NVIDIA’s proxy statement: “In addition to his extensive experience as a trial lawyer on a broad range of corporate issues, Mr. Neal has represented and advised numerous boards of directors, special committees of boards, and individual directors on corporate governance and other legal matters” In case you're curious, the word “succession” appears zero times in NVIDIA’s proxy statement. So maybe we need a sacrificial lamb of the board to “resign by choice” too. As a point of comparison, NVIDIA;’s main competitor, which coincidentally is led by another powerful CEO and Jensen’s cousin, Lisa Su, mentions “succession” 11 times: “As required by its charter, the Compensation Committee regularly reviews succession planning and talent development. The Compensation Committee at least annually reviews succession plans for the Chief Executive Officer ” as an example. A rarity at Liberty Media: the elimination of Super-Voting shares John Malone surrendered 2.3M high-vote Series B shares and saw his voting power shrink from 48% all the way down to 3%; Why? To prevent another egomaniacal controlling shareholder Also: The Adoption of a Poison Pill triggered if any party acquires 10% or more of voting power (15% for passive institutional investors); Chairman Robert Bennett’s Option Exchange valued at roughly $20M; Malone stepped down as Chairman Emeritus to serve as Senior Advisor; continuation of benefits for 5 years; Malone locked in a five-year "Protected Period" guaranteeing personal use of the corporate aircraft, dedicated secretarial/administrative staff, and health coverage. Under Section 5.1(A), if Malone becomes incapacitated, it cannot be deemed a termination of employment, and if he dies, the company is contractually obligated to continue providing these benefits to his widow and dependents for the remainder of the five years; Liberty Media agreed to pay up to $6,500,000 to cover the out-of-pocket legal, tax advisory, accounting, and consulting fees incurred by Malone and his family trusts in negotiating the exchange against the company COSTCO WHOLESALE Helena B. Foulkes resigned: elected governor of RI Stupid money… Clorox’s new CEO/director Fabian Garcia will receive $11M in equity as Linda Rendle steps down as CEO/Chair and as a member of the Board Evercore Inc. (EVR) 2 newly promoted co-Presidents, Nigel Dawn and Naveen Nataraj, each receive one-time $20M equity awards Align Technology The new CEO-elect and director Jennifer Davis, who is replacing Joseph Hogan will receive a golden hello award consisting of: one-time $16.5M equity award; $2M cash; $1M relocation (to San Jose despite the company HQ in Tempe, Arizona): Cincinnati: median sold price $300,000 Tempe median sold price $449,000 San Jose median $1.3 million; Former CEO Hogan will receive an annual consulting fee of $150,000, and will remain eligible to receive an annual cash bonus And then it gets tricky: Mr. Hogan is expected to remain on the Board until June 2027 as a non-executive, non-independent director The Board will nominate him for re-election at the Company’s annual stockholder meeting in 2027, conditioned upon his prior irrevocable resignation from the Board following the Board’s June 2027 strategy meeting HP INC (HPQ) Newly appointed CEO and director Emma Walmsley: golden hello: $2.5M relocation, $30M equity, $2.5M cash interim CEO Bruce Broussard becomes Chair Board to C-Suite The leadership boondoggle: T-Mobile US, Inc. former CEO G. Michael Sievert resigned But who cares, right? T-Mobile is controlled by Deutsche Telekom AG - 55% 5 directors are considered executives of the controlling shareholder, including chair Tim Höttges. Also, 4 directors are considered to be a Special Shareholder Representative. And you still have the CEO Srinivasan (Srini) Gopalan This is why Sievert leaves with 7th highest influence at 5% ATMOS ENERGY CORP (ATO) CEO J. Kevin Akers becomes Chair Mr. Kim R. Cocklin (17%) resigned; reached mandatory retirement age Last year Richard A. Sampson, Lead Director and Chair of the Human Resources Committee and Executive Committee, reached mandatory retirement age, and therefore is not standing for re-election. 75 Miracles do happen LD Nancy Quinn (17%) is 73 with 22 years tenure EQUITY LIFESTYLE PROPERTIES Marguerite Nader (22%) will cease to serve as Vice Chairman and CEO and segue to exec Vice Chair; COO Patrick Waite named CEO and director But leadership is still a mess:: Nader (22%) Scott Peppet (23%) is the son-in-law of the late real estate billionaire Sam Zell (the founder and long-time Chairman of Equity LifeStyle Properties, who passed away in May 2023). Peppet is married to Zell’s eldest daughter. Former CEO Thomas Heneghan (25%) LD Philip Callan (13%) with 21 years tenure Down to 2F Overall: 70 director changes: 32% incoming directors are women; 50% outgoing are women Net change +24 M; +6 W PROXY CAGE MATCH Albert White is stepping down as CEO/Chair of Cooper Companies. The company also promoted director Walter Rosebrough Jr. to Executive Chair and named him interim CEO while they figure out their mess. The changes come weeks after activist Jana Partners called for the company to immediately start an external search for a new CEO and appoint a new board chair. A CEO Search Committee comprised of Lawrence E. Kurzius, Cynthia L. Lucchese and Teresa S. Madden was formed At Ethan Allen Interiors’ 2026 annual meeting on November 4th, activist investor Douglas Bergeron (DGB Investments, 5% owner) won a majority of board seats, and then got rid of longtime CEO/Chair Farooq Kathwari from the board and then fired him altogether. Major proxy advisory firms—including Glass Lewis, Egan-Jones, and ISS—largely sided with Bergeron's call for boardroom change. Shareholders elected three of Bergeron's five nominees—Douglas Bergeron, Kristine Miller, and Stephen Oblak—giving the activist slate a 3–2 majority. Only two company-backed incumbents, Maria Eugenia Casar and Tara Stacom, retained their seats. Kathwari finished ninth out of ten candidates (with 13.26 million votes withheld versus 7.38 million in favor), losing both his board seat and his role as chairman. The board appointed former Neiman Marcus Group executive Stefanie Tsen Ward as Interim CEO while Bergeron took over as Executive Chairman, and Miller was named Lead Independent Director, and the board expanded from five to nine directors by adding Ward alongside Anna Brockway, Lindsay O'Reilly, and Adam Treanor. Whitbread shareholders have overwhelmingly rejected an attempt by activist investor Corvex to gain a seat on the board of the Premier Inn owner. Excluding the votes of Corvex, which owns a roughly 6.4 per cent stake in Whitbread, 91 per cent of shareholders voted against a resolution to appoint Corvex partner James Gemmel to the board Averting Proxy Wars: 10 Companies Opting for Activist Investor Settlements Activist investor Oasis Management, which owns 10% of company shares has reduced its dissident director slate from 4 to 2 at Vail Resorts upcoming election This happened after 18%-owner Baron Capital said it would back Vail’s entire current board. Oasis is sticking with former Walt Disney CEO Bob Chapek and Ashton Hudson, who has served on various boards, but dropped former Olympic ski champion Picabo Street and venture capitalist Bryce Robert, VOTE RESULTS TABLE Since October 21st 11 meetings at large market caps 3 total SHPs from 3 companies: Top story: John Chevedden CINTAS CORP: majority voting 43% yes Fox Corp: Simple Majority Vote 39% yes LAM RESEARCH: Right to Call for a Special Shareholder Meeting 42% yes Victories: Hate: Most: Other: Say on Pay All at least 91% support Directors All at least 93% average yes STANDEX INTERNATIONAL: classified; 15% no Charles Cannon Jr. Fox Corp: Lachlan K. Murdoch 15% no; Paul Ryan 22% no NEWS CORP: José María Aznar 18% no Lachlan 7% no Other stuff Upcoming Annual Shareholder Meetings November 17th The Campbell’s Company November 18th Oracle: Option grants: 250$M forCEO Clayton Magouryk $100M for the other CEO Michael Sicilia $50M for the other other CEO Larry Ellison In all the accounting reported vale for stock options granted to NEOs comes to about $1.1B Lumentum Holdings The Clorox Company THE BIG VOTE Nvidia’s board did nothing! And 32 year tenured Harvey Jones is now Chair! A recap: Nerd founder of company acts as CEO and Chair for 25 years and no one cares Company suddenly at middle of the meme, becomes biggest company on earth Nerd founder now cool Newly cool founder does bad things Board “investigates” Founder “resigns” before board does anything The Nvidia recipe: the board did not have to actually DO anything. There was no succession

