True Crime Recaps

Unknown

Hosts and storytellers Chris Nathan and Amy Townsend piece together the most gripping true crime cases the world can't stop talking about. From infamous serial killers to today's headline-making mysteries, they break it all down with thorough research, smart commentary, and the signature format that built their channel: All the crime in half the time.®

  1. A Pizza Delivery Gone Wrong on a Quiet Island: The Tessa Van Hart Case

    May 19

    A Pizza Delivery Gone Wrong on a Quiet Island: The Tessa Van Hart Case

    On a quiet winter night in 1994, 23-year-old Tessa Van Hart leaves her job at a small pizza shop on Chincoteague Island, Virginia, to complete what seems like a routine delivery. The address leads her to an empty summer home in a secluded area, and after she leaves, she never returns. Hours later, her car is discovered parked behind a vacant house, and Tessa is found inside the back seat, shot twice in the head, with the undelivered pizza still sitting in the front.The small island community is left in shock. With no clear suspects and limited forensic technology at the time, the investigation stalls for years. Then, more than two years later, a local man named Brian Cherrix comes forward while in custody on unrelated charges. He initially offers secondhand information about the crime, but eventually gives a detailed confession describing how he lured Tessa, assaulted her, and ultimately killed her before later retracting his statement and claiming coercion.Despite inconsistencies, investigators recover a rifle linked to the murder, and other evidence helps secure a conviction. Brian Cherrix is sentenced to death, later executed in 2004 after years of appeals. Tessa’s murder remains one of the most disturbing cases in the island’s history, forever changing the belief that nothing violent could ever happen in such a quiet, close-knit place.#TrueCrimeRecaps #TessaVanHart #ChincoteagueIsland #BrianCherrix #DeathPenalty Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

    11 min
4.7
out of 5
303 Ratings

About

Hosts and storytellers Chris Nathan and Amy Townsend piece together the most gripping true crime cases the world can't stop talking about. From infamous serial killers to today's headline-making mysteries, they break it all down with thorough research, smart commentary, and the signature format that built their channel: All the crime in half the time.®

You Might Also Like