I had the privilege of hearing a recent The Assignment podcast about “Political Violence,” that made me cringe. First of all, I was so shocked at how little effort was made to correct the statement about Malcom X’s views and perceived actions around violence. Therefore, I went to find source material (Chat GPT) to show that … Malcolm X himself did not personally engage in violent attacks in America.
Here’s the distinction:
• What he believed:
• Malcolm X (especially during his Nation of Islam years in the 1950s–early 1960s) preached self-defense, not unprovoked violence.
• He rejected Martin Luther King Jr.’s philosophy of strict nonviolence, saying that if Black people were attacked, they had the right to defend themselves “by any means necessary.”
• What he did:
• He never led or participated in violent riots, revolts, or attacks.
• His activism was primarily through speeches, organizing, and writing.
• After leaving the Nation of Islam in 1964, he continued to advocate for self-defense but also broadened his message toward international human rights and solidarity.
• Misconception:
• Opponents often painted him as an advocate of violence, but Malcolm X clarified many times that he was against aggression—only in favor of retaliation if attacked.
✅ So, to answer directly: Malcolm X did not use violence in America. He promoted armed self-defense as a principle, but his legacy is one of rhetorical power, not violent action.
Sources: Great question. Here are some reliable sources on Malcolm X and his stance on violence:
⸻
Primary Sources (His Own Words)
1. “The Ballot or the Bullet” Speech (1964) – Malcolm X emphasizes that Black people should use all means—including voting—but if the government fails to protect them, they have the right to self-defense.
• Source: Teaching American History archive – Malcolm X: The Ballot or the Bullet
2. Interview with Bay Area Television (1963) – He states:
“We are nonviolent with people who are nonviolent with us, but we are not nonviolent with anyone who is violent with us.”
• Source: KQED Newsroom, 1963
3. Autobiography of Malcolm X (1965, with Alex Haley) – His life story in his own words, including reflections on his stance on self-defense.
⸻
Secondary Sources (Historians & Scholars)
4. Manning Marable, Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention (2011, Pulitzer Prize-winning biography) – Provides a detailed historical account showing Malcolm never engaged in violent acts but consistently preached armed self-defense.
5. Michael Eric Dyson, Making Malcolm: The Myth and Meaning of Malcolm X (1996) – Explains how Malcolm X’s rhetoric on violence was often misunderstood.
6. PBS – Malcolm X: Make It Plain (Documentary) – Covers his philosophy and clarifies that while he rejected passive nonviolence, he never initiated violence.
• Source: PBS: Make It Plain
⸻
📌 Summary from these sources:
Malcolm X did not carry out violent acts. He called for self-defense against racial aggression, distinguishing it from unprovoked violence.
Would you like me to pull direct quotes from these sources so you can see Malcolm X’s own language on violence vs. self-defense?