  2. Oct 22

    EU ESG Ratings Regulations, plus Zuckerberg's new shares

    This is Proxy Countdown. Welcome to the big show for the week of October 19, 2026 alongside my tag team partner Matt Moscardi. I'm Damion Rallis. On today’s countdown: Zuck does what’s best for Zuck, part 8,000 The Copart CEO dresses like Elon Musk for Halloween A former Disney CEO is being paid to hang around and be ready to do something Some quirks at upcoming annual meetings And on the Big Vote, Matt talks EU regulations Trade Wire Top Stories: 36 Filings since October 13th The headlines Meta (Zuck) is creating a new share of stock (Class C for Clown) with zero voting power, meaning Mark Zuckerberg keeps total control of the company, etc. Non-Zuck Class A shareholders essentially get a 2-for-1 stock split. In a nutshell, Zuck can sell off or donate massive piles of stock to fund other projects without losing voting power. Meta (Zuck) is essentially letting Zuckerberg gradually cash out his new shares to cover a potential multi-billion-dollar California wealth tax, but only on the condition that he stays in California and continues running the company from headquarters for the next eight years. How did we get here? The decision was made by a Special Committee established in February 2026 consisting of Ambassador Robert M. Kimmitt, Charles Songhurst, and Tony Xu. “Special Committee Counsel summarized the findings of their independence analysis of the members of the Special Committee. Special Committee Counsel noted that Mr. Xu disclosed a personal friendship with Mr. Zuckerberg but that he affirmed that such relationship would have no impact on his ability to exercise his independent judgment in assessing a Potential Recapitalization.” Ambassador Kimmitt, Meta’s Lead Independent Director who chaired this Special Committee, is Senior International Counsel at WilmerHale. The filing reveals that Meta paid WilmerHale $62.3M in legal fees in 2025 alone (nearly 4% of the entire law firm’s annual revenue). It’s fine though because the Ambassador “is walled off from the firm’s representation of the Company.” Top 3 dumb things: The “I’m a Sad, Poor Billionaire” Defense: Since January 1, 2013, Mr. Zuckerberg has taken a salary of only $1 each year for his service as the Company’s chief executive officer and chairman of the Board. This is extraordinarily different from what his peer (and even non-peer) CEOs are paid. If the California wealth tax is enacted and Mr. Zuckerberg becomes liable for a tax payment, Mr. Zuckerberg would effectively be paying to serve as the Company’s chief executive officer while residing in California. “Independent” financial advisor Moelis & Company LLC’s conflict of interest is actually a good thing!: “In assessing Moelis' independence, the Special Committee noted that (i) a senior member of the proposed Moelis team, the name of whom was disclosed to the Special Committee, had acquired approximately 30,000 shares of Class A common stock of the Company, with such shares valued at $18,888,391 as of March 17, 2026 and that such interest was helpful in confirming that such senior member of the Moelis team was financially aligned with the Class A shareholders.” “The Special Committee Engaged in Robust Negotiations with Mr. Zuckerberg and Secured Meaningful New Commitments from Mr. Zuckerberg Regarding His Control and Leadership” “Mr. Zuckerberg would not consider changes to the terms of his voting shares, including the sunset provisions on the Class B common stock set forth in the Governance Proposal, and that Mr. Zuckerberg was considering establishing residence outside of California in light of the risk that California Proposition 40 could become law.” Stupid money… COPART: CEO A. Jayson Adair gets special equity award of 20M options worth up to about $788M: Tranche 1: $26.27 per share Tranche 2: $35.03 per share Tranche 3: $43.78 per share Tranche 4: $52.54 per share Trade Desk: options repricing A massive bailout for top executives—including CEO Jeff Green—who had their deeply underwater options slashed from as high as $75 down to $12.26 in exchange for just a six-month retention requirement. Final vote was 441M yes to 232M no Class A (1 vote per share) and and Class B (10 votes per share held almost entirely by founder/CEO Jeff Green) Heading into the October 19, 2026 Special Meeting, Green controlled roughly 42.1 million Class B shares, giving him 50.2% of the company's total voting power all by himself. Multiplied by 10, Green’s Class B shares alone represented approximately 421 million votes. Because Green was not required to recuse himself or abstain, he voted his super-voting shares "FOR" the proposal. EXPAND ENERGY: appointed Daniel E. Brown as CEO; Interim CEO Michael Wichterich will continue as board chair make-whole equity award to new CEO Daniel Brown worth $16M Interim CEO Michael Wichterich gets $1M equity for 8.5 months MATTEL: New CEO Roger Lynch golden hello equity awards: Make-Whole RSUs $6M & Inducement PRSUs $6M MongoDB: Interim CEO Dev Ittycheria (former CEO and current director) $500K golden hello cash; $15M equity vesting in 2027 Was CEO from 2014 to 2025 CFO Michael Berry retention award of $10M time-based equity with 100% accelerated vesting if terminated without cause or if he resigns for good reason Still caring about something COSTCO WHOLESALE: announced bonus awards to CEOs where $200K ($80K for NEOs) can be earned relating to environmental and social objectives based on quantitative performance metrics (including those concerning human capital and environmental-related areas). Board to C-Suite The leadership boondoggle: Down to 2F Overall: 19 director changes: 19% incoming directors are women; 33% outgoing are women PROXY CAGE MATCH Disney’s Former CEO Is Getting $100,000 a Month as Activist’s Nominee for Vail Board Oasis Management (9.6% stake in Vail Resorts) is paying former Disney CEO Bob Chapek $100,000 a month as a nominee for the board of Vail Resorts. Oasis also agreed to give Chapek a forgivable $500,000 loan to purchase Vail stock if he is elected to the company’s board Chapek is one of four nominees A proxy cage match at Empery Digital resulted in one director swap: Empery director Oran Olason was voted out (56% no) while one of four ATG Capital Management Nominees was voted in: Aaron T. Morris 56% yes. VOTE RESULTS TABLE Since October 14th: 3 companies Zero directors over 20% no; all boards averaged at least 93% yes; say on pay all over 91% yes PROCTER & GAMBLE 3 SHPs Lower Threshold for Special Meetings 37% yes: The Accountability Board Eligibility Thresholds Policy 26% yes: The National Legal and Policy Center adopt a policy committing the Company to include in its annual proxy statement any shareholder proposal submitted by a shareholder, or group of shareholders, that satisfies any of the following eligibility thresholds and is otherwise compliant with the procedural and substantive requirements of Rule 14a-8, regardless of any future federal regulation permitting higher ownership or holding-period requirements, and consistent with applicable state law: shares of the Company's common stock with a market value of at least $2,000 held continuously for at least three years prior to submission; or shares of the Company's common stock with a market value of at least $15,000 held continuously for at least two years prior to submission; or shares of the Company's common stock with a market value of at least $25,000 held continuously for at least one year prior to submission. Charitable Contributions Reporting 4% yes: The Bahnsen Family Trust (conservative Christian advocate): 2023 anti-DEI proposal at JPMorgan: My Bid to Make JPMorgan Less Woke Upcoming Annual Shareholder Meetings 20 Meetings key takeaways Weird times Performance Food Group Company 8:00 A.M. ET Avnet 8:00 am local time (PT) Lumentum Holdings 8:00 a.m. Pacific Time Western Digital 8am PT Sysco 7:00 a.m. Central Time Sandisk 8am PT BGC Group 10am ET Non-virtual Tesla: both virtually and in person for a limited number of shareholders at Tesla’s Gigafactory Texas Avnet: Corporate Headquarters Very Sad CEO Pay Ratios Lumentum Holdings 1478:1 Western Digital 1457:1 Fabrinet 1317:1 Very Fake CEO Pay Ratios Tesla 0.00:1 (Elon) Atlassian Corporation 0.23 to 1 (dual class co-founder with 43% voting power Michael Cannon-Brookes) 1 Actual SHP The Campbell’s Company: report on the effectiveness of the Company’s regenerative agriculture program including pesticide reduction outcomes: As You Sow 1 Fake SHP Avnet: ​​Provide Shareholders with the Ability to Call a Special Shareholder Meeting at a 10% Ownership Threshold: John Chevedden Board Proposal to Provide Shareholders with the Ability to Call a Special Shareholder Meeting at a 25% Ownership Threshold Tesla December 3, 2026, at 3:00 p.m. Central Time both virtually and in person for a limited number of shareholders at Tesla’s Gigafactory Texas elect three Class I directors Elon Musk, Robyn Denholm and JB Straubel 0 SHP CEO Pay Ratio 0.00:1 One share one vote Elon Musk 20% ​ ​ Vanguard 5% Performance Food Group Company November 18, 2026 8:00 A.M. Eastern Time virtual elect 10 directors 0 SHP CEO Pay Ratio 109:1 One share one vote Capital World Investors 15% BlackRock 9% Fidelity 7% Vanguard 5% George Holm 2% Atlassian Corporation December 1, 2026 2:00 p.m. Pacific Time virtual elect 9 directors 0 SHP CEO Pay Ratio 0.23 to 1 Dual class Class A 1 vote per share BlackRock 1% voting power Class B 10 votes per share Michael Cannon-Brookes 43% voting power Scott Farquhar 43% voting power Avnet November 20, 2026 8:00 am local time (PT) Avnet’s Corporate Headquarters elect 10 directors Board Proposal to Provide Shareholders with the Ability to Call a Special Shareholder Meeting at a 25% Ownership Threshold 1 SHP ​​Provide Shareholders with the Ability to Call a Special Shareholder Meeting at a 10% Ownership Threshold: John Chevedden C

  3. Oct 15

    The Great SEC Gaslight, plus Bobby Kotick's and Skydance

    Trade Wire Top Stories: 59 Filings since October 1st The headlines Skydance CEO David Ellison is scared to do the job himself: steals Ynon Kreiz from Mattel and names him co-CEO; David Ellison will continue as Chair. And then, Skydance Adds Bobby Kotick and Laurene Powell Jobs to Board, Taps Tony Blair as Adviser Before I get to Bobby, Laurene Powell Jobs is the widow of Apple’s Steve Jobs and Tony Blair is the former UK prime minister: both seem to represent channels to power and a slightly liberal-bent, possibly to counterattack the perception that this is a MAGA-friendly company? Now Bobby: After presiding over a toxic workplace scandal at Activision Blizzard, Bobby Kotick faced explosive revelations that he personally shielded accused abusers, concealed sexual assault allegations, and threatened an assistant's life. Instead of being fired, he walked away with a golden parachute worth over $400M when Microsoft absorbed the embattled publisher in a $69 billion buyout. And in case you’re wondering, people like Bobby Kotick represent actual risk; here’s a summary of legal action against Activision/Bobby: The California Civil Rights Department sued over a pervasive "frat boy" culture marked by constant sexual harassment, unequal pay, and retaliation against female employees. Activision settled in December 2023 for $54 million, sending roughly $46 million directly to female workers. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission targeted widespread sexual harassment and pregnancy discrimination across Activision Blizzard’s gaming studios. The company settled via a consent decree in 2022, creating an $18 million compensation fund for impacted workers. The SEC charged leadership with failing to track workplace misconduct complaints and using restrictive separation agreements that muzzled potential whistleblowers. Activision settled in early 2023 by paying a $35 million civil penalty without admitting wrongdoing. The family of a 32-year-old Blizzard finance manager sued, alleging severe workplace sexual harassment drove her to suicide during a 2017 company retreat. The family voluntarily dismissed the case with prejudice in 2022 and the case resulted in a confidential out-of-court settlement. And finally the Microsoft "Fire-Sale" Shareholder Lawsuit: Swedish pension funds and investors claimed Kotick rushed a discounted $69 billion buyout to Microsoft at $95 per share to secure a massive golden parachute and dodge personal liability. The case settled in 2026 for $250 million, split between Microsoft and board insurers to compensate qualifying shareholders. Stupid money… Live Nation CEO Michael Rapino received several new equity retention grants to keep him interested in being a CEO: Here’s the easiest way to explain this: He used to get an annual $10M long-term equity grant, starting in 2027 he will get 1) $10M in annual performance shares, 2) $15M in annual time-based RSUs, 3) $15M in annual PSUs, and then as a cherry on the top: $20M in upfront RSUs. New Pinterest CFO James Dibbo is getting a golden hello award worth $32M in equity. The previous CFO, Julia Brau Donnelly, served for only 3 years. 3 Pinterest board members have experience as CFO. Here’s a new term: golden handcuffs. Four Skydance named executive officers (including nepobaby David) are set to haul in an additional $50M in annual bonus compensation. Board to C-Suite The leadership boondoggle: COO Spencer S. Stiles is being promoted to CEO and director at Stryker, while former CEO Kevin Lobo will transition to Executive Chair At General Dynamics, President and board member Danny Deep will succeed Phebe Novakovic as CEO, with Novakovic transitioning to Executive Chair Down to 2F Overall: 44 director changes: 25% incoming directors are women; 35% outgoing are women PROXY CAGE MATCH Six Flags: Jana Partners wants a sale and a board shake-up, leveraging the star power of Mr. Taylor Swift. A recent rollercoaster death will make this easier or harder? Sanderson Design Group: Activist fund LBV (14% stake) is hammering Sanderson over high pay and low performance. Sanderson director Patrick Lewis has retaliated, threatening to sue LBV's founder for defamation over the campaign's aggressive claims. Ethan Allen: DGB Investments (5% stake) is pushing to blow up the board completely. As a bargaining chip, the activist is offering longtime CEO/Chair Farooq Kathwari a participation trophy in the form of the title Chair Emeritus. Whitbread: Corvex Management (7%) is demanding board representation and a strategic overhaul to fix an alleged "chronic misallocation of capital" at the Premier Inn parent. Whitbread called Corvex’s proposals a “complete waste” of time and money and “a complete waste of company – and shareholder – resources.” PepsiCo: Elliott Investment Management is targeting Doritos and Cheetos and blaming Ozempic! VOTE RESULTS TABLE Since September 1st 18 meetings at large market caps 10 total SHPs from 5 companies: Top story At Darden Restaurants: The Accountability Board is my new hero! They asked for a policy providing that if any director fails to receive at least 80% of the votes cast in an uncontested election, the Board’s independent directors will conduct a formal review of the circumstances underlying such vote, and publicly disclose a summary of findings and any responsive actions taken. Sadly only 3% said yes 1 Victory a policy requiring shareholder approval before distributing “blank-check” preferred stock 63% yes at General Mills The Accountability Board! Near wins independent board chair 39% yes at FedEx special meeting rights 39% yes at Casey’s General Stores Hate Bowyer Research hates the Human Rights Report! At Nike, a Charitable Support Report 0.7% yes Most: FedEx 3; General Mills 3 Other Say on Pay 32% no Nike Directors At Nike, 3 Class B directors were up for vote: Monica Gil and Robert Swan received well over 90% support but not Thasunda Duckett, who got 38% no votes. What makes her so different? All served for under a decade Robert Swan has been an Operating Partner at Andreessen Horowitz and sits on 2 other boards Monica Gil is a member of the Pay COmmittee: Say on Pay 32% no Thasunda? CEO of TIAA (Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America), no other boards, black woman?? The only other director over 20% no is a woman named Dolores Ennico (23%) from a classified board election at RBC Bearings Why Dolores? Maybe because she used to be the Chief Human Resources Officer of Olin Corporation? Nah. Oh, she’s too old! She’s 73. The other director up for vote was CEO/Chairman Dr. Michael J. Hartnett. He got 97% yes. He’s 81 years old. Overall average support was high 90s Other stuff Upcoming Annual Shareholder Meetings THE BIG VOTE The SEC is a Joke Part 1: Protect the oil The greatest gaslight of an “investigation” ever, as summarized by Paul “Oil Slurpee” Atkins himself: “The investigation considered evidence as to whether investors and asset managers, including BlackRock, Inc. (“BlackRock”), State Street Corporation (“State Street”) and The Vanguard Group (“Vanguard”) joined a group of ExxonMobil investors, including after BlackRock and State Street became members of CA100. This evidence included BlackRock and State Street, after becoming members of CA100, engaging in certain communications regarding ExxonMobil with Ceres, a Boston-based non-profit that serves as the North American investor network supporting CA100 (as explained below).The evidence also suggested CA100 and its members pressured BlackRock and State Street to support CA100 ̶flagged matters submitted to a shareholder vote, including the May 2021 election of dissident directors to ExxonMobil’s board.” Summary: Blackrock, State Street, Vanguard form a “group” for the purposes of activism coordinated by the Climate Action 100+ and pressured by non profit Ceres - to put directors on Exxon’s board - that’s the investigation - the SEC on behalf of Exxon wants to know if they formed a group and should have been subject to massive amounts of 13D filings and not considered passive investors On the other hand, Vanguard never became a member of CA100, and the investigation did not develop evidence that BlackRock or State Street agreed to vote proxies in certain manners or shared their proxy voting intentions with investors or others associated with CA100. In the next line, Atkins literally admits that NO, Vanguard never joined (but voted for dissidents) and there was NO EVIDENCE that Blackrock and State Street agreed to vote a certain way (or even discussed it) While most attorneys would stop there, not this asshole… Atkins uses the rest of the document, after finding no evidence of anything, to tell investors NOT to join groups like Climate Action 100+ because he’ll consider you part of a group ANYWAY, saying the ACT of joining any “signing statements” doesn’t shield you from the SEC determining, even if you “didn’t technically form a legal group”, they will use “implied” and “circumstantial evidence” to say you did Atkins focuses a LOT on Climate Action 100+ and Ceres, who try desperately to get investors to DO something, but investors largely commit to nothing at all Vanguard doesn’t even join but Atkins just lets that slide, ignoring the fact entirely as inconvenient to the narrative that a pair of dopey non-profits pressured multi trillion dollar asset managers to do something Atkins cites internal Ceres documents they subpoenaed where idiots at Ceres, a NON PROFIT who loves to talk big about winning and has won virtually nothing but funding, sends an email to a donor talking about how Blackrock joining the CA100 was mostly because they’re so good at pressuring them and had “leverage” Except that: “The minutes also detail discussion between BlackRock and Ceres regarding the ExxonMobil board refresh campaign: “

  4. Jul 31

    CEO Hotseats, plus Cracker Barrel’s CEO leaves and the SEC goes after activists

    Trade Wire Top Stories:  127 Filings since June 26th The headlines New CARPENTER TECHNOLOGY CEO/director Brian J. Malloy passed away just three weeks after he became CEO: former CEO/Chair Tony Thene became CEO/chair Cracker Barrel CEO Julie Masino is out after MAGA backlash to "Uncle Herschel" logo change $4.6M severance Cracker Barrel names David Deno CEO Burger King Yum! Brands and Pizza Hut Quiznos Best Buy Bloomin' Brands (Outback Steakhouse) Panera Brands (2024-): Audit Committee Chair Krispy Kreme (2016-) Bloomin' Brands (2019–2024) Peet's Coffee (2006-2012) Macalester College: Former Chair of the Board of Trustees (1998-2022). At COPART, CEO Jeff Liaw to step down, Jay Adair to return CEO Jeff Liaw is resigning from the board and company. Executive Chairman Jay Adair to boomerang back as CEO. The board has a Chair (founder Willis Johnson 40%) AND an Executive Chair: Willis’ son-in-law and co-founder and boomerang CEO Jay Adair 38% Snowflake: CEO Performance Award for Sridhar Ramaswamy worth up to $100B Speaking of Stupid money… FASTENAL: appointed new CEO Jeffery M. Watts to the board: will receive an annual cash retainer of $50,000 for his service as an employee director Snowflake: CEO Performance Award for Sridhar Ramaswamy worth up to $100B FRANKLIN RESOURCES: one-time special $15M retention equity awards to 4 NEOs, including  CEO Jennifer M. Johnson Chief Commercial Officer Daniel Gamba, Head of Public Market Investments Terrence J. Murphy, and CFO/COO Matthew Nicholls Archer-Daniels-Midland: $19M golden hello ($2.2M cash) to new COO Jeff Rowe L3HARRIS TECHNOLOGIES: special one-time equity awards to 3 NEOs CFO Kenneth Sharp ($5M), President, Missile Solutions Kenneth Bedingfield ($10M), and President, Space & Mission Systems and Communications & Spectrum Dominance Samir Mehta, President, Space & Mission Systems and Communications & Spectrum Dominance ($10M) FEDEX: established a one-time special cash bonus pool for eligible managing directors and above, approximately 1,100 employees CEO Rajesh Subramaniam $1.9M and Brie A. Carere $850k Board to C-Suite Ulta Beauty: Kelly E. Garcia will transition director to Chief Technology Officer The leadership boondoggle: American Healthcare REIT: CEO Danny Prosky resigned, stayed on board Jeffrey Hanson new CEO, will continue to serve as Chair appointed Scott A. Estes as Lead Independent Director PROCTER & GAMBLE: Executive Chair Jon R. Moeller resigned from board and company CEO Shailesh G. Jejurikar becomes Chair reappointed Joseph Jimenez as independent Lead Director ENTEGRIS: Executive Chair Bertrand Loy resigned from company and board Lead Independent Director James F. Gentilcore becomes Chair appointed CEO Robert A. Bruggeworth to board Down to 2F Female adds: 9; Male adds 43; Female subtractions 4; Male subtractions 15 Women accounted for 17.3% of all additions (9 out of 52) and 21.1% of all departures net addition of +5 female directors Men accounted for 82.7% of additions (43 out of 52) and 78.9% of departures net addition of +28 male directors Down to 2: PAYCHEX: Kara Wilson resigning Down to 1: Natera: Monica Bertagnolli resigned Dedicated to oncology, women's health, and organ health. Stay to 2 with female influence boost: Kohl’s Appoints Wendy Arlin as Chair of the Board Currently only 2: Robbin Mitchell (7%) and Wendy Arlin (1%) John Schlifske (27%) stepping down ‍ ‍ PROXY CAGE MATCH Activist investors in the U.S. must disclose the identities of their clients in regulatory filings In a surprise to many, the SEC updates to Schedule 13D and proxy rules will force hedge funds to disclose campaign financing—information they have long kept secret. Target companies welcome the change, arguing that campaign transparency is essential for evaluating activist motives and mounting board defenses. Nano Dimension and activist investor Murchison reached an agreement where CEO and director Dave Stehlin, board chair Robert Pons, and directors Joshua Rosensweig and Andrew Sriubas have all resigned In turn, Nano appointed three new directors to the board, including Moshe Rozenbaum, Eliezer Eli Tarlow and Paul Fruchthandler. Activist investor Saba failed in its attempt to overhaul the board of Workspace Group Saba, which owns about 21% of shares, was trying to oust all six non-executive directors (3M/3F) to be replaced by 6 dudes: Nick Shattock, Andrew Sim, Richard Starr and Gregory Attwood, Gautam Garg and Simon Hampton Results: between 60% to 68% yes When shareholder activists attack a company, its rivals may feel the heat too and change their ways Research from the College of Charleston:  shareholder activism can create what our team of business school professors calls “collateral impact”: a domino effect in which pressure on one company changes what its competitors are doing. found that when one company changes course in response to activist pressure, its competitors frequently follow suit – even when activists have not targeted them directly.   VOTE RESULTS TABLE  Since June 26th 27 meetings at large market caps 7 total SHPs from 4 companies: Top story 2 Victories Nvidia: simple majority voting 87% yes Snowflake: Majority Vote for Director Elections 65% yes Hate Nvidia faith-based groups 0.86% yes anti-DEI report 0.60% yes Most: Nvidia 4 Other KROGER: GHG emissions 17% yes Booz Allen Hamilton: 28% yes Act by Written Consent Nvidia: scope 3 ghg emissions 17% yes    Say on Pay Snowflake Inc. (SNOW): pay 56% no classified: Sridhar Ramaswamy 21% no; Teresa Briggs 31% no; Mark D. McLaughlin 40% no 70% said no in 2025 Rivian Automotive: pay 33% no $402M for CEO RObert Scaringe Directors As usual, classified stuff: BridgeBio Pharma: classified: Hannah Valantine 20% no StandardAero: classified: 15% avg no Rivian Automotive: classified: Karen Boone 19% no; Aidan Gomez 8% no Cloudflare: classified: Karim Lakhani 20% no;  Snowflake: classified: Sridhar Ramaswamy 21% no; Teresa Briggs 31% no; Mark D. McLaughlin 40% no MongoDB:  classified: Dwight Merriman 20% no; Archana Agrawal 21% no; Hope Cochran 28% no WM TECHNOLOGY: classified: 24% no Other stuff Dell Technologies: Dexit 97% yes WM TECHNOLOGY classified: 24% no pay 24% no Charter Amendment to Declassify Board 90% yes (failed) auditor 17% no Upcoming Annual Shareholder Meetings Friday, July 31, 2026 Cirrus Logic, Inc.CRUS~$6.75 Billion Wednesday, August 5, 2026 Flex Ltd.FLEX~$35.58 Billion Allegro MicroSystems, Inc. ALGM ~$9.3 Billion Thursday, August 6, 2026 Albertsons Companies, Inc.ACI~$5.41 Billion CorVel CorporationCRVL~$3.17 Billion Tuesday, August 11, 2026 Qorvo, Inc.QRVO~$7.7 Billion Wednesday, August 12, 2026 The J. M. Smucker CompanySJM~$13.56 Billion Monday, August 17, 2026 Pagaya Technologies Ltd.PGY~$1.1 Billion Tuesday, August 18, 2026 Microchip Technology IncorporatedMCHP~$45.20 Billion Thursday, August 20, 2026 James Hardie Industries plcJHX~$15.19 Billion Tuesday, August 25, 2026 Helen of Troy LimitedHELE~$1.2 Billion Wednesday, August 26, 2026 Dynatrace, Inc.DT~$14.20 Billion THE BIG VOTE Matt TWO QUESTIONS FIRST: Universal Safety Products Trump Media Cracker Barrel CEO Stepping Down After Logo Controversy, Activist Pressure CEOs in the Hotseat Criteria: Not dual class or founder board CEO is less than 30% influence Gap between CEO influence and highest non executive board member is less than 10% Board is low deference or independent Board is highly interconnected Average boards ever of non executive directors is >=2 Company performance 50% board does not have connections in common with the CEO Token vulnerability: CEO is a woman CEO is black or hispanic Summary 10,458 CEOs in our database 6,311 CEOs with less than 30% influence Fully 2,249 companies have CEOs with obvious vulnerabilities CEO on board with family/founders CEO on board with exec chair 67 in the top hit list Notable CEO hotseats: UPS - Carol Thome become CEO in 2020 AFTER being on the board since 2003 She has low influence gap to next independent director, the board is HUGELY connected - but not to her friends - she has a 23 year tenure on the board (plenty of time to make it work) and a bottom quartile TSR at the company vs peers in the last 3 years… plus, she’s a lady on a board full of people with core knowledge of the sector   We know it works because 23 of the 67 have CEO tenures of 2 years (they just swapped CEOs because they were vulnerable) Of those 23, 3 added female CEOs (Northland Power, SGS SA, Domino’s Pizza), so those are basically guaranteed glass cliffs - an unintended consequence of CEO vulnerability is after replacement, we have a marker for glass cliff-ism Succession much? That’s the Proxy Countdown for the week of July 27, 2026. Join us next week when we jump back into the Alternative Democracy pool... forever on the lookout for shareholder shenanigans, dopey directors, scandalous CEO pay ratios, and wayward BandAids

  5. Jul 8

    Proxy Season Crossover

    What are the overall results from AGMs in 2026? How did companies and shareholders do in AGM votes? Shareholder proposals Many fewer E&S Same or slightly more corp gov  Voting outcomes similar to past years(?) Proxy contests Many fewer compared to earlier years Activists prevailed at roughly the same rate, perhaps a little lower Many more settlements Notable activist situations ESG proposals Proxy contests Almost no really big ones Biglari lost two, CBRL and JACK Two mergers terminated CORZ, CoreWeave STAA Withhold campaigns didn’t work CBRL, JACK VSCO - started as a proxy contest Several smaller ones, where in all but one activists won no seats Important settlements LULU-Wilson WEX-Impactive TRIP-Starboard RGR-Beretta KMX-Starboard Still several to go for 2026, though FRMI-Neugebauer Regulatory actions - AML comments SEC State level Can’t avert our eyes from SPCX IPO, either Ownership Corp gov Trading So, what have we learned so far in 2026? The Key Takeaways: SHPs Total shareholder proposal submissions fell significantly from 951 in 2025 down to approximately 789 in 2026. Despite the SEC granting companies broader power to exclude rogue proposals, corporate boards remained hyper-cautious, allowing around 70% of submissions to proceed to a full vote to avoid investor backlash or litigation. Only about 7% to 8% of voted proposals achieved majority support (36 out of 425 proposals mid-season)—a steep drop from the 12% to 14% passed in 2025. Paradoxically, average support across all voted proposals crept up slightly to 25% (from 23% last year). Traditional corporate governance issues comprised 49% of all submissions. A tiny group of individual retail activists (John Chevedden/Jim McRitchie) monopolized the arena, driving over 75% of all governance submissions Shareholder proposals demanding formalized AI ethical governance, algorithmic transparency, and data privacy climbed to 20 submissions in 2026 (up from 12 in 2024). Management found it difficult to dodge these tech topics; 90% of AI-focused proposals successfully cleared regulatory hurdles to face a vote. 2027 Question: The Say on AI Advisory Vote: Will shareholder proposals demanding ethical AI oversight, algorithmic transparency, and labor displacement risks cross the threshold to become standardized, annual Say on AI advisory votes on mainstream ballots? Pay Only 9 Say-on-Pay packages failed outright across the market through early June—a drop from previous cycles. Major pay "revolts" (70% support) shrank to just 44 out of 1,108 companies. 2027 Question: Why should anybody care about Say on Pay anymore? Director Elections Corporate directors remain incredibly secure, averaging 95% investor support. Out of 8,167 tracked director votes, 86% cruised to comfortable re-election with 90%+ approval, while only 18 directors (0.2%) across 14 public companies failed to cross the 50% majority threshold. Proxy Advisors: Massive institutional investor groups publicly cut ties with ISS and Glass Lewis benchmark policies, relying instead on internal, proprietary stewardship frameworks. The Shrinking "ISS Penalty": In 2021, an ISS "Against" recommendation on Say-on-Pay dragged down company support by an average of 30 percentage points. In 2026, that penalty shrank to 19.8 percentage points across the Russell 3000 ISS backed 48% of all proposals in 2026 compared to just 34% in 2025, but this softening had minimal impact on increasingly independent asset managers. 2027 Question: With the historical ISS "Against" penalty on Say-on-Pay dropping to just 19.8 percentage points, will corporate boards begin systematically ignoring negative proxy advisor recommendations on share requests without fear of a failed vote? Activists Public proxy fights looked quieter on the surface because governance disputes are now aggressively negotiated in real time behind closed doors, avoiding public 13D filings. As of June 1, only one single traditional proxy contest went to a full public vote among US companies with a market cap over $250M (Summer Road, LLC winning a seat at Ingles Markets). 2027 Voting Questions The Retail Auto-Vote Expansion: Following ExxonMobil's successful launch of a board-aligned retail auto-voting program, will consumer-heavy "meme stock" companies deploy similar digital tools to completely silence minority activist groups? The AI-Driven Voting Monopoly: As institutional asset managers heavily integrate custom AI parsing tools to cut disclosure review times by 40%, will traditional proxy advisory firms like ISS and Glass Lewis face an existential collapse of their research monopolies? Algorithmic Error Liability: Will an institutional investor face immense legal and fiduciary liability after its proprietary AI stewardship bot accidentally misinterprets dense legalese and votes "Yes" on a hostile proposal? Data Center Environmental Revolts: Seizing on populist movements, will Big Tech and media giants face unprecedented institutional proxy revolts specifically over the compounding environmental risks, energy strains, and water demands of generative AI data centers? Events: No action set to “ignore” - did it matter? YES DExit - did it matter? YES Anti-ESG lawsuits - did it matter? YES Musk’s pay package - did it matter? YES Jay Hoag had the biggest jump from 74% AGAINST to 93% FOR between 2025 and 2026 - did it matter? NO Exempt solicitations are dead except for the super rich - did it matter? MIXED! Questions for 2026: In a NON ACTIVIST situation, does anything matter except attendance for director votes? Are activist shareholder proposals dead? Is the job of ISS and Glass Lewis simply to say whether you should back an activist or not? How many directors will be voted out? Will the SEC make it illegal to be a shareholder in 2026-27 (shareholders can be annoying after all)? AI China AI AI AI China China AI China China China?

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
6 Ratings

About

In the style of ESPN, The Proxy Countdown is an American pre-game show broadcast by Free Float as part of the company's coverage of the the executives and directors who control the corporate world. The show spotlights important CEO transitions, features contentious boardroom battles, and highlights shareholder votes at the alternative democracy of annual corporate shareholder meetings. Because unlike athletes, investors can get in the game.

You Might Also Like